You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hypothetical Wilf
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hypothetical Wilf


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Jan 23 8.54pm

Originally posted by stancummins

Sorry but its best now for both parties to go their separate ways . He appears to be a shadow of his former self , his close control and first touch are not as good and he has completely lost his pace as was shown in the first half when Erickson burnt him off. I also think him being here is holding up the development of players like Olise and Eze . I think he may flourish if he was a small fish in a big pond at this time of his career whether in England or abroad ,it would also free up monies even if it was just his salary to re invest

Totally agree. Even considering his place as one of the greats and a talisman etc, the reality is what he produces on the pitch and what he earns are gulfs apart and are not in keeping with a sensible wage structure at the club.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 20 Jan 23 3.39pm

Originally posted by stancummins

Sorry but its best now for both parties to go their separate ways . He appears to be a shadow of his former self , his close control and first touch are not as good and he has completely lost his pace as was shown in the first half when Erickson burnt him off. I also think him being here is holding up the development of players like Olise and Eze . I think he may flourish if he was a small fish in a big pond at this time of his career whether in England or abroad ,it would also free up monies even if it was just his salary to re invest


This and it's a shame we didn't sell him this window to get some cash for him.

PV needs to drop him maybe use as an impact sub for a few games.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

palace99 Flag New Mills 20 Jan 23 4.16pm

Originally posted by stancummins

Sorry but its best now for both parties to go their separate ways . He appears to be a shadow of his former self , his close control and first touch are not as good and he has completely lost his pace as was shown in the first half when Erickson burnt him off. I also think him being here is holding up the development of players like Olise and Eze . I think he may flourish if he was a small fish in a big pond at this time of his career whether in England or abroad ,it would also free up monies even if it was just his salary to re invest

Have to say i was shock that Erickson, who is not the quickest, overtook him so quickly. Even at the end despite a brilliant tackle by AWB he looked slow chasing that ball.

On the converse Olise and Eze are still very inconsistent and go missing for large periods of games, so Wilf is still an important player for us.

I have said for about 3 years now he will go when his contract runs out and i haven't changed my opinion.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 20 Jan 23 4.48pm

Originally posted by Vaibow

I'm sure I never said sell this jan, any club would be mad too when they can get him in the summer for less, a lot less.

My argument was Wilf should have been sold couple years back and we invest and move on in the mean time with the hope (yup, it is palace after all) that by now we have a plan a and plan b.

It's hard to invest around wilf if wilf won't be there next season, unless a like for like replacement is waiting in the wings or located.

The summer we sold AWB was the optimum time to sell wilf, losing two would have initially hurt, but AWB was a freak of nature stroke of luck, so 50 mil was too good to turn down and then whatever we got for Wilf, that total money 70/80 mil could have gone back into 3/5 players but, with Roy at the helm, it probably wasn't the right time to invest as his ideas may not have matched the future plans.

It's fair to say we haven't even began to rebuild.. RB, CB, Midfield all needs a good look at.

Edited by Vaibow (28 Dec 2022 8.01pm)

If he'd been sold a couple of years back, we'd be a couple of years into playing in the Championship again - I know hypothetically we invest that money and build a super team, but in reality, no amount of money would have given us access to a player of Wilf's quality in the final third, which is the hardest and most expensive part of a team for clubs our size to fill.

The reason we were much more willing to move on AWB is simply we don't need a £50m RB. A match-winner at the attacking end of the pitch however... invaluable and irreplaceable for our club our size.

I think our reliance on Wilf over the past few seasons is really understated by a lot of our fan base. No doubt we're seeing his powers declining, but I think he's still consistently our most dangerous player, our best finisher, and a bloke who clearly gets the club.

Pay him what he wants and build the statue.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 20 Jan 23 4.52pm

Originally posted by palace99

Have to say i was shock that Erickson, who is not the quickest, overtook him so quickly. Even at the end despite a brilliant tackle by AWB he looked slow chasing that ball.

