You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Still not happy
November 16 2026 5.04am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Still not happy


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 31 Jan 21 11.48am

Originally posted by Elwissthebest

A win I didn't expect, and a very necessary one. But nothing's changed except we are three points closer to the 38. It's not a question of 'doom mongering' or 'never being satisfied'. The same problems remain. In the first half we looked like a collection of individuals who hadn't been introduced. Things looked much better when Riedewald came on and as has been said before, Luka's game improved then as well. I thought Eze distinctly ordinary until a great goal. Batshuayi was awful and subbed just in time.


Perhaps not that surprising considering the change in formation, but as you say we got better when Jairo came on and his presence did seem to help Luka. Also agree that Batshuayi wasn't up to much.

Eze was ok but no more than that, apart from his goal - not just his control and finish but the way he made space and urged Ayew to give him the ball. He's one of the few players we have who looks for the ball to be played to him and wants it. Jairo's another one who's happy to have it and lets that be known. Too many are just statues who only seem to come to life when the ball is played in their direction.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 31 Jan 21 12.04pm

Originally posted by gaz1959

Its not 100% but its Saturday night and FFS we have won.

Happy days.

Let's just enjoy the 3pts

Edited by gaz1959 (30 Jan 2021 6.08pm)

Yes, the old half full, half empty. Whenever I see us with another three points its a good day. We're very likely staying up, that's something, though yes there is much we need to build on and plenty of performances I didn't want to watch the first time let alone watch back!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 31 Jan 21 2.09pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

So you would get rid of 2 out of 4 strikers! That’s good thinking. Totally agree about Jairo have been saying this for some time

Bats and Benteke might as well not be here for all they contribute, so yes, get rid. Also we have goal scorers in team - Zaha / Eze / Ayew / Schlupp (when fit) and new addition Mateta. We should be fine, as long aas they pick up the goals between them.

 

glaziermart Flag 31 Jan 21 10.21pm

Originally posted by aashman12

WTF are you on about. Was never going to sub batshuayi but did sub him.

Why don't you read my comment properly. I clearly meant he was never going to sub Batshuayi for Mateta. I did say he took Batshuayi off, but only because he brought Townsend on to shore things up

 

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 31 Jan 21 11.00pm

Don't think anyone will need 38 points to stay up this season. Extremely unlikely any of current bottom 3 will get to 37. I reckon 34-35 points will still mean survival, potentially with some daylight to spare.

Originally posted by Elwissthebest

A win I didn't expect, and a very necessary one. But nothing's changed except we are three points closer to the 38. It's not a question of 'doom mongering' or 'never being satisfied'. The same problems remain. In the first half we looked like a collection of individuals who hadn't been introduced. Things looked much better when Riedewald came on and as has been said before, Luka's game improved then as well. I thought Eze distinctly ordinary until a great goal. Batshuayi was awful and subbed just in time.

 

OneMax Flag Maidstone 31 Jan 21 11.15pm

Originally posted by gaz1959

Really some of you guys & girls should get in the real world do any of you remember the old 3rd Division ??

I remember the Palace in the Third Division Malcolm
Allison Kenny Samson Peter Taylor winning games playing great football what was there not to enjoy that was when I started loving Palace.


Edited by OneMax (31 Jan 2021 11.16pm)

 

subbuteo Flag 31 Jan 21 11.19pm

Originally posted by gaz1959

Its not 100% but its Saturday night and FFS we have won.

Happy days.

Let's just enjoy the 3pts

Edited by gaz1959 (30 Jan 2021 6.08pm)

Bang on mate. Didn’t even have a look on here last night. Enjoyed a proper drink, a Saturday afternoon victory, nice takeaway tea for the family. Smile smile smile. Deal with the problems another day &#128515;

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 31 Jan 21 11.52pm

Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2

Has anyone thought Wolves did look poor because we made them look poor COYP

Maybe that's why there wasn't a shot on target at either end for 55 minutes? MoTD showed ALL the highlights of that game in 5 minutes later that evening.
You can still support Palace and say we consistently play some of the dreariest football in the PL ... I do!

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 01 Feb 21 8.06am

I've seen us play better and lose.

And if you look at Brighton, they get compliments on their playing style every week but are below us in the table. Potter gets the same kind of criticism from their fans that Hodgson gets on here - '' no Plan B, plays his favourites '' etc.

We have a run of games coming up in which we should be competitive. Saturday's result is a good building block as we start that run. So I'll take that all day long.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 01 Feb 21 9.26am

I don’t know what all the fuss is about, it’s not like we are in the bottom 3 on less than 10 points!

