You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We're A Championship Side
November 16 2026 12.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We're A Championship Side


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Eggy Flag Sutton 07 May 14 2.23pm

Not sure if this has been mentioned before, but the team currently 11th in the Barclays Premier League with 44 points, and which just pulled back the title chasing Liverpool from 3-0 down to 3-3 is, effectively, a Championship side.

Looking at our starting line-up on Monday, 8 of those players were Championship players last season. By the end of the game we were fielding 10 2012/13 Championship players, with the 11th (Ledley) never having played in the EPL either.

Two things:
1. Further demonstrates the remarkable job Pulis has done, getting the best (and more) from the players he had available.

2. Shows that to move on next season we do need to strenghten the squad and to bring in a bit more quality / experience, whilst not losing the team spirit and work ethic. I'm not suggesting this team cannot do it again next season, but it's a bit like the season we finished 3rd in the old 1st Division, in that an element of the success is down to the fact a majority of players have reached their peak at the same time, which may prove harder to maintain next season.

This is not a negative thread in any way what so ever, just an observation while also again shouting from the rooftops what an amazing season this has been, from an amazing manager, amazing squad of great hard working players, and amazing fans.

God I love being a Palace fan !!

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 07 May 14 3.28pm


Interesting post. Don't you thinking in the long run the championship class will start working against the side and they will get picked off? It's ok to play counter attacking formations but they only work as long as the opposition don't score or Palace need to win. The players required to change to more varied tactics may not be found among those we have. Not sure though as Ward, Ince, Williams and Gayle are still to develop.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 07 May 14 3.42pm

Quote adrian b at 07 May 2014 3.28pm


Interesting post. Don't you thinking in the long run the championship class will start working against the side and they will get picked off? It's ok to play counter attacking formations but they only work as long as the opposition don't score or Palace need to win. The players required to change to more varied tactics may not be found among those we have. Not sure though as Ward, Ince, Williams and Gayle are still to develop.


You really do talk some nonsense don't you? DW is certainly one of the players that will attract a lot of interest from other PL clubs in the window.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 May 14 4.06pm

Individual talent can make the difference, but a well drilled, cohesive team that plays to its strengths and more importantly uses players other strengths to nulify its weaknesses is always superior.

For all their flare on the attack, and goal scoring prowess, Liverpool's title hopes were dashed because they just can't defend. Their goal scoring papered over their cracks, and we got right at them, but the simple fact is that any team that throws away a 3-0 advantage has serious problems.

Liverpool couldn't defend in midfield, and they certainly couldn't defend at the back. They pretty much had a back two, as their full backs were always out of position, and lacked the capacity to get back - and when up the field lacked a defensive midfield presence.

Anyone who questions what KG does, needs to look at those three goals we scored.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Barcelona Based Fan Flag No longer Barcelona, now living in... 07 May 14 4.08pm

I reckon there's a lot of players in our squad who will attract some serious offers the biggest battle we face is keeping the current crop happy enough with ££££ and bonuses!

I hate closed season, Agents get busy and greedy players holding clubs to ransom!

 


TaxiMark
Sheffield Wednesday Fan
Posted 23 February 2013 - 07:49 PM
I don't mind palace to be fair. Much better club than tinpot Charlton and Brighton

Gameover Flag 07 May 14 4.21pm

We can't let sentiment get in the way of what we need to do as a club. The squad needs to be strengthened and alot of players will likely not play as much as they did this season. I would love for the current squad to play every minute of every match but is unlikely as TP will look to bring in more quality and cover which will also create more competition for places. But TP and the board know what we need to do and I trust in their decisions although Speroni defo needs a new contract and if they dont make it happen then that would be a travesty.

 


" AN AMAZING NIGHT AT SELHURST PARK LIVERPOOL HAVE CAVED IN"

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 08 May 14 12.53am

You could [could] put together a starting XI of players who you would want in the Championship who played for us this season, but won't potentially play for Palace again.

Price
Moxey
Gabbs
Paddy (didn't play - yet)
Marange
Thomas
Bannan
Dobbie
Kebe
Phillips
Wilbs

Including some on loan, like Rambo, who we may not see again.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

MikeT Flag Burlington (Toronto Area) 08 May 14 3.14am

Quote pstrutt at 08 May 2014 12.53am

You could [could] put together a starting XI of players who you would want in the Championship who played for us this season, but won't potentially play for Palace again.

Price
Moxey
Gabbs
Paddy (didn't play - yet)
Marange
Thomas
Bannan
Dobbie
Kebe
Phillips
Wilbs

Including some on loan, like Rambo, who we may not see again.

Paddy came on as a 3rd CB in the home game against Hull where TP completely outmanaged Judas Bruce & son.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 08 May 14 5.49am

Quote pstrutt at 08 May 2014 12.53am

You could [could] put together a starting XI of players who you would want in the Championship who played for us this season, but won't potentially play for Palace again.

Price
Moxey
Gabbs
Paddy (didn't play - yet)
Marange
Thomas
Bannan
Dobbie
Kebe
Phillips
Wilbs

Including some on loan, like Rambo, who we may not see again.

I think you're right about all these players, plus Parr maybe as well. That would mean signing 2 new LBs

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 08 May 14 6.52am

Quote MikeT at 08 May 2014 3.14am

Quote pstrutt at 08 May 2014 12.53am

You could [could] put together a starting XI of players who you would want in the Championship who played for us this season, but won't potentially play for Palace again.

Price
Moxey
Gabbs
Paddy (didn't play - yet)
Marange
Thomas
Bannan
Dobbie
Kebe
Phillips
Wilbs

Including some on loan, like Rambo, who we may not see again.

