You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Howard Webb...again!
November 16 2026 12.25pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Howard Webb...again!


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Johnny Byrne Flag Pinner 22 Apr 14 4.55pm

He is officiating at the Citeh game.

 


1 June 2010 - saved from oblivion by CPFC 2010
27 May 2013 - promoted to Premier League
2013-14 - 11th in PL
2014-15 - 10th in PL
2015-16 - 15th in PL
2016-17 - 14th in PL (and grateful for that!)

Hoof Hearted 22 Apr 14 4.57pm

Unless he's been appointed as the new Manure Manager!

 

Proper_Gander Flag Anerley 22 Apr 14 5.00pm

Quote Johnny Byrne at 22 Apr 2014 4.55pm

He is officiating at the Citeh game.

I went home from the Villa game, thinking he was utter dogs***e.

But having seen the highlights on telly later, I have to admit he made the right calls. And it took some balls to change his mind when it came to the penalty decision, for a home side, no less.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 22 Apr 14 5.34pm

Quote Proper_Gander at 22 Apr 2014 5.00pm

Quote Johnny Byrne at 22 Apr 2014 4.55pm

He is officiating at the Citeh game.

I went home from the Villa game, thinking he was utter dogs***e.

But having seen the highlights on telly later, I have to admit he made the right calls. And it took some balls to change his mind when it came to the penalty decision, for a home side, no less.


Have to agree, spent most of the game thinking he was just re-enforcing how s*** a ref he is. Then I got home and the w***er got all the big deciions right, think i was more pissed off, he called them correctly than when I thought he was wrong!!

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 22 Apr 14 5.41pm

Quote Proper_Gander at 22 Apr 2014 5.00pm

I went home from the Villa game, thinking he was utter dogs***e.

But having seen the highlights on telly later, I have to admit he made the right calls. And it took some balls to change his mind when it came to the penalty decision, for a home side, no less.

He correctly rescinded the pen for handball, but (1) he should not have given the pen without first consulting his lino - especially as the ball had gone out behind the goal so he had time; and (2) after rescinding it, he gave a goal kick instead of a corner.

He missed their keeper kicking out at Jedinak - a straight red and a penalty. He missed Bolasie's shooting foot being kicked away from him in the act of shooting - also a straight red and a penalty.

Coward Webb bottles the big decisions, i.e. making calls against the perceived bigger team in favour of the perceived smaller team. Man City have just got a handy replacement for Silva.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

EagleLegend97 Flag London 22 Apr 14 5.48pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 22 Apr 2014 5.41pm

Quote Proper_Gander at 22 Apr 2014 5.00pm

I went home from the Villa game, thinking he was utter dogs***e.

But having seen the highlights on telly later, I have to admit he made the right calls. And it took some balls to change his mind when it came to the penalty decision, for a home side, no less.

He correctly rescinded the pen for handball, but (1) he should not have given the pen without first consulting his lino - especially as the ball had gone out behind the goal so he had time; and (2) after rescinding it, he gave a goal kick instead of a corner.

He missed their keeper kicking out at Jedinak - a straight red and a penalty. He missed Bolasie's shooting foot being kicked away from him in the act of shooting - also a straight red and a penalty.

Coward Webb bottles the big decisions, i.e. making calls against the perceived bigger team in favour of the perceived smaller team. Man City have just got a handy replacement for Silva.

Agree that the Jedinak incident should have been a red card and a pen, but to be fair to the w***er, the Bolasie incident wasn't. He just out his footing. But I still hate Webb, especially after his awful performance in our game against Southampton.

 

Proper_Gander Flag Anerley 22 Apr 14 6.53pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 22 Apr 2014 5.41pm

Quote Proper_Gander at 22 Apr 2014 5.00pm

I went home from the Villa game, thinking he was utter dogs***e.

But having seen the highlights on telly later, I have to admit he made the right calls. And it took some balls to change his mind when it came to the penalty decision, for a home side, no less.

He correctly rescinded the pen for handball, but (1) he should not have given the pen without first consulting his lino - especially as the ball had gone out behind the goal so he had time; and (2) after rescinding it, he gave a goal kick instead of a corner.

He missed their keeper kicking out at Jedinak - a straight red and a penalty. He missed Bolasie's shooting foot being kicked away from him in the act of shooting - also a straight red and a penalty.

Coward Webb bottles the big decisions, i.e. making calls against the perceived bigger team in favour of the perceived smaller team. Man City have just got a handy replacement for Silva.


I disagree with the Bolasie incident, I don't think it's such a clear cut case.

 

Mangopablo Flag south LONDON 22 Apr 14 9.27pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 22 Apr 2014 5.41pm

Quote Proper_Gander at 22 Apr 2014 5.00pm

I went home from the Villa game, thinking he was utter dogs***e.

But having seen the highlights on telly later, I have to admit he made the right calls. And it took some balls to change his mind when it came to the penalty decision, for a home side, no less.

He correctly rescinded the pen for handball, but (1) he should not have given the pen without first consulting his lino - especially as the ball had gone out behind the goal so he had time; and (2) after rescinding it, he gave a goal kick instead of a corner.

He missed their keeper kicking out at Jedinak - a straight red and a penalty. He missed Bolasie's shooting foot being kicked away from him in the act of shooting - also a straight red and a penalty.

