You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dopey led down the garden path.
November 21 2026 10.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dopey led down the garden path.


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
W12 23 Sep 19 10.45pm

Originally posted by samprior

Yep the benefits system has its faults, along with other contributing factors to making raising a family financially challenging such as zero hour contracts, large corporations scrimping on staff salaries, cuts to public services etc

What is the traditional working class British family? Is it the same as it was 10/20/30 years ago? Will it always remain the same? Can it always remain the same?

I guess the representation of the traditional British working class family in the media has changed for sure. In part to reflect modern society and in part to push what some might feel an overly liberal/inclusive agenda. When it comes to what's on TV I'm not the most informed as I don't own one but I'm all for positive representations of the British working class family.

..but I guess there's a huge (and interesting) debate to be had over what that is as I'm sure people hold a vast array of valid and personal opinions on how one defines British, working class and the family. To reach a consensus on that would be tough but the only logical starting point.

Ps the questions here are more just me thinking out loud/verbal diarrhea not ones I expect a response to...though obviously that's your choice

Edited by samprior (23 Sep 2019 10.02pm)

These things are always changing but in this case I believe most of the changes were due to social engineering.

 

.TUX. Flag 23 Sep 19 10.51pm

Originally posted by samprior

Hmm it's a strange one. In my day to day I don't have much use for a flag. But during the world cup it's out which I guess is the same for many but some would argue not enough.

I get the flag can be used a symbol so for some can be devisive as the message behind it is not always the same.

For me I'd stand under the flag along with whoever wants to unify under it. But I'd walk away if the flag was just used as a display of superiority (unless it's in a world cup).

So fly that flag proudly (and have a nice prepared answer that you can proudly reel off when someone asks you about why it's up...as there'll always be one!)

Hmm what would mine include. Family, football, Beatles, Orwell, the countryside...so much goodness

No, it's quite simple.

 


Buy Litecoin.

tome Flag Inner Tantalus Time. 24 Sep 19 6.42am

Originally posted by W12

These things are always changing but in this case I believe most of the changes were due to social engineering.

Where do you see that, then?

Personally I wonder why many posters are wary of change or challenge. Society has always changed and evolved, the introduction of new ideas, technology and other people always encourages shifts in society. I tend to think it's a positive thing that reduces the prevalence of bad ideas and out of date notions.

Also, we are all just people. What is it you are worried about in a scenario in which there are fewer 'white' people? As Matov argues, it's the values that matter - people are just people. Things aren't going to change much unless lots of people change their views and vote in laws which bring about that change.

Seems to me that universally, change is happening faster and more people are moving about. The uncertainty this creates is often the problem, visibly different newcomers are merely the most visible aspect. But typically internal migration is much larger than international migration.

 


A one and a two...

samprior Flag Hamburg 24 Sep 19 7.05am

Originally posted by samprior
Hmm it's a strange one. In my day to day I don't have much use for a flag. But during the world cup it's out which I guess is the same for many but some would argue not enough.

I get the flag can be used a symbol so for some can be devisive as the message behind it is not always the same.

For me I'd stand under the flag along with whoever wants to unify under it. But I'd walk away if the flag was just used as a display of superiority (unless it's in a world cup).

So fly that flag proudly (and have a nice prepared answer that you can proudly reel off when someone asks you about why it's up...as there'll always be one!)

Hmm what would mine include. Family, football, Beatles, Orwell, the countryside...so much goodness

Originally posted by .TUX.

No, it's quite simple.

Fair enough but for the points I've mentioned I'd obviously argue it is not. But I guess we can agree to disagree. Simple

Have a good day

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 24 Sep 19 7.17am

Originally posted by tome

Where do you see that, then?

Personally I wonder why many posters are wary of change or challenge. Society has always changed and evolved, the introduction of new ideas, technology and other people always encourages shifts in society. I tend to think it's a positive thing that reduces the prevalence of bad ideas and out of date notions.

Also, we are all just people. What is it you are worried about in a scenario in which there are fewer 'white' people? As Matov argues, it's the values that matter - people are just people. Things aren't going to change much unless lots of people change their views and vote in laws which bring about that change.

Seems to me that universally, change is happening faster and more people are moving about. The uncertainty this creates is often the problem, visibly different newcomers are merely the most visible aspect. But typically internal migration is much larger than international migration.

There are generational distinctions, in that most youngsters now have friends of all races, all born here. They aren't looking over their pals for definitions of what constitutes who belongs most, because to them that would absurd. And indeed as I oft say, if you're born here and hold this country dear, no matter black or white, this is your country. You're not a guest.

Aside from that, immigration policy should in my view be the decision of the people, not the EU, and not cheap labour loving governments. So on that front there could be some crossover in terms of what various groups might want. Outside of the EU I could see a serious push for a low cap based on skills required, but it certainly wouldn't exclude based on race - nor should it. It would be best to push for a limit on numbers, which would be a popular move, than something that's antithetical to the values of most people.


