Catfish Burgess Hill 08 Apr 14 7.17pm |
|
|
Given the ethnic mix of Croydon, South Norwood and South London in general, should there be more black and Asian Palace fans?
Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial
|
Qwijibo Bournemouth 08 Apr 14 7.30pm |
|
|
Yes.
The fact we're not probably means we've failed to appeal to these communities. Hasn't this been touched upon for years?
If there is such thing as a 'typical' Palace fan, ironically I think they live away from the area, whilst many of those who are local support other teams. Do we represent a working class club?
Don't ask me though, I live f***ing miles away.
|
JL85 London,SE9 08 Apr 14 7.32pm |
|
|
How would you feel if the club handed ticket discount to people who live locally? Hard done by or a good way of generating more support?
Not for ST, but for matchday tickets only, for example.
|
Qwijibo Bournemouth 08 Apr 14 7.41pm |
|
|
I'm no marketer, but I think for a business to thrive there has to be more to a promotion than just money off. Somehow it needs to generate some sort of cultural appeal, and in this case, definitely a sense of community.
Additionally, the 'punter' has to have a likelihood to recommend the experience to someone else, who in turn comes along. We can't resort to diluting our ARPU, especially if this generates a perception that 'new' fans get a better deal than those who stuck by through all the administrations. There has to be a brand value that is representative through something other than price.
As to how you do this, I've no idea. People have to want to come! I think if anyone knows this stuff, surely it's Steve Parish.
The only discount I would actively promote on a big scale refers to kids, as this is a case of 'buying' a new generation who will eventually mature into a fully-fledged season ticket holder for the next 50 years!
|
maghull 08 Apr 14 7.48pm |
|
|
Growing up in south norwood in the late 70s-early 80s,which by then already had a large black community as did thornton heath. Most of the black kids I grew up with liked and played football, but did't ever really attend football matches. I know more black people go to football now than back then, but not in great numbers. And I suppose if they do go to games ,there are a lot more attractive teams in London to follow than palace. The first time I remember seeing large groups of young black people at games was at spurs and arsenal in the mid 80s but not at palace.
Edited by maghull (08 Apr 2014 7.49pm)
|
EastEndPalace WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 08 Apr 14 7.55pm |
|
|
There are black and Asian fans. But a majority of the black Asian community are either Man UTD or Arsenal fans. They don't really seem to be interested in football as such but will support who is the best side at the time.
|
Kosowski Standing at the top of B Block 08 Apr 14 7.58pm |
|
|
Without wanting to ruffle anyone's feathers, a lot of Asians often seem to be gloryhunting types who will 'support' the flavour of the month on TV or down the pub. Couldn't care less about attracting that sort, and it has bollocks all to do with ethnicity.
Block B comment of 2011/2012 Season:
"That's better Palace, better...but still fucking shit!"
----------------------------------------------------------------
Dann to Much, Much to Yong.
|
Qwijibo Bournemouth 08 Apr 14 7.59pm |
|
Quote maghull at 08 Apr 2014 7.48pm
Growing up in south norwood in the late 70s-early 80s,which by then already had a large black community as did thornton heath. Most of the black kids I grew up with liked and played football, but did't ever really attend football matches. I know more black people go to football now than back then, but not in great numbers. And I suppose if they do go to games ,there are a lot more attractive teams in London to follow than palace. The first time I remember seeing large groups of young black people at games was at spurs and arsenal in the mid 80s but not at palace.
There are more attractive teams for everyone to support, so why do a disproportionate amount of black people support (eg) Arsenal over Palace? If our assumptions are true, there's some sort of cultural reason. Why are we less appealing?
|
maghull 08 Apr 14 8.04pm |
|
Quote EastEndPalace at 08 Apr 2014 7.55pm
There are black and Asian fans. But a majority of the black Asian community are either Man UTD or Arsenal fans. They don't really seem to be interested in football as such but will support who is the best side at the time.
Your right there,and I think that's always been the case. I think its got a lot to do with family. Most white working class familys I know have always followed there local team and attended games going back years. I would think most people started going to football with there dad or another family member.
|
EastEndPalace WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 08 Apr 14 8.09pm |
|
Quote Qwijibo at 08 Apr 2014 7.59pm
Quote maghull at 08 Apr 2014 7.48pm
Growing up in south norwood in the late 70s-early 80s,which by then already had a large black community as did thornton heath. Most of the black kids I grew up with liked and played football, but did't ever really attend football matches. I know more black people go to football now than back then, but not in great numbers. And I suppose if they do go to games ,there are a lot more attractive teams in London to follow than palace. The first time I remember seeing large groups of young black people at games was at spurs and arsenal in the mid 80s but not at palace.
There are more attractive teams for everyone to support, so why do a disproportionate amount of black people support (eg) Arsenal over Palace? If our assumptions are true, there's some sort of cultural reason. Why are we less appealing?
