This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Adrian Mariappa
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Alex55 SM1 14 Apr 14 1.22pm |
|
|
Havent seen too much said about his performances. But I thought Saturday was the best he has played for us. He is a total revelation at right back. Am I hyping him or is he really that good?
'- Really? Honestly? Back in the USSR,,,you don't know how lucky you are.
|
Sparkie Epping 14 Apr 14 1.25pm |
|
|
He's got better and more comfortable with every game he has played, so glad TP brought him in and switched Wardy to left back....Although Moxey started the season well I feel both he and Parr are a little out of their depth at this level.
|
EastEndPalace WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 14 Apr 14 1.26pm |
|
|
Looks better at full back then he did at CB definitely.
|
Plane Bromley 14 Apr 14 1.28pm |
|
Quote Alex55 at 14 Apr 2014 1.22pm
Havent seen too much said about his performances. But I thought Saturday was the best he has played for us. He is a total revelation at right back. Am I hyping him or is he really that good?
Scoring goals for Palace...Oops, sorry, I've got the wrong defender, I meant John Terry 
I think he's been really good since he arrived and is really learning the role of a full back, he gets forward a lot better recently, his defensive game is very good.
|
EagleLegend97 London 14 Apr 14 1.28pm |
|
|
Works really well with Punch on the right aswell.
|
adrian b Landrindod, Wales 14 Apr 14 1.30pm |
|
|
Adrian M is very lucky to be in the side. He gets caught out on pace many times but is able to foul his way to safety. Definitely knows how not to get booked
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 14 Apr 14 1.32pm |
|
|
Last three games he's looked really good, and links up well going forwards. I thought his game saturday wasn't as good as Cardiff or Chelsea, but that might be not having KG in front of him.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
palace99 New Mills 14 Apr 14 1.40pm |
|
|
changed my seat on sat and was near front of the Arthur so had a good look at him 1st half.
He did a decent job but is pretty ordinary. Going forward likes an extra touch and often declines to cross but kept it simple and rarely lost possession.
Defensively he did ok but has a tendency to drift inside (near the centre backs) when villa are attacking down the other side.
He's decent back up at both centre and right back but for over £2m thought we might be getting more for our money.
Has definitely improved overall though - at Wigan in the cup he was a complete liability.
Not trying ot have a pop, just saying it as i see it.
|
Alex55 SM1 14 Apr 14 1.42pm |
|
|
Thanks fellas. Its nice to know that I am generally on the right side of this one. The guy is looking like a seriously good right back. No disrespect to Moxey or Parr. Hoping he can go on and confirm what I think I see.
'- Really? Honestly? Back in the USSR,,,you don't know how lucky you are.
|
adrian b Landrindod, Wales 14 Apr 14 1.42pm |
|
Quote palace99 at 14 Apr 2014 1.40pm
changed my seat on sat and was near front of the Arthur so had a good look at him 1st half.
He did a decent job but is pretty ordinary. Going forward likes an extra touch and often declines to cross but kept it simple and rarely lost possession.
Defensively he did ok but has a tendency to drift inside (near the centre backs) when villa are attacking down the other side.
He's decent back up at both centre and right back but for over £2m thought we might be getting more for our money.
Has definitely improved overall though - at Wigan in the cup he was a complete liability.
Not trying ot have a pop, just saying it as i see it.
Yup
|
Alex55 SM1 14 Apr 14 1.44pm |
|
|
Ooops...well I will have to be guided as I have only seen him on telly. Shame.
'- Really? Honestly? Back in the USSR,,,you don't know how lucky you are.
|
SeagullHunter Reading 14 Apr 14 1.45pm |
|
Quote palace99 at 14 Apr 2014 1.40pm
changed my seat on sat and was near front of the Arthur so had a good look at him 1st half.
He did a decent job but is pretty ordinary. Going forward likes an extra touch and often declines to cross but kept it simple and rarely lost possession.
Defensively he did ok but has a tendency to drift inside (near the centre backs) when villa are attacking down the other side.
He's decent back up at both centre and right back but for over £2m thought we might be getting more for our money.
Has definitely improved overall though - at Wigan in the cup he was a complete liability.
Not trying ot have a pop, just saying it as i see it.
Is that not Pulis's style of defending? A narrow back four with the wingers tucking in... I think he's been superb and really hasn't received the credit he deserves. Gets forward really well and can defend too.
