You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should Palace prioritise the FA CUP?
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Should Palace prioritise the FA CUP?


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 01 Jan 19 8.14pm

Honestly, us being in the prem and moving out to canada at the same time was a stoke of luck in that i can watch 90% of the games, home or away.

However, i speak for myself, but i reckon a lot can relate - 70% of the season has been either frustration, heart break, anxiety and horrible to watch.

Pardew's first year was amazing - keeping us up and then top 6 at xmas, but after that, his time was a joke and our second season in the prem looked so promising, until Pulis walked. We haven't found our groove since.

Our aim should always be 30 points going into the new year. Currently leicester, wolves, watford, west ham and perhaps brighton are on course for that. Is it too much to ask that we be on that level?? Then, it gives us the breathing room to have some fun in the cup.

If we finished the season on 45 - 50 points each year and never really looked in danger of relegation and continually got to the last 8/4 of the cups, that would be awesome.

5-7 years later you then sit down and think - ok, what next.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Melbourne Eagle Flag Melbourne 07 Jan 19 2.46am

Realistically the 2 cups are the only things we can win, so let's have a go.

We are good enough on our day to win it and a major cup win could help change our club's mentality (slight inferiority complex?) Cup days are dedicated Saturdays now so the extra load is manageable and for the next round at least, gives us a chance to give our bench warmers a run to keep match fit.

I'm all for it, as long as we can avoid dreaded replays.

A Tuesday night in Grimsby in January, for instance.

 

Den1923 Flag 07 Jan 19 2.16pm

I tend to agree the cup's are a bad distraction for a team that needs all its energy to stay in the division and we certainly do not want to risk injury to our few good players (look at the tackle by Fox on Townsend, at the weekend, we were lucky that did not break his leg). We have to concentrate on getting the 40 points or so that we need to stay in PL. Relegation would be a disaster for the club and its finances. As someone said earlier in the post we should be capable of getting 50 points without all this anxiety that we have to endue season on season!

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 07 Jan 19 2.32pm

Originally posted by Vaibow

Honestly, us being in the prem and moving out to canada at the same time was a stoke of luck in that i can watch 90% of the games, home or away.

However, i speak for myself, but i reckon a lot can relate - 70% of the season has been either frustration, heart break, anxiety and horrible to watch.

Pardew's first year was amazing - keeping us up and then top 6 at xmas, but after that, his time was a joke and our second season in the prem looked so promising, until Pulis walked. We haven't found our groove since.

Our aim should always be 30 points going into the new year. Currently leicester, wolves, watford, west ham and perhaps brighton are on course for that. Is it too much to ask that we be on that level?? Then, it gives us the breathing room to have some fun in the cup.

If we finished the season on 45 - 50 points each year and never really looked in danger of relegation and continually got to the last 8/4 of the cups, that would be awesome.

5-7 years later you then sit down and think - ok, what next.

This for me.

All logic states for a smaller club like ours concentrate on the league. But the fans don't like an early exit. The coffers don't like it. And the players hate it and it rocks confidence.

I have heard pundit after pundit saying a good cup run adds nothing to fatigue and provides a real buzz and drive to a squad who are all getting a game and sharing in the collective momentum.

On balance a good cup run has to be a good thing.

 

Den1923 Flag 07 Jan 19 3.02pm

Originally posted by silvertop

This for me.

All logic states for a smaller club like ours concentrate on the league. But the fans don't like an early exit. The coffers don't like it. And the players hate it and it rocks confidence.

I have heard pundit after pundit saying a good cup run adds nothing to fatigue and provides a real buzz and drive to a squad who are all getting a game and sharing in the collective momentum.

On balance a good cup run has to be a good thing.

It did not work out on our last good cup run, we got to the final but did poorly in league from when the cup run started and its was our for in the first half of the season that kept us up that year!

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 07 Jan 19 3.12pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Yeah, another season of dross and a late scramble for 11th. Then wildly over promote our 7th season in the top division.

We're getting relegated eventually, let's take a trophy with us. You can't put the occasional giant killing in a trophy cabinet!

All out for the cup and go down. Championship is a better division with quality away days anyway. Poke modern football.

Don't really disagree in that I have no fear of the Championship -it can be great fun. But right now I'd buy another couple of seasons in the PL just to get the stand done and funded. It may not be a cup but it would be a great legacy of our time at the top.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 07 Jan 19 3.15pm

Originally posted by Den1923

It did not work out on our last good cup run, we got to the final but did poorly in league from when the cup run started and its was our for in the first half of the season that kept us up that year!

