You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Suing a 16 Year Old
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Suing a 16 Year Old


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Mapletree Flag Croydon 19 Jul 15 12.47pm

I know this site has some pukka lawyers as well as thousands of barrack room ones.

May I have some advice please.

My (now) 16 year old is mad on horses and bought one with her own money. After a couple of years she sold it but the new owner has decided it has a back problem of which my daughter should have known.

It's all very spurious but my questions are:

1) Can you sue a 16 year old at all?
2) Alternatively can you sue the parents?
3) If the latter, and the child knew there was a problem but the parent did not (not in fact the case but just to check) would the parent still be liable?

Many thanks to anyone that can help.

 

Bekken Flag 19 Jul 15 1.01pm


Not sure on the legality side of things but I would notify your legal expenses insurers of this incident immediately so that they can respond to protect you and offer legal advice. This insurance may be an extension of your Household insurance policy, if it's any good!

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 19 Jul 15 1.04pm

Quote Bekken at 19 Jul 2015 1.01pm


Not sure on the legality side of things but I would notify your legal expenses insurers of this incident immediately so that they can respond to protect you and offer legal advice. This insurance may be an extension of your Household insurance policy, if it's any good!


Thanks Bekken

At the moment it seems to be only a threat, I was going to let the household insurer know as soon as it gets more real. Do you think I need to do that even at this point?

 

wizlon Flag ... 19 Jul 15 1.17pm

Did the buyer ask for and receive a recent veterinary medical report before purchase?

If not then it's a case of caveat emptor.

If so and the report was indicative of existing or potential problems, then again caveat emptor.

2 years after purchase is far too long for anyone to reasonably discover an issue that should have been reported/discovered at purchase.

Personally I think that the buyer is attempting to bully your child into paying and wouldn't have a leg to stand on in any court.

 


HOMO SAPIENS NON URINAT IN VENTUM

palace777 Flag belfast 19 Jul 15 2.02pm

just tell them to f*ck off.
buyer beware!!

 

Harry Beever Flag Newbury 19 Jul 15 2.56pm

Quote wizlon at 19 Jul 2015 1.17pm

Did the buyer ask for and receive a recent veterinary medical report before purchase?

If not then it's a case of caveat emptor.

If so and the report was indicative of existing or potential problems, then again caveat emptor.

2 years after purchase is far too long for anyone to reasonably discover an issue that should have been reported/discovered at purchase.

Personally I think that the buyer is attempting to bully your child into paying and wouldn't have a leg to stand on in any court.


Sounds like a lot of hot air to me. Know a little bit about this. If the purchaser didn't have a veterinary pre-purchase examination performed at the time they bought it then they've nowhere to go as Wizlon has said. There are also a lot of unqualified people who label horses as having back problems that don't (usually a riding instructor). I wouldn't engage with them personally. Tell them you're sorry they are having problems but the horse never had a problem when it was with you and you'd be happy to see any evidence they have to suggest to the contrary. They won't be able to produce any conclusive evidence to the contrary. A lot can happen to a horse over the course of 2 years. Not a lawyer but know a bit about horses.

 

Harry Beever Flag Newbury 19 Jul 15 3.03pm

Quote Harry Beever at 19 Jul 2015 2.56pm

Quote wizlon at 19 Jul 2015 1.17pm

Did the buyer ask for and receive a recent veterinary medical report before purchase?

If not then it's a case of caveat emptor.

If so and the report was indicative of existing or potential problems, then again caveat emptor.

2 years after purchase is far too long for anyone to reasonably discover an issue that should have been reported/discovered at purchase.

Personally I think that the buyer is attempting to bully your child into paying and wouldn't have a leg to stand on in any court.


Sounds like a lot of hot air to me. Know a little bit about this. If the purchaser didn't have a veterinary pre-purchase examination performed at the time they bought it then they've nowhere to go as Wizlon has said. There are also a lot of unqualified people who label horses as having back problems that don't (usually a riding instructor). I wouldn't engage with them personally. Tell them you're sorry they are having problems but the horse never had a problem when it was with you and you'd be happy to see any evidence they have to suggest to the contrary. They won't be able to produce any conclusive evidence to the contrary. A lot can happen to a horse over the course of 2 years. Not a lawyer but know a bit about horses.

Sorry just read the post in more detail. How long after it was sold did they start to complain? (thought it was 2 years but that's obviously how long your daughter had the horse for) Not an uncommon story. Did you sell the horse with the original saddle or did they buy a new one? I'd tell them to have it checked by a saddler if there using a different one. The other thing is it may be that the horse had a back problem you weren't aware of and the new rider is heavier than your daughter so it's just come to light. Not your fault.

 

becky Flag over the moon 19 Jul 15 5.42pm

A 16 year old can sue and be sued, but whether or not she could be sued for something that occurred before she reached 16 I couldn't say.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

dannyb1 Flag Chichester 19 Jul 15 6.08pm

Send it to judge Rinder.

 

Dweeb Flag East London 19 Jul 15 6.13pm

Quote dannyb1 at 19 Jul 2015 6.08pm

Send it to judge Rinder.

Not sure a dose of sarcasm from him will help.

 


Taking the bungy jump since 1964. Never to see John Jackson in a shirt again

Sorry to see Lee Hills go, did we ever see Alex Marrow? We did January 2013

Bekken Flag 19 Jul 15 6.14pm

Quote Mapletree at 19 Jul 2015 1.04pm

Quote Bekken at 19 Jul 2015 1.01pm


Not sure on the legality side of things but I would notify your legal expenses insurers of this incident immediately so that they can respond to protect you and offer legal advice. This insurance may be an extension of your Household insurance policy, if it's any good!


