You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Alan Shearer new Englan manager
November 22 2026 8.40pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Alan Shearer new Englan manager


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
2095 Flag Manly 04 Jul 16 3.00pm

Ive lived in Australia for a while now so am slightly detached from the daily bulls***, but the more i see of him - why would you not give Alan Shearer a go at the England job. You are not going to teach the players much new at that level in a short space of time, its about getting them to play for the shirt 80% and tactics 20%. Rugby league is the same in Oz with State of Origin where you get an old legend that everyone respects to manage and over a short period of time mould young blokes into legends without changing too much of their DNA which makes me think England get it wrong too often.

THE THOUGHT THAT Southgate could possibly get it is a f***ing disaster. If you interviewed 1,000,000 people and asked should Southgate be the next manager, ireckon all 1,000,000 would say - f u c k o f f

 

Part Time James Flag 04 Jul 16 3.01pm

Hello. Welcome to the forum!

 




dowie101 Flag Colchester 04 Jul 16 3.14pm

I think you're very tired, considering it must be 2 am in Australia, and you're saying silly things like Shearer being manager. He's got less experience than Southgate.

Plus your very tired bleary eyes must of missed the fact that this is the Palace Talk thread, and the only link to Palace here is that Southgate is a former player.

Good night.

 


Brighton Diaries!! - Voted funniest thread 2005/06

ALLEZ LA BLEU!!! and red

2095 Flag Manly 04 Jul 16 3.33pm

Yeah, Kind of missed my point. Just because someone has been with the under 21s, does that mean you are a shoe in? Or get someone who will give a rocket up current players with a modicum of football savvy and passion about the shirt - is that not a better option. I reckon if you lined up 1,000,000 fans and said shearer or Southgate, I'm comfortable where that would sit.

(Please don't say this should be Ina different forum or anything else pointless cos I don't care)

 

Part Time James Flag 04 Jul 16 3.37pm

Originally posted by 2095

Yeah, Kind of missed my point. Just because someone has been with the under 21s, does that mean you are a shoe in? Or get someone who will give a rocket up current players with a modicum of football savvy and passion about the shirt - is that not a better option. I reckon if you lined up 1,000,000 fans and said shearer or Southgate, I'm comfortable where that would sit.

(Please don't say this should be Ina different forum or anything else pointless cos I don't care)

I like your style sir. Screw the system! You against The Man!

 




2095 Flag Manly 04 Jul 16 3.47pm

Yeah, Kind of missed my point. Just because someone has been with the under 21s, does that mean you are a shoe in? Or get someone who will give a rocket up current players with a modicum of football savvy and passion about the shirt - is that not a better option. I reckon if you lined up 1,000,000 fans and said shearer or Southgate, I'm comfortable where that would sit.

(Please don't say this should be Ina different forum or anything else pointless cos I don't care)

 

sotac464 Flag Berkshire 04 Jul 16 3.55pm

I think most fans have given up with the national side now and don't give a monkeys about them. It's the same old story every 2 year's. I've enjoyed this euros it's helped past a month whilst waiting for the premiership season to start again. England getting knocked out didn't bother me, I cheered Wales on more for obvious reasons.

England players talk about its nothing to do with passion. So how can Wales get to the semis with on paper an inferior squad?

There was a moment in the first ten minutes against Belgium, where Hennessey made a save, and then after 2 Wales players done blocks against the shot. Thats dying for the cause and your country.

Doesn't matter what manager we have, we can never achieve that passion and desire.

 


My equalibrium unbalanced me. Paul Draper Brighton 19/2/2018

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 04 Jul 16 4.19pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I like your style sir. Screw the system! You against The Man!

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

chateauferret Flag 04 Jul 16 4.30pm

Originally posted by sotac464

I think most fans have given up with the national side now and don't give a monkeys about them. It's the same old story every 2 year's. I've enjoyed this euros it's helped past a month whilst waiting for the premiership season to start again. England getting knocked out didn't bother me, I cheered Wales on more for obvious reasons.

England players talk about its nothing to do with passion. So how can Wales get to the semis with on paper an inferior squad?

There was a moment in the first ten minutes against Belgium, where Hennessey made a save, and then after 2 Wales players done blocks against the shot. Thats dying for the cause and your country.

Doesn't matter what manager we have, we can never achieve that passion and desire.

When Iceland came out last night for the second half against France they played as if they thought they could win it. Even at 5 - 1 down and with ten minutes left they were fighting for every ball and trying to score goals.