Yeah that would be the logic. Thin resources stretched even thinner. One bad injury of a key players in a "pointless " 4th round tie...

However as others have said our circumstances were very different then. Different squad and coaching team horrible injuries incurred in training not the cup etc. Maybe lessons learned?

The cup still has value oversea and winning it for a club our size literally puts us on the map and boosts non Tv revenue.

Always a trade off but on balance...

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 07 Jan 19 3.21pm

Originally posted by Omph

Don't really disagree in that I have no fear of the Championship -it can be great fun. But right now I'd buy another couple of seasons in the PL just to get the stand done and funded. It may not be a cup but it would be a great legacy of our time at the top.


Wasn't it supposed to be "funded" by ring-fenced monies from our US owners, or was that 'fake news'?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

matt23 Flag Crawley 07 Jan 19 4.00pm

Originally posted by Omph

Don't really disagree in that I have no fear of the Championship -it can be great fun. But right now I'd buy another couple of seasons in the PL just to get the stand done and funded. It may not be a cup but it would be a great legacy of our time at the top.

Yeah when I am lying on my death bed in however many years time who wants to be reminicising about that fabulous day at Wembley when we won the Fa cup and the european matches the following season when I can just say to my son, at least you have a lovely stand to sit in!!!!!

 

chateauferret Flag 07 Jan 19 10.59pm

I was bang up for the cup this year until I saw the last four left in the fourth round draw. Citeh, U*****d, Spurs and us.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 07 Jan 19 11.10pm

That's what I thought ... it won't be this year we're doomed!

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Omph Flag Liverpool 08 Jan 19 9.11am

Point taken.

This may be naive but I can't help but think that the ring fenced money is money that may otherwise be invested in the playing side. In any event whichever way you look at it the stand needs to be paid for and prem money is the likeliest way of achieving that.

If we went down in the meantime the financial squeeze would really be on - generous though parachute payments are. A couple more years of prem money would go a long way to covering the costs and mean we would be on an even keel when we do go down. (To me we feel like West Brom and Stoke a couple of seasons before they imploded - too many journeymen prem players on inflated salaries and too close to FFP limits).

Originally posted by bexleydave


Wasn't it supposed to be "funded" by ring-fenced monies from our US owners, or was that 'fake news'?

Edited by Omph (08 Jan 2019 10.34am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 08 Jan 19 9.36am

Originally posted by Omph

Point taken.

This may be naive but I can't help but think that the ring fenced money is money that may otherwise be invested in the playing side. In any event whichever way you look at tithe stand needs to be paid for and prep money is the likeliest way of achieving that.

If we went down in the meantime the financial squeeze would really be on generous through parachute payments are. A couple more years of prem money would go a long way to covering the costs and mean we would be on an even keel when we do go down. (To me we feel like West Brom and Stoke a couple of seasons before they imploded - too many journey men prem players inflated salaries).


You roughly get to spend up to £40 mil on transfers every summer, if your wages aren’t bloated or the prospects aren’t being mercenary, and that’s just to stand still. If we spent nothing for 1 season let alone 2 we’re likely to be relegated. The way we have to do it is either as it was planned. A director buy in or bank loan or director loans. That way it can be paid off on over a longer timeframe than 2 years or when those owners sell the club onto someone who can’t be bothered with a complete overhaul of the club. What we’re doing is quite pathetic seeing how rich the Americans are, what was claimed when they bought in with 2010’s shares reduced to issue some of that share to the Americans and the £100mil buy in ringfenced for the new stand. It really does make you wonder and suspect how much we’re flying by the seat of our pants and what we’d actually be doing if we didn’t have Zaha and Popovic recommending us Jedinak plus whoever spotted Bolasie and Delaney suddenly becoming available after the season had started and he was about to retire because we wouldn’t have been promoted and would probably still pretending to run as a professional football club.

 


COYP

Omph Flag Liverpool 08 Jan 19 10.51am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You roughly get to spend up to £40 mil on transfers every summer, if your wages aren’t bloated or the prospects aren’t being mercenary, and that’s just to stand still. If we spent nothing for 1 season let alone 2 we’re likely to be relegated. The way we have to do it is either as it was planned. A director buy in or bank loan or director loans. That way it can be paid off on over a longer timeframe than 2 years or when those owners sell the club onto someone who can’t be bothered with a complete overhaul of the club. What we’re doing is quite pathetic seeing how rich the Americans are, what was claimed when they bought in with 2010’s shares reduced to issue some of that share to the Americans and the £100mil buy in ringfenced for the new stand. It really does make you wonder and suspect how much we’re flying by the seat of our pants and what we’d actually be doing if we didn’t have Zaha and Popovic recommending us Jedinak plus whoever spotted Bolasie and Delaney suddenly becoming available after the season had started and he was about to retire because we wouldn’t have been promoted and would probably still pretending to run as a professional football club.

