You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wilf potential ban?
November 16 2026 7.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Wilf potential ban?


Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4
spartakev2 Flag Anerley 01 Jan 18 4.56pm

Wilf wad in front of Stelling and if he hadn't been fouled would have been one on one with thd keeper and or baby score. Whh on earth would he dive?

 

cp forever Flag south london 01 Jan 18 5.20pm

Just when I thought the whole discussion in the media would be about Puncheon's tackle it turns out to be a really nasty attack on Wilfred, the incident was just in front of my spot in the Holmesdale, it was at speed and no way a dive...the only shock was that having seen Wilf brought down so often without any free kick or penalty, couldn't believe it was given especially by Moss.
My goodness who would have expected such vitriol from some of the most boring and tedious commentators alive, at least MOD gave proper thought and reason to it all and showed respect for what the team achieved. Although Wilfred gets some proper recognition these days this shows he is still vulnerable to being targeted for criticism which feels like an attack on Palace.
We just were not supposed to be showing Man City up were we and once the cry goes out they all follow..

 

wwarr009 Flag 01 Jan 18 5.30pm

I liked the dive he did earlier in the game where he just threw himself on the floor for no reason ha

 


Beans beans there good for your heart, the more you eat the more you fart, the more you fart the more you eat the more you sit on the toilet seat

eag-les Flag Coulsdon 02 Jan 18 2.45pm

Originally posted by essetwentyone

Statistics show Wilf to be one of the most fouled players in the Prem and that doesn’t include the countless fouls we all see but are not penalised by refs. Is it any surprise that he anticipates these fouls and goes down to ensure they are penalised ? The opposition know that they can’t leave him alone because then he would destroy them so they lean on him and he goes down - and that is a foul and a pen in the area.
Basically he’s just too good for them and long may it last !!
The views of has beens like Poll and Sutton are totally irrelevant

Graham "How many cards did I give him" Poll
Chris "Common assault" Sutton
Michael"I never dived against Argentina" Owen
What a f****** nerve
They aint got a clue!

 


If I agreed with you we'd both be wrong

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 02 Jan 18 3.12pm

Originally posted by Sayer

Graham Poll was giving it some on BT about it being classed as dive


Did he deem it worthy of the third yellow?

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

taylors lovechild Flag 02 Jan 18 4.37pm

I still don't really get this one. I really did not see it as a dive, full stop. Sterling clearly infringed his passage and Zaha went down with no exaggeration. Based on the referee allowing Walker to push Zaha over every time he went past him I was surprised that he gave it, but I still can't work out why people are saying it was a dive? Having a referee in the studio does highlight how incompetent they can be even with television replays though.

 

twist Flag Miami, Florida 02 Jan 18 5.52pm

Fact is, players go down easy all over the field because if they didnt, the ref likely would not blow up. Same in the penalty area, if wilf is fouled enough to put him off a good shot/pass and he didnt go down, it wouldnt be a penalty, so he goes down expecting one, and thats when the ref is forced into a decision.

Theres a difference between going down easy, and a dive.

 

bicycle repair man 02 Jan 18 6.55pm

Before big mouth Poll goes shooting his mouth off I suggest he looks at players like Kane or Ali who are continually diving, but the pundits call it being "clever".Apart from the fact they are not adverse to dishing out career threatening tackles,which no one seems bothered about.
I'm a bit tired of Wilf being victimised and demonized every time he's awarded a penalty,and therefore in future referees will be prejudiced against him.
I was about 20 yards away from the incident and I knew straight away it was a foul,and the ref had no hesitation at all.It never occured to me that such a fuss would be made by sensationalist ex-players and duff has-been referees who should know better.


 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 02 Jan 18 7.34pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

Before big mouth Poll goes shooting his mouth off I suggest he looks at players like Kane or Ali who are continually diving, but the pundits call it being "clever".Apart from the fact they are not adverse to dishing out career threatening tackles,which no one seems bothered about.
I'm a bit tired of Wilf being victimised and demonized every time he's awarded a penalty,and therefore in future referees will be prejudiced against him.
I was about 20 yards away from the incident and I knew straight away it was a foul,and the ref had no hesitation at all.It never occured to me that such a fuss would be made by sensationalist ex-players and duff has-been referees who should know better.



I was really enjoying this post of yours until you want us to believe 'career threatening tackles that nobody cares about'. Where do you live?

