You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 3-5-2 formation, God I hate it.....
November 16 2026 10.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

3-5-2 formation, God I hate it.....


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
Icepick Tony Flag Chester 23 Jan 17 11.33pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Glorious

Just when you thought he couldn't raise the bar any higher...this guy is top class. I bet he can suck himself off.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Bangell Flag Oxford 23 Jan 17 11.41pm

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

Just when you thought he couldn't raise the bar any higher...this guy is top class. I bet he can suck himself off.

You mean he tells people that he can suck himself off, when in reality he just about managed to lick the tip after 2 weeks of daily stretching back at age 14

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 23 Jan 17 11.52pm

Originally posted by Bangell

You mean he tells people that he can suck himself off, when in reality he just about managed to lick the tip after 2 weeks of daily stretching back at age 14

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Geoff Thomas Flag Tonbridge - 24 Jan 17 8.39am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Are you ever going to say anything positive. I thought the system worked really well for us today and we almost got a point against a very good everton side who put 4 past city last week. What was more important to me was that every player gave 10% today and were shattered at the end. Something I haven't seen for a long while. If we play like we did today against the 'lower ' reams I feel confident we will pick up points.

Really? We created so little? Need to give it a go against the crap teams.
Everton hardly broke a sweat and still could have won comfortably only for Hennessey finding that he had arms for once.
Everton are a good team but over the past couple of seasons, we would have got stuck in to them and not let them settle!
That's where we are falling down defeatist attitude and trying not to lose instead of trying to win.
BFS would have been happy with a point which sums it up!
Face the truth we are doomed unless the attitude changes. Don't give a s*** about going down, but with a whimper is a joke.
If and when we do let's weed out these lacklustre players and get in fighters.

GT

 


Eagles S*** on Seagulls, Eagles S*** on Seagulls,
La La La La,!
La La La La!

mattteo Flag 24 Jan 17 8.39am

Originally posted by Bangell

You mean he tells people that he can suck himself off, when in reality he just about managed to lick the tip after 2 weeks of daily stretching back at age 14

This takes intelligence to a whole new level on this forum.

Is this the type of joke that cracks you up and you make every day?

 

mattteo Flag 24 Jan 17 8.42am

Originally posted by Bangell

Glorious

Yeah, because we should just bow down to the Gods they are and acknowledge that they hold the ultimate truths )

 

Painter Flag Croydon 24 Jan 17 8.55am

Originally posted by Bangell

You mean he tells people that he can suck himself off, when in reality he just about managed to lick the tip after 2 weeks of daily stretching back at age 14

You are very disrespectful to a contributor of such wisdom and knowledge. It's pretty clear that opportunities in life have passed him by and he yearns acceptance and praise of his undoubted knowledge on forums, as he cannot apply them in real life.

 

mattteo Flag 24 Jan 17 10.00am

Originally posted by Painter

You are very disrespectful to a contributor of such wisdom and knowledge. It's pretty clear that opportunities in life have passed him by and he yearns acceptance and praise of his undoubted knowledge on forums, as he cannot apply them in real life.

)))
I don't yearn anything. Really, not on this forum. And if I do want to be proven right.....don't we all actually?

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 24 Jan 17 10.07am

So if Patrick Van Aanholt joins where does Jeffrey Schlupp play?

At the moment our 3 CBs are:
Dann
Damo
Tompkins

LWB Schlupp
RWB Ward (i hope we can still make a deal for jenkinson)

CDM:Cabaye
CDM:McArthur

AM:Punch

STenteke
ST:Remy

Come to think about it where does zaha play?

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 24 Jan 17 10.20am

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

So if Patrick Van Aanholt joins where does Jeffrey Schlupp play?

At the moment our 3 CBs are:
Dann
Damo
Tompkins

LWB Schlupp
RWB Ward (i hope we can still make a deal for jenkinson)

CDM:Cabaye
CDM:McArthur

AM:Punch

STenteke
ST:Remy

Come to think about it where does zaha play?

I think you'll find that formation was an expedient, based on the players available, and won't be seen very often. Expect 4-4-2- or 4-4-3 when Zaha is back. If we sign PVA, expect to see Schlupp and him on the left and Zaha on the right, with the real question being, where does Townsend fit in?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 24 Jan 17 10.24am

Originally posted by bexleydave

I think you'll find that formation was an expedient, based on the players available, and won't be seen very often. Expect 4-4-2- or 4-4-3 when Zaha is back. If we sign PVA, expect to see Schlupp and him on the left and Zaha on the right, with the real question being, where does Townsend fit in?

