You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Orgreave
November 22 2026 12.40am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Orgreave


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
matt_himself Flag Matataland 01 Nov 16 6.48am

Government rules out an inquiry into the Battle of Orgreave:

[Link]

There were no deaths and no wrongful convictions. The police had a difficult job to do in the face of the tactics of the strikers. It seems, to the cynically minded, that it is a tactic to try and discredit the Thatcher government and drag up the sentiment of the Miners Strike to attempt to whip up industrial action.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Kingvagabond Flag London 01 Nov 16 7.05am

Police used as an instrument of the state. Police assaulting strikers. Police proven to commit perjury. Police proven to have falsely imprisoned 74 strikers. Many of the same officers and top brass involved as hillsbrough. Media proven to have lied through their back teeth. Politicians proven to have lied through their back teeth. What reason could their possibly be to want an inquiry? How could anyone possibly discredit Thatcher's government?

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

matt_himself Flag Matataland 01 Nov 16 7.24am

Originally posted by Kingvagabond

Police used as an instrument of the state. Police assaulting strikers. Police proven to commit perjury. Police proven to have falsely imprisoned 74 strikers. Many of the same officers and top brass involved as hillsbrough. Media proven to have lied through their back teeth. Politicians proven to have lied through their back teeth. What reason could their possibly be to want an inquiry? How could anyone possibly discredit Thatcher's government?

And of course none of the strikers were overly aggressive and having a go at the Police, using unnecessary violence?

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 01 Nov 16 7.43am

Originally posted by matt_himself

And of course none of the strikers were overly aggressive and having a go at the Police, using unnecessary violence?

Which is why we need an equity. No one convicted get hundreds kept on remand beer on falsified police evidence. To do nothing does nothing to offer closure here.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 01 Nov 16 8.28am

Originally posted by matt_himself

And of course none of the strikers were overly aggressive and having a go at the Police, using unnecessary violence?

I'd imagine there may have been one or two but people don't think all palace fans are nobbers because you are.

The whole thing is an establishment stitch up.

Edited by nickgusset (01 Nov 2016 8.29am)

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 01 Nov 16 8.39am

[Link]

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 01 Nov 16 8.51am

Read it and digest Matthew, read and digest.

 

legaleagle Flag 01 Nov 16 9.02am

Those who dismiss the concerns about Orgreave seemingly just because of political bias (ie only the left's actions/errors should be subject to review) should IMO be ashamed of themselves and show their true colours as biased propagandists.

If this wasn't a clear cut case of seeming way OTT state-sponsored violence and abuse of police powers,nothing ever will be...

"A former police officer who was at the 1984 “Battle of Orgreave” says police had been told to use “as much force as possible” against striking miners.
Police clashed with miners at the Orgreave coke plant in South Yorkshire, on 18 June – and campaigners want a new inquiry into policing on the day.
The ex-Merseyside constable told the BBC senior officers “were anticipating trouble and in some ways relishing it”.

...Speaking to the BBC, the officer – who asked to remain anonymous – said senior South Yorkshire Police officers briefed them the night before the 18 June clashes.
He was among about 6,000 officers called in to bolster police ranks protecting the Orgreave coke works.

“They were anticipating trouble and in some ways relishing it and looking forward to it,” he said.
“It was a licence to do what we wanted, which I didn’t think was right because we didn’t know what was going to happen.”
He said officers had been ordered to charge a largely peaceful crowd.
“There were running battles and miners were falling over and police officers were batoning them,” the officer said.
“I couldn’t believe what I was seeing. I was just seeing police officers attack people. These were people on the ground and even if they weren’t doing anything – just walking away – police officers had their batons and they were just hitting people.”

Stefan Wysocki was one of the 95 miners who was arrested at Orgreave. He was accused of throwing a stone.
He said: “They marched me back down the hill to the line of police officers with shields and bounced me off them. The line opened up and they knocked ten bells of crap out of me. I was punched and kicked.”
Most of the miners were charged with riot or unlawful assembly.
They had faced long prison sentences, but the case collapsed in court a year later and they were all cleared. There have been allegations that police officers had been told what to write in their statements to justify more serious charges."