Lets not start all this pandering bollocks LOL. We are less appealing because football is less important to the black community then the white community. Black people up and down the country support Arsenal, City, UTD and Liverpool, passionate black football fans support local teams.
|
maghull 08 Apr 14 8.17pm |
|
|
I would say Liverpool and man utd have the largest Asian support more than any other team ive seen. Now in liverpools case that's got nothing to do with community as there is no Asian community in Liverpool. They come from all over the country to watch them.
|
Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Stoke sub normal 08 Apr 14 8.22pm |
|
|
I think that if we were to stay in the prem for a few years, we would attract more fans of all races. I live in Somerset, nearest club Yeovil Town. Nearly everyone watches the YT results and wears the colours on a match day, but if you ask them who the support, they will invariably mention a prem club. This is because they were non league a few years ago. I believe their gate has increased since promotion to the Championship, and is likely to drop again when relegated. I imagine this is quite normal, as our gates fluctuate. I don't think we look that attractive to young fans who like to win things. Nothing to do with culture.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers
|
Harry Beever Newbury 08 Apr 14 8.24pm |
|
Quote maghull at 08 Apr 2014 8.17pm
I would say Liverpool and man utd have the largest Asian support more than any other team ive seen. Now in liverpools case that's got nothing to do with community as there is no Asian community in Liverpool. They come from all over the country to watch them.
There's a pretty big Chinese community in Liverpool.
|
PalaceFaithful 08 Apr 14 8.29pm |
|
|
As a black fan, i would say that the way to generate more fans from other ethnic groups is to start by appealing to kids. When i was in primary school my headteacher (palace fan) would often have 2 games a season where it was encouraged for the whole school to go with a parent for cheap prices, which was a great day out. There's also the fact that many parents in the area came over and supported the better teams of their generation when they we're teens/young adults, and this is passed onto their children, but it can be broken. My dad is a united "fan" and i broke away from the norm and supported palace, and have loved every moment of it. It will be a slow process but give it a generation or two and there will be changes i think.
|
Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Stoke sub normal 08 Apr 14 8.31pm |
|
Quote Harry Beever at 08 Apr 2014 8.24pm
Quote maghull at 08 Apr 2014 8.17pm
I would say Liverpool and man utd have the largest Asian support more than any other team ive seen. Now in liverpools case that's got nothing to do with community as there is no Asian community in Liverpool. They come from all over the country to watch them.
There's a pretty big Chinese community in Liverpool.
Yes. But they wash the team strips and cater for the fans after the games.
Just kidding 
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers
|
s2art1e 08 Apr 14 8.38pm |
|
|
Good question...
As a Lambeth born Palace fan of Asian decent, I think as some of the previous posters have suggested, its got a lot to do with family, I would have thought a lot of our supporters were introduced to the club via another family member, Dad, Uncle etc taking little their son or nephew down to Selhurst for his first game and support the local team. Certainly in the Asian community, in my age group, a lot of my ethnic peers support Liverpool, as they were the successful team of the time, and because there was no family connection or allegiance to a particular team.
With me, it was more about supporting my local team, and if I look at our team in the late nineties, the ethnicity of our team was a reflection of the demographic of the area, more so then some other teams, which I thought was great.
Edited by s2art1e (08 Apr 2014 8.53pm)
|
maghull 08 Apr 14 8.39pm |
|
Quote Harry Beever at 08 Apr 2014 8.24pm
Quote maghull at 08 Apr 2014 8.17pm
I would say Liverpool and man utd have the largest Asian support more than any other team ive seen. Now in liverpools case that's got nothing to do with community as there is no Asian community in Liverpool. They come from all over the country to watch them.
There's a pretty big Chinese community in Liverpool.
And your point is?
|
Catfish Burgess Hill 08 Apr 14 8.54pm |
|
|
If the crowd does not reflect the local demographic then there is something wrong. It would be really difficult to target ethnic groups without appearing to be desperate, patronising or both. I think those who say that the club should target local school children n general are right.
Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial
|
Mapletree Croydon 08 Apr 14 9.36pm |
|
Quote PalaceFaithful at 08 Apr 2014 8.29pm
As a black fan, i would say that the way to generate more fans from other ethnic groups is to start by appealing to kids. When i was in primary school my headteacher (palace fan) would often have 2 games a season where it was encouraged for the whole school to go with a parent for cheap prices, which was a great day out. There's also the fact that many parents in the area came over and supported the better teams of their generation when they we're teens/young adults, and this is passed onto their children, but it can be broken. My dad is a united "fan" and i broke away from the norm and supported palace, and have loved every moment of it. It will be a slow process but give it a generation or two and there will be changes i think.
Is the right answer.
Many people that go to Palace do so because as small children they were taken by a relative. The first generation of Black and Asian people to arrive post war probably didn't come from a history of football and saw it as irrelevant. Then when their children did get into football, why would they take an interest in Palace when there were some sexy teams to support. They didn't have the family allegiance so could choose for themselves. Now their children are probably mostly following in their footsteps. Hopefully in due course the schoolkids will get some peer pressure to support their local team and Palace should carry on targeting schools for deals.
I wonder how it is for cricket, are there big communities of black and asian people supporting Surrey? The first generation came mostly from cricket mad countries.
|
lush1076 leatherhead 08 Apr 14 9.54pm |
|
|
The current generation of black people have lost interest in cricket in this country. In the 70's and 80's the oval was packed with black people whenever the West Indies were here. Now there is nothing. Asian people still have a massive interest in cricket and it is reflected locally in club teams.
|