On the converse Olise and Eze are still very inconsistent and go missing for large periods of games, so Wilf is still an important player for us.

I have said for about 3 years now he will go when his contract runs out and i haven't changed my opinion.

He was injured. Had his knee strapped up after half-time. Would not be surprised if he does not play Saturday

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 20 Jan 23 4.57pm

Eriksen was the player on the pitch I'd have most wanted Zaha to be one on one against. Watching Eriksen keep up with him, and get across him, was like watching the end of an era.

His close control and ability in small spaces is still very good but he's definitely lost a yard of pace in going past players and Wednesday looked like he'd lost another one - might just be an injury causing that.

I can't see Palace and Zaha being in a position in September where both are happy. If anything, I can see both being unhappy. Likely scenario looks like Wilf goes on a free and probably not to the heights he's hoping for. On the bright side, if he does go somewhere right at the top and gets game time, it'll mean he has a bloody good next few months so that's something to look forward to.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 20 Jan 23 10.05pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

If he'd been sold a couple of years back, we'd be a couple of years into playing in the Championship again - I know hypothetically we invest that money and build a super team, but in reality, no amount of money would have given us access to a player of Wilf's quality in the final third, which is the hardest and most expensive part of a team for clubs our size to fill.

The reason we were much more willing to move on AWB is simply we don't need a £50m RB. A match-winner at the attacking end of the pitch however... invaluable and irreplaceable for our club our size.

I think our reliance on Wilf over the past few seasons is really understated by a lot of our fan base. No doubt we're seeing his powers declining, but I think he's still consistently our most dangerous player, our best finisher, and a bloke who clearly gets the club.

Pay him what he wants and build the statue.

Great post absolutely spot on IMO

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 20 Jan 23 11.35pm

All the time there is the sell on fee it has made little sense to sell Wilf as at his peak you couldn’t get close to a player of his stature with the sales receipt.

You also have to take into account that it’s never been proven that we have had a large bid for him anyway. Possibly the only time was when Arsenal paid 70m? for Pepe and it was being banded around that Palace wanted similar but up front and not on the never never which is why they ultimately chose Pepe. Even that is just a story so not sure it was true.

I suppose in reality he has always been worth far more to us than anyone else and now he is getting to the end of his career I personally have no problem with him disappearing on a free at the end of the season. He has done his bit for CPFC and I reckon we’ve already been rewarded with the best he has to offer.

By the end of this season we need to be looking at Olise and Eze to step up and carry more responsibility out wide. They certainly have the ability to do so and it may be the time to concentrate on a new system and improving our personnel in the centre of midfield rather than buying new wingers.

It also shouldn’t be forgotten that getting Wilf’s salary off the books frees up sufficient for a couple of very decent players wages.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jan 23 5.41am

Originally posted by ambrose7

I can't see Palace and Zaha being in a position in September where both are happy. If anything, I can see both being unhappy. Likely scenario looks like Wilf goes on a free and probably not to the heights he's hoping for.

But which large English club would want him as the big boys all seem to be signing up younger wingers at the moment leaving European clubs as his best option

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Jan 23 9.03am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

But which large English club would want him as the big boys all seem to be signing up younger wingers at the moment leaving European clubs as his best option

Exactly Chelsea have just signed a second winger Noni Madueke whilst Arsenal have signed Trossard.

I'm afraid all the noise about Zaha is being generated by his agent.

 


One more point

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 21 Jan 23 9.22am

Originally posted by Badger11

Exactly Chelsea have just signed a second winger Noni Madueke whilst Arsenal have signed Trossard.

I'm afraid all the noise about Zaha is being generated by his agent.

Trossard to Arsenal is I think a telling blow to Wilf’s hopes of going there.

I think he’ll end up with big cash offers at seasons end from Arab or Turkish leagues, but I can’t see him going to any of the top English teams, nor the traditional European big hitters.

 

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hypothetical Wilf