You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cooper
November 16 2026 2.29am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cooper


Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6
est1905 Flag 08 Feb 24 5.13pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I’m curious as to why people dislike Cooper so much when you look at his CV.
He won the youth World Cup with England, and took Swansea to the play offs in his first season.
He went to Nottingham Forest and took them from the bottom of the Championship to the Premier League , a feat that they hadn’t achieved for many years.
Promoted clubs often struggle as we have seen in recent years and frequently go straight back down.
However, he kept them up against the odds despite a basket case owner who bought players against Cooper’s wishes and constantly undermined him.
That to me looks a pretty unblemished career up until this season.
The fans idolised him there which seemed to antagonise the owner even more so it was no surprise that there was a parting of ways.

I’m not particularly a fan of the football his teams play, but it seems only fair to try and introduce some balance into the debate.

Its incorrect to say players were bought against his wishes. I saw an interview with him a few weeks into his first season in the Premiership and he categorically stated he was aware of as well as approved of every single incoming player. In fact many of them were targets he asked Forest to bring in. So its a myth to say he didn't want any of these players. Besides, Its a laughable defence of a manager anyway. First we're supposed to feel sorry for a manager that isn't supported in the transfer market. Now we're supposed to feel sorry for one that is given a whole new team to go with the one he has? Its a nonsense.
The reality is he did very well with an England youth team that had so much talent in it any manager would have fancied his chances of success. I have no argument with his Championship successes at Swansea and getting Forest promoted by those achievements are irrelevant when talking about managing in the Premiership.
If you look only at what he has done as a top flight manager in his first year he spent more than most top 6 teams, had no significant injury problems, was languishing in the bottom 4 for the whole of that season and stayed up by the skin of his teeth. In his second season he had to be sacked because he was taking Forest down. You only have to look at what Nuno has done with the same players since Cooper left.

Its all about opinions, no argument there. I respect other peoples but for me? he is not good enough, certainly no better than Roy which is surely what we all want if we are going to make a change and personally I very very much hope Parish doesn't turn to him just because he is available. Theres a good reason why in the months he has been that no other club has.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 08 Feb 24 5.14pm

Originally posted by Charlie B

Simon Jordan on Talksport said Dougie doesn't want the job.

If it was the same edition that I listened to on Tuesday, Jordan also said that if Parish asked Freedman to do it then he thought he would.

Dougie himself told me that he wasn't interested in management anymore, but that was some time ago now and people do change their minds.

However, I don't see DF taking the job should it become available.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

PatrickA Flag London 08 Feb 24 6.20pm

You says it’s incorrect?
Cooper would see it differently.
He told Carragher in an interview,
‘As a manager I can’t just go , ‘I did’nt want him. It’s not the players’ fault.I can’t just go I never bought them so I’m not playing them..The training ground is a nightmare.’
Carragher added that Forest was the one club where the manager hadn’t a clue who was coming in .
The last point is probably an exaggeration because Cooper no doubt was involved in the acquisition of young British players like Gibbs White.

Even if one accepts that Cooper hasn’t done well more recently, the same argument could be applied to Hodgson.
A terrible winless run at the end of his last spell at Palace, took Watford down, and has presided over a team this season that can’t defend nor attack nor score from set pieces.

I don’t know if Cooper would be right for Palace, but it does seem unfair to dismiss him out of hand without looking at his career record is decent.


Originally posted by est1905

Its incorrect to say players were bought against his wishes. I saw an interview with him a few weeks into his first season in the Premiership and he categorically stated he was aware of as well as approved of every single incoming player. In fact many of them were targets he asked Forest to bring in. So its a myth to say he didn't want any of these players. Besides, Its a laughable defence of a manager anyway. First we're supposed to feel sorry for a manager that isn't supported in the transfer market. Now we're supposed to feel sorry for one that is given a whole new team to go with the one he has? Its a nonsense.
The reality is he did very well with an England youth team that had so much talent in it any manager would have fancied his chances of success. I have no argument with his Championship successes at Swansea and getting Forest promoted by those achievements are irrelevant when talking about managing in the Premiership.
If you look only at what he has done as a top flight manager in his first year he spent more than most top 6 teams, had no significant injury problems, was languishing in the bottom 4 for the whole of that season and stayed up by the skin of his teeth. In his second season he had to be sacked because he was taking Forest down. You only have to look at what Nuno has done with the same players since Cooper left.

Its all about opinions, no argument there. I respect other peoples but for me? he is not good enough, certainly no better than Roy which is surely what we all want if we are going to make a change and personally I very very much hope Parish doesn't turn to him just because he is available. Theres a good reason why in the months he has been that no other club has.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 08 Feb 24 6.45pm

Maybe we should put all the season ticket holders in a hat, and pick out the new manager

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 08 Feb 24 7.16pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Maybe we should put all the season ticket holders in a hat, and pick out the new manager

I've lost mine now

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cooper