You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Akshata Murty tax affairs
November 21 2026 9.35pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Akshata Murty tax affairs


Page 14 of 14 << First< 10 11 12 13 14
BlueJay Flag UK 21 Apr 22 3.03pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman


Does Tim have this approach to everything? Shut up, never make a comment unless you’re going to protest or actually change it yourself. No discussion, no debate, no displeasure. Change it or you’re an idiot. An outraged idiot. What a joy to be around. Must get invited out loads.

The closest to a meaningful campaign or protest most have seen on here is taking Wisbech Eagle to task . Yes though, we must have adopt new HOL system on the double, where for every ten posts on a topic we make, we take to the streets.. only for 'About Turn Tim' then to do another coin toss and decide that we're outraged idiots for doing that too.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 21 Apr 22 3.05pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

It's as much an issue of how rules crafted for the rich by the rich are clearly not in the interests of the average person who elects these 'servants of the people'. As in, it's not even about what 'others would do' or one person, but more that the various ways in which politicians, the rich and corporations pick our pocket should have more push back and shouldn't be options to begin with. If there were easy answers we'd already have them, but I'd certainly say that it's not a useful start for people to be 'outraged' that some 'idiots' would take issue with it to begin with.


People may well scoff but fundamentally it's wider discussion about the lack of accountability of those who 'we' elect and who should be 'working for us' not dictating how it is to us with no shame or accountability attached (it that attracts the ubiquitous 'virtue signalling' tag so be it). That's clearly an issue for you and where you feel politicians have led us as much as it is anyone else though really. I doubt many answers exist in greasing the wheels of the status quo (and i don't mean the band!).

Edited by BlueJay (21 Apr 2022 2.39pm)

Certainly the rich pick our pockets and they are fortunate in so much as they have got themselves to that position or their ancestors have.
It is a difficult ideological conundrum, since any one of us could be 'the rich' but only a few of us are, and those who are make the rules and therefore often benefit themselves as all of us probably would.

Certainly there should be more checks and balances to ensure that the wealthy don't have it all their own way, but this really relies on some of those very people effectively legislating against themselves in the interests of what is fair.

This has happened throughout history. Some in the ruling classes have on occasion put the plight of the great unwashed before personal interest.
You could argue that our democratic system is evidence enough that the will and the needs of the people are a strong enough influence on those who make the rules.

My concern is that the current super rich of this world are eroding that influence with purposeful division and control of information.
The affairs of the Chancellor's wife are small potatoes.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 21 Apr 22 3.44pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Certainly the rich pick our pockets and they are fortunate in so much as they have got themselves to that position or their ancestors have.
It is a difficult ideological conundrum, since any one of us could be 'the rich' but only a few of us are, and those who are make the rules and therefore often benefit themselves as all of us probably would.

Certainly there should be more checks and balances to ensure that the wealthy don't have it all their own way, but this really relies on some of those very people effectively legislating against themselves in the interests of what is fair.

This has happened throughout history. Some in the ruling classes have on occasion put the plight of the great unwashed before personal interest.
You could argue that our democratic system is evidence enough that the will and the needs of the people are a strong enough influence on those who make the rules.

My concern is that the current super rich of this world are eroding that influence with purposeful division and control of information.
The affairs of the Chancellor's wife are small potatoes.

Certainly, it's more an accumulation of behaviour that takes the p!ss than any particularly story or event. I agree that often the system fits around these people, rather than the other way around, and so any effort to improve matters will result in adjustments in the opposite direction. I've often thought that those who are principled or non corruptible routinely get filtered out before they reach positions of significant power.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Apr 22 7.40pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3715357]

Well, I came to this thread and asked if she had to pay remittance. And if she does it would be £30k, rising to £60k. If she pays no remittance, I'll stand corrected, but this is the first time it was mentioned.

What Sunak does may anger you, and most others, including me, but to post outrage about it whilst doing nothing to change the system is such a futile approach. Do something, like lobby your MP, or write letters to the press, or organise a protest march.

Just stop whining.

Erm, I am in touch with Sarah Jones about HMRC at the moment. I am not whining, unless you count correcting the mistakes of others whining.

So, once again. Murthy is what used to be called RNOR, Resident Not Ordinarily Resident, in other words with her prime domicile is in another jurisdiction. She can be so despite living here. Then when she has been in the UK for 7 out of the previous 9 years she has to pay the (relatively small) £30k charge. I say relatively small in the context of her overall income and that she is able to recover this charge from her Indian tax. All the time she is non-dom she pays her tax on a remittance basis, i.e. any money she brings into the country is then subject to tax as earnings. She will not have remitted any funds so no charge.

After 7 UK years she is required to pay a charge of £30k per annum. That is because she is a non-dom. By extension is does mean she is paying on a remittance basis but it isn't called a remittance or a remittance charge

All make sense?

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 22 Apr 22 1.10am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Erm, I am in touch with Sarah Jones about HMRC at the moment. I am not whining, unless you count correcting the mistakes of others whining.

So, once again. Murthy is what used to be called RNOR, Resident Not Ordinarily Resident, in other words with her prime domicile is in another jurisdiction. She can be so despite living here. Then when she has been in the UK for 7 out of the previous 9 years she has to pay the (relatively small) £30k charge. I say relatively small in the context of her overall income and that she is able to recover this charge from her Indian tax. All the time she is non-dom she pays her tax on a remittance basis, i.e. any money she brings into the country is then subject to tax as earnings. She will not have remitted any funds so no charge.

After 7 UK years she is required to pay a charge of £30k per annum. That is because she is a non-dom. By extension is does mean she is paying on a remittance basis but it isn't called a remittance or a remittance charge

All make sense?

Yes, thanks. Basically, she pays £30k every year. Which is what I said. But it is not called remittance, it is called a charge. I stand corrected. But you have enlightened me. I didn't realise that remittance was on top of that. So, despite your assertion that she has remitted no funds into the country, if she does, she will pay more to HMRC in actual tax remittance.

However, and whichever, it is still more than the average Joe Public pays to HMRC. Which was my original post that all the schoolkids got outraged about.

The pedantics about "RNOR, Resident Not Ordinarily Resident" is just fluff. Non-Dom explains it better to the above mentioned.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (22 Apr 2022 1.12am)

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Page 14 of 14 << First< 10 11 12 13 14

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Akshata Murty tax affairs