Ok cheers

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 24 Jan 17 10.50am

Originally posted by bexleydave

I think you'll find that formation was an expedient, based on the players available, and won't be seen very often. Expect 4-4-2- or 4-4-3 when Zaha is back. If we sign PVA, expect to see Schlupp and him on the left and Zaha on the right, with the real question being, where does Townsend fit in?

Snuggled up on the bench in between Mutch and a.n.other....

ready to sprint a few times for a ball going out for a goal kick in the last 5 mins.

Or in a prosperous suburb of Newcastle.

 


COYP

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 24 Jan 17 11.21am

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

Ok cheers


Don't quote me on it though

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

budapest cpfc Flag Wien 24 Jan 17 11.32am

I agree with you on the 4-4-2 but please explain our we can play 4-4-3 unless we play without a keeper, if we can get away with it i'm up for it maybe we can win a game or two with 12.

Originally posted by bexleydave

I think you'll find that formation was an expedient, based on the players available, and won't be seen very often. Expect 4-4-2- or 4-4-3 when Zaha is back. If we sign PVA, expect to see Schlupp and him on the left and Zaha on the right, with the real question being, where does Townsend fit in?

 

mattteo Flag 24 Jan 17 11.49am

Originally posted by budapest cpfc

I agree with you on the 4-4-2 but please explain our we can play 4-4-3 unless we play without a keeper, if we can get away with it i'm up for it maybe we can win a game or two with 12.


4-3-3 would work best

Use Puncheon as a playmaker in front of defense, like Pirlo played when he got older or like Kroos played for Real Madrid. Most teams usually play the defensive midfielder right in front of the defence and the rather more technical CM a little above him. But the defensive midfielder doesn't really take the ball out of his own half as he should. I've noticed that it's better to use the slightly slow, aging clear mind playmaker there. Being the holding midfielder is not that much about pace, but about covering space and closing down passing possibilities.

The reason why I'd play Punceon lower is because McArthur has proven to be a box-to-box goal scorer (at least this season and he has the momentum). So I'd have him appear behind Benteke and Cabaye in the opposing box on Palace's attacks in order to finalize.

Henessey/Mandanda
?, Tomkins, Dann, van Aanholt
Puncheon
Zaha, McArthur, Cabaye, Townnsend/Schlupp
Benteke

Kind of like a 4-3-3 if you count McArthur, Puncheon and Cabaye to be the midfield.Having Remy instead of Cabaye would be too risky, as Cabaye does run, press and closes spaces, while a striker is doesn't know how to close spaces so well. Maybe Remy instead of Benteke.

 

mattteo Flag 24 Jan 17 12.06pm

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

So if Patrick Van Aanholt joins where does Jeffrey Schlupp play?

At the moment our 3 CBs are:
Dann
Damo
Tompkins

LWB Schlupp
RWB Ward (i hope we can still make a deal for jenkinson)

CDM:Cabaye
CDM:McArthur

AM:Punch

STenteke
ST:Remy

Come to think about it where does zaha play?


How about these players instead of Jenkinson?

van der Wiel- lost his place in Fenerbahce after being brought in from PSg on a free transfer. The Turkish manager is insane preferring the Turkish Ozbayrakli there, I rate van der Wiel among the best 5 right defenders in Europe. He was absolutely spectacular for PSG and Ajax. A little underwhelming for the national team, but still....

Figueiras- was very appreciated in Sevilla, but left because he wanted to play and Mariano (who is equally amazing) was playing ahead of him. He is now with Olympiakos where he is the starting right back and doing great (1 goal and 3 assists in the league), but the Greeks couldn't refuse an offer of around 2,5-3 million from a Premier League team if it wanted him. That's much less than what Jenkinson would cost and I dare say for more quality

Ricardo Esgaio- this guy would be very cheap, Sporting would sell him for 1-2 million. He has been 3rd choice so far, promoted to second choice now that the old J. Perreira has left. He's still young. I know him since he was one of the best right midfielders for Sporting B. Didn't manage to get into the first team as a midfielder because there was tremendous competition, but was further trained as a right back and got into the Portugal U20 and U21 team as such. Watched him in the U21 Euro 2 years ago and he was amazing for Portugal. Him and Raphael Guerreiro really pushed the game up for the Portuguese. Raphael Guerreiro is in Dortmund with Borussia, someone should take this guy too. Now is the time, he has had 2-3 years to settle as a right back, he learnt what was necessary defensively.

