This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
HS2 Review
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Badger11 Beckenham 04 Oct 23 12.34pm |
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The infrastructure of the country in particular the rail network, is not improved, but reduced, by HS2.
The project management has been a disaster but if we want a rail service fit for the this century then we need a high speed rail system not only up the spine of the country to Scotland but into Wales and the South West.
One of my many complaints was why did they start in London? They should have started it oop North and gone downwards, so perhaps at say Birmingham if the cost got too much then just use the existing line to London.
If we want to be green in this country we need a fast railway system but it should not be an either or plenty of other rail projects to be done as well.
Edited by Badger11 (04 Oct 2023 12.35pm)
One more point
|
NE14T 04 Oct 23 1.13pm |
|
|
Unfortunately the contractors between London and Birmingham held the government to ransom and completely fleeced the tax payer. The profiteering must border on fraud. Sure the government could have done more and been tougher holding them accountable contractually.
Either way the contractors killed the golden goose. Rip off Britain at it worse and don’t give me the inflation bollox argument which is dwarfed by the sheer basic dishonest over-charging.
The beatings will stop when morale improves.
|
dreamwaverider London 04 Oct 23 2.29pm |
|
Originally posted by NE14T
Unfortunately the contractors between London and Birmingham held the government to ransom and completely fleeced the tax payer. The profiteering must border on fraud. Sure the government could have done more and been tougher holding them accountable contractually.
Either way the contractors killed the golden goose. Rip off Britain at it worse and don’t give me the inflation bollox argument which is dwarfed by the sheer basic dishonest over-charging. This is exactly why Palace need to tread very carefully re new stand. Only do it on a fixed price and make sure we have got the cash in full before they start. If they think £100m three years ago, then expect £200m by the time it's finished now. Something we currently cannot contemplate.
|
Hrolf The Ganger 04 Oct 23 2.35pm |
|
|
HS2 was a bad idea. Sunak has made a brave decision to cancel it, but ultimately, it was the right choice.
I feel sorry for the people who had to sell their houses on the route but at least the north will get better connections which it badly needs.
|
YT Oxford 04 Oct 23 4.03pm |
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
HS2 was a bad idea. Sunak has made a brave decision to cancel it, but ultimately, it was the right choice.
I feel sorry for the people who had to sell their houses on the route but at least the north will get better connections which it badly needs.
I agree. It was an insane project from the outset.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)
|
Forest Hillbilly in a hidey-hole 04 Oct 23 7.05pm |
|
|
The money 'saved' (forgetting all the cash already wasted) will be used on "stuff for the North" and BETTER ROADS. 
what a bunch of electioneering incompetent b'asterds.
I disengage, I turn the page.
|
Hrolf The Ganger 04 Oct 23 7.25pm |
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
The money 'saved' (forgetting all the cash already wasted) will be used on "stuff for the North" and BETTER ROADS. 
what a bunch of electioneering incompetent b'asterds.
It looks like a bad choice to some whatever Sunak does.
Ideally, the thing gets finished, but the cost of it is now far more than the benefits. I came into this week thinking that it should be finished, but when you think about the potential for improving northern connections with that money, you have to concede that it could be better spent there. Beyond the politics and after consideration, many up north might feel that too.
Announcing this at a conference might not have been the wisest thing. It then looks like a political decision and grabs the headlines.
|
Matov 04 Oct 23 7.25pm |
|
|
I think cancelling this cancellation is insanity. The issue is not about people getting somewhere a few minutes early, the issue is that the HS project represents a confidence in the UK's future. Most foreign investment comes in London and the SE because the north of the country is seen as some bleak provisional hell hole.
HS2 was as much about image as anything else. The kind of project a confident nation carries out.
To ditch it as this stage is to just surrender to decline. And just when it is revealed that the UK is outstripping the likes of Gemrany and France in terms of post-Covid growth.
This project was about national prestige. To say to investors that you might want to live in the SE but if you invest up North, we can speed you up there quicker than now.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.
|
Hrolf The Ganger 04 Oct 23 7.31pm |
|
Originally posted by Matov
I think cancelling this cancellation is insanity. The issue is not about people getting somewhere a few minutes early, the issue is that the HS project represents a confidence in the UK's future. Most foreign investment comes in London and the SE because the north of the country is seen as some bleak provisional hell hole.
HS2 was as much about image as anything else. The kind of project a confident nation carries out.
To ditch it as this stage is to just surrender to decline. And just when it is revealed that the UK is outstripping the likes of Gemrany and France in terms of post-Covid growth.
This project was about national prestige. To say to investors that you might want to live in the SE but if you invest up North, we can speed you up there quicker than now.
This is one of those situations where neither option is very appealing. The mistake was doing it in the first place.
|
WJK1960 04 Oct 23 8.45pm |
|
|
On the Today programme yesterday the boss of HS1 explained very simply why this project was so expensive and how, despite his obvious knowledge and experience in building HS1 he was overlooked for a senior role within HS2. I don't know whether to laugh or cry.
[Link]
|
Forest Hillbilly in a hidey-hole 05 Oct 23 5.46pm |
|
|
The facts have changed, says Rishi Sunak 
Government says it will recoup money spent compulsorily purchasing property on the route, by re-selling back on the property market.
I can only imagine the devastation caused to former property owners by having their homes taken and then re-sold , likely at a large profit.
Edited by Forest Hillbilly (05 Oct 2023 11.13pm)
I disengage, I turn the page.
|
Lawrie Brooks Green (near Horsham) 05 Oct 23 6.43pm |
|
|
Just to lighten things up a little….9
Attachment: IMG_2924.png (4,244.76Kb)
|
steeleye20 Croydon 06 Oct 23 5.33pm |
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
The money 'saved' (forgetting all the cash already wasted) will be used on "stuff for the North" and BETTER ROADS. 
what a bunch of electioneering incompetent b'asterds.
This is jam tomorrow post next election which the north will probably not get as they are used to not getting.
'Vast swathes of the London to Birmingham leg of HS2 will have to be redesigned as part of a review ordered by the Government that could push costs even further'.
100 billion + who knows, or what the route is, even now.
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 06 Oct 23 6.16pm |
|
|
I'm reminded of those silent movies with the hand cranked railway trolleys. Perhaps a green idea? And night club bathroom attendants would surely find it a decent job. Food for thought.
Red and Blue Army!
|
steeleye20 Croydon 09 Oct 23 7.36pm |
|
|
Rishi Sunak admits list of HS2 replacement projects just ‘illustrative’ and not pledges.
Euston really wishful thinking depending now on private funds.
Really it looks like any investment with him there is 'doing your dough'.
|
Forest Hillbilly in a hidey-hole 17 Feb 24 7.35pm |
|
|
Government haven't got a Scooby-doo what to do next. However, they could start by hiring some diggers to infill these holes 
"Sinkholes thought to be caused by the boring of tunnels for the HS2 rail project have opened up in a field.
Two new holes were discovered on land on the outskirts of South Heath, near Great Missenden, Bucks, where the Chiltern Tunnel is being constructed.
It means four craters have been caused by HS2 in the county in nine months." (BBC website, 17,2,24)
Looks like going for low-cost options on construction is turning out to be quite expensive.
[Link]
I disengage, I turn the page.
|
georgenorman 17 Feb 24 8.51pm |
|
|
I read the news today, oh boy Four thousand holes in Blackburn, Lancashire And though the holes were rather small They had to count them all Now they know how many holes it takes to fill the Albert Hall
|