England against Iceland with ten minutes left and only a single goal down looked as sh!te as I've ever seen a team look in an international finals, with the possible exception of Brazil in the 2014 World Cup semi-fial.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Stuk Flag Top half 04 Jul 16 4.34pm

Originally posted by 2095

Ive lived in Australia for a while now so am slightly detached from the daily bulls***, but the more i see of him - why would you not give Alan Shearer a go at the England job. You are not going to teach the players much new at that level in a short space of time, its about getting them to play for the shirt 80% and tactics 20%. Rugby league is the same in Oz with State of Origin where you get an old legend that everyone respects to manage and over a short period of time mould young blokes into legends without changing too much of their DNA which makes me think England get it wrong too often.

THE THOUGHT THAT Southgate could possibly get it is a f***ing disaster. If you interviewed 1,000,000 people and asked should Southgate be the next manager, ireckon all 1,000,000 would say - f u c k o f f

8 games, 1 win, 2 draw, 5 points and relegation.

Plus he's not got the required badges.

 


Optimistic as ever

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 04 Jul 16 4.39pm

Paul Clement?


Young progressive and English.


The last thing you need to do is ask former players (as suggested by Danny Murphy) when they have a record that was just as abysmal

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 04 Jul 16 4.48pm

Alan Shearer - the man who moans about the FA not considering him when he last applied. The reason you were not considered is because you are not a manager! You are a pundit, and a boring one at that.

 


@sxp55555

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 04 Jul 16 4.54pm

Originally posted by sxp55

Alan Shearer - the man who moans about the FA not considering him when he last applied. The reason you were not considered is because you are not a manager! You are a pundit, and a boring one at that.

Well said. He has improved as a pundit but it has taken him 10 years to go from awful to boring.

If he wanted it that badly he would get his coaching badges and then apply. He still wouldn't get it though.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Jul 16 5.02pm

Originally posted by 2095

Ive lived in Australia for a while now so am slightly detached from the daily bulls***, but the more i see of him - why would you not give Alan Shearer a go at the England job. You are not going to teach the players much new at that level in a short space of time, its about getting them to play for the shirt 80% and tactics 20%. Rugby league is the same in Oz with State of Origin where you get an old legend that everyone respects to manage and over a short period of time mould young blokes into legends without changing too much of their DNA which makes me think England get it wrong too often.

THE THOUGHT THAT Southgate could possibly get it is a f***ing disaster. If you interviewed 1,000,000 people and asked should Southgate be the next manager, ireckon all 1,000,000 would say - f u c k o f f

I'm in support of this, as it would relegate Shearer off our TV screens, except when he was actively trying to justify how s**t he is in the face of a nation that hates him.

I see no reason to ruin any talented managers career with the so called 'top job' in English football.

That said, I reckon you could just appoint the captain to pick the team and tactics, and probably not do much worse that England in the last three or four Tournaments.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Tyrelli Flag London 04 Jul 16 5.46pm

Managed to get Newcastle relegated .. has no other experience, No

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 05 Jul 16 9.39am

Originally posted by Tyrelli

Managed to get Newcastle relegated .. has no other experience, No

Ideally suited to the England job then, capable of taking a high profile team, with talent, and underachieving on a regular basis.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Part Time James Flag 05 Jul 16 9.42am

We need a manager with chewing gum. Alex Ferguson used to eat his body weight in chewing gum at Manchester United and he did really well. In more recent times, look how good Chris Coleman is doing with a gobful of gum.

 




DaiShwmae Flag 05 Jul 16 10.25am

Yes please!

 

HeathMan Flag Purley 05 Jul 16 10.36am

Originally posted by sxp55

Alan Shearer - the man who moans about the FA not considering him when he last applied. The reason you were not considered is because you are not a manager! You are a pundit, and a boring one at that.


Well said. He has improved as a pundit but it has taken him 10 years to go from awful to boring.

If he wanted it that badly he would get his coaching badges and then apply. He still wouldn't get it though.

It does appeal. Mr Shearer under FA control, as figurehead - ably assisted by real quality, with Mr Linaker commenting to the nation and telling Mr Shearer he is not eating enough crisps.

COYP

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 05 Jul 16 4.21pm

I'm going to defend Shearer here....


... I think he has been a relatively entertaining pundit for the Euros. If only purely because he has deliberately set out to be a harsh critic of the England team.

But fcuk me I would not want him as England manager. A guy with a win ratio of 12.5% and 8 games experience as a manager should not be being offered the nominally biggest role in British football.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Alan Shearer new Englan manager