You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs City Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs City Match Thread


Page 10 of 10 << First< 6 7 8 9 10
Kant Flag exeter 15 Apr 19 2.11am

Originally posted by Numbers Man

Today’s performance was very poor. We were again far to defensive and allowed City to dominate play especially in the first half. Patrick Van Aanholt didn’t have a clue on how to mark Sterling and was mainly responsible for both of his goals. His passing game has also been poor for a number of weeks. We are also losing goals in the final minutes like today. These problems are down to poor management and coaching and RH like most 70+ year olds should get on and retire.

We are beaten by one of the best teams in Europe, who are on for an unparalleled quadruple, and the defeat is due to the age of our manager?

I think 50%+ of the posters on here should retire.

 

stanzerman Flag Hastings 15 Apr 19 3.00am

Originally posted by Kant

We are beaten by one of the best teams in Europe, who are on for an unparalleled quadruple, and the defeat is due to the age of our manager?

I think 50%+ of the posters on here should retire.

Totally agree,I thought City were absolutely brilliant today and thoroughly deserved the win

 


Stanzerman

Sherlock II Flag The Big Mango 15 Apr 19 5.05am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

beaten by a much better team.

no grumbles here, they controlled the game from the outset.


Agree. City are one of the best teams in the world while we, with some honourable exceptions, have basement Prem/Championship players past their best. First two goals were Patsy's responsibility and the third was offside.

 


Originally Sherlock, the Holmesdale Online class Of 2001

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 15 Apr 19 6.06am

A display of superb footballing skills ... but it wasn't from us. It made me wonder how the blazes we beat them up at their place?

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 15 Apr 19 6.47am

What I don't understand, not just in this match, but first half of the season we were, according to some, including me, playing some of yhe best football we've seen at palace. Crisp, quick passing, creating loads of chances. All we needed was a CF to knock those chances in. We get a CF in jan, and since then we've been playing slow, negative football, can't pass the ball and create nothing.....What's happened? Shoukd we go back to playing wilf and andros up front?

 

The Dolphin Flag 15 Apr 19 7.42am

City are the best team I have seen for a long time and we could have been three down at half time!
There is no shame in losing to them - BUT -
We give possession away so easily - unforced errors.
We panic - and not just yesterday - every week.
We ball watch.
We get sucked in to the ball too easily when opposition teams are in possession.
Van Aanholt is just having a 'mare week in and week out and if there were a replacement he needs a rest.
We are too negative and despite how good City were I still feel that we should have pressed them a bit more - we lack ambition and belief in ourselves which is a shame.
On the flip side it was only 3-1 and i would have settled for that so we move on to next Sunday where I think we have a very good chance of turning Arsenal over!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Apr 19 7.53am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

City are the best team I have seen for a long time and we could have been three down at half time!
There is no shame in losing to them - BUT -
We give possession away so easily - unforced errors.
We panic - and not just yesterday - every week.
We ball watch.
We get sucked in to the ball too easily when opposition teams are in possession.
Van Aanholt is just having a 'mare week in and week out and if there were a replacement he needs a rest.
We are too negative and despite how good City were I still feel that we should have pressed them a bit more - we lack ambition and belief in ourselves which is a shame.
On the flip side it was only 3-1 and i would have settled for that so we move on to next Sunday where I think we have a very good chance of turning Arsenal over!

I take an alternative view of this.Arsenal have won their last 7 home games,in all competitions - it will be another hard watch for us supporters.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 15 Apr 19 9.02am

Originally posted by spartakev2

What I don't understand, not just in this match, but first half of the season we were, according to some, including me, playing some of yhe best football we've seen at palace. Crisp, quick passing, creating loads of chances. All we needed was a CF to knock those chances in. We get a CF in jan, and since then we've been playing slow, negative football, can't pass the ball and create nothing.....What's happened? Shoukd we go back to playing wilf and andros up front?

CF in natural midfielder out. We went from control in midfield but no end to losing midfield and no supply to CF.

That's my theory anyway.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 15 Apr 19 9.14am

Originally posted by Willo

I take an alternative view of this.Arsenal have won their last 7 home games,in all competitions - it will be another hard watch for us supporters.


You mean you disagree?!

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 15 Apr 19 9.17am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

City are the best team I have seen for a long time and we could have been three down at half time!
There is no shame in losing to them - BUT -
We give possession away so easily - unforced errors.
We panic - and not just yesterday - every week.
We ball watch.
We get sucked in to the ball too easily when opposition teams are in possession.
Van Aanholt is just having a 'mare week in and week out and if there were a replacement he needs a rest.
We are too negative and despite how good City were I still feel that we should have pressed them a bit more - we lack ambition and belief in ourselves which is a shame.
On the flip side it was only 3-1 and i would have settled for that so we move on to next Sunday where I think we have a very good chance of turning Arsenal over!

