You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s right Brentford or us?
November 16 2026 3.27am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who’s right Brentford or us?


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
steeleye20 Flag Croydon 15 Aug 22 12.24pm

The U18s and now under 21s bring so much to the club I wouldn't want to be without them.

I follow them assiduously, they play quality opposition and I can imagine preferring them to the seniors!

 

eaglesdare Flag 15 Aug 22 12.28pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

Well, what Brentford definitely have not done is haemorrhage money in the transfer market with zero return.

For example : Yohan Cabaye £10m - Left on a free.
: Connor Wickham £9m - Left on a free.
: Andros Townsend £13m - Left on a free.
: Christian Benteke £27m - Left on a free (ish)
: Patrick van Aanholt £13m - Left on a free.
: Mamadou Sakho £26m - Left on a free.
: Cheikhou Kouyate £10 - Left on a free.

These incredible losses are simply unsustainable for a club of our size.

Hmm yes....but then how much each year did we get for staying in the premier league becuase we had these players?

 

johnny the eagle Flag wivenhoe 15 Aug 22 1.06pm

Not us.

 


South London born and bred
red and blue till im dead.

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 15 Aug 22 2.21pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

Well, what Brentford definitely have not done is haemorrhage money in the transfer market with zero return.

For example : Yohan Cabaye £10m - Left on a free.
: Connor Wickham £9m - Left on a free.
: Andros Townsend £13m - Left on a free.
: Christian Benteke £27m - Left on a free (ish)
: Patrick van Aanholt £13m - Left on a free.
: Mamadou Sakho £26m - Left on a free.
: Cheikhou Kouyate £10 - Left on a free.

These incredible losses are simply unsustainable for a club of our size.

those players weren't born with selling on in mind - we got value out of Kouyate, Cabaye, PVA and Andros - Ben and Sakho was not such good value, but it's more the wages where the lack of sustainability is - and remember our sell-ons ... Bolasie, AWB?

 

YT Flag Oxford 15 Aug 22 3.04pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

Hmm yes....but then how much each year did we get for staying in the premier league becuase we had these players?

When you say "did we get"...the vast majority of whatever "we" get is paid out to the players.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 15 Aug 22 4.38pm

The answer to the original question will be revealed on 30th August.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 15 Aug 22 4.46pm

Who’s right Brentford or us?
If the aim is/was to stay in the PL and earn the revenue that comes from it, then our initial policy of signing seasoned pros for that purpose has thus far worked.
That was obviously the first step, Parish is on record saying that the academy is the next step alongside improving the stadium.

 

YT Flag Oxford 15 Aug 22 6.38pm

Originally posted by Elwissthebest

The answer to the original question will be revealed on 30th August.

Lol, but not necessarily true in a one-off match. We took 4 points off Man City last season, for example, but even the greatest Palace optimist in the history of Palace optimists would struggle to argue that we've got it right whereas City have got it wrong.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Dubai Eagle Flag 15 Aug 22 7.05pm

Maybe the answer is both clubs have got it right - we did what suited our position at the time & Brentford did what suited their position - The eventual answer will more likely be measured as which club amassed greater longevity in the PL, traded more effectively during that PL period & at the time of relegation only fell into the championship, not beyond -

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 16 Aug 22 8.59am

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

They had a right go against Chelsea last year, the point I’m making is Brentford do not show too much respect to the big clubs.

Very early for Brentford, lets see how they're doing after another couple of seasons.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Aug 22 11.14am

As I already said - what will their fans be saying about Mitchell? A 40 mil full back breaks these sums down pretty quickly.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 17 Aug 22 12.56pm

Not read all the comments, so apologies if this is a repetition...

It's been well documented in recent years that South London is a real hotbed of football talent - arguably the best in world currently. I think there was a recent stat that around 45% of the England players through all age groups combined were from South London.

You don't need to be a rocket scientist to put two and two together here. We are ideally placed as the only South London based PL team and should be all over this and hoovering up the young talent. I guess the bigger question is whether our academy coaches up to scratch? - should we have more youth players coming through?

However, all you need is 1 quality player to emerge every 3 years for it to be a success. We've had Mitchell, AWB and Zaha who have all gone on to play for England in the past decade. Prior to that Moses and Routledge have done well. We seem to have a constant stream of promising youngsters in the pipeline, hopefully Rak-Sakyi will have a successful loan with The Clowns and become a first team regular next season.

I will add that our recruitment appears to have dramatically improved since the arrival of PV - perhaps we've now got the best of both? The future is bright for Palace.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Aug 22 1.17pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Not read all the comments, so apologies if this is a repetition...

It's been well documented in recent years that South London is a real hotbed of football talent - arguably the best in world currently. I think there was a recent stat that around 45% of the England players through all age groups combined were from South London.

You don't need to be a rocket scientist to put two and two together here. We are ideally placed as the only South London based PL team and should be all over this and hoovering up the young talent. I guess the bigger question is whether our academy coaches up to scratch? - should we have more youth players coming through?

However, all you need is 1 quality player to emerge every 3 years for it to be a success. We've had Mitchell, AWB and Zaha who have all gone on to play for England in the past decade. Prior to that Moses and Routledge have done well. We seem to have a constant stream of promising youngsters in the pipeline, hopefully Rak-Sakyi will have a successful loan with The Clowns and become a first team regular next season.

I will add that our recruitment appears to have dramatically improved since the arrival of PV - perhaps we've now got the best of both? The future is bright for Palace.

Mitchell came from their academy - which they then closed. I agree with you but I'm trying to make that point. Had they kept their academy, they might have had Mitchell. They didn't and he's ours.

 


Red and Blue Army!

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 17 Aug 22 1.59pm

Outside of the financial argument. Clubs have consistently shown that its hard in early years to spot all the right talent. 2 close to home examples.

Olise was released from Arsenal, Chelsea and Man City

Eze released from Arsenal, Fulham, Reading, Millwall

2 players that will play the remainder of their career at PL level and command a decent fee if they move. Both would ahve been looked at by 100's of skilled coaches

I think Eze was picked up by QPR at 18 and Olise at 16


So is there an argument that before these kids have started to mature its close to impossible to know who has a chance. And instead focus on 17 and older when physically you have a better understanding.

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s right Brentford or us?