Dont let Cabaye go
|
EagleLegend97 London 14 Apr 14 1.46pm |
|
Quote adrian b at 14 Apr 2014 1.30pm
Adrian M is very lucky to be in the side. He gets caught out on pace many times but is able to foul his way to safety. Definitely knows how not to get booked
Bit harsh to say he's lucky to be in the side. If you're part of a defence that has got as many clean sheets as we have, then you must be doing something right. Plus he looks a lot more comfortable than Parr and Moxey in defence.
|
adrian b Landrindod, Wales 14 Apr 14 1.51pm |
|
Quote EagleLegend97 at 14 Apr 2014 1.46pm
Quote adrian b at 14 Apr 2014 1.30pm
Adrian M is very lucky to be in the side. He gets caught out on pace many times but is able to foul his way to safety. Definitely knows how not to get booked
Bit harsh to say he's lucky to be in the side. If you're part of a defence that has got as many clean sheets as we have, then you must be doing something right. Plus he looks a lot more comfortable than Parr and Moxey in defence.
As mentioned, his positioning may be governed by TPs direction. This only makes him a moderate player being groomed to be better. For Palace to go the next step we should be looking for a player with a bit more, rather like Ward.
|
Y Ddraig Goch In The Crowd 14 Apr 14 1.58pm |
|
Quote adrian b at 14 Apr 2014 1.51pm
Quote EagleLegend97 at 14 Apr 2014 1.46pm
Quote adrian b at 14 Apr 2014 1.30pm
Adrian M is very lucky to be in the side. He gets caught out on pace many times but is able to foul his way to safety. Definitely knows how not to get booked
Bit harsh to say he's lucky to be in the side. If you're part of a defence that has got as many clean sheets as we have, then you must be doing something right. Plus he looks a lot more comfortable than Parr and Moxey in defence.
As mentioned, his positioning may be governed by TPs direction. This only makes him a moderate player being groomed to be better. For Palace to go the next step we should be looking for a player with a bit more, rather like Ward.
It depends what you want from your Full Back. Ward is definitely a better defender but Mariappa & Puncheon's understanding going forward gives us much more of an attacking threat - hence mariappa getting caught out and Puncheon often dropping back to cover.
For my money all the time that Punch is playing then Mariappa should be in the team.
the dignified don't even enter in the game
|
sxp55 South Norwood 14 Apr 14 1.58pm |
|
|
we look a better side with him in the team. more balanced too
@sxp55555
|
Plane Bromley 14 Apr 14 2.00pm |
|
Quote SeagullHunter at 14 Apr 2014 1.45pm
Quote palace99 at 14 Apr 2014 1.40pm
changed my seat on sat and was near front of the Arthur so had a good look at him 1st half.
He did a decent job but is pretty ordinary. Going forward likes an extra touch and often declines to cross but kept it simple and rarely lost possession.
Defensively he did ok but has a tendency to drift inside (near the centre backs) when villa are attacking down the other side.
He's decent back up at both centre and right back but for over £2m thought we might be getting more for our money.
Has definitely improved overall though - at Wigan in the cup he was a complete liability.
Not trying ot have a pop, just saying it as i see it.
Is that not Pulis's style of defending? A narrow back four with the wingers tucking in... I think he's been superb and really hasn't received the credit he deserves. Gets forward really well and can defend too.
Nope, that's how everyone defends.
Palace99, what is he meant to do, stay out on the wing when the ball is on the other side of the pitch? That would isolate him and would virtually mean that we are playing with a man short. I'm also not really sure what you expect for the sum of £2m? AM has done everything asked of him while in a Palace shirt.
|
victor43 St. Albans 14 Apr 14 2.09pm |
|
|
Really good player, has been brilliant these last few weeks. Has a very impressive leap on him too! His link up play with Punch is also usually very goo as people have mentioned. Much prefer to have him at RB and Ward at LB and not have Moxey and Parr. As good as they have been, they are not really good enough for the prem.
Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]
Twitter:
|
adrian b Landrindod, Wales 14 Apr 14 2.10pm |
|
|
Good stuff Plane and the rest. I thought we were discussing Maryupher as a player in himself. But you are right, he does need to do what he is told and well, which he does. The point about Punchey covering is also a good one. There is a bit of a problem here tho'. Will all players of Punchy's ilk have to take into account the weaknesses of fellow players and will there be a time when Palace will invest in a player without having to make do? And by weaknesswes I don't mean the occasional mistake but built in failings ALA Maryupher.
|
Plane Bromley 14 Apr 14 2.18pm |
|
Quote adrian b at 14 Apr 2014 2.10pm
Good stuff Plane and the rest. I thought we were discussing Maryupher as a player in himself. But you are right, he does need to do what he is told and well, which he does. The point about Punchey covering is also a good one. There is a bit of a problem here tho'. Will all players of Punchy's ilk have to take into account the weaknesses of fellow players and will there be a time when Palace will invest in a player without having to make do? And by weaknesswes I don't mean the occasional mistake but built in failings ALA Maryupher.
It's only you and Palace99 that see these 'weaknesses', all players have to defend to a certain extent when we haven't got the ball, that's all elementary stuff and I really shouldn't need to explain it to ya Ade!
As victor says above, he has a terrific leap on him and being a central defender, he often has the vision to move inside and pick up things that the two CB's may miss.
|