This is a decent summary. It’s not the result that pains me it’s the manner in which we played. We did not pick up a player until they were halfway into our half inviting them to try and pick us apart which they duly did. If you watched them when we had the ball they were on us in seconds, hunting in packs to turn over the ball. Our idea of pressing seems to be Benteke lumbering backwards and forwards between the two centre half’s as they calmly pass it round him.

If it was only against City and Liverpool that we did this you could sort of live with it, however we have performed in a similar manner for most of the season and it does not make for pleasant viewing. I sat with a Spanish guy yesterday to watch the match who didn’t know a lot about football who asked me which league Palace were in. He thought it was a cup match and we were from the first or second division. Sums it up really. City are good, but to sit off as we did was making it so easy for them and was only ever going to end up with one result.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Apr 19 9.17am

Originally posted by JRW2


You mean you disagree?!

Affirmative !
Opposite sides of the house on this matter.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 15 Apr 19 10.56am

I agree with many of the summary posts above. Clearly our midfield had been told not to break lines and get ahead of the ball so City couldn't counter us. This was hugely frustrating as Benteke won absolutely everything in the air. It even got to the stage where City weren't even competing for the first ball, but just made sure they picked up the second ball. This is where we needed those runners to anticipate the knockdowns.
Our best option yesterday was route one and by passing midfield - as we were clearly outclassed in this and many other departments.
Anyway, we will just have to wait until next season to do the double over them

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 15 Apr 19 11.27am

Originally posted by Willo

And the first and second goals were down to abject defending by Van Aanholt who had a game to forget.Much better coming forward than defending.

Apropos the game, it panned out as I expected with us dropping behind the ball trying to deny Man C space between the lines and with Man C having the lion's share of possession.Never really laid a glove on them.

Defensively PVA looks like a weak link. AWB looks a far better defender already than this guy. No defensive positional sense whatsoever. As a result he needs back up negating any movement forward on the left wing. If he is exposed defensively one on one he is weak. Okay Sterling is now a world class winger/striker but PVA's been found wanting positionally previously. For a solid defence next season we need a better left back, for attack, a dead ball specialist and a decent striker. 2-0 down we actually gave it a go and they looked shaky. Too late though, as we had a horrible game "plan" up to then.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 15 Apr 19 11.30am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

City are the best team I have seen for a long time and we could have been three down at half time!
There is no shame in losing to them - BUT -
We give possession away so easily - unforced errors.
We panic - and not just yesterday - every week.
We ball watch.
We get sucked in to the ball too easily when opposition teams are in possession.
Van Aanholt is just having a 'mare week in and week out and if there were a replacement he needs a rest.
We are too negative and despite how good City were I still feel that we should have pressed them a bit more - we lack ambition and belief in ourselves which is a shame.
On the flip side it was only 3-1 and i would have settled for that so we move on to next Sunday where I think we have a very good chance of turning Arsenal over!

Luka and Andros in my mind we both poor in this department. Luka couldn't place a long pass and Andros kept running himself into trouble.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 15 Apr 19 11.35am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

City are the best team I have seen for a long time and we could have been three down at half time!
There is no shame in losing to them - BUT -
We give possession away so easily - unforced errors.
We panic - and not just yesterday - every week.
We ball watch.
We get sucked in to the ball too easily when opposition teams are in possession.
Van Aanholt is just having a 'mare week in and week out and if there were a replacement he needs a rest.
We are too negative and despite how good City were I still feel that we should have pressed them a bit more - we lack ambition and belief in ourselves which is a shame.
On the flip side it was only 3-1 and i would have settled for that so we move on to next Sunday where I think we have a very good chance of turning Arsenal over!

Love your optimism but they are on a good run of form at home and this fixture away has always been a graveyard for us. That said we were robbed by poor officiating at Selhurst this season on one of our better performances there and due a slice of luck against them so let's hope for it at the weekend. COYP !!

Edited by Booted Eagle (15 Apr 2019 11.36am)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 17 Apr 19 12.24am

Originally posted by Willo

I take an alternative view of this.Arsenal have won their last 7 home games,in all competitions - it will be another hard watch for us supporters.

You confidently said Brighton would beat Cardiff tonight too!

 

Aray Flag South London 17 Apr 19 1.23pm

Originally posted by Kant

We are beaten by one of the best teams in Europe, who are on for an unparalleled quadruple, and the defeat is due to the age of our manager?

I think 50%+ of the posters on here should retire.

Apologies Kant as I've not read all the posts on here but if the 50% you're referring to are complaining about Saturday's performance, then you're wrong. So so wrong. Yes they are a very good attacking team but they can be got at. And the very least I want is to try to stop them from playing and an attempt to play football ourselves.

One of my work mates is a Man City supporter, his words to me on Monday:

"What happened to you lot? Normally that is a really tough game you only seemed to have a go briefly. It seemed like a training game."

Exactly the same thing said to me on Sunday by my mate sitting next to me. We were so passive and lacking basic competencies.

I guess teams' form can come and go. Hopefully I will get to see a game at home where we play well but its been a long time.

 

Page 10 of 10 << First< 6 7 8 9 10

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs City Match Thread