This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
MacArthur better than Kouyate? No way, Jose. Not anymore. ..very weird how you and ChrisGC both dislike Hodgson with a vengeance and prefer Kouyate over McArthur, I wonder how many others think this way?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
Jimmy Mac is miles ahead of Kouyate at the moment his only major negative is his lack of pace and he appears to be getting slower. He does have moments where he makes you go Cor blimey!..but you are mainly right as he is very wasteful with passing very similar to the passing skills of PVA and Kouyate, they all need to sort themselves out quick.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ghostship
As much as Jimmy Mac has been a really good player for us I think his time is coming to an end which pains me to say considering the contributions he has made. I don't think we should let him go as I think he could still be an impact sub in terms of nicking a goal here and there and providing the odd assist. Kouyate is very good at moving the ball forward and is nimble on the ball despite his gangly appearance plus his physical presence helps us retain or regain possession we have yet to see the real best of him. ..for the opposition yes!
|
|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
Bit unfair to lump Kouyate in with that lot, especially the comparison to Schlupp. Decent player imo i like jimmy mac, but the difference between the 3 is that we have had jimmy for a long time so there is that part of us that holds him in higher esteem. the crux of it for me is all 3 are average PL midfielders, absolutely nothing wrong with that whatsoever, you couldnt see a team above us wanting to sign them, you could argue that one is better than the other but it would be very marginal. whereas luca, and potentially max (a year os so down the line) you could see that happening.
‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway |
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by braunstoneagle
i like jimmy mac, but the difference between the 3 is that we have had jimmy for a long time so there is that part of us that holds him in higher esteem. the crux of it for me is all 3 are average PL midfielders, absolutely nothing wrong with that whatsoever, you couldnt see a team above us wanting to sign them, you could argue that one is better than the other but it would be very marginal. whereas luca, and potentially max (a year os so down the line) you could see that happening.
All this "he's from Serbia" s***e and he doesn't want to know when it comes to getting crunched. That said, I like him, he's positionally excellent and runs for 90 mins with good Pens and FKs in his locker. Don't need both him and Macca starting imo. Both are getting to 30 we should be looking to source replacements.
|
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Tickled pink
..very weird how you and ChrisGC both dislike Hodgson with a vengeance and prefer Kouyate over McArthur, I wonder how many others think this way? Maine Eagle is usually absolutely spot on about Palace, see's the situation for what it is. Isn't bothered about being shouted down by the vocal minority of "Hodgson's the greatest" brigade either which I admire.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
All this "he's from Serbia" s***e and he doesn't want to know when it comes to getting crunched. That said, I like him, he's positionally excellent and runs for 90 mins with good Pens and FKs in his locker. Don't need both him and Macca starting imo. Both are getting to 30 we should be looking to source replacements. im not talking about his nationality...but he is DMF and he is going to get clattered, much like cabaye did when he played there, his tactical fouls are great. you dont need a DMF to be the best passer in the world, jedi was s*** at passing...even n’golo kante the best in the world at the postition doesnt bing balls like scholes. you need disciplined players in your team with wingers like wilf & andros, and the fore mentioned players will graft all day, hustle, close down and chip in with goals assists. i think you need to realise chris, our style of play couldnt work with KDB / silva / silva kind of players we would get smashed every week.with our budgets & situation our current midfielders are pretty damn good.
‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway |
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by braunstoneagle
im not talking about his nationality...but he is DMF and he is going to get clattered, much like cabaye did when he played there, his tactical fouls are great. you dont need a DMF to be the best passer in the world, jedi was s*** at passing...even n’golo kante the best in the world at the postition doesnt bing balls like scholes. you need disciplined players in your team with wingers like wilf & andros, and the fore mentioned players will graft all day, hustle, close down and chip in with goals assists. i think you need to realise chris, our style of play couldnt work with KDB / silva / silva kind of players we would get smashed every week.with our budgets & situation our current midfielders are pretty damn good. Not nationality: the song. I don't buy that he's a hardnut. As for Jedi? Unpopular opinion but that was the only good thing Pardew did for us long term, he needed shipping out. Always in the right place but it was meaningless as he would give the ball immediately to the opposition 2 yards away. I don't think I need to realise anything Baustone, I just see it differently to you. We should aspire to be top 8 by playing a more positive form of football and utilising the technically better players over the carthorses.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
All this "he's from Serbia" s***e and he doesn't want to know when it comes to getting crunched. That said, I like him, he's positionally excellent and runs for 90 mins with good Pens and FKs in his locker. Don't need both him and Macca starting imo. Both are getting to 30 we should be looking to source replacements. I agree with you completely about Luka. He is far from a tough man, get's bullied around the pitch more often than not and his passsing leaves a lot to be desired. We have some shocking passers of the ball havn't we, should be one of the most simplest tasks un football and we about 3 players who can consistently pass the ball 10 yards.
|
|
|
Where did you find this chant
|
|
|
Despite what I and others may think Roy clearly values the 'not spectacular' Schlupp and sees him as very important to the team: [Link] So that puts to bed any idea of him being ousted. The article does incorrectly state he is playing at left back, but it's an easy Schlupp-up to make. If you're reading this Jeffrey I hope you prove me wrong this season, just as Ayew has done so far.
|
|
|
Originally posted by A89M
I like Schlupp, works hard, gets the odd goal, great for getting us up the field with his pace and he's not bad defensively bar the odd concentration issue much like PVA. I've gone completely off Meyer, we can't say he's not been given the opportunities. He's weak on the ball, passes sideways and defensively he's non-existent. He's technically better on the ball than Schlupp but you can see why Schlupp gets in ahead in of him, he's more effective. He has been better out on the left, to be fair to him, but I still think he could do more to support PvA. He is clearly a target for Vicente's long kicks and he does do direct runs and has pace to burn. Kouyate has been far more effective in the middle than Schlupp was last season though. The question is, if Townsend finds form who loses out? For me Schlupp is still the weakest player in our starting midfield.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.