You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Forest
November 16 2026 2.16am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Forest


Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6
Dubai Eagle Flag 26 Mar 24 6.50am

Surprised to read that they are appealing against the 4 point deduction - I kind of understood it as a 3 point deduction for falling foul of the regulations, plus 3 points for the value of the overspend (£34.5 million) reduced by 2 points for co operation =
4 points penalty.

I cant believe that they have found new evidence in such a short period of time so they must be arguing that the original process / outcome was flawed in some way-

It will be interesting to see the outcome.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Mar 24 6.50am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Surprised to read that they are appealing against the 4 point deduction - I kind of understood it as a 3 point deduction for falling foul of the regulations, plus 3 points for the value of the overspend (£34.5 million) reduced by 2 points for co operation =
4 points penalty.

I cant believe that they have found new evidence in such a short period of time so they must be arguing that the original process / outcome was flawed in some way-

It will be interesting to see the outcome.

Beat me to it although I think your post is better.

 


One more point

Dubai Eagle Flag 26 Mar 24 6.51am

Clearly we were typing at the same time, lol

Originally posted by Badger11

Forest have appealed their points deduction. Bearing in mind that they were let off 2 points for co-operating I hope the appeal takes back those 2 points for not accepting the verdict.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 26 Mar 24 6.58am

Maybe they are going to argue that Forest & Everton are being treated differently to Man City ? & there should be a commonality of how each case is viewed / treated & judged including timelines (in that respect I think most reasonable even minded people would probably agree)

I read that the Man City hearing dates have been agreed but its not been made public & its not going to be until 2025 (presumably thats one of the reasons why its not been made public, because for sure its not a level playing field for everyone else)


Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Surprised to read that they are appealing against the 4 point deduction - I kind of understood it as a 3 point deduction for falling foul of the regulations, plus 3 points for the value of the overspend (£34.5 million) reduced by 2 points for co operation =
4 points penalty.

I cant believe that they have found new evidence in such a short period of time so they must be arguing that the original process / outcome was flawed in some way-

It will be interesting to see the outcome.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 26 Mar 24 8.13am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Surprised to read that they are appealing against the 4 point deduction - I kind of understood it as a 3 point deduction for falling foul of the regulations, plus 3 points for the value of the overspend (£34.5 million) reduced by 2 points for co operation =
4 points penalty.

I cant believe that they have found new evidence in such a short period of time so they must be arguing that the original process / outcome was flawed in some way-

It will be interesting to see the outcome.


Indeed. They seem to want to argue over the lack of fairness in the system for clubs such as them who haven't had the recent benefit of parachute payments etc. Like Badger, I do hope Forest have the 2 points originally given back to them for co-operation withdrawn. I think clubs have to see that there is a jeopardy in going to appeal on spurious grounds (if that is, indeed, what is happening here).

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Mar 24 8.29am

[Link]

A grin of rapt adoration fell on my face on perusing the comments by Darragh MacAnthony and I agree with the general thrust of his preferred solution.I found myself nodding like a donkey.


Edited by Willo (26 Mar 2024 8.39am)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 26 Mar 24 8.48am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Surprised to read that they are appealing against the 4 point deduction - I kind of understood it as a 3 point deduction for falling foul of the regulations, plus 3 points for the value of the overspend (£34.5 million) reduced by 2 points for co operation =
4 points penalty.

I cant believe that they have found new evidence in such a short period of time so they must be arguing that the original process / outcome was flawed in some way-

It will be interesting to see the outcome.

Well they just threw that out the window.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 26 Mar 24 8.52am

Originally posted by Willo

[Link]

A grin of rapt adoration fell on my face on perusing the comments by Darragh MacAnthony and I agree with the general thrust of his preferred solution.I found myself nodding like a donkey.


Edited by Willo (26 Mar 2024 8.39am)

Quality idea.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 26 Mar 24 8.57am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Surprised to read that they are appealing against the 4 point deduction - I kind of understood it as a 3 point deduction for falling foul of the regulations, plus 3 points for the value of the overspend (£34.5 million) reduced by 2 points for co operation =
4 points penalty.

I cant believe that they have found new evidence in such a short period of time so they must be arguing that the original process / outcome was flawed in some way-

It will be interesting to see the outcome.

Would be interesting to know what specifically there are appealing against, and by proxy the 1 or 3 points.

Does anyone know any of the 'rules'? Could the 2 point reduction be added on?

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 26 Mar 24 9.30am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Maybe they are going to argue that Forest & Everton are being treated differently to Man City ? & there should be a commonality of how each case is viewed / treated & judged including timelines (in that respect I think most reasonable even minded people would probably agree)

I read that the Man City hearing dates have been agreed but its not been made public & its not going to be until 2025 (presumably thats one of the reasons why its not been made public, because for sure its not a level playing field for everyone else)

It is appropriate for Man City to be treated differently as they are being prosecuted for different rule breaches under a different regime.


 

PahrTee Flag 26 Mar 24 9.44am

Draft Picks ? Surely a spoonerism....

 

Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Forest