You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle vs Palace Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Newcastle vs Palace Match Thread


Page 8 of 8 << First< 4 5 6 7 8
Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 22 Dec 19 8.37am

Should have won this, Newcastle were there for the taking. You know this when the oppositions goal keeper is given man of the match..

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Dec 19 8.47am

Originally posted by Mugaman

He said: "There was no need to bring Max Meyer on, I thought the three midfielder players were playing extremely well. It was 0-0, it looked to be heading towards a very good point, perhaps even three good points because we were asking lots of questions to the Newcastle defence.

"There was nothing that Max could have done out there, the other three weren't doing. As a result when we did go down, we gave Max those ten minutes but I was really happy with the three central midfield players, It would have hard for Max to give a better performance than those three.


Yes we were the better team BUT honestly did the 3 midfielders create anything? Luke and mcarthur haven't got a clue how to thread passes

But they are workmanlike, are disciplined in the way Hodgson likes them to play in terms of shape and distances and in our circumstances he believes this is the best way to survive in the PL.

 

PatrickA Flag London 22 Dec 19 8.55am

You can dress it up any way you want but in reality 1 point and 1 goal from three games against Watford , Brighton and Newcastle is not very good.
In fairness we were a little unlucky yesterday, but as the game wore on with us not taking our chances , there was a feeling that Newcastle may eventually get an opportunity which unfortunately they took.
Manquilo marked Zaha out of the game and contained him very easily in the restricted zone that Zaha seems to play in this season.
I wish Zaha had the freedom to move to the right or across the front line when he struggles against an opponent.
We are so rigid in how we play.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 22 Dec 19 8.57am

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

MacArthur should’ve been taken off after 70. Loads of passes straight out of play when on the counter. Instead Rot waits until 1-0 down.

Didn’t deserve to lose but didn’t deserve to win either. A point from last two games is fair based on performances. Disappointing that we have got two points from Watford, Brighton and Newcastle and only scored one goal.

Also, f*** knows why PVA and Zaha we’re pushing each other and having a row after the goal

I thinkVan pinched his mince pie at half time

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 22 Dec 19 9.00am

Originally posted by Willo

One can compare the statistics with regard to our recent managers and draw conclusions from them but stats sometimes don't tell the whole story.

At the end of the day Hodgson with hardly any backing at all in the transfer market has done a sterling job and his priority is to ensure we remain in the PL.Indeed we are a hard watch but Hodgson is a vastly experienced manager and the organisation and discipline he has instilled in the team has been pivotal to our survival.

Supporters of course would yearn a more expansive game but Hodgson clearly believes with the players at his disposal the style he has imposed is best suited to remaining in the PL.

This sums things up quite nicely.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 22 Dec 19 9.59am

Its not been needed recently but i think 40 points is the least we will need this season

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 22 Dec 19 10.03am

Originally posted by cryrst

Clearly, but he should have seen 3 points were there for the taking with meyer coming on.
That is the frustration.
Ok so if meyer came on and we lost it then cynically it gets roy a get of jail (I told you so)free card.
But to not spot the reward that was on offer was very poor from him.

During his time as Palace manager, I've seen no indication that Hodgson has that positive thought process in his tactical locker.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 22 Dec 19 10.08am

I watched most of the second half and though we dominated Newcastle handed us possession in the same way Pulis used to do when he was in charge, and we did not show much sense of purpose or link up very well, lacked direction and conviction , lots of stray passes and running into dead ends, surprised Roy was so happy with the midfield, Jimmy Mac was poor at times and Meyer should have come on earlier, lack of ambition cost us a result - as for new players we all know we need a right back and a striker but we need an offensive midfielder just as much - hopefully we can do a transition over the next seaon or two where we get rid of the over paid deadwood and freshen up the squad with two or three up and coming players

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 22 Dec 19 10.16am

As with other posters, Palace's performance befitted 3 pts were it not for great saves and not properly executing chances created. Much better possession and fight than demonstrated against Brighton but suffering from depth in attack and once again, relying far too much on Zaha to be the game changer. West Ham and Norwich will fancy their chances.

 

askyourself Flag 22 Dec 19 12.01pm

Extremely blunt but sad to say, so very true.
Why do we attract SO many negative thoughts? Especially after a good display from a patched-up team in a game where the oppo keeper was probably their finest player by some margin.
We've come such a long way. Well done lads incl Roy.

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

what a bunch of bed wetters.

 


We move in the direction of our thoughts.
Just think a little.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 22 Dec 19 12.50pm

What the club is missing is a goalscorer.
We bought Benteke for big money and he has failed to deliver goals after his first season.
All the time we score so few goals we will likely be at the end of 1-0 defeats.
We have the best footballing side we have ever had and are doing better than average so far this season.

Injuries will always cost a club with limited resources and we have to dig in and grind out the points.

We need 15 more from 20 games.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Dec 19 1.06pm

Looking at the goal we conceded, just like the Brighton goal we had players sitting deep in the 6 yard box and nobody picking up a player who was let unmarked in a central position next to the penalty spot.And perhaps PVA or Zaha could have done better to prevent the player getting in a cross.

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 22 Dec 19 1.09pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

During his time as Palace manager, I've seen no indication that Hodgson has that positive thought process in his tactical locker.

This game rings relegation alarm bells. these were 3 points to be had, but negative football mindset was the main architect of our downfall. when we roll over against the spuds and say we will make it up in winnable games, then gift away the those? roy should be ashamed not pleased of this outcome.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Dec 19 1.12pm

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

This game rings relegation alarm bells. these were 3 points to be had, but negative football mindset was the main architect of our downfall. when we roll over against the spuds and say we will make it up in winnable games, then gift away the those? roy should be ashamed not pleased of this outcome.

Of course he is not pleased with the defeat!
Nor I would suggest he is ashamed.
Clearly disappointed and perhaps has found positives with many aspects of the performance.

 

Coach 3 Flag Sandown Isle of Wight 22 Dec 19 1.50pm

Yesterday was another example outlining the fact that we need a goal scorer, most of our supporters have been saying that for the last two years. It will continue to be a problem as long as our board insist that they don't want to spend any money. They seem to believe that our resources are sufficient, clearly up front that is wrong. Roy does his best with what is available but Benteke, Wickham and Ayew just are not up to getting 30 goals between them a season, reinforcements are needed.

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 22 Dec 19 9.14pm

Originally posted by Willo

Looking at the goal we conceded, just like the Brighton goal we had players sitting deep in the 6 yard box and nobody picking up a player who was let unmarked in a central position next to the penalty spot.And perhaps PVA or Zaha could have done better to prevent the player getting in a cross.


And the Liverpool goals! Our last 4 goals conceded are scarily similar.

 


Spirit of 1974

Old Spice Flag green st green 22 Dec 19 9.40pm

not sure if mentioned but the referee was awful, never heard of him, I try to be objective but I saw fouls by them going unpunished. Fouls were never given and those that eventually were ( second half ) should have been yellows. And I saw a foul by their player on ours and he gave them the foul ? Am I right ?

This game was never going to go our way with a novice in charge

 

Page 8 of 8 << First< 4 5 6 7 8

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle vs Palace Match Thread