Thanks Bekken

At the moment it seems to be only a threat, I was going to let the household insurer know as soon as it gets more real. Do you think I need to do that even at this point?

A preliminary notification should be made as soon as an event which could give rise to a claim is known


 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 19 Jul 15 6.18pm

Very difficult and costly for the buyer to prove that your daughter was aware of the horses back problem presale. Would tell the buyer to saddle up and f*** off.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 19 Jul 15 7.28pm

Thanks to you all

Surprised a 16 year old can be sued, just goes to show you can't trust Google.

The woman decided there was a back problem after my daughter put her in touch with the chiropractor. As thoroughbreds do it had tweaked itself a couple of times but no sign of a long term problem. Just wishful thinking from the buyer now she finds she can't handle a horse as well as someone that was 15 when she bought it. So she is trying to say there was an underlying back problem to force my daughter to buy the horse back.

Meanwhile it is out of work and appears to be suffering muscle wastage.

What really was outrageous is that she made the threat to take my daughter to Court right in the middle of her GCSEs, the night before two of her most difficult ones.

 

shaun57 Flag chislehurst 19 Jul 15 7.35pm

Hi,
Just a little of what I know.
I have some horses, and if you buy them as foals, they do not have to be vetted.

Anytime after that, you would be silly not to have them checked out.
Bit like a house survey.
All the best.

 

Harry Beever Flag Newbury 19 Jul 15 7.43pm

Quote Mapletree at 19 Jul 2015 7.28pm

Thanks to you all

Surprised a 16 year old can be sued, just goes to show you can't trust Google.

The woman decided there was a back problem after my daughter put her in touch with the chiropractor. As thoroughbreds do it had tweaked itself a couple of times but no sign of a long term problem. Just wishful thinking from the buyer now she finds she can't handle a horse as well as someone that was 15 when she bought it. So she is trying to say there was an underlying back problem to force my daughter to buy the horse back.


Meanwhile it is out of work and appears to be suffering muscle wastage.

What really was outrageous is that she made the threat to take my daughter to Court right in the middle of her GCSEs, the night before two of her most difficult ones.


An equine chiropractor is permitted to treat a horse but they are not permitted to make any form of diagnosis under any circumstances. In the eyes of the law the only professional entitled to make a diagnosis relating to an animal is a veterinary surgeon. The word of a chiropractor would not be taken as meaningful in court even if they are correct!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 19 Jul 15 9.39pm

Talk to a solicitor, chances are that the emphasis is 'buyer beware', but there may well be special legal grounds that cover live stock and especially horses.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

EagleEyedAlbert Flag ...too far north of the water. 19 Jul 15 10.30pm

Quote wizlon at 19 Jul 2015 1.17pm

Did the buyer ask for and receive a recent veterinary medical report before purchase?

If not then it's a case of caveat emptor.

If so and the report was indicative of existing or potential problems, then again caveat emptor.

2 years after purchase is far too long for anyone to reasonably discover an issue that should have been reported/discovered at purchase.

Personally I think that the buyer is attempting to bully your child into paying and wouldn't have a leg to stand on in any court.


A horse with a bad back & an owner with no legs to stand on:

Something tells me this horse isn't going to win the Grand National anytime soon.

 


"IS HE!!?"

-Can often be found on HOL Radio chatting Palace-related nonsense:

Catch it here, Sunday Nights 8pm: [Link]

HOL Radio Twitter: [Link]

Me on the Twitter: [Link]


"You don't own a dog & bark yourself, do you?"

Irisheagle87 Flag Co.Derry 20 Jul 15 12.16am

Quote Mapletree at 19 Jul 2015 7.28pm

Thanks to you all

Surprised a 16 year old can be sued, just goes to show you can't trust Google.

The woman decided there was a back problem after my daughter put her in touch with the chiropractor. As thoroughbreds do it had tweaked itself a couple of times but no sign of a long term problem. Just wishful thinking from the buyer now she finds she can't handle a horse as well as someone that was 15 when she bought it. So she is trying to say there was an underlying back problem to force my daughter to buy the horse back.

Meanwhile it is out of work and appears to be suffering muscle wastage.

What really was outrageous is that she made the threat to take my daughter to Court right in the middle of her GCSEs, the night before two of her most difficult ones.

This is the modern world mapletree. Common sense used to be a good sense of knowledge. Now as the saying goes we're I'm from I reckon I'm smart because I know I'm stupid!

 


THE 17th OF MAY. MY 17th BIRTHDAY. MICHEAL HUGHES SCORES THE WINNING PENALTY, WHAT WAS HIS NUMBER? 17!!!!!

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 20 Jul 15 2.53am

I don't think a person of 16 could be sued. Legally they're a child and I'd be very surprised if you could take a child to court for something like that.

But I'd get some proper legal advice if I was you Maple.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 20 Jul 15 9.52am

get proper legal advice.

For what its worth, I'd tell her to crack on, as she won't be getting a penny. Further more I would also make it clear that if she harrases my daughter again over the matter (as a minor), you will class this as child bullying and inform the police, with a view to taking out an injunction against her contacting your "child".

I imagine that will cool her jets.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Suing a 16 Year Old