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 01 Nov 16 9.11am

Originally posted by legaleagle

Those who dismiss the concerns about Orgreave seemingly just because of political bias (ie only the left's actions/errors should be subject to review) should IMO be ashamed of themselves and show their true colours as biased propagandists.

If this wasn't a clear cut case of seeming way OTT state-sponsored violence and abuse of police powers,nothing ever will be...

"A former police officer who was at the 1984 “Battle of Orgreave” says police had been told to use “as much force as possible” against striking miners.
Police clashed with miners at the Orgreave coke plant in South Yorkshire, on 18 June – and campaigners want a new inquiry into policing on the day.
The ex-Merseyside constable told the BBC senior officers “were anticipating trouble and in some ways relishing it”.

...Speaking to the BBC, the officer – who asked to remain anonymous – said senior South Yorkshire Police officers briefed them the night before the 18 June clashes.
He was among about 6,000 officers called in to bolster police ranks protecting the Orgreave coke works.

“They were anticipating trouble and in some ways relishing it and looking forward to it,” he said.
“It was a licence to do what we wanted, which I didn’t think was right because we didn’t know what was going to happen.”
He said officers had been ordered to charge a largely peaceful crowd.
“There were running battles and miners were falling over and police officers were batoning them,” the officer said.
“I couldn’t believe what I was seeing. I was just seeing police officers attack people. These were people on the ground and even if they weren’t doing anything – just walking away – police officers had their batons and they were just hitting people.”

Stefan Wysocki was one of the 95 miners who was arrested at Orgreave. He was accused of throwing a stone.
He said: “They marched me back down the hill to the line of police officers with shields and bounced me off them. The line opened up and they knocked ten bells of crap out of me. I was punched and kicked.”
Most of the miners were charged with riot or unlawful assembly.
They had faced long prison sentences, but the case collapsed in court a year later and they were all cleared. There have been allegations that police officers had been told what to write in their statements to justify more serious charges."

Three points I make to the above which 'justify my political bias [sic]':

1. The trouble started when the strikers charged the police I. Order to try and prevent lorries leaving the site;
2. If campaigners want an inquiry, why are they not campaigning for an inquiry on the Battle of Saltely Gate in '72? One can only hazard a guess that it was because he strikers smashed the f*** out of the police that day but justify it as part of a legitimate strike action, which in turn smacks of hypocrisy;
3. What good would an inquiry do? The Police force and way it operates is completely different from 1984. An inquiry is supposed to be held in order to not only assess but also effect change. Change isn't required here therefore one can only deduce that the motives for the inquiry are driven by political reasons. I repeat, no one died and there were no wrongful convictions. This is not the same scenario as Hillsborough.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Nov 16 9.13am

Originally posted by matt_himself

Three points I make to the above which 'justify my political bias [sic]':

1. The trouble started when the strikers charged the police I. Order to try and prevent lorries leaving the site;
2. If campaigners want an inquiry, why are they not campaigning for an inquiry on the Battle of Saltely Gate in '72? One can only hazard a guess that it was because he strikers smashed the f*** out of the police that day but justify it as part of a legitimate strike action, which in turn smacks of hypocrisy;
3. What good would an inquiry do? The Police force and way it operates is completely different from 1984. An inquiry is supposed to be held in order to not only assess but also effect change. Change isn't required here therefore one can only deduce that the motives for the inquiry are driven by political reasons. I repeat, no one died and there were no wrongful convictions. This is not the same scenario as Hillsborough.

Matt

Very good.
Here is a link :

[Link]

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 01 Nov 16 9.31am

[Link]


The fall-out from Orgreave was considerable although it would be many years before its full truth was revealed. TV viewers were treated to scenes of mobs of violent thugs hurling bricks and stones before embattled mounted police moved in to disperse the offenders. Only it wasn’t like that at all. As Red Pepper reported, nearly thirty years after the event, “When broadcasting footage of Orgreave, the BBC, incredibly, transposed the sequence of events, making it appear that police cavalry charges had been a defensive response to antagonism by stone-throwing pickets rather than an act of aggression. Only in 1991 did the BBC issue an apology for this, claiming that its action footage had been “inadvertently reversed.” The publicly-funded, ‘neutral’ state broadcaster had reversed footage which, in its original form, showed cowering pickets with nowhere to run, desperately fending off charging police with whatever they had to hand. Given the pre-digital era of 1984, with physical tape being used for filming, which required conscious human cutting, splicing and chopping for editing purposes, one can view the BBC’s claims of the footage being “inadvertently reversed” with a degree of contempt.

