You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labour's next direction
November 22 2026 2.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Labour's next direction


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
lil j-eagle Flag little bookham 12 May 15 2.59pm

Back to new labour to appeal to the middle class more? Go further left? Stay where they are but with a better strategy?

 


Messi, you're good, but you can't hit a ball like ambrose

imbored Flag UK 12 May 15 3.05pm


They'll go for the centre ground now. Definitely not more to the left.

 

ghosteagle Flag 12 May 15 3.41pm

Quote lil j-eagle at 12 May 2015 2.59pm

Back to new labour to appeal to the middle class more? Go further left? Stay where they are but with a better strategy?

Probably a futile and pathetic move in towards the centre.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 12 May 15 3.44pm

They'll change their name to New Tory.

 

imbored Flag UK 12 May 15 3.46pm

Quote ghosteagle at 12 May 2015 3.41pm

Quote lil j-eagle at 12 May 2015 2.59pm

Back to new labour to appeal to the middle class more? Go further left? Stay where they are but with a better strategy?

Probably a futile and pathetic move in towards the centre.

Not exactly futile. In two party politics you're never many elections from being back in power.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 May 15 4.02pm

Thing is that they actually did better than they did in 2010, just not in Scotland. Their share of the vote is higher and their percentage increased.

In terms of the UK they were only 6% off the Conservatives, despite taking a right royal bumming from the SNP.

Outside of Jocklandia, they gained 22 seats over all.

232 Seats is a fairly respectable result, all told, in 1997 the Conservatives lost with only 165 to Labours 418.

The big swing since then has been the demise of the Liberal Democrats, and the rise of the Green, UKIP and SNP.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

johnno42000 Flag 12 May 15 4.05pm

They could split and have a completely separate Labour party for Scotland which could be left of centre to appeal to the more left wing voters in Scotland. The English Labour party could be more centrist to appeal to the voters in England and Wales.

Obviously they would both be close allies but separate much like the Conservatives and the DUP or Labour and the SDLP.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

ghosteagle Flag 12 May 15 4.10pm

Quote imbored at 12 May 2015 3.46pm

Quote ghosteagle at 12 May 2015 3.41pm

Quote lil j-eagle at 12 May 2015 2.59pm

Back to new labour to appeal to the middle class more? Go further left? Stay where they are but with a better strategy?

Probably a futile and pathetic move in towards the centre.

Not exactly futile. In two party politics you're never many elections from being back in power.

Agreed. I meant futile more in the sense that if Labour moves back towards the centre as urged by Mandelson et co then it may gain power but only as a tory-lite party.

 

imbored Flag UK 12 May 15 4.14pm

Quote ghosteagle at 12 May 2015 4.10pm

Quote imbored at 12 May 2015 3.46pm

Quote ghosteagle at 12 May 2015 3.41pm

Quote lil j-eagle at 12 May 2015 2.59pm

Back to new labour to appeal to the middle class more? Go further left? Stay where they are but with a better strategy?

Probably a futile and pathetic move in towards the centre.

Not exactly futile. In two party politics you're never many elections from being back in power.

Agreed. I meant futile more in the sense that if Labour moves back towards the centre as urged by Mandelson et co then it may gain power but only as a tory-lite party.

That's true and somewhat unfortunate.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 12 May 15 4.14pm

They'll seperate themselves entirely from the unions if they know what's good for them.

 


Optimistic as ever

ghosteagle Flag 12 May 15 4.15pm

Quote Stuk at 12 May 2015 4.14pm

They'll seperate themselves entirely from the unions if they know what's good for them.

How will this help?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 May 15 4.19pm

Quote Stuk at 12 May 2015 4.14pm

They'll seperate themselves entirely from the unions if they know what's good for them.

I think they need maybe to look back more towards re-establishing their core roots and basis, they did remarkably well under Blair (admittedly against a Conservative party that was dead on its feet).

Their problem, is how do they make up for the losses in Scotland. After that, the difference between the number of seats for a majority, is fairly minor. They'd be 20 or so seats off a Majority.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

ghosteagle Flag 12 May 15 4.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 May 2015 4.19pm

Quote Stuk at 12 May 2015 4.14pm

They'll seperate themselves entirely from the unions if they know what's good for them.

I think they need maybe to look back more towards re-establishing their core roots and basis, they did remarkably well under Blair (admittedly against a Conservative party that was dead on its feet).

Their problem, is how do they make up for the losses in Scotland. After that, the difference between the number of seats for a majority, is fairly minor. They'd be 20 or so seats off a Majority.


i thought they made the move towards re-establishing their core roots this election and were now being criticised for doing so?

 

Stuk Flag Top half 12 May 15 4.31pm

Quote ghosteagle at 12 May 2015 4.15pm

Quote Stuk at 12 May 2015 4.14pm

They'll seperate themselves entirely from the unions if they know what's good for them.

How will this help?

It might make them look like a political party, rather than puppet for the unions.

Number of people in trade unions = 6.5 mill and ever dropping.

