This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Sportyteacher
What about any of the following: Suchan You (From Vol: 3 1960s release) Will grab m'coat... You forgot 'Return To Blender' and 'The Wonder Of Stew'.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Yeah, but the girls didn't.....And while Orbison was a great, he was no Elvis. Elvis had it all and that's why he brings it even forty years afterwards. Like the Beatles....some gold, never gets old. Well both Elvis and Roy had career ups and downs; they both fell from the limelight from time to time. Roy from about '65 to a late career revival in the 80s with some stellar companions. Elvis has a very lean period between '64 and '68 and again from about 72 until his death. I don't agree that "Elvis had it all", he wasn't a musician or songwriter, yes he was a charismatic performer in the early days but after the comeback in '68 he gradually became a shambling wreck of a human being, so much more a tragedy given his earlier physical appeal.
I used to be immortal |
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
I don't agree that "Elvis had it all", he wasn't a musician or songwriter, yes he was a charismatic performer in the early days but after the comeback in '68 he gradually became a shambling wreck of a human being, so much more a tragedy given his earlier physical appeal. Well, Elvis was a musician, you should really know that, but no not a songwriter. When I said he had it all I was talking about voice, statue, looks, personality, sex appeal and front man ability. The minute most people saw him they recognised genuine x-factor times ten. Orbison isn't still making 55 million dollars a year (2015) like Elvis. Old Roy was good, but he was on a different level to Elvis on most of those attributes in the first paragraph. Orbison had a great voice and is responsible for co-writing some rock n roll classics...it's not exactly criticism.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
What was his last hit?
When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC |
|
|
I like Elvis - must be an age thing - if I had to pick one then Jailhouse Rock.
|
|
| wordup |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Michaelawt85
What was his last hit? The pan
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well, Elvis was a musician, you should really know that, but no not a songwriter. When I said he had it all I was talking about voice, statue, looks, personality, sex appeal and front man ability. The minute most people saw him they recognised genuine x-factor times ten. Orbison isn't still making 55 million dollars a year (2015) like Elvis. Old Roy was good, but he was on a different level to Elvis on most of those attributes in the first paragraph. Orbison had a great voice and is responsible for co-writing some rock n roll classics...it's not exactly criticism. Elvis wasn't a musician, could barely strum an acoustic guitar and never played on any of his records. And the majority of the money his estate makes is from Graceland ticket sales, not from anything to do with actual music. Roy's estate benefits from songwriting royalties mainly, as he wrote some classic songs that are still generating millions each year. Elvis obviously had sex appeal and charisma, Roy hid behind his dark glasses and sang his heart out. Elvis was somewhere in a venn diagram of the talents of Roy and Little Richard, a great star rather than a great musical talent.
I used to be immortal |
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
Elvis wasn't a musician, could barely strum an acoustic guitar and never played on any of his records. And the majority of the money his estate makes is from Graceland ticket sales, not from anything to do with actual music. Roy's estate benefits from songwriting royalties mainly, as he wrote some classic songs that are still generating millions each year. Elvis obviously had sex appeal and charisma, Roy hid behind his dark glasses and sang his heart out. Elvis was somewhere in a venn diagram of the talents of Roy and Little Richard, a great star rather than a great musical talent. Outside of singing I don't think Elvis was a 'great musical talent' no....But it's very harsh not to consider Elvis a musician. Elvis was fine on the guitar and played it most of his life. He also played the piano too. Sure he wasn't the best but most aren't. Also Elvis played on some of his early recordings between 56 and 58. Some of that was 'credited' just to get the extra cash but other musicians confirm he wasn't bad and there is very strong evidence he played on recordings such as 'Baby I Don’t Care'. Elvis used the guitar less as the sixties went on. As for how the money is made....? People go to Elvis's birthday because it's Elvis....The fact remains that he makes far more than Roy for his estate.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
Elvis wasn't a musician, could barely strum an acoustic guitar and never played on any of his records. And the majority of the money his estate makes is from Graceland ticket sales, not from anything to do with actual music. Roy's estate benefits from songwriting royalties mainly, as he wrote some classic songs that are still generating millions each year. Elvis obviously had sex appeal and charisma, Roy hid behind his dark glasses and sang his heart out. Elvis was somewhere in a venn diagram of the talents of Roy and Little Richard, a great star rather than a great musical talent. Just a brief google and you'd know this is not true.