The South Yorkshire Police didn’t stop at merely bludgeoning defenceless men, either. Ninety five pickets were arrested and charged with a number of offences. The most serious being charges of rioting and affray which carried sentences of upwards of ten years. In 1987 the trials soon collapsed in a welter of conflicting police evidence, fabricated statements and embarrassing inconsistencies. Although described by renowned QC, Michael Mansfield, as “the biggest frame-up ever,” no officers were ever investigated or charged. This was despite South Yorkshire Police being forced to hand over nearly half-a-million pounds in compensation to thirty nine of the arrested pickets and incurring costs of over £100,000.

 

legaleagle Flag 01 Nov 16 9.35am

Originally posted by matt_himself

Three points I make to the above which 'justify my political bias [sic]':

1. The trouble started when the strikers charged the police I. Order to try and prevent lorries leaving the site;
2. If campaigners want an inquiry, why are they not campaigning for an inquiry on the Battle of Saltely Gate in '72? One can only hazard a guess that it was because he strikers smashed the f*** out of the police that day but justify it as part of a legitimate strike action, which in turn smacks of hypocrisy;
3. What good would an inquiry do? The Police force and way it operates is completely different from 1984. An inquiry is supposed to be held in order to not only assess but also effect change. Change isn't required here therefore one can only deduce that the motives for the inquiry are driven by political reasons. I repeat, no one died and there were no wrongful convictions. This is not the same scenario as Hillsborough.

In response to your numbering:

1.You appear not to have read carefully what the ex-police officer said in the piece I referred to

2.Attacking "ther left" in a generic manner about unconnected events is rather transparently unmeritorious,no?Deal wiyth Orgrerave on its own terms.

3. Where large numbers of people appear to have been brutally assaulted by police in our green and pleasant land and there indications large numbers of police were complicit in perjury and in people being unlawfully detained and charged,I would hope people might think (even 30 years on) that deserved thorough inquiry,both to set the record straight and as an example to encourage something similar to never happen again.

If you and Willo,see no merit in my points (presumably because they are not knocking the left or demanding an inquiry into the left's actions),so be it but I am less than impressed.If the following isn't a scandal,nothing is.

"Officers had arrested and charged 95 miners with riot, an offence of collective violence carrying a potential life sentence. Yet in July 1985 the prosecution withdrew and all the miners were were acquitted after the evidence of some police officers, including those in command, had been discredited under cross-examination.

In 1991 South Yorkshire police paid £425,000 compensation to 39 miners who had sued the force for assault, unlawful arrest and malicious prosecution. But still the police did not admit any fault, and not a single police officer was ever disciplined or prosecuted".

,,,in its report, finally published last month, the IPCC found “support for the allegation” that three senior police officers in command at Orgreave had “made up an untrue account exaggerating the degree of violence (in particular missile throwing)” from miners to justify their use of force and the charges of riot. The report said one of these most senior officers had his statement typed and witnessed by another officer who led a team of detectives which, the IPCC said, dictated those identical opening paragraphs of junior officers’ statements.The report says the BBC had indeed reversed footage in its news broadcast that night (to make it look like the miners started the violence) , an accusation the BBC has never officially accepted.

Explosively, the IPCC revealed for the first time that South Yorkshire police, when contemplating the civil claims, recognised there had been some excessive violence by officers and perjury in the trial that followed, but covered it up. The force settled the claims, the IPCC stated, “very much prompted” by senior officers’ knowledge of this misconduct."

Off to work now...

Edited by legaleagle (01 Nov 2016 9.36am)

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 01 Nov 16 10.07am

I didn't realise, or had forgotten, that the BBC had edited the event and managed to broadcast the thing backwards. ITN broadcast chronologically. So we've always had the evidence that the BBC were beyond inept on that day.

However, in light of the discredit on the South Yorkshire Police at that time, whether you doubt the there's much to be gain by an enquiry, it seems to me to be the only way to go.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Nov 16 10.09am

Originally posted by matt_himself

And of course none of the strikers were overly aggressive and having a go at the Police, using unnecessary violence?