Edited by dollardays (24 Sep 2019 7.40am)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 24 Sep 19 8.00am

Originally posted by W12

By the way, I would answer my own question with “Kingsman” (the movie). I happen to know the producer and although he’s middle class he’s also ex forces so has respect for the working classes because he’s actually spent time with them.

Completely off topic, my son got his first extras role in the new Kingsman film due out in February. First of many I hope, although proper acting roles would be preferable.Perhaps you could put in a word

 

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Sep 19 11.18am

Originally posted by dollardays

There are generational distinctions, in that most youngsters now have friends of all races, all born here. They aren't looking over their pals for definitions of what constitutes who belongs most, because to them that would absurd. And indeed as I oft say, if you're born here and hold this country dear, no matter black or white, this is your country. You're not a guest.

The demographic map doesn't fit your idealist view regardless of generations. What you suggest isn't a happy reality anywhere in the world let alone here.

As for your ideas on about 'this is your country'....this use to be my view ten years ago. There are posts on Hol where I'd state this.

I'm no longer a normie who sees the world in idealistic terms. Where someone is born does not determine their allegiance.....that's an outdated viewpoint. What matters is allegiance.

How you see things is how the state curently views it...inside or outside of the cities the demographic map is still divided but as that changes more will wake up and be practical rather than idealistic and braver in stating it.

Brexit was a message that was in part a recognition that people know what's coming....and they don't want it.


Originally posted by dollardays

Aside from that, immigration policy should in my view be the decision of the people, not the EU, and not cheap labour loving governments. So on that front there could be some crossover in terms of what various groups might want. Outside of the EU I could see a serious push for a low cap based on skills required, but it certainly wouldn't exclude based on race - nor should it. It would be best to push for a limit on numbers, which would be a popular move, than something that's antithetical to the values of most people.

Edited by dollardays (24 Sep 2019 7.40am)


Once a nation is stripped of its historical and ancestral roots who really cares about numbers anymore? Only neo liberals.

England is meant to be ruled by the English.


Edited by Stirlingsays (25 Sep 2019 12.43pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Sep 19 1.49pm

Watched and enjoyed Romesh Ranganathan stand up the other night. Late on I questioned why he has integrated so much that he’s exactly the same as white people he grew up with apart from skin tone and his parents’ accents (and this isn’t new to me as he would’ve been a mate of mine, before I get pelters), and how so many people of colour want to be so different, sound so different, stay detached from white Britain or be completely isolated from it. I have and have had Asian friends agree.

The first thing is he’s a Christian Sri Lankan. From experience Hindus also integrate and adapt. But now it seems unless you go to a white school the majority will share very little in common with white people around them or want to. This is my gripe, and it seems is for everyone else, explaining a lot of White flight. I expect pelters, especially from one, but that’s how I feel.

 


COYP

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Sep 19 2.38pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Watched and enjoyed Romesh Ranganathan stand up the other night. Late on I questioned why he has integrated so much that he’s exactly the same as white people he grew up with apart from skin tone and his parents’ accents (and this isn’t new to me as he would’ve been a mate of mine, before I get pelters), and how so many people of colour want to be so different, sound so different, stay detached from white Britain or be completely isolated from it. I have and have had Asian friends agree.

The first thing is he’s a Christian Sri Lankan. From experience Hindus also integrate and adapt. But now it seems unless you go to a white school the majority will share very little in common with white people around them or want to. This is my gripe, and it seems is for everyone else, explaining a lot of White flight. I expect pelters, especially from one, but that’s how I feel.

It's all about the numbers my friend.

I remember reading a study done on how well integration works.

Essentially it's common sense and how you state. Whenever we talk about groups we can only talk in generalisations but the numbers don't lie.

If an individual is surrounded by a culture they have little option but to adapt as best they can to it. Most will try to integrate.

If an individual has a community around them that looks like them and has a separate identity then they are most likely going to take that group identity....it's human nature.

The social constructionists and idealists told us that immigrants would integrate......when the reality is that at the start when numbers were low integration was more common....though never high....slowly areas were taken over and white flight started.

Now they don't even bother with the integration lie and we even have the new security head telling us that we shouldn't require any of these communities to integrate.

Maybe it's better that the English lose their country. Since the world wars we aren't a patch on our ancestors and allowed 'words' to frighten us into giving up our own nation.

The ideology of the left that Orwell criticised. The type that hate the nation state and its heritage...those people have become the state and infect its institutions.

Unless something happens to change things it's drip drip until we flatline.....the boomers didn't listen to Powell in large enough numbers and it's probably too late now.

It's about the future for our children or grandchildren and where that will be.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Sep 2019 6.01pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Invalid user 2019 Flag 27 Sep 19 12.48pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays
As for your ideas on about 'this is your country'....this use to be my view ten years ago.

