You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Southgate - Best England Manager since Hoddle
November 22 2026 7.46pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southgate - Best England Manager since Hoddle


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
black eagle. Flag south croydon. 08 Jul 18 12.23pm

I think we look fantastic playing the ball out from the back.

This is the best I have seen from England have looked for years.

No hoof ball, we playing a good position based football but not forgetting things that we are good at like set pieces.

I'm actually excited watching England again and it's all down to Gareth.

Never did I think the very polite Gareth Southgate who i met in a Croydon night club over 20 years ago could actually lift the world cup.

Bring it home Gareth.

Steve Coppell, Terry Venables and co taught you well.

 

johnno42000 Flag 08 Jul 18 1.11pm

Originally posted by black eagle.

I think we look fantastic playing the ball out from the back.

This is the best I have seen from England have looked for years.

No hoof ball, we playing a good position based football but not forgetting things that we are good at like set pieces.

I'm actually excited watching England again and it's all down to Gareth.

Never did I think the very polite Gareth Southgate who i met in a Croydon night club over 20 years ago could actually lift the world cup.

Bring it home Gareth.

Steve Coppell, Terry Venables and co taught you well.

I disagree abut no hoof ball, although others may call it long targeted tactical passing or a Delaney . At least twice in the Sweden match the ball was lumped forward to Sterling and that is not a bad thing.

Mixing the play up is a good thing and keeps the opposition on edge. If you purely play it one way the opposition can counter it , mix it up and they are never too sure.

Edited by johnno42000 (08 Jul 2018 1.21pm)

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 08 Jul 18 1.44pm

What Southgate has done is actually mould these players into a team, which no England manager has achieved since Robson at Italia 90. I heard Rio Ferdinand recently say that, at previous World Cups, he could sense that certain players of the so-called "golden generation" simply didn't really want to be there and I can well believe it.

Peaking with the 2010 World Cup, the England team was stuffed with arrogant, egotistical arseholes, managed by mercenaries and who, almost to a man, were thoroughly unlikeable. Compare that lot to this squad who are young, hungry and not too up themselves to refuse to be guided. Southgate has tapped into this and has instilled not only a degree of pride amongst the players but also a proper team spirit and the intelligence to work to a plan and stick with it. These things don't happen by accident - the person running the team has to take the credit for it.

England are no longer riding on the coat-tails of history - Southgate has actually got these lads believing and that can be like a twelfth man. As he said himself, 'go out there and make your own history'.

England in a World Cup semi final: that alone makes him the most effective England manager since Bobby Robson.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

becky Flag over the moon 08 Jul 18 2.03pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

What Southgate has done is actually mould these players into a team, which no England manager has achieved since Robson at Italia 90. I heard Rio Ferdinand recently say that, at previous World Cups, he could sense that certain players of the so-called "golden generation" simply didn't really want to be there and I can well believe it.

Peaking with the 2010 World Cup, the England team was stuffed with arrogant, egotistical arseholes, managed by mercenaries and who, almost to a man, were thoroughly unlikeable. Compare that lot to this squad who are young, hungry and not too up themselves to refuse to be guided. Southgate has tapped into this and has instilled not only a degree of pride amongst the players but also a proper team spirit and the intelligence to work to a plan and stick with it. These things don't happen by accident - the person running the team has to take the credit for it.

England are no longer riding on the coat-tails of history - Southgate has actually got these lads believing and that can be like a twelfth man. As he said himself, 'go out there and make your own history'.

England in a World Cup semi final: that alone makes him the most effective England manager since Bobby Robson.

If we should make it through and win then it's only him and Alf Ramsey. Sir Gareth has a nice ring to it...

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 08 Jul 18 2.11pm

Originally posted by becky

If we should make it through and win then it's only him and Alf Ramsey. Sir Gareth has a nice ring to it...

He deserves the knighthood for vomiting over Ron Noades - winning the World Cup would be secondary to that.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

mattteo Flag 08 Jul 18 2.42pm

Did he really create a team if we consider the World Cup road with wins against Panama, Tunisia, Sweden and a draw against Colombia?

I mean it's just 4 matches. He could even go all the way against Croatia and 1 more opponent. It would be 6 decent matches, not very relevant. Would he have success in a 38 fixtures season?? It's really hard to say, for all we know it could just be luck.

But I guess that's the beauty of national teams football, it's just 90 minutes to being considered a total success or total failure....
If Tunisia had scored a 2-1 goal instead of England and they'd have gone through while England stayed at home with just 3 points in the group, I think everyone would have called Southgate the worst manager

Edited by mattteo (08 Jul 2018 2.43pm)

 

CB Flag 08 Jul 18 4.50pm

International management is, as you say, very different to club management. Southgate has taken to it and there's buy in and belief from the players. Winning six games in a world cup is not irrelevant and that's a bonkers theory, like being the world no1 in rankings is all well and good but if you can't win a trophy.

