This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The leader once in position is free to try and steer to his heart's content. What is in discussion is how the leader is elected. How on earth is it a 'small band of activists'? It's the majority of party members. As stated, the general public won't vote for what they consider too extreme. So you are doom mongering or abusing as to what is actually extreme. Once again, if there is this giant majority for your personal brand of politics then what's wrong with creating a party that represents it? Apparently loads of people would join it. Labour Blairites considered this during Corbyn's reign and actually did it....and the reality of democracy played out. I would agree that they should be given equal access to publicity instead of corporations and social media companies deciding what's right for the public to hear....because that's why that new party failed so massively....well that and actual Blairism not being as popular as they thought. Or perhaps it is you who are too scared to actually allow for a more democratic environment.
Actually, I didn't comment on how a leader is elected. I commented on this from you:- "The leader of a party really should reflect it." Which to me suggests that you believe that the leader should follow policies which are in line with the wishes of the majority of its members. I don't. I believe they should lead their members to adopt policies which will command a majority with the electorate, because being pragmatic is the only way to achieve anything. Idealism isn't realism. It's too easy to say the way forward is for the silent majority in the centre to form a new party, much though I would love that to happen and think it is both long overdue and badly needed. As we know, brave souls have cast their destinies on such ventures and found themselves flung aside, thus losing some of our best political people. With the way both major parties are funded, it is almost impossible to see how a new party could emerge in the short term. It would take a few major donors to step forward. It could still happen. As the Brexit disaster becomes more obvious, once the pandemic is finally out of the way and our comparative position is clear, the Tory ineptitude will make them extremely unappealing. Unless Starmer manages to recreate Blairism, which seems unlikely, Labour will remain as a fading, unelectable vision. Only then could a credibility vacuum force a new party, or several new parties, to emerge in sufficient strength to take enough seats to force a coalition. Which would probably include the SNP and their demand for a referendum. Too many unknowns for predictions, other than as we are in such a huge mess it's going to be a long, hard journey to get out of it. At least Starmer is trying. He realises that unless he dumps the far left, Labour are finished. It's probably too late, and they already are.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
I’d rather see Diane Abbott as chancellor and Emily Thornberry as Home Secretary. She’d probably want any men she didn’t like the look of locked up.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by CPFC1965
Tories are fascist scum etc is part and parcel of what the left what to present. Four failed elections have shown how ineffective they really are, especially outside of London. The Tories gave us Austerity they cried, and the truth was that they had mismanaged the economy so badly and brought us to the brink of bankruptcy and the possibility of having to apply for an IMF loan. 40 years ago, when the North was unionised, to not vote Labour was to be branded a scab, their rhetoric rang a bell. Now we're not, we're middle class, we've escaped the pits, we still have the same ideals of a progressive labour party but what we have seen is a return to the militant 70's. Labour lost the Red Wall because we voted to leave the EU, Corbyn and his acolytes chose to ignore us and WE voted NO. Labour treated their Northern membership with utter contempt, Rayner is nothing more than a Trade Union puppet who forgets she is a Manchester MP. I'll continue to vote Labour in the mayoral elections, because they know how to run regional systems and are competent at that level, but Nationally/Internationally I have grave doubts.
Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course). |
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by crystal-purley
Indeed, and most of it going on PPE, which ended up off shore in their own accounts!
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Actually, I didn't comment on how a leader is elected. I commented on this from you:- "The leader of a party really should reflect it." Which to me suggests that you believe that the leader should follow policies which are in line with the wishes of the majority of its members. I don't. I believe they should lead their members to adopt policies which will command a majority with the electorate, because being pragmatic is the only way to achieve anything. Idealism isn't realism. It's too easy to say the way forward is for the silent majority in the centre to form a new party, much though I would love that to happen and think it is both long overdue and badly needed. As we know, brave souls have cast their destinies on such ventures and found themselves flung aside, thus losing some of our best political people. With the way both major parties are funded, it is almost impossible to see how a new party could emerge in the short term. It would take a few major donors to step forward. It could still happen. As the Brexit disaster becomes more obvious, once the pandemic is finally out of the way and our comparative position is clear, the Tory ineptitude will make them extremely unappealing. Unless Starmer manages to recreate Blairism, which seems unlikely, Labour will remain as a fading, unelectable vision. Only then could a credibility vacuum force a new party, or several new parties, to emerge in sufficient strength to take enough seats to force a coalition. Which would probably include the SNP and their demand for a referendum. Too many unknowns for predictions, other than as we are in such a huge mess it's going to be a long, hard journey to get out of it. At least Starmer is trying. He realises that unless he dumps the far left, Labour are finished. It's probably too late, and they already are. Labour won't win a GE without Scotland. They would be foolish to allow another referendum, as if Scotland votes to leave, Labour will never win a GE again. I think you are more likely to see the hard-left create a new party (or several, Splitters!). It may take a much bigger rebrand that New Labour to get them credibility though. Perhaps a total name changes as the term "Labour" no longer reflects the jobs of the majority of working class people.
|
|
|
I 100% agree with this, in particular, the loss of the Scottish Westminster seats is crucial. Logically the hard left should split but at the end of the day, they do like their parliamentary salaries and perks they know they would lose if they formed a hard left party and ran for election. This way they can play student politics at the taxpayer's expense. Labour would be much more of a threat with more centrist MPs. The Corbynistas are now all/mostly in very safe seats that would be won by any Labour candidate. Originally posted by jeeagles
Labour won't win a GE without Scotland. They would be foolish to allow another referendum, as if Scotland votes to leave, Labour will never win a GE again. I think you are more likely to see the hard-left create a new party (or several, Splitters!). It may take a much bigger rebrand that New Labour to get them credibility though. Perhaps a total name changes as the term "Labour" no longer reflects the jobs of the majority of working class people.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
Labour won't win a GE without Scotland. They would be foolish to allow another referendum, as if Scotland votes to leave, Labour will never win a GE again. I think you are more likely to see the hard-left create a new party (or several, Splitters!). It may take a much bigger rebrand that New Labour to get them credibility though. Perhaps a total name changes as the term "Labour" no longer reflects the jobs of the majority of working class people. It would need a bloody long new name. The London ex-grads, benefit claimants, work dodgers, celebrities, and immigrants required for votes party. Promoted by the bbc.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
It would need a bloody long new name. The London ex-grads, benefit claimants, work dodgers, celebrities, and immigrants required for votes party. Promoted by the bbc. That made me laugh and I was always a Labour voter. Not these days, for obvious reasons.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.