You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thank you PV
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Thank you PV


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 12 Apr 23 10.15am

Originally posted by Painter

Just how did the board let Vieira down, they gave him an opponent the resurrect his managerial career, let him take on his useless coaching team. Gave him time to turn things around this season, then hear he was touting himself to Leeds and refusing to take calls from his Chairman.

There was only going to be one outcome.

Yep I agree there.

If his approach to managing is success contingent on a blank chequebook, which would be very 'Pep', then he'll struggle just about everywhere.

I have no idea the extent or actual truth but his general manner made it quite easy for me to believe he was avoiding the board and actively job hunting to suggest he had strayed very far from his identity as Palace manager.

The fact for me is that we have a far better squad now than we have had for some time and the old codger many paint Roy out to be came in and won games back to back scoring seven goals when we looked about as far away from scoring as possible, and without a win, for months under the disinterested and apathetic PV. The squad needs and needed improvement however was very far from the disappointing and disjointed performances we were churning out under Pat.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

taylors lovechild Flag 12 Apr 23 10.30am

Originally posted by Painter

Just how did the board let Vieira down, they gave him an opponent the resurrect his managerial career, let him take on his useless coaching team. Gave him time to turn things around this season, then hear he was touting himself to Leeds and refusing to take calls from his Chairman.

There was only going to be one outcome.

If that rumour is true then it was inevitable and the correct decision. Personally I was concerned that confidence was too low for us to bounce back when the fixtures became easier, so I do understand the change even though I was more willing to be patient than most (I tend to be more forgiving with most players and managers so long as they don't sh!t where they eat). Kudos to Parish and Roy as so far the move has worked.

 

EddieMac Flag 12 Apr 23 10.59am

Originally posted by Badger11

The board did let PV down however the mark of a good manager is making the best of what you have and I am afraid that PV didn't.

I think it is clear to see that PV let himself down more than anyone else. No one forced him to keep playing Schlupp in that role that he could not play.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 12 Apr 23 11.26am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

An astute point. It's not as if Parish woke up the morning of PV's final game and out of the blue thought to himself, "I'll sack Pat today." Negotiations with Hodgson must have been ongoing for a while, combined with, as you mention, the revelation that the board had thought of getting rid of PV going back to February, at which point our league position was fine. There's more to this than meets the eye methinks, the departure of Derry just another random clue thrown in to try and comprehend what was going on behind the scenes.

He should have been sacked at the latest Feb, i could see the massive decline from midway through last season, so Parish should have seen it, The board is not at fault financially, as Willo said 120m is a lot of money, say 60m a year for two years, money spent on players not ready for the team, any team in England appointing him is a mug, he will never make it as a manager.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 12 Apr 23 11.46am

It would have been nice if he had been given the chance to get through a difficult spell, but it seems there was stuff going on behind the scenes, Derry and PV's recruits clearly did not fit, and looking at the improved performances, not only of Eze and Olise, but of Doucoure, you have to say Parrish has been vindicated, though I was very anti the sacking at the time. PV won't be described as a failure here though, it's a mixed record with far more positives than negatives, criticising PV for playing players out of position is a bit unfair, do you give good players a different role or bad players a familiar one? Schlupp is best as an attacking midfielder, but it's fair to expect him to play a bit deeper to help Doucoure even though Schlupp's positional sense isn't the best (though I think it improved under PV). Younger managers can over-complicate things maybe, sometimes it's just about an arm round the shoulder or a kick up the *rse, Eze and Olise play with a 'smile on their face', off the ball they need to frown a bit more, and that's what we're getting with Roy back in charge - 'aggression off the ball' as the great man said after the Leeds game.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 12 Apr 23 11.48am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

As I have mentioned elsewhere and as you note, this was a necessary spend, without it we would have half a team, and frankly the job was only half finished, particularly given that a number of players are now out of contract and / or clearly over the hill. The rebuild after Hodgson's initial tenure was always going to take place over a few seasons, probably due to financial considerations and the hope that the academy would eventually come good. PV didn't have the financial backing in the second season, and he failed to make the most of what he had left over from the first.
We are more or less where we were when Roy took over from FdB previously, eking out a PL existence with the hope of breaking into the top 10 should circumstances improve.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (12 Apr 2023 9.23am)

We are now arriving at a point almost identical to when PV arrived. We have potentially about 6 to 10 players who are likely to leave for one reason or another so it will be another crossroads for the team.

I reckon these will go

Butland
Clyne
Riedewald
Milivojevic
McArthur
Zaha
Tomkins

Then there are others who could also leave

Ward
Mateta
Guehi
Ferguson

Out of all of the above, only Mateta and Guehi would bring in fees so you get the awful feeling that short term contracts are going to be offered to players who are clearly past it. It will be an interesting few months for sure.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 12 Apr 23 11.50am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

He should have been sacked at the latest Feb, i could see the massive decline from midway through last season, so Parish should have seen it, The board is not at fault financially, as Willo said 120m is a lot of money, say 60m a year for two years, money spent on players not ready for the team, any team in England appointing him is a mug, he will never make it as a manager.

He didn't see it because there was no '' massive decline ''.

In February 22 Palace were in 12th place in the table, 8 points away from the relegation zone.

Last season ended with 1 defeat in the last 6 games.