Difference of course is that they were likely to end up arrested and facing charges. The police do not get a carte blanche to do what they like.

And they did give 'as good as they got' with the only difference is none of them were charged or arrested, obviously.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 01 Nov 16 10.51am

Unless you are of a certain age it's very difficult to understand truly how extremely violent, thuggish and, ironically, lawless many of the police were back in the eighties.

Even before clashes they would up the ante by thumping their batons zulu-drum like style on their shields. The sobriquet of 'Maggies Boot Boys' was well founded.

A Met PC i met in The Forum in 1985 told me "we had a competition to see who could break the most noses" during the miners strike. They took off their identity lapels before enjoying the day. Other forces hated The Met after they were deployed up north. Lots of theft by the London lot, apparently.

Add to that the many deaths in custody late 70's to the mid eighties then it is fair to say that the police were operating like a paramilitary force in some cases and with Maggie's blessing.

One of the first things she did when she came to power was give them significant pay rises. Plenty carried around their Tory member cards alongside their badges. They knew they could get away with anything. What they didn't project was perhaps being brought to task decades later for their crimes.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Hoof Hearted 01 Nov 16 12.08pm

I've more to add on this debate.... but for starters....

Why are Labour MP's like Andy Burnham so riled up about this now?

Seems to me that there was no better opportunity to have an Inquiry between 1997 and 2010 when Labour governed? The economy was in a better shape initially too (until they ruined it) so we could afford a full on Inquiry.

Why do left wingers continually want Inquiries anyway?

They are extremely costly, often have no real purpose and achieve nothing of real value despite people saying they will bring "closure".

With all the pressure on this government to bring spending under control, the last thing they need is yet another Inquiry into events carried out in the Eighties.

There's already the Inquiry into Saville, Janner etc., that looks like it's going to run for ever and cost billions and we've only just got the results of Chilcott (Iraq War).

You lefties sure know how to spend (waste) other people's money pursuing the truth and ending up with a whitewash.

Barristers and Judges must love the constant offers of cushy lucrative work put their way.

-.-'

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 01 Nov 16 12.38pm

I seem to remember Scargill getting a bit of a kicking that day. Rough justice and all that.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 01 Nov 16 1.38pm

I find the miners strike fascinating looking back on it.

I understand their stance, ie. for them, their complete way of life was being taken away, jobs, communities etc. And they would be prepared to fight for it.

However, I don't see why a new investigation is needed.

1. These weren't men who going to there to just picket behind a line, they were there looking for confrontation, and my word they got it.

As said in a post previously, the Police force in the 80's had a reputation for being excessive with physical restraint. So, the miners knew full well what they were up against.

2. Just to illustrate the types of strikers they were, I saw an interview with Kelvin Mckenzie about the undercover reporter he sent in to infiltrate the flying pickets. This bloke just about got away with his life after they suspected he was a reporter. He was locked in a van with a group of 12 men, and got way with a 7 to 5 vote. Had he lost, would he be here now ?

This is without the terrible imitation they gave working miners and their young families.


3. For MPs to try and equate this to Hillsborough is disgusting. I would severely angry if I was one of the grieving families.

One group left on a sunny day innocently to watch a football match and never came home. Another group set out that morning looking for confrontation, and some got arrested (albeit heavy handedly) and no one died. No comparison.

As said, why is it copping up now.

Even now, what 30 years later, some of these ex-miners refuse to move on and let it go. Not everything lasts forever, I don't see the steel workers going mental over the steel works being closed. And they have been screwed over the government as well by refusing to tax Chinese steel to make it unattractive.

Just my views of course.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 01 Nov 16 1.44pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

3. For MPs to try and equate this to Hillsborough is disgusting. I would severely angry if I was one of the grieving families.

One group left on a sunny day innocently to watch a football match and never came home. Another group set out that morning looking for confrontation, and some got arrested (albeit heavy handedly) and no one died. No comparison.


Just my views of course.

but you've just compared them both......

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Nov 16 1.56pm

All to predictable wails of outrage from Labour. Don't recall them instigating an enquiry when they were in Government.

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Orgreave