You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Trident
November 22 2026 12.00am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Trident


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
Stirlingsays Flag 26 Apr 17 10.22pm

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

What would Russia or China want to blackmail us over? Stop buying cheap tat from us and we'll bomb you? Stop laundering our money through London property and we'll nuke you?

You do make a good point about having nukes to stop people messing with you. A quick check on history since 1980 will show who attacks countries that can't defend themselves with nukes.

Russia and China certainly aren't peaceful, but I say again, where's the threat to us that's worth spending another £200+ billion on?

Edited by Mr_Gristle (26 Apr 2017 10.07pm)

Really you can't think of the obvious?

The most obvious is at a time of war or warning of a war with another country, for example a Nato country. 'You move your troops here, in defence of **** and we shall regard it as an act of war and respond as we see fit'.

The point of the nuclear deterrent is always to do with the most extreme situations. It is to deter them from happening....to promote 'jaw jaw and not war war'.

Essentially it's the bully in the playground. You can't compete with me physically so I'm going to tell you what you can and can't do when the sh-t hits the fan.

The fact that you can't see this is beyond me. Reagan closed this argument down decades ago yet here we are in this country undergoing CND mark 2.


Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2017 10.30pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Apr 17 9.54am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

I agree with this, but I can't really see Nato or Russia using strategic nuclear weapons even against an overwhelming conventional force. Russia as the USSR had a no first strike policy, and that was dropped at the end of the USSR but its tactical plan in response to an attack would probably be to use Taccy Nukes against forces that crossed in to Russia. I think tactical nuclear weapons could be used defensively but its hard to see anyone who has both the capability and the desire to get in to a situation that could escalate to that level.

If the cold war had turned hot, it would have likely been NATO that would have used nuclear / chemical and or Biological weapons first. Realistically, to deal with the numerical superiority of the Soviet war machine.

NATOs conventional capacity to resist the Red Army was really about trying to hold as much ground as possible until they could be reinforced by the US. In order to achieve that NATO would probably need to use mass casualty weapons to reduce the soviet capacity to overrun and encircle western forces.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Apr 17 9.59am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

It's fine to speculate on probabilities but no one sensible would ever design a defence system on what you think the other side would do.

You design a system that could punish if attacked....they do the same and hence you have stalemate.

Hence no world wars for two and half generations.

Well that's actually how trident was envisioned. Its design and processes are all built around what the Soviet could potentially achieve. Trident is designed specifically so that even if everyone in the UK was wiped out in a surprise attack.

The only way to stop Trident, is to sink the submarines. And to do that you have to know where they are, at any given time.

We couldn't destroy the Soviet, but we could inflict such horrific causalities and damage in response that it was a effectively assured destruction.

Its about a fail safe as a system as could be devised.

Although thinking about it, Trident was more about what the other side was capable of doing. I'd argue that our place on the Security Council pretty much is based on being a nuclear nation (same as France).

Edited by jamiemartin721 (27 Apr 2017 10.01am)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 27 Apr 17 11.23am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Well that's actually how trident was envisioned. Its design and processes are all built around what the Soviet could potentially achieve. Trident is designed specifically so that even if everyone in the UK was wiped out in a surprise attack.

The only way to stop Trident, is to sink the submarines. And to do that you have to know where they are, at any given time.

We couldn't destroy the Soviet, but we could inflict such horrific causalities and damage in response that it was a effectively assured destruction.

Its about a fail safe as a system as could be devised.

Although thinking about it, Trident was more about what the other side was capable of doing. I'd argue that our place on the Security Council pretty much is based on being a nuclear nation (same as France).

Edited by jamiemartin721 (27 Apr 2017 10.01am)

There is nothing safe about nuclear submarines there have been 22 major accidents since year 2000 thats only the ones that we can find out about.

You have to consider the other nuclear submarines out there from other countries its like 'underwater dodgems'.

Despite what you say the impression you give of professionalism is not the real world where anything nuclear can and does go wrong.

We are probably only here because Russian commanders would not carry out their orders to fire missiles during the Cuba crisis and under Andropov where they panicked thinking they had only minutes from an American attack.

The sooner we are not on the UN security council the better for what use it is, then we can evaluate a cheaper and more effective system based on our needs and not an ego trip based on the power we no longer are.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 27 Apr 17 11.36am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Well that's actually how trident was envisioned. Its design and processes are all built around what the Soviet could potentially achieve. Trident is designed specifically so that even if everyone in the UK was wiped out in a surprise attack.

The only way to stop Trident, is to sink the submarines. And to do that you have to know where they are, at any given time.

We couldn't destroy the Soviet, but we could inflict such horrific causalities and damage in response that it was a effectively assured destruction.

Its about a fail safe as a system as could be devised.

Although thinking about it, Trident was more about what the other side was capable of doing. I'd argue that our place on the Security Council pretty much is based on being a nuclear nation (same as France).

Edited by jamiemartin721 (27 Apr 2017 10.01am)

I agree.

Whatever the system we use it has to go along with this general principle. The main threats are still Russia and definitely China, which is investing considerably in its military in a bid to compete with the US.

We can't compete on the same terms but we must be able to inflict a significant cost for attacking us. As we can't shield ourselves that's the only deterrent option.

As the technology exists turning our eyes away from it doesn't help us and isn't an option. We are only a support anyway.

Reagan ultimately proved that if you win the economic battle and hence the technological....then that makes the military race unsustainable.

I hope that reductions can be secured in the future but I know that this can only be done from a position of strength, not weakness.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Trident