 

eaglesdare Flag 01 Feb 21 10.31am

Somtimes it takes an ugly win to kick start some good form.

It happens to every "mid table team" winless, bad form, bad football, then they kick on.

I never supported palace for the "Fancy" football we play

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 01 Feb 21 10.54am

it wasn't great, it wasn't awful.

With 3 games in 8 days Roy was right to mix the side and was also correct to play it safe in the last 10 minutes as the 3 points were critical.

No sure about Bats upfront - can't hold the ball and can't head it and his movement is poor. For an international striker he should have more to his game. His missed chance showed a glaring lack of technique too.

We've moaned about throw ins before but i have to add defending corners. We are conceding too many and almost did the same late on but for a fantastic VG save.
Why was Clyne marking their tall centre forward?? Ridiculous. Surely the players can switch things themselves. Luka and Jairo could have done so, assuming the 2 centre backs were marking their opposites.
Roy's response was to bring Ward on, but are players micro managed so much now that they can't make decisions on the pitch?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 01 Feb 21 11.34am

Originally posted by palace99

it wasn't great, it wasn't awful.

With 3 games in 8 days Roy was right to mix the side and was also correct to play it safe in the last 10 minutes as the 3 points were critical.

No sure about Bats upfront - can't hold the ball and can't head it and his movement is poor. For an international striker he should have more to his game. His missed chance showed a glaring lack of technique too.

We've moaned about throw ins before but i have to add defending corners. We are conceding too many and almost did the same late on but for a fantastic VG save.
Why was Clyne marking their tall centre forward?? Ridiculous. Surely the players can switch things themselves. Luka and Jairo could have done so, assuming the 2 centre backs were marking their opposites.
Roy's response was to bring Ward on, but are players micro managed so much now that they can't make decisions on the pitch?


Listening to Lewington's barking and that of coaches at most if not all of the other PL clubs, the answer would seem to be "yes they are micro-managed"

 

si_1967 Flag Surrey 01 Feb 21 11.59am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I hope Mateta is a raging success for us, but I'm amazed at how many people are demanding his immediate inclusion when we've literally never seen him play, as if Benteke, Batshuyi and Ayew have not a single, solitary positive attribute, as if (joking aside) they're pretending to be footballers and we've just rumbled them and this scandal must be corrected this very second.

Actually, our existing forwards are proven to be of a certain standard. Not amazing, not something we can't improve on, and not something the new man can't aim to overtake, but not nothing either.

That is the 'Roy out' mindset all over. Demanding change for its own sake immediately as if we've nothing to lose, when we absolutely have got everything to lose.

We were one up against a good team today in a very tight game, had lost one player to injury and used another sub for fresh legs. It wasn't the time to ask an unknown quantity to step into the unknown, whatever our hopes for him might ultimately be.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (30 Jan 2021 11.09pm)


This is a great bit of analysis, well said.
I'm not happy with how Palace have played recently, and i'm sure this poster isn't either, but you have to have some rational thinking too.
And besides which Roy made 6 changes for the game too!

 


... what

GujiMadDog Flag England 01 Feb 21 12.57pm

I felt the last 10-15 minutes of the Spammer game paved the way forward and had hoped RH would start the same, with Jairo infront of the back four. He went with McCarthy who did put in a typical industrious performance. However, in Tomkin's absence, Jairo has provided much needed solidity to the back four and showed again the intelligence to fill spaces vacated by the back four. Something McCarthy doesnt have in his game.

Milivojevic was poor once again. He has been an erstwhile servant but I feel his time is up. Our forward play was at best disjointed, much of it down to misplaced passes. Although this cant all be put on our captain's shoulders, on numerous occasions he was at fault. Unfortunately this has been a recurring theme, with Milivojevic putting in the odd good performance.

I like the 4-2-3-1 formation. It has brought the best out of a skillful Ayew, albeit no goals, while his industry made sure we weren't overrun in midfield against Wolves. Unlike the Spammers game, bar last 10 minutes.

Do we have Benteke, Batsman or Mateta spearheading the formation? Benteke holds the ball up well while Batsman is better with the ball on the floor. The hope is Mateta can do both well and add much needed goals.
RH must give him chance.

We have seen Meyer and Sorloth leave to the RH tune 'admittedly he didnt get a fair crack of the whip', leaving many of us wondering why this was the case given our obvious shortcomings.

As for RH out... He is not perfect but few, if any, could achieve what has done with limited resources. That said, if he was to go at the end of the season then I would want somebody like Brentford's Thomas Frank to replace one of our own, RH.

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Still not happy