Edited by adrian b (02 Jan 2018 7.35pm)

 

bicycle repair man 02 Jan 18 7.58pm

Originally posted by adrian b


I was really enjoying this post of yours until you want us to believe 'career threatening tackles that nobody cares about'. Where do you live?

Edited by adrian b (02 Jan 2018 7.35pm)

When the two recent horrific tackles by Kane & Ali were highlighted on MOTD by one of the pundits, Lineker said we don't want to talk about that,let's just talk about the football,imagine if Puncheon had commited a foul as bad as one of theirs,he'd have been hung , drawn & quartered.

 

batcountry Flag Melbourne 02 Jan 18 11.42pm

I think Wilf proved today that he really doesn’t go down easy. He went to extraordinary lengths to stay on his feet against some pretty agricultural defending.

 

boo909 Flag Figeac 02 Jan 18 11.57pm

Originally posted by batcountry

I think Wilf proved today that he really doesn’t go down easy. He went to extraordinary lengths to stay on his feet against some pretty agricultural defending.

I've criticised him in the past for going down too easy but I have to admit he really was trying to stay on his feet this match and holding off on the moaning at the ref. Hopefully something good will come out of the recent criticism and he's turned a corner on that aspect of his game.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

eagleide Flag London 03 Jan 18 12.51am

Wasn't at the match today, but MOTD did show an excellent ref decision by awarding Sako a free kick (which led to our first goal) after the ref allowed Sako a chance for advantage, before pulling it back. Just saying, credit where it's due.
Still believe Wilf has to be assaulted before a free kick is to be given for him, and sitting in holmesdale upper the foul by Sterling did look a foul.

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 03 Jan 18 8.25am

It was a foul - the ref gave it.

I don't see how you can say that Wilf has to be assaulted in one sentence and then talk about "that" decision in the same thread.

The referees call it how they see it - either give them all the tools at their disposal, or accept that they are going to get it wrong sometimes - video refereeing will see more right decisions being made, but might reinforce punishments for diving, red cards and the like. Expect to see a rise in sending offs, and less interesting debate about things like this.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 03 Jan 18 8.43am

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

When the two recent horrific tackles by Kane & Ali were highlighted on MOTD by one of the pundits, Lineker said we don't want to talk about that,let's just talk about the football,imagine if Puncheon had commited a foul as bad as one of theirs,he'd have been hung , drawn & quartered.

The fact those two tackles are being discussed here and had been mentioned on telly means people do care. Get it? Linker is right, MOTD is about using limited tine to accentuate the positive.
I saw last night's MOTD where an incident concerning a player on the bench and spectators was being hi-lighted. I watch for the football and not side shows. I don't care how a manager reacts to a missed chance. The cameras leave the field of play to scan the face of a ball-boy. Not the way to go, and I think Linaker knows it.

Edited by adrian b (03 Jan 2018 8.43am)

Edited by adrian b (03 Jan 2018 8.44am)

 

bicycle repair man 04 Jan 18 9.27am

After seeing the blatant diving by Wilshere and Hazard last night,I'm expecting Graham Poll,Chris Sutton & all to call for them to be banned.
They were quick enough to demonize Wild.

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 04 Jan 18 10.28am

Ain't that the truth! The more cameras around the pitch the worse the shown footage seems to get. It annoys me massively, the continues zooming around, focussing on stuff around the pitch but also on players while the game is flowing. You want to see MOVEMENT in an overview, not a close shoot up of a single player even if he has the ball. I genuinely think a lot of football game editors have been educated in the showbusiness and lack knowledge of, and love for the game.

Originally posted by adrian b

The fact those two tackles are being discussed here and had been mentioned on telly means people do care. Get it? Linker is right, MOTD is about using limited tine to accentuate the positive.
I saw last night's MOTD where an incident concerning a player on the bench and spectators was being hi-lighted. I watch for the football and not side shows. I don't care how a manager reacts to a missed chance. The cameras leave the field of play to scan the face of a ball-boy. Not the way to go, and I think Linaker knows it.

Edited by adrian b (03 Jan 2018 8.43am)

Edited by adrian b (03 Jan 2018 8.44am)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 04 Jan 18 12.32pm

The commentators in the Southampton stream I was watching were very keen to point out that there should not be so much focus on Wilf supposedly diving as it may harm what great talent he has. As it goes, I think the negative publicity actually appears to be spurring him on, although I'd rather people stopped regurgitating this myth that he's a diver.

 

Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wilf potential ban?