This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
A pal I used to work with (former Palace academy player, now playing non league) told me previously that in his opinion, often the difference between Premier League and League 2 is luck and getting the opportunity. His general frustration is that a lot of youngsters don't get a chance over a foreign import or more established player. If we look at AWB, he would never have got a sniff it it wasn't for an injury crisis. He could be on loan at somewhere like Oldham now if he didn't get the lucky break. I think back to watching Hiram Boeteng coming on as a sub away at Swansea a few years ago and thought he was great. I don't think he ever got the chance again. Often you've just got to throw a kid in to see how they cope, will they sink or swim. Some will thrive and take their game up a notch to a new level. Now is the risk free time of the season to take this sort of gamble.
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A |
|
|
Don’t think Roy is to blame for this one. No affinity with the club - clearly no loyalty = shouldn’t be surprised.
|
|
|
Anybody seen him play?
|
|
|
Originally posted by chris123
Anybody seen him play? Apparently West Ham have.
|
|
|
Originally posted by chris123
Anybody seen him play?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Qwijibo
I'm assuming someone's already highlighted Mandela Egbo's move a few years ago. I can't remember who he plays for now? (poss in the US), but he never got going at Monchengladbach, literally played about one game. For every Egbo there is a Jadon Sancho or Jude Bellingham who did move to Germany and have done well out there
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglehamster
If we have matches remaining after hitting 40 points, wouldn't that be a golden opportunity to give some youngsters a try? I can't think of a reason why not but I expect Roy will. Edited by Eaglehamster (18 Mar 2021 3.54pm) Bubbles?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglehamster
If we have matches remaining after hitting 40 points, wouldn't that be a golden opportunity to give some youngsters a try? I can't think of a reason why not but I expect Roy will. I think it's Parish that won't want to relax after 40 points as he will be aware of the £1m per place on offer so will want to go all out to climb the table
|
|
|
Originally posted by chris123
What has Michael Jackson's monkey got to do with it
|
|
|
Originally posted by Qwijibo
I'm assuming someone's already highlighted Mandela Egbo's move a few years ago. I can't remember who he plays for now? (poss in the US), but he never got going at Monchengladbach, literally played about one game. We need to market ourselves better with young players. We should be a better option than Chelsea, and yet we are no more likely to play young prospects than they are. In fairness, until recently our youth players were incomparable to Chelsea's, and we were never in a position to promote youth players as frequently. You only have to compare the impact Chelsea's youths had in the championship at Derby (Mount, Tomori), Wigan (James), Swansea and Villa (Abraham) to our loanees, failing so far to make any impression even at League One level. Part of the investment in the academy seems to be to do better in the highly competitive youth market, and I agree that having a track record of promoting young players quickly is of course going to help the club attract the best players. I'm sure it will have occured to Abraham, Hudson-Odoi, Tomori and Loftus-Cheek that they would get a game with us, and not be cluttering up the bench or out on loan, which is what happened to them as soon as Chelsea were allowed to spend money again. In that sense we could, as you say, be the more attractive proposition in the hugely valuable and productive South London market. Whilst it's great to have a good, nationally competitive youth team to promote from, I'm less sure about making the promotion of youth players central to the business plan, which is what would have to happen for us to promote the likes of Rak-Sakyi as quickly as he would like, and might get in Germany. Firstly, nobody has ever been able to maintain the production of stellar players forever. Southampton had a great crop over a three or four year period, with Bale, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Walcott, Shaw, Lallana, Chambers etc, but these things go in cycles and the ones they rely on now just aren't all that good. Nobody will be paying tens of millions for their current crop, and it's been a very long time since they made that kind of profit. What happens to the business model then? Secondly, do we want to be a nursery club? Look at Dortmund, literally targeting he very best young players in the world. They will turn a handsome profit on Sancho, Haaland, Reyna, Bellingham etc, but at the same time, their team is further away from catching Bayern Munich than ever. They are a huge, historic club, playing in front of 80,000 people, and they seem to have become a nursery for richer clubs, including the one they are trying to catch. What's the point in that? I'm sure it helped balance the books when Southampton sold so many great youth players as a League One or Championship side, but I can't really see how it helped develop their club once they were in the premier league. It didn't help West Ham back in the day either.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
In fairness, until recently our youth players were incomparable to Chelsea's, and we were never in a position to promote youth players as frequently. You only have to compare the impact Chelsea's youths had in the championship at Derby (Mount, Tomori), Wigan (James), Swansea and Villa (Abraham) to our loanees, failing so far to make any impression even at League One level. Part of the investment in the academy seems to be to do better in the highly competitive youth market, and I agree that having a track record of promoting young players quickly is of course going to help the club attract the best players. I'm sure it will have occured to Abraham, Hudson-Odoi, Tomori and Loftus-Cheek that they would get a game with us, and not be cluttering up the bench or out on loan, which is what happened to them as soon as Chelsea were allowed to spend money again. In that sense we could, as you say, be the more attractive proposition in the hugely valuable and productive South London market. Whilst it's great to have a good, nationally competitive youth team to promote from, I'm less sure about making the promotion of youth players central to the business plan, which is what would have to happen for us to promote the likes of Rak-Sakyi as quickly as he would like, and might get in Germany. Firstly, nobody has ever been able to maintain the production of stellar players forever. Southampton had a great crop over a three or four year period, with Bale, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Walcott, Shaw, Lallana, Chambers etc, but these things go in cycles and the ones they rely on now just aren't all that good. Nobody will be paying tens of millions for their current crop, and it's been a very long time since they made that kind of profit. What happens to the business model then? Secondly, do we want to be a nursery club? Look at Dortmund, literally targeting he very best young players in the world. They will turn a handsome profit on Sancho, Haaland, Reyna, Bellingham etc, but at the same time, their team is further away from catching Bayern Munich than ever. They are a huge, historic club, playing in front of 80,000 people, and they seem to have become a nursery for richer clubs, including the one they are trying to catch. What's the point in that? I'm sure it helped balance the books when Southampton sold so many great youth players as a League One or Championship side, but I can't really see how it helped develop their club once they were in the premier league. It didn't help West Ham back in the day either.
You overcomplicate this Consider the investment as just that, an investment. What return do we get on the capital we employ in our development structure. Whether we use the financial returns on buying in experienced players, or take the benefit of good young players ourselves is neither here nor there. I assume we shall aim to do both. I see it like Wenger's time. He just held Arsenal in the Premiership whilst investing in and paying for the new stadium. Minimised spend on players to just enough, then grew other parts of the club's infrastructure to give a big financial return in the longer run. Our development structure is probably the same, spend on it rather than new players for a while until it starts to pay off. Dortmund is benefiting from its development infrastructure and I assume it makes a handsome return. The first team is quite simply a different issue. If it can benefit from development squad members then great but that is only one strand of contribution towards overall success.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I don't hold to the myth that if Bostock had stayed with us he would have become a regular first team player and possibly even a great player. It didn't work out at Spurs but he had plenty of opportunities elsewhere and has never been more than a 2nd or 3rd tier player. Yes maybe he would have knuckled down we will never know. Patrick Bamford is a good example of a player who failed at Palace and Norwich but he found his way at boro and Leeds and has proved his point. Bostock could have done that but didn't. Edited by Badger11 (17 Mar 2021 10.08am) Bostock is 30 next year. He could be just what Hodgson is looking for by then!
|
|
|
Originally posted by YT
West Germany....deutschmarks... I wonder if that pesky Berlin wall will be coming down any time soon? 😂
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.