You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Does Pardew know his best team ?
November 16 2026 12.00pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Does Pardew know his best team ?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Eagles1979 Flag Kent 10 Sep 16 2.43pm

I understand we have injures but I feel he makes to many changes. By now we need a settled 11, this is probably due to leaving our transfer activity late in the window and injuries. Isee Fryers is on the bench. Also Dreher, is he good ? I don't know much About him.

image.jpeg Attachment: image.jpeg (117.04Kb)

 


Eze Good ! Eze Good ! Eberechi Eze good !!

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 10 Sep 16 3.28pm

If Kelly and ward are playing and Pap injured why wouldn't Fryers be in the bench.?

COYP!!!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Sep 16 4.44pm

Hopefully Fryers is there on merit. It'd be great if he's managed to massively improve since his debut when signed (although being better than that probably wouldn't be that much of an improvement).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

in-exile Flag Sevenoaks 11 Sep 16 9.35pm

Just be thankful to have Kelly playing at last...

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 11 Sep 16 9.45pm

There is no "best team" for any Premiership side. It all depends upon who they are playing.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 12 Sep 16 3.46pm

I think Pards is starting to figure it out now that he has a set roster. You can't judge until all the transfer nonsense is over, and that wasn't until the middle of last week when Flamini joined the squad.

I think it's clear that Benteke can thrive as the lone striker with feed from Zaha and Townsend - both of whom were outstanding against Boro. The midfield is a little more interchangeable, but McArthur is a must, Punch is playing his way to being the same and Cabaye will be a first-choice player when fit.

The back four writes itself in, particularly now with Souare being out. Goalie should be Steve's for the keeping.

So there you have it:

Mandanda

Ward - Dann - Delaney - Kelly

Puncheon - Cabaye - McArthur

Zaha - Benteke - Townsend

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 12 Sep 16 3.56pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

I think Pards is starting to figure it out now that he has a set roster. You can't judge until all the transfer nonsense is over, and that wasn't until the middle of last week when Flamini joined the squad.

I think it's clear that Benteke can thrive as the lone striker with feed from Zaha and Townsend - both of whom were outstanding against Boro. The midfield is a little more interchangeable, but McArthur is a must, Punch is playing his way to being the same and Cabaye will be a first-choice player when fit.

The back four writes itself in, particularly now with Souare being out. Goalie should be Steve's for the keeping.

So there you have it:

Mandanda

Ward - Dann - Delaney - Kelly

Puncheon - Cabaye - McArthur

Zaha - Benteke - Townsend


I agree, except I can see Tomkins coming on for Delaney soon. It hasn't been just him, but we have looked shaky on corners especially. And his lack of pace has been exposed a few times.
Though ironically, with Benteke there, we actually have more use for Delaney's patented diagonal cross-field lob now.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 12 Sep 16 4.31pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

There is no "best team" for any Premiership side. It all depends upon who they are playing.

Yup.

He needs to see how teams work with the new guys in real games before he knows what combinations suits us most.

I know I am getting boring, but mid October he should know very well. Hopefully earlier.

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 12 Sep 16 5.04pm

I think that the excitement about the deliveries from Wilf and Andros are a little premature. Wilf had a great game on the weekend, gift wrapped and handed to him by George Friend, and we know what AT is capable of. However, there have been games where previously CW has struggled for service and it could be the same for Benteke if we don't have multiple plans and multiple teams who can work together for results. Some players will know that they are going to be a sub (Ledley / Chungy / Flamini) and that if they come on it is because they will be playing plan B or C or whatever.

One team with one plan of get it to Big Ben will not work all season!

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 12 Sep 16 5.21pm

Unless I've forgotten someone we now only have 5 fit defenders in the squad so the defence virtually chooses itself anyway. We did great transfer business in the end but God knows why we didn't bring in another defender. Any more injuries there and we're screwed.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

citizensmudge Flag midlands 12 Sep 16 6.13pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

Unless I've forgotten someone we now only have 5 fit defenders in the squad so the defence virtually chooses itself anyway. We did great transfer business in the end but God knows why we didn't bring in another defender. Any more injuries there and we're screwed.

Dann,Delaney,Ward,Kelly,Fryers,Tomkins plus Ledley and Flamini who both have experience playing at full back.

 

bodge Flag 12 Sep 16 7.00pm

No and until we have seen Tomkins and Flamini play a good few games we do not know either.

