You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Blessing in disguise?
November 16 2026 12.00pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Blessing in disguise?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
glaziermart Flag 08 Sep 16 10.03pm

There are quite a lot of us who do not think 4-4-2 formation works with us. If Remy had been fit this Saturday, Pardew probably would have played him up front with Benteke. Then Wilf probably would have been dropped to the bench and Punch played out wide which is not his best position anymore, he is better in the Number 10 role, even though he is not playing as well as he did two years ago. The injury to Remy means we will likely see Flamini playing with Jimmy Mac or Cabaye in the middle, or we have the option of moving Cabaye into the number 10 role and playing Jimmy Mac and Flamini behind. Joe Ledley of course could sit behind as well. All this would mean Wilf and Townsend can push up wide and frighten defences. To be honest i was more pleased we got Flamini. That was desperately needed

 

miles18 Flag Telford 08 Sep 16 10.06pm

Cabaye is injured so not think he's playing on Saturday.

A fit Remy would have scored more than Wickham this season. The fact that we now only have Benteke and Wickham is not a good thing.

 



.

premier fan Flag BR4 08 Sep 16 10.07pm

Originally posted by glaziermart

There are quite a lot of us who do not think 4-4-2 formation works with us. If Remy had been fit this Saturday, Pardew probably would have played him up front with Benteke. Then Wilf probably would have been dropped to the bench and Punch played out wide which is not his best position anymore, he is better in the Number 10 role, even though he is not playing as well as he did two years ago. The injury to Remy means we will likely see Flamini playing with Jimmy Mac or Cabaye in the middle, or we have the option of moving Cabaye into the number 10 role and playing Jimmy Mac and Flamini behind. Joe Ledley of course could sit behind as well. All this would mean Wilf and Townsend can push up wide and frighten defences. To be honest i was more pleased we got Flamini. That was desperately needed

Really? A key player is injured and it's a blessing?

 

Murray's the man Flag round ear 08 Sep 16 10.18pm

Yes its a blessing in disguise, some of his performances in training were superb though

Think we will forget the transfer for now!

 


Johnny will return

Murray's the man Flag round ear 08 Sep 16 10.21pm

Originally posted by miles18

Cabaye is injured so not think he's playing on Saturday.

A fit Remy would have scored more than Wickham this season. The fact that we now only have Benteke and Wickham is not a good thing.

Actually I think we are a better team without Cabaye and Remy. Feeling confident for Sat now

 


Johnny will return

Dan89 Flag Se25 08 Sep 16 10.24pm

I agree 442, will not worked at palace imo with wilf on the wing as it leaves us weak defensively. Let's hope chungy form continues, I predict a big season for chungy.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

.TUX. Flag 08 Sep 16 10.38pm

Originally posted by Dan89

I agree 442, will not worked at palace imo with wilf on the wing as it leaves us weak defensively. Let's hope chungy form continues, I predict a big season for chungy.

Really!?
The lad works his nuts off compared to many (internationals) in his position in this league.

2 up front please as i'm bored to tears watching one man chasing lost causes and giving the oppositions defence an easy ride.

 


Buy Litecoin.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 08 Sep 16 10.43pm

Well, Pardew has said he is going to change the way we play.

Looking at our record for 2016, I would say that something does need to change.

So...to what ? Are we just going to replace Wickham with Benteke as the one man up front ? Or are we going to be a bit more adventurous with a front 2 ?

Clearly when the 2 was Wickham and Benteke against Bournemouth for the first half, it didn't look pretty. But if Remy had stayed fit then I reckon AP would have gone with him and Benteke up front.

So potentially another re think called for...

 


Old, Ungifted and White

wonder Flag Madrid 09 Sep 16 2.18am

Pardew is a nervous b****** and these injuries allow him to confidently slot puncheon behind the striker. If he fails to do this and we dont get lucky, things wont be looking up til next month.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 09 Sep 16 4.34am

Losing Remy is a big loss for us. Forget all you expert tacticians who clearly don't realise without goals you don't win.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 09 Sep 16 6.16am

[quote=Murray's the man;3055147]

Actually I think we are a better team without Cabaye and Remy. Feeling confident for Sat now

Christ we haven't even seen Remy play for us yet and you've written him off already

Losing a striker is a disaster when scoring goals is our problem.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

palace99 Flag New Mills 09 Sep 16 10.00am

Cabeye at No 10 - did you watch a game in 2016?

The guy can't play this role anymore - he wants to drop deep, often leaving Jimmy Mac to try and support the strikers, which is not his best position.

we tried it again in the cup final and he was the worst player on the pitch.

Cabeye on paper was a great signing but other than a few nice touches he's not doing enough for me.

Not saying I wouldn't play him, just not as a No10

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 09 Sep 16 10.07am

Originally posted by palace99

Cabeye at No 10 - did you watch a game in 2016?

The guy can't play this role anymore - he wants to drop deep, often leaving Jimmy Mac to try and support the strikers, which is not his best position.

we tried it again in the cup final and he was the worst player on the pitch.

Cabeye on paper was a great signing but other than a few nice touches he's not doing enough for me.