Paddy came on as a 3rd CB in the home game against Hull where TP completely outmanaged Judas Bruce & son.

Entirely missed that. Was on me holidays.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

The Dolphin Flag 08 May 14 7.20am

Interesting in that it shows that purchasing a new team doesn't make you any better.
Probably why other than a few exceptions that us buying so many in the summer didn't work for Holloway.
As Neil Warnock often said - the team that got you there has the heart to keep you there and in our case
Speroni
Ward
Delaney
Gabbidon for part of the campaign
Jedinak
KG
Parr/Moxey - ditto
Bolasie
Murray - some games

show that a team is a team and that can get you a long way.
Add Tony Pulis to that equation and hey presto!

 

Calzardi Flag Croydon 08 May 14 7.22am

Interesting thread. I feel that when we got promoted, yes, we were a championship club still. Bit as soon as Pulis and his coaches came, he instilled a lot of premier league quality into the team, even though a few of our players were evolving it naturally anyway. I agree that in hindsight, because a lot of our players played in the championship last season, we can be seen as a championship club, but we're not now we're a premier league club with some naturally developed premier league quality. It can only get better with new additions too.

 


"DFS are selling Boat Sofa's. They've got a sail on."

Bitter Flag Harpenden 08 May 14 8.44am

Quote Calzardi at 08 May 2014 7.22am

Interesting thread. I feel that when we got promoted, yes, we were a championship club still. Bit as soon as Pulis and his coaches came, he instilled a lot of premier league quality into the team, even though a few of our players were evolving it naturally anyway. I agree that in hindsight, because a lot of our players played in the championship last season, we can be seen as a championship club, but we're not now we're a premier league club with some naturally developed premier league quality. It can only get better with new additions too.


I think this comment has hit the nail on the head. The Championship players have developed into Premiership players. We are now guaranteed to finish in 11th place. I was thinking that it would only take a small change in luck for those 1-0 wins to become 1-0 defeats, but Tony Pulis has built a career out of being lucky every year, which leads me to wonder how much is it about having a positive mentality - he manufactures luck!

 

Hoof Hearted 08 May 14 10.21am

Quote Bitter at 08 May 2014 8.44am

Quote Calzardi at 08 May 2014 7.22am

Interesting thread. I feel that when we got promoted, yes, we were a championship club still. Bit as soon as Pulis and his coaches came, he instilled a lot of premier league quality into the team, even though a few of our players were evolving it naturally anyway. I agree that in hindsight, because a lot of our players played in the championship last season, we can be seen as a championship club, but we're not now we're a premier league club with some naturally developed premier league quality. It can only get better with new additions too.


I think this comment has hit the nail on the head. The Championship players have developed into Premiership players. We are now guaranteed to finish in 11th place. I was thinking that it would only take a small change in luck for those 1-0 wins to become 1-0 defeats, but Tony Pulis has built a career out of being lucky every year, which leads me to wonder how much is it about having a positive mentality - he manufactures luck!


Shades of the old golf expression (many top golfers have used it) .... "Yeah I was lucky, but the more I practice, the luckier I get!"

 

crackerau Flag melbourne 08 May 14 12.18pm

We are not just a premiership club, but a good premiership club. we have beaten two title contenders. I think Bolasie, Gayle and Ince can cause a lot of problems, but we need a good striker or two. we were lucky with injuries, but had some decent backup.

 


Reports of my death are highly exaggerated

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 08 May 14 12.27pm

Quote crackerau at 08 May 2014 12.18pm

We are not just a premiership club, but a good premiership club. we have beaten two title contenders. I think Bolasie, Gayle and Ince can cause a lot of problems, but we need a good striker or two. we were lucky with injuries, but had some decent backup.


Chelsea and........?

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Proper_Gander Flag Anerley 08 May 14 12.36pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 08 May 2014 12.27pm

Quote crackerau at 08 May 2014 12.18pm

We are not just a premiership club, but a good premiership club. we have beaten two title contenders. I think Bolasie, Gayle and Ince can cause a lot of problems, but we need a good striker or two. we were lucky with injuries, but had some decent backup.


Chelsea and........?


In fairness to him, coming back from 0-3 when we didn't even need any points felt like a victory.

Just a shame Gayle's last shot was wide. Imagine if he had scored a hat-trick and we had won 4-3...

 

Eggy Flag Sutton 08 May 14 12.47pm

Quote Calzardi at 08 May 2014 7.22am

Interesting thread. I feel that when we got promoted, yes, we were a championship club still. Bit as soon as Pulis and his coaches came, he instilled a lot of premier league quality into the team, even though a few of our players were evolving it naturally anyway. I agree that in hindsight, because a lot of our players played in the championship last season, we can be seen as a championship club, but we're not now we're a premier league club with some naturally developed premier league quality. It can only get better with new additions too.


As the OP this was very much the point I was trying to make, along with the fact that all this success has effectively been achieved with a team made up of players from the Championship, and who went toe to toe with title contenders.

I do think we're a Premier league team, which has been achieved by making players better, not buying in loads of Premier League experience / mercenaries etc..

In TP I'm sure we have the right man to add the right players to the squad (as already proved in January) to strengthen further and take us forward.

 

Generix Flag Orpington 08 May 14 1.04pm

I think the oppo to OP.

Clearly the players are Prem players who last season were playing in the Championship...

 

Eagle_SA Flag Just outside Cape Town 08 May 14 2.07pm

They say the table doesn't lie.

11th in the league with 44 points would suggest we're a credible Premier League team.

 


And I see signs of half remembered days, I hear bells that chime in strange familiar ways

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We're A Championship Side