 

Pussay Patrol Flag 08 Jul 18 4.55pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Did he really create a team if we consider the World Cup road with wins against Panama, Tunisia, Sweden and a draw against Colombia?

I mean it's just 4 matches. He could even go all the way against Croatia and 1 more opponent. It would be 6 decent matches, not very relevant. Would he have success in a 38 fixtures season?? It's really hard to say, for all we know it could just be luck.

But I guess that's the beauty of national teams football, it's just 90 minutes to being considered a total success or total failure....
If Tunisia had scored a 2-1 goal instead of England and they'd have gone through while England stayed at home with just 3 points in the group, I think everyone would have called Southgate the worst manager

Edited by mattteo (08 Jul 2018 2.43pm)

Sorry to piss on your chips but these are games we have struggled in previously.
Remember 2010? Algeria, Slovenia? USA? The so called EASY group, 2006 we made hard work of beating Trinidad! We couldn't beat Costa Rica 4 years ago, were dire in all these games

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Pussay Patrol Flag 08 Jul 18 5.07pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

What Southgate has done is actually mould these players into a team, which no England manager has achieved since Robson at Italia 90. I heard Rio Ferdinand recently say that, at previous World Cups, he could sense that certain players of the so-called "golden generation" simply didn't really want to be there and I can well believe it.

Peaking with the 2010 World Cup, the England team was stuffed with arrogant, egotistical arseholes, managed by mercenaries and who, almost to a man, were thoroughly unlikeable. Compare that lot to this squad who are young, hungry and not too up themselves to refuse to be guided. Southgate has tapped into this and has instilled not only a degree of pride amongst the players but also a proper team spirit and the intelligence to work to a plan and stick with it. These things don't happen by accident - the person running the team has to take the credit for it.

England are no longer riding on the coat-tails of history - Southgate has actually got these lads believing and that can be like a twelfth man. As he said himself, 'go out there and make your own history'.

England in a World Cup semi final: that alone makes him the most effective England manager since Bobby Robson.

Alot of that has to do with the disastrous idea of recruiting foreign managers, how on earth could they resonate with players about the pride and passion of playing for your country? Crapello couldn't speak English FFS! Was embarrassing being an England fan back then

England manager should be English and there are always plenty of good candidates, they don't have to be top names or proven at club level either as Southgate has proven

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

cryrst Flag The garden of England 08 Jul 18 5.24pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Did he really create a team if we consider the World Cup road with wins against Panama, Tunisia, Sweden and a draw against Colombia?

I mean it's just 4 matches. He could even go all the way against Croatia and 1 more opponent. It would be 6 decent matches, not very relevant. Would he have success in a 38 fixtures season?? It's really hard to say, for all we know it could just be luck.

But I guess that's the beauty of national teams football, it's just 90 minutes to being considered a total success or total failure....
If Tunisia had scored a 2-1 goal instead of England and they'd have gone through while England stayed at home with just 3 points in the group, I think everyone would have called Southgate the worst manager

Edited by mattteo (08 Jul 2018 2.43pm)

Not a guarentee of only 3 points as he wouldn't have made the changes against Belgium, who we may have beaten with a stronger side.
England doing well really seems to annoy some people and then you get all the old chestnuts.
Easy group games, easy run in knockouts, other teams missing players.
You beat what's in front of you.
End of.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 09 Jul 18 1.31pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Did he really create a team if we consider the World Cup road with wins against Panama, Tunisia, Sweden and a draw against Colombia?

I mean it's just 4 matches. He could even go all the way against Croatia and 1 more opponent. It would be 6 decent matches, not very relevant. Would he have success in a 38 fixtures season?? It's really hard to say, for all we know it could just be luck.

But I guess that's the beauty of national teams football, it's just 90 minutes to being considered a total success or total failure....
If Tunisia had scored a 2-1 goal instead of England and they'd have gone through while England stayed at home with just 3 points in the group, I think everyone would have called Southgate the worst manager

Edited by mattteo (08 Jul 2018 2.43pm)

We all know that it isn't luck. We're not a team that has scored wonder goals to win our games, nor relied on one or two mercurial talents to be the game plan. i.e. give it to Messi, Ronaldo, Neymar etc.

Everything has been extensively worked on it seems, from the number of set piece goals we've scored to the notes for the goalkeeper in the penalty shoot out.

 


Optimistic as ever

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Southgate - Best England Manager since Hoddle