You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Brook vs golovkin
November 22 2026 12.40am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Brook vs golovkin


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 12 Sep 16 1.08pm

Originally posted by SurreyEagle16

Mate...entitled to your opinion...but from the seat I watched it in...Brook did enough to show he was in the fight and exceeded a lot of the predictions like the ones you have made.

My prediction was that he would lose the fight. He did.

He had no chance. You keep believing what you wish.

I expect you think wrestling is real.

 

blackpalacefan Flag 12 Sep 16 1.32pm

It's beginning to sound like the next big fight will be a couple of you having a punch up

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 12 Sep 16 1.43pm

I watched the fight (and won 60 quid ) the only thing I was mildly surprised at was that it went 5 rounds.

GGG summed it up perfectly for me, when he was interviewed after the fight he smiled (without a mark on him) saying "he is not middleweight", also when asked if he hurt him he replied flatly "No".

Total mismatch, brook deserves credit for even getting in the ring but we all know the fights should have been Khan V Brook and Canelo v GGG.

I think he might stand a chance at light middle, but he should stop thinking about the middle weight division unless he wants to end up seriously injured.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 12 Sep 16 1.51pm

Originally posted by dannyh

I watched the fight (and won 60 quid ) the only thing I was mildly surprised at was that it went 5 rounds.

GGG summed it up perfectly for me, when he was interviewed after the fight he smiled (without a mark on him) saying "he is not middleweight", also when asked if he hurt him he replied flatly "No".

Total mismatch, brook deserves credit for even getting in the ring but we all know the fights should have been Khan V Brook and Canelo v GGG.

I think he might stand a chance at light middle, but he should stop thinking about the middle weight division unless he wants to end up seriously injured.


Agreed on all the above. Brook did himself and his career no harm on Saturday, he'll step up to light middleweight with a much higher profile than he previously thought. Not his fault no-one in his current division wants to fight him.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

rikz Flag Croydon 12 Sep 16 2.05pm

Originally posted by SurreyEagle16

That's true...but some boxers don't get better cutting weight. Bellew was a prime example. Bellew was killing himself to make light heavy and struggled twice against Chilemba, lost to Cleverley wide and got annihilated by Stevenson.

Up a weight division he is a different animal and knocked out someone who most though would beat him easily.

And Khan didn't lose to Alvarez because of weight. He was outboxing him before getting hit by one big shot...the same as he had against Willie Limmond years earlier. He was strong and fast at the weight and had to gain a lot more than Brook has.

Bernard Hopkins...middleweight to light heavy
Roy Jones...middle to heavy
so many more

Elite boxers have climbed through weight divisions for decades. Putting weight on with the amount of science they have behind them is nothing new and has seen plenty of success in the past.

If brook loses I don't think it will be because of weight...it will be because Golovkin can fight.


He lost entirely down to weight, alvarez knew he could walk through his punches before eventually tiring and that's when he would start catching khan and it would be game over.

Roy Jones, toney, hollyfield, Duran, de la hoya, pacquiao, mayweather ect were all regarded as the best at their weight before moving up.

Or you get other fighters that will never be the best so they move to a less packed division, especially British fighters who will get a title shot just because they bring so much money to the title.

Brook is in his prime and has so many big fights in his own division, a lot probably wouldnt even name him as the best light welterweight in the world. If he had problems making weight then he should of went to super welter, not stepping upto middleweight to fight golovkin. The fight was purely money.

Catch weights are happening far to frequently in boxing now and it's down to boxers not wanting to fight each other more needs to be done to stop it. Basically the public are getting robbed.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 12 Sep 16 2.11pm

Originally posted by rikz

He lost entirely down to weight, alvarez knew he could walk through his punches before eventually tiring and that's when he would start catching khan and it would be game over.

Roy Jones, toney, hollyfield, Duran, de la hoya, pacquiao, mayweather ect were all regarded as the best at their weight before moving up.

Or you get other fighters that will never be the best so they move to a less packed division, especially British fighters who will get a title shot just because they bring so much money to the title.

Brook is in his prime and has so many big fights in his own division, a lot probably wouldnt even name him as the best light welterweight in the world. If he had problems making weight then he should of went to super welter, not stepping upto middleweight to fight golovkin. The fight was purely money.

Catch weights are happening far to frequently in boxing now and it's down to boxers not wanting to fight each other more needs to be done to stop it. Basically the public are getting robbed.

Add to that the sham of Super titles, silver titles, international belts etc. On top of the fact there are so many sanctioning bodies in the first place.

 


Optimistic as ever

rikz Flag Croydon 12 Sep 16 3.07pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Add to that the sham of Super titles, silver titles, international belts etc. On top of the fact there are so many sanctioning bodies in the first place.

I know mate, WBA now has 3 world titles, then with the other 3 main ones, refusing to work together, refusing to rank certain fighters. I find it hard enough to keep up let alone your casual boxing fan

 

Stuk Flag Top half 12 Sep 16 3.38pm

Originally posted by rikz

I know mate, WBA now has 3 world titles, then with the other 3 main ones, refusing to work together, refusing to rank certain fighters. I find it hard enough to keep up let alone your casual boxing fan

And then some get all the time in the world to take a mandatory, while others get the belt removed 5 minutes after they've won it.

 


Optimistic as ever

blackpalacefan Flag 12 Sep 16 3.45pm

Originally posted by rikz

I know mate, WBA now has 3 world titles, then with the other 3 main ones, refusing to work together, refusing to rank certain fighters. I find it hard enough to keep up let alone your casual boxing fan

It's a farse and partially the reason MMA has become so popular in recent years. The politics of boxing has really damaged the sport.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 12 Sep 16 4.02pm

Best way is to see who holds the ring magazine, which is a select few at the moment. That's why I hope the public gets behind crolla as he actually wants to be no1 in his division and willing to fight the best.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 12 Sep 16 4.06pm

Originally posted by rikz

Best way is to see who holds the ring magazine, which is a select few at the moment. That's why I hope the public gets behind crolla as he actually wants to be no1 in his division and willing to fight the best.

Just stay away from the burglars.

I do wish Ring magazine, or some other organisation, could usurp the other bodies and bring a collective agreement of who is the world champion at any weight.

 


Optimistic as ever

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 12 Sep 16 5.07pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

Triple GGG's movement will be too much for Brook alas...GGG in 5

Wonder what the odds were?

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Stuk Flag Top half 12 Sep 16 5.17pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

Wonder what the odds were?

Not a lot. 8s I think it was.

Brook was 66/1 in any round.

 


Optimistic as ever

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Brook vs golovkin