Smolnikov- now Zenit usually sells for very big numbers, but lately they have had some financial trouble and have only brought in low cost players. They brought in another Russian right back and the starting one this half of season had been Anyukov. I'm not very sure how the manager Lucescu rates Smolnikov because he was also injured, but if he has recovered and is not in the manager's plans he should be picked up by a good side fast. He was one of the best right backs in the Champions League and in European football in the past 5 years.

Yedlin- now if you have some cash to splash this is your player. He has played great every time I watched him. Could have gotten him for 4-5 million in the summer. Now I think he'd cost 7-8 million. Still, Benitez rates Anita higher and mostly plays him as right back, but Yedlin has 5 assists and 1 goal in the Championship this season. And he's a right back!! Him and van Aanholt saved Sunderland's ass last season, together with Borini and Defore. This season Sunderland suffers tremendously without him


Edited by mattteo (24 Jan 2017 12.09pm)

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 24 Jan 17 12.43pm

Originally posted by budapest cpfc

I agree with you on the 4-4-2 but please explain our we can play 4-4-3 unless we play without a keeper, if we can get away with it i'm up for it maybe we can win a game or two with 12.


Apologies, 4-3-3 (just a typo).

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 24 Jan 17 4.18pm

Originally posted by mattteo


How about these players instead of Jenkinson?

van der Wiel- lost his place in Fenerbahce after being brought in from PSg on a free transfer. The Turkish manager is insane preferring the Turkish Ozbayrakli there, I rate van der Wiel among the best 5 right defenders in Europe. He was absolutely spectacular for PSG and Ajax. A little underwhelming for the national team, but still....

Figueiras- was very appreciated in Sevilla, but left because he wanted to play and Mariano (who is equally amazing) was playing ahead of him. He is now with Olympiakos where he is the starting right back and doing great (1 goal and 3 assists in the league), but the Greeks couldn't refuse an offer of around 2,5-3 million from a Premier League team if it wanted him. That's much less than what Jenkinson would cost and I dare say for more quality

Ricardo Esgaio- this guy would be very cheap, Sporting would sell him for 1-2 million. He has been 3rd choice so far, promoted to second choice now that the old J. Perreira has left. He's still young. I know him since he was one of the best right midfielders for Sporting B. Didn't manage to get into the first team as a midfielder because there was tremendous competition, but was further trained as a right back and got into the Portugal U20 and U21 team as such. Watched him in the U21 Euro 2 years ago and he was amazing for Portugal. Him and Raphael Guerreiro really pushed the game up for the Portuguese. Raphael Guerreiro is in Dortmund with Borussia, someone should take this guy too. Now is the time, he has had 2-3 years to settle as a right back, he learnt what was necessary defensively.

Smolnikov- now Zenit usually sells for very big numbers, but lately they have had some financial trouble and have only brought in low cost players. They brought in another Russian right back and the starting one this half of season had been Anyukov. I'm not very sure how the manager Lucescu rates Smolnikov because he was also injured, but if he has recovered and is not in the manager's plans he should be picked up by a good side fast. He was one of the best right backs in the Champions League and in European football in the past 5 years.

Yedlin- now if you have some cash to splash this is your player. He has played great every time I watched him. Could have gotten him for 4-5 million in the summer. Now I think he'd cost 7-8 million. Still, Benitez rates Anita higher and mostly plays him as right back, but Yedlin has 5 assists and 1 goal in the Championship this season. And he's a right back!! Him and van Aanholt saved Sunderland's ass last season, together with Borini and Defore. This season Sunderland suffers tremendously without him


Edited by mattteo (24 Jan 2017 12.09pm)

They could be good but i just prefer jenkinson

 

essetwentyone Flag london 25 Jan 17 11.39am

In our current position I imagine that Sam wants players that he knows and trusts and who have Premiership experience - any other targets can wait till the end of the season.

As for the Topic of 3-5-2 I don't think we will be using that system in every game. That system suited against Everton purely down to the players available but depending on who we manage to buy I'll bet that Sam varies it in future games depending on the opposition and who we have available.

 

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 3-5-2 formation, God I hate it.....