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I'm no longer a normie who sees the world in idealistic terms. Where someone is born does not determine their allegiance.....that's an outdated viewpoint. What matters is allegiance.


Quote Once a nation is stripped of its historical and ancestral roots who really cares about numbers anymore? Only neo liberals.


Your take home appears to be that the country needs to stay majority white / European so it genetically matters that those people are born here ahead of their individual outlook. However, if someone is non white and born here this isn't their country, and the fact that they were born here is less relevant or useful to the nation unless they make their allegiance much clearer than the former.

But let's just use an open goal type example to help you clear this up. Let's take Frank Bruno for example. Surely you accept that this is his country too? If you don't, where else do you propose that he belongs?


There's little that's idealistic about just taking people for who they are regardless of colour and creed, and then separately and politically having a view about where to cast your vote and with what ends in mind going forward (immigration policy for instance as assimilation and numbers are perfectly valid concerns). I think with some that distinction all but disappears and all that succeeds in doing is fostering a sweeping aversion to groups with occasional exceptions to the rule.

Edited by dollardays (27 Sep 2019 1.57pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Sep 19 6.11am

Originally posted by dollardays

Your take home appears to be that the country needs to stay majority white / European so it genetically matters that those people are born here ahead of their individual outlook. However, if someone is non white and born here this isn't their country, and the fact that they were born here is less relevant or useful to the nation unless they make their allegiance much clearer than the former.

But let's just use an open goal type example to help you clear this up. Let's take Frank Bruno for example. Surely you accept that this is his country too? If you don't, where else do you propose that he belongs?


There's little that's idealistic about just taking people for who they are regardless of colour and creed, and then separately and politically having a view about where to cast your vote and with what ends in mind going forward (immigration policy for instance as assimilation and numbers are perfectly valid concerns). I think with some that distinction all but disappears and all that succeeds in doing is fostering a sweeping aversion to groups with occasional exceptions to the rule.

Edited by dollardays (27 Sep 2019 1.57pm)

The thread is more about the future for Anglo Saxons or English whites which is only partly related to nationhood but I'm ok with you retreading these old arguments.....but wary because the topic area is huge.

Frank Bruno is a western style social conservative. Like many from my generation I kind of view him as a national treasure.

The question as to where Bruno belongs is the same question everyone has to answer when it comes to identity. These are questions for the individual.

Frank is genetically a West Indian. I imagine he has very little European in him but his allegiance is to Britain.....I've always said that the individual has the right to transcend genetics and that ethnicity is multifaceted....not many are going to do it but it's the right of every individual.

You make some good points but ultimately these are still old points. Any sensible person only needs to look out into the world to see that on the holistic level homogeneous populations work whereas heterogeneous populations are divided and troubled.....it isn't any different here to anywhere else and no amount of 'jam tomorrow' will change that.

In terms of England remaining English. It's a question of numbers.....When we have 20 million Frank Brunos and Chris Eubanks you might just have a difficult question to ask me but that's not going to happen is it......Frank Bruno is ridiculed by many in the black community and far left whites as an uncle Tom.

I accept those that stand with me....I just know that only a limited number will....but where they are genuine they are my brothers and sisters all the same.


Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Sep 2019 7.17am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

DanH Flag SW2 28 Sep 19 8.01am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

The thread is more about the future for Anglo Saxons or English whites which is only partly related to nationhood but I'm ok with you retreading these old arguments.....but wary because the topic area is huge.

Frank Bruno is a western style social conservative. Like many from my generation I kind of view him as a national treasure.

The question as to where Bruno belongs is the same question everyone has to answer when it comes to identity. These are questions for the individual.

Frank is genetically a West Indian. I imagine he has very little European in him but his allegiance is to Britain.....I've always said that the individual has the right to transcend genetics and that ethnicity is multifaceted....not many are going to do it but it's the right of every individual.

You make some good points but ultimately these are still old points. Any sensible person only needs to look out into the world to see that on the holistic level homogeneous populations work whereas heterogeneous populations are divided and troubled.....it isn't any different here to anywhere else and no amount of 'jam tomorrow' will change that.

In terms of England remaining English. It's a question of numbers.....When we have 20 million Frank Brunos and Chris Eubanks you might just have a difficult question to ask me but that's not going to happen is it......Frank Bruno is ridiculed by many in the black community and far left whites as an uncle Tom.

I accept those that stand with me....I just know that only a limited number will....but where they are genuine they are my brothers and sisters all the same.


Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Sep 2019 7.17am)

This is some proper Oswald Mosley style stuff.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Sep 19 8.09am

Originally posted by DanH

This is some proper Oswald Mosley style stuff.

Really? Interesting....Don't know about Mosley....Not that much into Labour politicans.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dopey led down the garden path.