 

dmendenhall_9 Flag 12 Sep 16 7.04pm

I would argue that CW is half the reason we always complain about the bad service to him. He wins about half as many aerials as Benteke does and lost possession quite often. He was getting better but not even close to as good as a holdup striker as Benteke. I would be banging my head on how many headers he missed while watching him and how many times he got tackled with the ball at his feet and back to the opposition's goal. It will come good this year. Our service was as good as any other teams last year but just had no finish on it. Check out this little spreadsheet I made comparing crossing accuracy during last year's season.

[Link]

Originally posted by pstrutt

I think that the excitement about the deliveries from Wilf and Andros are a little premature. Wilf had a great game on the weekend, gift wrapped and handed to him by George Friend, and we know what AT is capable of. However, there have been games where previously CW has struggled for service and it could be the same for Benteke if we don't have multiple plans and multiple teams who can work together for results. Some players will know that they are going to be a sub (Ledley / Chungy / Flamini) and that if they come on it is because they will be playing plan B or C or whatever.

One team with one plan of get it to Big Ben will not work all season!

 

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 12 Sep 16 7.56pm

I like the set-up now. Benteke is head-it first, whereas Wickham would rather shoot. The CBs are trying to stay very tight to Benteke, which means the wingers are more likely facing one v one situations and have more time before getting double-teamed.

Zaha and Bolasie had very similar games, I think the mix with Zaha and Townsend is looking better. Zaha will still punish with tricks and speed (though now he is finally stopping to pop an early cross in now and then!), AT likes to cut inside and look for a shot or short pass. It seems likely AT will soon get his first goal from a cutback from Benteke, who draws a lot of attention.

As far as Plan B, I hope AP is working on a 2 striker system that has Wickham and Benteke working together instead of putting Wickham on the wing, which won't work. They need to figure out a way to make that work, because we'll be doing that when we are chasing the game.

I liked Kelly's game, but if he doesn't keep impressing, I think we may see Ward at LB, and Tomkins or Flamini in at RB. Though Fryers looked good in preseason, so him starting isn't as terrifying as it would have seemed last year.

Overall, despite the injuries I like our depth a lot better (Little Ben notwithstanding) Bringing Campbell, Sako or Mutch on to try to save a game was just depressing.

Edited by ThatPetrolRelation (12 Sep 2016 7.58pm)

 

lindzay Flag 12 Sep 16 8.20pm

The average fan knows naff all about such subjects.........How insulting to even ask such a question. What happened to loyalty? We have a very good manager....and so many good managers have to put up with this kind of stupidity.

Come on Palace!

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 12 Sep 16 9.04pm

Originally posted by lindzay

The average fan knows naff all about such subjects.........How insulting to even ask such a question. What happened to loyalty? We have a very good manager....and so many good managers have to put up with this kind of stupidity.

Come on Palace!

Last week Pardew said that he doesn't currently know the best team and he will need to fit the pieces together.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

srh Flag london 13 Sep 16 6.53am

Originally posted by Eagles1979

I understand we have injures but I feel he makes to many changes. By now we need a settled 11, this is probably due to leaving our transfer activity late in the window and injuries. Isee Fryers is on the bench. Also Dreher, is he good ? I don't know much About him.

Yes he does as does everyone else. We only have about 12 fit possible first team players atm. The only players to come back into ghe first team are Cabye and Souare and then Tomkins. Or do you disagree and think he's missing someone out?

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 13 Sep 16 10.41am

Originally posted by dmendenhall_9

I would argue that CW is half the reason we always complain about the bad service to him. He wins about half as many aerials as Benteke does and lost possession quite often. He was getting better but not even close to as good as a holdup striker as Benteke. I would be banging my head on how many headers he missed while watching him and how many times he got tackled with the ball at his feet and back to the opposition's goal. It will come good this year. Our service was as good as any other teams last year but just had no finish on it. Check out this little spreadsheet I made comparing crossing accuracy during last year's season.

[Link]

Interesting reading. I would suggest that the same applies to Benteke if better opposition is cutting out the crosses we put in. Friend was awful on Saturday and Wilf took advantage. We won't get such treatment from better clubs.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Sep 16 10.46am

Originally posted by srh

Yes he does as does everyone else. We only have about 12 fit possible first team players atm. The only players to come back into ghe first team are Cabye and Souare and then Tomkins. Or do you disagree and think he's missing someone out?

Yes the bench at Mboro wasn't the strongest was it.

 


COYP

OhthisbloodyPC Flag 13 Sep 16 12.04pm

Pardew's best team is Reading.


Sorry, couldn't resist that!

Bit unfair.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Does Pardew know his best team ?