You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Reading V 1st XI
November 16 2026 4.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Reading V 1st XI


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
jeeagles Flag 01 Aug 21 12.03pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I think you have hit the nail on the head. There is a reluctance to try given the financial implications. In days gone buy if you were mid table and safe one or two of the youngsters would have got a run out at the end of the season

This is a false economy. We gave Mitchell a couple of games at the end of the 19/20 season and he proved he'd be ready to step up to first team level. Signing a player to play in his position would have cost £15m to £20m.

We lost 7 out of 8 of the last games with our first XI. Would have been an excellent chance to bring a few youngsters on hungry to prove a point whilst the senior pro's were already in holiday mode.

Ultimately, we didn't gain any places in those final games and only took a brief look at one young player. So failed on both fronts.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 01 Aug 21 12.04pm

Maybe we should consider buying a National League or similar standing club ? (is it even allowed ?)

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

The big teams used to be in favour of having a b team in the league below - I used to be against the idea because I felt that the only reason they did it was because they had such talent / resources at their disposal for some it was the only way they could get a competitive game regularly, and eventually you could end up with 2 Man City teams being in the Prem - however to a lesser degree for us to have a b team maybe in League 1 could actually be an answer to Neillos earlier mentioned dilemma.

Clearly - just making the point, there would have to be some considerable amount of water under the bridge & agreement on rules before it ever became a reality

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 01 Aug 21 12.10pm

Presumably the thinking of the management team about our chances of winning / picking up some points / keeping goal difference down to a minimum before those 8 games would have been different from if you asked them afterwards, knowing the outcome they probably would have agreed with you / reached the same conclusion.

Originally posted by jeeagles

This is a false economy. We gave Mitchell a couple of games at the end of the 19/20 season and he proved he'd be ready to step up to first team level. Signing a player to play in his position would have cost £15m to £20m.

We lost 7 out of 8 of the last games with our first XI. Would have been an excellent chance to bring a few youngsters on hungry to prove a point whilst the senior pro's were already in holiday mode.

Ultimately, we didn't gain any places in those final games and only took a brief look at one young player. So failed on both fronts.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 01 Aug 21 12.21pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

This is a false economy. We gave Mitchell a couple of games at the end of the 19/20 season and he proved he'd be ready to step up to first team level. Signing a player to play in his position would have cost £15m to £20m.

We lost 7 out of 8 of the last games with our first XI. Would have been an excellent chance to bring a few youngsters on hungry to prove a point whilst the senior pro's were already in holiday mode.

Ultimately, we didn't gain any places in those final games and only took a brief look at one young player. So failed on both fronts.

Mitchell showed promise when he got his chance, but no more than that. Over time he has developed and with PVA not being extended, he's made the LB position his but I don't think he was ready at the end of 2019/20.

The point about youngsters not being blooded due to the financials can't be considered to be a false economy if those players aren't ready in the view of the manager. You are one of the people ( it would seem ) that advocate playing youngsters for the sake of it - I refer back to Mark Bright's comments on that philosophy.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

jeeagles Flag 01 Aug 21 3.08pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Presumably the thinking of the management team about our chances of winning / picking up some points / keeping goal difference down to a minimum before those 8 games would have been different from if you asked them afterwards, knowing the outcome they probably would have agreed with you / reached the same conclusion.

I assume they were going for maximum points. Sports management is all about picking the right strategy and they got it it wrong.

You make a good point about covid bubbles which may have played a part.

As for points from other posters about not being ready to play - the last two youngsters we have given an opportunity to have been very impressive. I wouldn't expect all the players to be that impressive, but its a chance to find out if they are good enough or if we need to spend millions in the transfer market. If the young player doesn't quite cut it, then at least you've put them in the shop window and you might get a couple of million from a championship team for them.

Anyway. That's the past. It's great to have a manager that is thinking about the youth and has a CV that would inspire any young player.

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 01 Aug 21 3.46pm

How did we do for points/places in the last 2 seasons once we were safe from relegation?

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 01 Aug 21 5.23pm

Surely the integrity of the competition has to be considered?

I’m not saying these situations actually occurred but it wouldn’t be looked on kindly if we decided to play potentially weakened sides just for the sakes of blooding a few youth players…and the knock on effect was that a club got relegated because of it.

I think it’s only fair to apply the same philosophy from the start of the season to the end.

Clubs have every opportunity to test their youth in training against the 1st team. Wan.B got his chance in the 1st team due to his handling of Zaha in training. Says it all really. If you’re not clearly already better than palace 1st team players in training I’d argue you’re no way near ready for the Prem.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 01 Aug 21 10.31pm

Might have only been Reading, but credit to the players for turning the game on its head after being reduced to 10 men…

Special mention for the referee, he was s***!

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 01 Aug 21 10.39pm

Originally posted by Hudsoneagle

Surely the integrity of the competition has to be considered?

I’m not saying these situations actually occurred but it wouldn’t be looked on kindly if we decided to play potentially weakened sides just for the sakes of blooding a few youth players…and the knock on effect was that a club got relegated because of it.

I think it’s only fair to apply the same philosophy from the start of the season to the end.

Clubs have every opportunity to test their youth in training against the 1st team. Wan.B got his chance in the 1st team due to his handling of Zaha in training. Says it all really. If you’re not clearly already better than palace 1st team players in training I’d argue you’re no way near ready for the Prem.

The point you make in the last paragraph has been alluded to by others but is also the point missed by so many.

There’s a team of experienced coaches watch them play every day and will judge how they perform in training against established premier league players who aren’t keen to be knocked off their perch. If they aren’t at the level they’re not going to get a sniff of a Premier League appearance.

Big Toe Punt is right - we’ve not seen many good ones get away.

 

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Reading V 1st XI