I think that depends on the starting point doesn't it?

We've just had our first season of nearly zero net spend and I suspect next time around will be similar. But our starting point was having one of the strongest - albeit underperforming - "other" squads in the prem. My guess is if we keep Roy for another season we'll be safe if underwhelming. Once he goes and the new manager comes in and the squad needs to be overhauled on minimal money to fit his ideas then the gig is over (WBA and Stoke style).

I don't like it one bit but the only way I can see us spending in the next season or so to any level is by cashing in on Wilf or more especially AWB who I guess will be a target for at least one of the big boys this summer. Our net spend will still be minimal but our outlay would increase. (I'm assuming here that no ownership change is on the cards and that as with WBA our scope for manoeuvre is limited by FFP and that is unlikely to change any time soon - happy be corrected on that).

Edited by Omph (08 Jan 2019 10.52am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 08 Jan 19 11.12am

Originally posted by Omph

I think that depends on the starting point doesn't it?

We've just had our first season of nearly zero net spend and I suspect next time around will be similar. But our starting point was having one of the strongest - albeit underperforming - "other" squads in the prem. My guess is if we keep Roy for another season we'll be safe if underwhelming. Once he goes and the new manager comes in and the squad needs to be overhauled on minimal money to fit his ideas then the gig is over (WBA and Stoke style).

I don't like it one bit but the only way I can see us spending in the next season or so to any level is by cashing in on Wilf or more especially AWB who I guess will be a target for at least one of the big boys this summer. Our net spend will still be minimal but our outlay would increase. (I'm assuming here that no ownership change is on the cards and that as with WBA our scope for manoeuvre is limited by FFP and that is unlikely to change any time soon - happy be corrected on that).

Edited by Omph (08 Jan 2019 10.52am)

Good points although I still think we may spend up to an affordable £30 mil next season even if Roy stays. It would be great to clear the decks without spending more than £20 mil over these 2 seasons to provide a new manager with £50+ mil to spend but it’s unrealistic. Players age and lose their prime before you attempt to add more to the team or squad.

We actually did well bringing in 3 perm players (albeit 1 a keeper) on a net spend of £10 mil but that isn’t always possible and Meyer isn’t the finished article anyway. But that was after a shambolic January so it became the bare essentials and thank fvck it wasn’t another shambles.

Or we do as you suggest and cash in on Wilf or AWB.

 


COYP

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 08 Jan 19 12.01pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Good points although I still think we may spend up to an affordable £30 mil next season even if Roy stays. It would be great to clear the decks without spending more than £20 mil over these 2 seasons to provide a new manager with £50+ mil to spend but it’s unrealistic. Players age and lose their prime before you attempt to add more to the team or squad.

We actually did well bringing in 3 perm players (albeit 1 a keeper) on a net spend of £10 mil but that isn’t always possible and Meyer isn’t the finished article anyway. But that was after a shambolic January so it became the bare essentials and thank fvck it wasn’t another shambles.

Or we do as you suggest and cash in on Wilf or AWB. [
/quote]

If Moses does indeed come in I would not be surprised

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Jan 19 12.21pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Good points although I still think we may spend up to an affordable £30 mil next season even if Roy stays. It would be great to clear the decks without spending more than £20 mil over these 2 seasons to provide a new manager with £50+ mil to spend but it’s unrealistic. Players age and lose their prime before you attempt to add more to the team or squad.

We actually did well bringing in 3 perm players (albeit 1 a keeper) on a net spend of £10 mil but that isn’t always possible and Meyer isn’t the finished article anyway. But that was after a shambolic January so it became the bare essentials and thank fvck it wasn’t another shambles.

Or we do as you suggest and cash in on Wilf or AWB.

In terms of Zaha, of course he would command a substantial price but I have heard it said from more than one supporter that in their opinion the hype far exceeds the substance.Views expressed that he was somewhat over-rated, a bit of a 'Show pony' with histrionics who tries to over-elaborate all the time.Many others of course will have him on the Palace pantheon of greats.

Edited by Willo (08 Jan 2019 12.22pm)

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 08 Jan 19 4.28pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

I was bang up for the cup this year until I saw the last four left in the fourth round draw. Citeh, U*****d, Spurs and us.

Or maybe arse, utd, spurs and us? But point taken, nearly as bad!

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should Palace prioritise the FA CUP?