You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Gary Cahill
November 16 2026 12.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Gary Cahill


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Lyons550 Flag Shirley 27 Sep 16 8.37am

If the rumours are true in that Conte/Chelski are after Michael Keane from Burnley then i'd like to us to approach them for Cahill.

As a Centre Back he still has a lot to offer, he's 5 years younger than Damo and in Dann/Tomkins he could very well allow us to playa back 3.

For England it would also be a good move.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 27 Sep 16 8.46am

Originally posted by Lyons550

If the rumours are true in that Conte/Chelski are after Michael Keane from Burnley then i'd like to us to approach them for Cahill.

As a Centre Back he still has a lot to offer, he's 5 years younger than Damo and in Dann/Tomkins he could very well allow us to playa back 3.

For England it would also be a good move.


Why would we want to do that? It's not one of the least used formations for nothing.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 27 Sep 16 8.57am

Originally posted by bexleydave


Why would we want to do that? It's not one of the least used formations for nothing.

Like everything in life there are cycles...a back 3 would allow a potential plan B...the fact it IS now one of the least used formations means it would be unusual to play against....staying with the flock like sheep isn't always the answer...being willing to change BEFORE others do sometimes is.

I'm certainly not suggesting that i'd like to see a back 3 permanently but at least it'd provide the ability to be flexible when its called for.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Sep 16 9.42am

Originally posted by bexleydave


Why would we want to do that? It's not one of the least used formations for nothing.

I cannot vouch statistically as to it's use worldwide, but I know that Conte and Mazzari used this defensive "Shape" in Italy and Flores used this at Watford last season.Watford last night started with a back three.

Having studied the tactics used by Bielsa, he favoured a 'Back Three' throughout his career and has used 3-3-1-1, 3-4-3 and 3-3-3-1 amongst others.

Edited by Willo (27 Sep 2016 9.46am)

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 27 Sep 16 10.15am

Cahill would expect to be starting every week at Palace.

Unless we played with a back 3, then he wouldn't replace a recent £10m signing or Scott Dann....

 


Old, Ungifted and White

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 27 Sep 16 10.44am

Wouldn't get in our team

 


@sxp55555

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 27 Sep 16 10.50am

Interesting that a couple of people think that he wouldnt get in our team....i'd disagree and see him as a better defender to both Tomkins and Damo and has greater experience than Dann.

Surely competition in that department is exactly what we'd be after, however i'd agree that coming from Chelsea he may want some sort of guarantee with regards to game time.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 27 Sep 16 11.38am

Originally posted by Lyons550

If the rumours are true in that Conte/Chelski are after Michael Keane from Burnley then i'd like to us to approach them for Cahill.

As a Centre Back he still has a lot to offer, he's 5 years younger than Damo and in Dann/Tomkins he could very well allow us to playa back 3.

For England it would also be a good move.

At this present time Cahill is playing the poorest football of his career and you want The Palace to buy him.
I'll leave it to AP.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 27 Sep 16 11.54am

Originally posted by Willo

I cannot vouch statistically as to it's use worldwide, but I know that Conte and Mazzari used this defensive "Shape" in Italy and Flores used this at Watford last season.Watford last night started with a back three.

Having studied the tactics used by Bielsa, he favoured a 'Back Three' throughout his career and has used 3-3-1-1, 3-4-3 and 3-3-3-1 amongst others.

Willo, when you studied Bielsa's tactics the 3 3 1 1 team must have been very good.!!

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 27 Sep 16 12.08pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

Interesting that a couple of people think that he wouldnt get in our team....i'd disagree and see him as a better defender to both Tomkins and Damo and has greater experience than Dann.

Surely competition in that department is exactly what we'd be after, however i'd agree that coming from Chelsea he may want some sort of guarantee with regards to game time.

Whenever I see references to Cahill I am reminded of Martin O'Neill's comment about him; that he can do everything except defend.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Sep 16 12.13pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Originally posted by Willo

I cannot vouch statistically as to it's use worldwide, but I know that Conte and Mazzari used this defensive "Shape" in Italy and Flores used this at Watford last season.Watford last night started with a back three.

Having studied the tactics used by Bielsa, he favoured a 'Back Three' throughout his career and has used 3-3-1-1, 3-4-3 and 3-3-3-1 amongst others.

Willo, when you studied Bielsa's tactics the 3 3 1 1 team must have been very good.!!