Number of voters = much more and increasing.

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 12 May 15 4.33pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 May 2015 4.19pm

Quote Stuk at 12 May 2015 4.14pm

They'll seperate themselves entirely from the unions if they know what's good for them.

I think they need maybe to look back more towards re-establishing their core roots and basis, they did remarkably well under Blair (admittedly against a Conservative party that was dead on its feet).

Their problem, is how do they make up for the losses in Scotland. After that, the difference between the number of seats for a majority, is fairly minor. They'd be 20 or so seats off a Majority.


They can't, watch them get another kicking at the Holyrood elections.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 May 15 4.34pm

Quote ghosteagle at 12 May 2015 4.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 May 2015 4.19pm

Quote Stuk at 12 May 2015 4.14pm

They'll seperate themselves entirely from the unions if they know what's good for them.

I think they need maybe to look back more towards re-establishing their core roots and basis, they did remarkably well under Blair (admittedly against a Conservative party that was dead on its feet).

Their problem, is how do they make up for the losses in Scotland. After that, the difference between the number of seats for a majority, is fairly minor. They'd be 20 or so seats off a Majority.


i thought they made the move towards re-establishing their core roots this election and were now being criticised for doing so?

Scotland is their primary issue in terms of seats. They gained 22 new seats at this election, they actually gained seats in the mainland (over all they were down 24 seats).

In truth they need to focus, I think, somewhere between the Labour and New Labour of Blair. They also could do with a leader who doesn't look like he's come of the short bus when he thinks.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 May 15 4.36pm

Quote Stuk at 12 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote ghosteagle at 12 May 2015 4.15pm

Quote Stuk at 12 May 2015 4.14pm

They'll seperate themselves entirely from the unions if they know what's good for them.

How will this help?

It might make them look like a political party, rather than puppet for the unions.

Number of people in trade unions = 6.5 mill and ever dropping.

Number of voters = much more and increasing.

In terms of the Left, I think this would represent their best interests, as the Unions would likely as not form a new political party.

Of course that would probably result in 6m less votes for Labour.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

ghosteagle Flag 12 May 15 4.40pm

Quote Stuk at 12 May 2015 4.31pm

Quote ghosteagle at 12 May 2015 4.15pm

Quote Stuk at 12 May 2015 4.14pm

They'll seperate themselves entirely from the unions if they know what's good for them.

How will this help?

It might make them look like a political party, rather than puppet for the unions.

Number of people in trade unions = 6.5 mill and ever dropping.

Number of voters = much more and increasing.

I would argue that the connection to the unions is historically one of the things that defines Labour as a party. The problem has been in the recent past that Labour has been too scared to stand up for the unions publicly. This makes them, given their connection, look a little silly.

 

ghosteagle Flag 12 May 15 4.44pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 May 2015 4.34pm

Quote ghosteagle at 12 May 2015 4.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 May 2015 4.19pm

Quote Stuk at 12 May 2015 4.14pm

They'll seperate themselves entirely from the unions if they know what's good for them.

I think they need maybe to look back more towards re-establishing their core roots and basis, they did remarkably well under Blair (admittedly against a Conservative party that was dead on its feet).

Their problem, is how do they make up for the losses in Scotland. After that, the difference between the number of seats for a majority, is fairly minor. They'd be 20 or so seats off a Majority.


i thought they made the move towards re-establishing their core roots this election and were now being criticised for doing so?

Scotland is their primary issue in terms of seats. They gained 22 new seats at this election, they actually gained seats in the mainland (over all they were down 24 seats).

In truth they need to focus, I think, somewhere between the Labour and New Labour of Blair. They also could do with a leader who doesn't look like he's come of the short bus when he thinks.

The problem of a good leader is an issue, and given the people being mooted for the leadership at the moment is likely to remain one.
I'd hate to see them regressing back towards the new labour of blair, that really would be a betrayl of their core roots.

 

SamCPFC17 Flag Croydon 12 May 15 4.50pm

Labour's problem in this election wasn't so much about their policies, it was about the delivery of their policies. I don't honestly think many voters really disagreed with for example the Mansion Tax, the bankers bonus tax the abolition of the Bedroom Tax, the problem was that these things were the only things they talked about.
They didn't set out a vision for the country and where they wanted to take it in the long run. Yes they talked about how they'd help the working classes, but they did so without repudiating the failed policy of austerity. Also, they failed to even mention the middle classes during the campaign. They talked about the rich and the poor, not those who exist in between.
Consequently, though many middle class people may have agreed with Labour's policies, they didn't feel included in the overall project.
Looking forwards, I personally feel the best thing the Labour party can do is to not swing to the right drastically. They should appoint a new, young leader who actually comes across as leaderlike, and who talks about how the Labour Party will help both the working AND middle classes.
Unfortunately though, I feel they'll just elect a new version of Blair who'll drag them even closer to the Tories, and who'll fail to realise that it is possible to appeal to both the working and middle classes without losing the support of either.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labour's next direction