I referenced a report that said that Palace were considering sacking Vieira as long ago as February 22. I also wrote that such an action would be hard to justify given the placing in the league at that time.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 12 Apr 23 11.54am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

We are now arriving at a point almost identical to when PV arrived. We have potentially about 6 to 10 players who are likely to leave for one reason or another so it will be another crossroads for the team.

I reckon these will go

Butland
Clyne
Riedewald
Milivojevic
McArthur
Zaha
Tomkins

Then there are others who could also leave

Ward
Mateta
Guehi
Ferguson

Out of all of the above, only Mateta and Guehi would bring in fees so you get the awful feeling that short term contracts are going to be offered to players who are clearly past it. It will be an interesting few months for sure.

Another crossroads also given the fact that as things stand we don't have a manager for next season !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

taylors lovechild Flag 12 Apr 23 12.51pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

He didn't see it because there was no '' massive decline ''.

In February 22 Palace were in 12th place in the table, 8 points away from the relegation zone.

Last season ended with 1 defeat in the last 6 games.

I referenced a report that said that Palace were considering sacking Vieira as long ago as February 22. I also wrote that such an action would be hard to justify given the placing in the league at that time.

I don't remember anyone complaining when we smashed Arsenal 3-0 in April, or beat United on the final day, or when we won 4-0 against Everton in the cup in March. If that is a massive decline then sign me up!

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 12 Apr 23 1.44pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I don't remember anyone complaining when we smashed Arsenal 3-0 in April, or beat United on the final day, or when we won 4-0 against Everton in the cup in March. If that is a massive decline then sign me up!


I think Lanzo was referring to Feb this year not last year and I have to agree that there are grounds for stating that a serious decline had become evident by then.

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 12 Apr 23 1.47pm

Originally posted by anerley_eagle

I suggest a thread where we are positive about PV, if he were to ever read this site, he could skip to just the kind messages.

Honestly, he did ok. He fell short of our expectations (and his own), but he leaves her with good karma and respect from me and others. We now have some really exciting players, we have attack options, we defend well, we seem to be solid in midfield now... we need some more luck, but our league position isn't bad (relative to other seasons).

One thing you can say is it is obvious he cared - he spoke with emotion and honesty and you could see he really wanted to make this team great.

Personally, I would have loved to see him tackle the last few games which look easier on paper - but actually, if it was time for him to go, we have Paddy Mac who has been great stuff with the youth teams.

Thanks PV - it's sad managers don't get very long these days, I would have kept you on for longer, good luck with your next challenge.

Well said, Anerley Eagle!

There can be no doubt that despite relatively poor team investment during more recent transfer windows, that Vieira left a stronger team in the hands of Hodgson than what the former inherited. Pre-Vieira, we played too defensively and over-cautiously with so many fans bemoaning the lack of attacking bite. Vieira shifted the dial enabling Palace players to move with more confidence and flair yet always cohesively - egos always parked back in the changing room (if allowed anywhere near the club unlike the travails at certain other Prem clubs).

Perhaps it was more of a case of other Prem teams also reading more into Vieira's tactical approach second season in charge and whilst the goals up front dried up in a particularly tough run of matches against top flight teams post World Cup, Palace still managed to pull together creditable (if not impressive) draws against many with individual errors all too often out of PV's hands.

Hodgson's age means that he's not going to be a long term managerial appt therefore the chance to see him work alongside Vieira within a consultative, nurturing capacity, might've been a better option. Hodgson has clearly been able to move on from the tactics of old under his previous reign and move into territory more fruitful by way of scores yet there is undeniably some influence of Vieira's strategy at the heart of his new managerial style. Only caveat is that Palace still have periods of the game, when they resort to soaking up pressure rather than dictating the game - Leeds were profligate with opportunities on Sunday (and also known for dropping off come second half). Better teams will exploit when Palace waste possession and drop off themselves. Southampton and West Ham alone should provide sterner tests.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 12 Apr 23 3.16pm

Originally posted by doombear


I think Lanzo was referring to Feb this year not last year and I have to agree that there are grounds for stating that a serious decline had become evident by then.

Yes I think he was referring to Feb this year in terms of sacking PV.
And I was responding to his comment that he saw a massive decline midway through last season. Which I didn't .

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Jacey Flag 12 Apr 23 4.10pm

A fair assessment as to why PV,had to go!!


[Link]

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 12 Apr 23 4.26pm

Originally posted by Jacey

A fair assessment as to why PV,had to go!!


[Link]


Perhaps but I think it also says something about Hodgson. With his previous squad he operated a pretty rigid 442 system. We used to wonder whether he had them tied together by string, the way they moved to-and-fro across the pitch.

In the last two games he has allowed at least some players a degree of freedom. It speaks to me of him believing that some players in the current team can be trusted to do the right things most of the time whereas he saw his previous squad as limited and in need of rigid on pitch discipline.

In short it reinforces my belief that Hodgson, whilst on the cautious side, will quickly identify what player resources he has and will set them up according to how he thinks they are best suited rather than to any rigid system of his own making.

Edited by doombear (12 Apr 2023 4.27pm)

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 12 Apr 23 4.59pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Yes I think he was referring to Feb this year in terms of sacking PV.
And I was responding to his comment that he saw a massive decline midway through last season. Which I didn't .

I was referring to both, there was a clear decline in form 2/3s through last season, which was noticeable, and just after Christmas we looked a complete shambles, i posted on Jan 22nd he should go, and if he didn't we would be relegated.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thank you PV