Sorry !
I meant 3-3-1-3.
This is what happens when your wife chirps away to you when you are in the middle of typing !

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Sep 16 12.15pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

Whenever I see references to Cahill I am reminded of Martin O'Neill's comment about him; that he can do everything except defend.

The same has been said of John Stones and David Luiz.

It must be some 10 years ago that O'Neill commented that Cahill has a lot of talent but makes elementary mistakes.But he has improved since then with experience.

Edited by Willo (27 Sep 2016 12.27pm)

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 27 Sep 16 12.37pm

Originally posted by Willo

The same has been said of John Stones and David Luiz.

It must be some 10 years ago that O'Neill commented that Cahill has a lot of talent but makes elementary mistakes.But he has improved since then with experience.


Edited by Willo (27 Sep 2016 12.27pm)


A fair point though I think the two you refer to are slightly different in that I think both are in some ways too talented for their own good and try to complicate things when they would be better off just hoofing it clear at times. Luiz is an odd one. He clearly has plenty of talent but his performances can sometimes be shockingly bad. For example in the World Cup against Germany which must be one of the worst defensive performances of all time (though the left back ran him close)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Sep 16 12.54pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe


A fair point though I think the two you refer to are slightly different in that I think both are in some ways too talented for their own good and try to complicate things when they would be better off just hoofing it clear at times. Luiz is an odd one. He clearly has plenty of talent but his performances can sometimes be shockingly bad. For example in the World Cup against Germany which must be one of the worst defensive performances of all time (though the left back ran him close)

Very baffling signing in that he is not a Conte type defender when you consider some of the types of defenders he had at Juventus.Was signed very late in the 'Window' - perhaps he tried others and wasn't successful, he really needed to get someone in and decided to sign Luiz at the last minute. Sold by Chelsea for £50 Mill and re-signed for £34 Mill ! He certainly needs to bolster his defensive ranks in January.

Edited by Willo (27 Sep 2016 1.01pm)

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 27 Sep 16 1.06pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

Interesting that a couple of people think that he wouldnt get in our team....i'd disagree and see him as a better defender to both Tomkins and Damo and has greater experience than Dann.

Surely competition in that department is exactly what we'd be after, however i'd agree that coming from Chelsea he may want some sort of guarantee with regards to game time.

Cahill is a truly awful defender and is no way better than Dann, Tompkins or Delaney. If Zuma were fit he would be playing in his position. Conte will have him out of the door as soon as he is able.

 


Bring back Brolin

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 27 Sep 16 1.41pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Cahill is a truly awful defender and is no way better than Dann, Tompkins or Delaney. If Zuma were fit he would be playing in his position. Conte will have him out of the door as soon as he is able.

He's certainly struggling with form at present but to suggest he's truly awful and not as good as Damo and Tomkins, is stretching things..... a fair bit

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Sportyteacher Flag London 27 Sep 16 7.28pm

Why don't we approach every SUPPOSED supreme Prem player who is clearly not fit for playing in The Premiership? As I write this, I bow my head unattempted forgiveness for previously assuming that Bony and / or Zaza would be TOP buys in recent transfer market...and how they come to show themselves of late as bereft of form.

Cahill simply needs to work DAMN hard at rediscovering former top form and then reigniting his status within First X!

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 27 Sep 16 7.29pm

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Why don't we approach every SUPPOSED supreme Prem player who is clearly not fit for playing in The Premiership? As I write this, I bow my head unattempted forgiveness for previously assuming that Bony and / or Zaza would be TOP buys in recent transfer market...and how they come to show themselves of late as bereft of form.

Cahill simply needs to work DAMN hard at rediscovering former top form and then reigniting his status within First X!

Make that: First XI[/

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 28 Sep 16 9.03am

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Make that: First XI[/

Or even First XI

The only reason I mention him is that he's a proven CB of quality (Form is temporary) and would be a step up from what we have. If he was playing well currently I wouldn't even be suggesting him as Chelsea wouldn't consider letting him go (which is the report on which I based this thread)....we're not currently in the position that we can start poaching players from top sides because we want to...we're still in a position where we need to feed off of the scraps from the top teams table.


Edited by Lyons550 (28 Sep 2016 9.05am)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

glaziermart Flag 03 Oct 16 10.53am

He is not the player he was three years ago, and currently is nowhere near as good as Dann or Tomkins. He would be a bench warmer for us

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Gary Cahill