You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Ban Smoking
November 19 2026 5.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ban Smoking


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
Lee McB Flag Van Basten's nephew... 04 Jan 05 10.00pm

Quote HorshamEagle at 04 Jan 2005 8:12pm
But the argument here is to turn a block of seats where people smoke into a non smoking area. Tell me why is that fair? the smokers have agreed to do it away from everyone else in a confined area, so why try and and 2nd class us even more and stop it all together?


I agree that to tell someone who smokes not to, when they are sitting in a designated smoking area is not right.

I was fortunate in that when I first moved into the Holmesdale many years ago, the crowds were lower than what they are now and so I had the choice as to whether I wanted to sit in a smoking or no-smoking area. Unfortunately for people joining this season (whether they only be here for Premiership football or not) they will get limited choice as to where they sit. However when I applied for my seat in the Holmesdale I was made aware of the smoking/no smoking areas, and I'm sure times haven't changed. Therefore, if you are a non-smoker sitting in a smoking area then you do have to put up with it.

If I'm honest I'd prefer the whole stadium to be non-smoking but I admit that's just me seeing things through the eyes of a non-smoker who just wants to go to a football match and not worry about what I am inhaling.

I can understand why smokers would be against this.

Quote
Ash is prevention of smoking, but i was commenting on their single mindess and the fact that they have come out with a statement that is incredibly obvious, but is also the tip of the iceberg with regards the NHS and it's blood suckers! They can only comment on the subject in hand, but it is a silly argument to make and one where many comparisons can be made!


What argument/statement is this that ASH have made? Or have I missed a post somewhere along the way? I'm sure your point is valid but I'm not entirely sure what it's referring to.

Quote
Every little helps - You're totally right lee, me smoking at football does make a difference to you, but the difference is so small you will never feel the effects. If you were in a room with me and other smokers for a prolonged period of time then you would feel the effects. But the argument can be levelled at anything that lets out poisonous fumes. All vehicles are a danger to my health with their fumes, i don't drive, i don't expect others to stop driving, it's part of life which i have to accept, it's not a worry to my health because i realise the danger to my own health is minimal.


So what are your views on banning smoking in pubs and restaurants? I noticed a previous post where you said you were considerate when others were around, which is good to know, but in some pubs you get smoking/non-smoking areas even though (ventilation or not) it is still an enclosed space and there is still an effect on the non-smokers.

I accept your argument about smoking in an open stadium and driving fumes, but how often do you breathe in car fumes in a pub?

So will banning smoking in these places be allowed?

Quote
I'm not deliberately going out to hurt people, i'm partaking in a habit with which i have very little control over. Fair enough, i want to to smoke, it curves the nerves, it relaxes me, this doesn't mean i could stop smoking with a click of the fingers. With effort and willpower anyone can do anything, but why should i stop? Selfish view to take i know, but for once i'd like to to be selfish about something.


Sorry, it just came across from a previous post of yours that you wanted to quit but couldn't because you were addicted. I obviously misinterpreted it, so apologies.

Quote
My comment about perhaps football is the wrong sport for premier fan was a silly one to make and one which was ill thought out and i apologise. Everyone is welcome at football, but this also means that smokers should be welcomed as much as the next person.


Agreed...as long as they do it in the designated areas

 


I am running the 2011 Virgin London Marathon in aid of The Children's Trust: [Link]

Pete the Eagle is on twitter:

Pete and Alice are on Facebook: [Link]

HorshamEagle Flag under the union jack 04 Jan 05 10.13pm

Quote Lee McB at 04 Jan 2005 10:00pm
Agreed...as long as they do it in the designated areas

Precisely!!!!!!!!!!

 


Do you know where hell is?

Lee McB Flag Van Basten's nephew... 04 Jan 05 10.18pm

Quote johnno42000 at 04 Jan 2005 8:36pm
Look at Ireland, New York, San Francisco etc. A certain percentage of people have been forced to give up smoking in order to keep their jobs, that is not democracy or freedom it is the strictist form of tyranny.


Any idea what percentage and what kind of jobs we are talking about here? I'm just curious because I can think of any myself.

I also don't think it's the strictest form of tyranny. That's taking it way too far. It's like I could say stopping people from murdering each other is not democracy or freedom, but the strictest form of tyranny. It's extreme to say the least.

All it is is another law for people to follow. No one agrees with every single law.

Quote
This WILL effect the amount of revenue raised and people WILL continue to smoke (but in fewer numbers), but as in New York and in Ireland there will be job losses in the leisure industry...pubs etc as addicted smokers are not visiting these premises and the revenue has fallen, where are the Government going to make up the shortfall when the revenue from Public Houses goes down?


Fortunately I don't work for the Government so don't have to figure this one out in depth, but how have New York managed it?

I agree revenue may be likely to fall but people who are addicted will continue to buy cigarettes. And people who aren't addicted, but perhaps smoke socially, will still go to bars and clubs. And maybe even more non-smokers will go out to bars and clubs?

A question for those who do smoke: Do you go to pubs/bars/clubs to smoke? Or do you go to socialise with mates? I know for many that both come hand in hand, but what I'm getting at is if smoking was banned in public places, and pubs and restaurants, would you confine yourselves to your homes or would you still go out and socialise with your mates?

Being a non-smoker I don't know the answer to that, as the only reason I go to pubs is to meet mates, so I'd be interested in your opinions.

Quote
What would happen if this freedom loving Government (sic!) decides to ban smoking at Football Grounds? I don't know the exact figures but I should imagine there is a fair percentage of supporters who smoke (and are probably addicted)...will they vote with their feet and not turn up? Where will the clubs make up any lost revenue?


So if you were prevented from smoking for 90 minutes every other week (or every week if you go to away games) then you would stop coming to Palace altogether? Really? You would turn your back on Palace and football for the sake of those 3/4 cigarettes you get through each game?

Quote
Where will the Government turn to next to raise the loss in Revenue? If the whole country stopped smoking today, the benefit on the savings on the NHS costs would probably take many years to come through, where would they make up the shortfall...higher taxes for all. The same is true if 10% of people give up smoking...somewhere along the line you, me and everyone else will have to pay higher taxes in one form or another as there WILL be a shortfall.


But the whole country wouldn't stop smoking. If there was a ban then it would be in public places. Yes, that would mean a decrease in income through this way, but I don't think it would be so drastic that this country would slide into a massive decline.

But if someone can prove otherwise with reliable sources of information then I'm happy to re-evaluate my views. To be honest though, I think there's very little we know (both smokers and non-smokers) about the facts and likely outcomes of any bans compared to the Government, who I'm sure would only introduce smoking bans if they knew it would be beneficial.

 


I am running the 2011 Virgin London Marathon in aid of The Children's Trust: [Link]

Pete the Eagle is on twitter:

Pete and Alice are on Facebook: [Link]

palaceareback Flag Surrey 05 Jan 05 1.56pm

Smoking rocks

 


Increase the Peace

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 04 Oct 08 8.59pm

bumping...just for nostagia's sake!

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Ban Smoking