Coward Webb bottles the big decisions, i.e. making calls against the perceived bigger team in favour of the perceived smaller team. Man City have just got a handy replacement for Silva.

Spot on, Ray

 


"The course of true love never did run smooth"

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 22 Apr 14 11.01pm

He definatly owes us a few decisions but with the title in the balance he will bottle everything that might go in our favour.

 

7@burnley79 Flag Battersea 22 Apr 14 11.35pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2014 4.57pm

Unless he's been appointed as the new Manure Manager!


Apparently Utd did want to employ within so this fits

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 23 Apr 14 7.56am

Quote Proper_Gander at 22 Apr 2014 6.53pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 22 Apr 2014 5.41pm

Quote Proper_Gander at 22 Apr 2014 5.00pm

I went home from the Villa game, thinking he was utter dogs***e.

But having seen the highlights on telly later, I have to admit he made the right calls. And it took some balls to change his mind when it came to the penalty decision, for a home side, no less.

He correctly rescinded the pen for handball, but (1) he should not have given the pen without first consulting his lino - especially as the ball had gone out behind the goal so he had time; and (2) after rescinding it, he gave a goal kick instead of a corner.

He missed their keeper kicking out at Jedinak - a straight red and a penalty. He missed Bolasie's shooting foot being kicked away from him in the act of shooting - also a straight red and a penalty.

Coward Webb bottles the big decisions, i.e. making calls against the perceived bigger team in favour of the perceived smaller team. Man City have just got a handy replacement for Silva.


I disagree with the Bolasie incident, I don't think it's such a clear cut case.


Holt stood on Bolassie's standing foot, def penalty and red card (possibly).

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 23 Apr 14 9.45am

This guy always favours the big teams. Bad news.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

AussieJedinak Flag Folkestone 23 Apr 14 9.54am

How did he ever bag the WC final?

I don't think he's ever had two decent games on the trot?

 

indianapalace85 Flag Bromley 23 Apr 14 10.18am

Quote Ray in Houston at 22 Apr 2014 5.41pm

Quote Proper_Gander at 22 Apr 2014 5.00pm

I went home from the Villa game, thinking he was utter dogs***e.

But having seen the highlights on telly later, I have to admit he made the right calls. And it took some balls to change his mind when it came to the penalty decision, for a home side, no less.

He correctly rescinded the pen for handball, but (1) he should not have given the pen without first consulting his lino - especially as the ball had gone out behind the goal so he had time; and (2) after rescinding it, he gave a goal kick instead of a corner.

He missed their keeper kicking out at Jedinak - a straight red and a penalty. He missed Bolasie's shooting foot being kicked away from him in the act of shooting - also a straight red and a penalty.

Coward Webb bottles the big decisions, i.e. making calls against the perceived bigger team in favour of the perceived smaller team. Man City have just got a handy replacement for Silva.


The ball never went off the pitch, so how can it have been a corner?

 

lankygit Flag Lincoln 23 Apr 14 10.36am

Quote 7@burnley79 at 22 Apr 2014 11.35pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 22 Apr 2014 4.57pm

Unless he's been appointed as the new Manure Manager!


Apparently Utd did want to employ within so this fits


You may jest lads but you can get 500/1 on him.

[Link]

 


Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link]

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 23 Apr 14 4.24pm

Quote indianapalace85 at 23 Apr 2014 10.18am

The ball never went off the pitch, so how can it have been a corner?


I remember that it went behind, but some reports say it was collected by the goalie. The commentary crew were adamant that it should have been a corner. However, if it did go to the goalie, then how is it that the game restarts with a goal kick? It's a drop ball in their penalty area, right?

Any way you slice it, Webb completely spit the bit on that sequence. While under absolutely no pressure other than that of his own making. Overall his performance was appalling.

Edited by Ray in Houston (23 Apr 2014 4.27pm)

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 23 Apr 14 6.04pm


Some talk of how brave Webb was for admitting he was wrong and changing his mind. This puts me in mind of a 'goal' at Selhurst in the early 70s. A palace player had a shot and missed, the ball hitting the outside of the side netting. The ref gave it as a goal and the opposition went nuts. The ref consulted the lino, but neither saw tit properly, so the ref continued to be adamant. The opposition asked him to ask the Palace captain, Stevie Kember, who, honestly admitted there was no goal scored, and the ref gave a goal kick instead. On telly the panel said Kember should not have been so honest as in the future Palace will get a goal that will not be given for no good reason, and these things even themselves out. Some time later Clive Allen put a free into the Coventry net, but the ball hit the back stanchion so hard, the ball flew out and no goal given. Ideal opportunity for the ref to be 'big' and change his mind. He didn't. The moral is to assume the ref is always right and take the good with the bad, as it may even out. In Webb's case, Palace have lots of credit owed!

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 23 Apr 14 8.30pm

Jedi at the coin toss, "Long time, no see, Baldy!"

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

dg1937 Flag 23 Apr 14 8.37pm

And the Freddie Sears goal at Bristol City, that was another one that hasn't 'evened out' yet (though we are veering off topic a bit). We need a 'great Palace refereeing injustices' thread!

 

Master Coin Flag 23 Apr 14 8.42pm

Quote kenbarr at 23 Apr 2014 8.30pm

Jedi at the coin toss, "Long time, no see, Baldy!"


Doesn't sound like Jedi. Not nearly enough strewths or cobbers in there methinks.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Howard Webb...again!