|
|
|
Originally posted by chris123
Just a brief google and you'd know this is not true. I'm not sure which point you're suggesting is not true, but it's clear that Elvis never played on any of his records or wrote any of the songs he sang. Here's an interesting article quoting some of the musicians who did play on his later records, including the great guitarist James Burton. I saw all these guys backing Emmylou Harris live in London a couple of times in the mid 70's they were pretty good musicians. The guys who played on his early rock'n'roll records did all the heavy work, while Elvis strummed an acoustic guitar off-mike! Most people who hang out with musicians can eventually strum a guitar or pick out chords on the piano; they do it to relieve the boredom, doesn't make them musicians any more than having a driving licence makes me a formula one driver!
I used to be immortal |
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
I'm not sure which point you're suggesting is not true, but it's clear that Elvis never played on any of his records or wrote any of the songs he sang. Here's an interesting article quoting some of the musicians who did play on his later records, including the great guitarist James Burton. I saw all these guys backing Emmylou Harris live in London a couple of times in the mid 70's they were pretty good musicians. The guys who played on his early rock'n'roll records did all the heavy work, while Elvis strummed an acoustic guitar off-mike! Most people who hang out with musicians can eventually strum a guitar or pick out chords on the piano; they do it to relieve the boredom, doesn't make them musicians any more than having a driving licence makes me a formula one driver!
|
|
|
Originally posted by chris123
To quote your link "perhaps the lack of a mike on his playing" lead people to believe he was not a musician!
I used to be immortal |
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
40 years ago. I remember this more than the Lewisham riots. Me Aunty Pam cried for days. A legend who bought black music to the masses in an acceptable (notwithstanding the hips) way.
In The Ghetto is one I've always late. Liked the Evening News. Wouldn't touch the Standard and still dislike it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by matthau
Who cares re musician. The guy could outsing anyone and had charisma in droves. There's not many male singers women go crazy for and men love their music too. He was unique. Frank skinner said he would've been the only guy he'd let his wife sleep with to find out after what it was like. Lol Orbisons voice was special too. Edited by matthau (17 Aug 2017 11.31pm) There were plenty of others who followed Elvis with charisma too, perhaps this guy was one of them? Edited by crystal balls (17 Aug 2017 11.40pm)
I used to be immortal |
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
To quote your link "perhaps the lack of a mike on his playing" lead people to believe he was not a musician! And this
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
You forgot 'Return To Blender' and 'The Wonder Of Stew'. Very good,Hrolf. Keeping to the cake theme, it inspired Elvis to produce a number of cover versions of classics including: Yule Log Never Walk Alone
|
|
|
Originally posted by Sportyteacher
Very good,Hrolf. Keeping to the cake theme, it inspired Elvis to produce a number of cover versions of classics including: Yule Log Never Walk Alone I prefer 'American Grillogy'. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (18 Aug 2017 10.25am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I prefer 'American Grillogy'. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (18 Aug 2017 10.25am) Very good again. You've just raised the steaks...
|
|
|
Originally posted by jimruss
Glad it's not just me that doesn't get all the hype around Elvis, awful boring music. Maybe if I was born in the Elvis era I'd feel differently. Although I'd say the same about the Beatles as well About sums him up for me too jim.I was born in 1950 so maybe you wouldn`t feel differently. I was never a great fan of the Beatles either, though I wouldn`t call them awful and boring.
Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link] |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.