Not saying I wouldn't play him, just not as a No10


To be fair to him, I don't think he ever did very often, his best position has always seemed to be more deep lying and I didn't expect that to change when he joined us.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Part Time James Flag 09 Sep 16 10.11am

The squad is made up of 25 players that the manager feels are the best 25 players he has on his books. He'll believe that they are the 25 players most capable of playing for the first team in the Premier League. So no, losing any one of them is not a good thing. Otherwise we'd have a 24 man squad.

 




EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 09 Sep 16 3.47pm

[quote=Murray's the man;3055147]

Actually I think we are a better team without Cabaye and Remy. Feeling confident for Sat now

I bow to your tactical genius, as I have no idea how well we preform with Remy in the team.
-.-'

 

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 09 Sep 16 3.55pm

If Remy being injured means stopping AP playing a 442 and reverting to 1 striker, then it is a blessing. We might get a team for 90 minutes this time. In our case 'less is more'. We need one great striker, either Benteke or Wickham (who contrary to what some think is actually a great striker and I'm betting he'll go close to outperforming Benteke), because we need more success in the midfield, and playing one up front is what we're currently good at - not playing 442 - not yet. We need points. We can't keep stuffing up a 442 for half a match for half the season before we start getting it right. Having Benteke up front scaring the cr@p out of them is much better, especially as most our team are capable of scoring too. Having a rusty Remy on the pitch would have meant a deficit, and often when players aren't used to each other they end up spoiling each other, getting in the way, putting the mids and wingers in two minds about who to pass it to - not good. Yes it's a blessing - if Pards doesn't start with CW & CB!! Like he did last match. Then there'll be a big rant from me.

 


[Link]

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 09 Sep 16 5.08pm

[quote=Murray's the man;3055147]

Actually I think we are a better team without Cabaye and Remy. Feeling confident for Sat now

What a bizarre comment given none of us have ever seen them play together with a Palace shirt on.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 09 Sep 16 5.49pm

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

If Remy being injured means stopping AP playing a 442 and reverting to 1 striker, then it is a blessing. We might get a team for 90 minutes this time. In our case 'less is more'. We need one great striker, either Benteke or Wickham (who contrary to what some think is actually a great striker and I'm betting he'll go close to outperforming Benteke), because we need more success in the midfield, and playing one up front is what we're currently good at - not playing 442 - not yet. We need points. We can't keep stuffing up a 442 for half a match for half the season before we start getting it right. Having Benteke up front scaring the cr@p out of them is much better, especially as most our team are capable of scoring too. Having a rusty Remy on the pitch would have meant a deficit, and often when players aren't used to each other they end up spoiling each other, getting in the way, putting the mids and wingers in two minds about who to pass it to - not good. Yes it's a blessing - if Pards doesn't start with CW & CB!! Like he did last match. Then there'll be a big rant from me.


'Most of our team are capable of scoring'
Are they? Who?
Ward doesn't
Delaney doesn't
Soare doesn't
Kelly doesn't
Delaney doesn't
MacArthur doesn't
Ledley doesn't
Cabaye doesn't
Zaha doesn't
Puncheon doesn't

Benteke, Townsend hopefully will.
Danns great at scoring for a defender.
Not exactly free scoring though are we.

Remy being injured isn't a good thing. Gutted for him and us.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 09 Sep 16 5.51pm

Originally posted by ParchmoreEagle

If Remy being injured means stopping AP playing a 442 and reverting to 1 striker, then it is a blessing. We might get a team for 90 minutes this time. In our case 'less is more'. We need one great striker, either Benteke or Wickham (who contrary to what some think is actually a great striker and I'm betting he'll go close to outperforming Benteke), because we need more success in the midfield, and playing one up front is what we're currently good at - not playing 442 - not yet. We need points. We can't keep stuffing up a 442 for half a match for half the season before we start getting it right. Having Benteke up front scaring the cr@p out of them is much better, especially as most our team are capable of scoring too. Having a rusty Remy on the pitch would have meant a deficit, and often when players aren't used to each other they end up spoiling each other, getting in the way, putting the mids and wingers in two minds about who to pass it to - not good. Yes it's a blessing - if Pards doesn't start with CW & CB!! Like he did last match. Then there'll be a big rant from me.

Well I think Remy was brought in specifically to play a front 2...but at the moment we are all guessing.

Yes, the first 45 against Bournemouth was a mess, but to be fair AP switched it around and he's never going to know if things work or not unless they are tried. Personally, I don't think a Benteke / Wickham partnership is a goer.

I can't agree with your opinion on Wickham - there is nothing to suggest that he can and will outperform Benteke. Indeed if Remy was available, I don't think Wickham would be in the starting line up.

Playing 1 up front hasn't been successful now for close on a year.

And despite what we saw against Bournemouth, I do believe professional teams learn new tactics in training. We didn't always play with just 1 up front, how do you think the players got used to that ??

Most of our team are capable of scoring ? Really ?? The stats suggest otherwise.

Remy will only get sharp by playing regularly.

And if we don't provide a better service from other areas - including the full backs - into Benteke, then we will have wasted our money on him.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

premier fan Flag BR4 09 Sep 16 5.52pm

[quote=Murray's the man;3055147]

Actually I think we are a better team without Cabaye and Remy. Feeling confident for Sat now

Did you see them play together in a dream?

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Blessing in disguise?