You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Mike Dean
November 22 2026 8.28pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mike Dean


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Dec 16 9.37am

Just been reading an article about his antics. Twitter is awash with suggestions of his bias towards Spurs..he has reffed them 3 times this season, he has sent off an opposition player every match and given Spurs 2 penalties. Watch the warm handshake, near hug given to him by Dembele when he was substituted (the same player that scored, when it looked like Dean was celebrating against AV)
Now before Willo gets on his high horse I have not suggested any wrongdoing but.... these refs need to be taken down a peg or two, they are not celebrities and decisions for/against certain teams certainly should be monitored.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Dec 16 9.52am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Just been reading an article about his antics. Twitter is awash with suggestions of his bias towards Spurs..he has reffed them 3 times this season, he has sent off an opposition player every match and given Spurs 2 penalties. Watch the warm handshake, near hug given to him by Dembele when he was substituted (the same player that scored, when it looked like Dean was celebrating against AV)
Now before Willo gets on his high horse I have not suggested any wrongdoing but.... these refs need to be taken down a peg or two, they are not celebrities and decisions for/against certain teams certainly should be monitored.

Maybe these decisions were 100% correct and if so the referee has done his job.

Do you really want a situation whereby the authorities highlight stats to a referee as described above which could of course influence his decision making during a game ?

Anyhow I'm not going to get involved any further in this debate and the "Conspiracy" theories, because as sure as night follows day it will evolve into a WILLO thread full of vitriol, vituperation and risible allegations.

Happy New Year to you all !

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 29 Dec 16 10.27am

Wasn't there some rubbish about Howard Webb favouring Man Utd a few years ago. It's all Bull, made up by conspiracy theorists and people with overly large chip on their shoulder.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Dec 16 11.07am

Originally posted by Andy_G

Wasn't there some rubbish about Howard Webb favouring Man Utd a few years ago. It's all Bull, made up by conspiracy theorists and people with overly large chip on their shoulder.

Then he retired and immediately was given and accepted corporate hospitality from....you guessed it Man Utd

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Dec 16 11.10am

Originally posted by Willo

Maybe these decisions were 100% correct and if so the referee has done his job.

Do you really want a situation whereby the authorities highlight stats to a referee as described above which could of course influence his decision making during a game ?

Anyhow I'm not going to get involved any further in this debate and the "Conspiracy" theories, because as sure as night follows day it will evolve into a WILLO thread full of vitriol, vituperation and risible allegations.

Happy New Year to you all !

Maybe they were, I did not suggest otherwise.
Why did you respond at all then? We all know, in your eyes, referees never make mistakes and we are all conspiracy theorists to suggest otherwise.

 

rednblue4eva Flag Norwood 31 Dec 16 8.13am

Could probably find some stats on any ref - there was one (now retired) who seemed to be lucky for Leeds United. Apparently Leeds never lost when he officiated, and twice he awarded a penalty for Leeds at Old Trafford.

He also disallowed a goal for Palace against Leeds at Selhurst that put us out of the FA Cup even though pictures show the ball clearly crossed the line.

Conspiracy or something more sinister?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Dec 16 8.18am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Maybe they were, I did not suggest otherwise.
Why did you respond at all then? We all know, in your eyes, referees never make mistakes and we are all conspiracy theorists to suggest otherwise.

You know darned well I have never said this. I have consistenty stated that referees are only human and will err from time to time but these are honest mistakes made due to having to make split-second decisions in a fast moving scenario without the aid of umpteen TV cameras and replays.

Edited by Willo (31 Dec 2016 8.18am)

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 31 Dec 16 8.18am

Originally posted by rednblue4eva

Could probably find some stats on any ref - there was one (now retired) who seemed to be lucky for Leeds United. Apparently Leeds never lost when he officiated, and twice he awarded a penalty for Leeds at Old Trafford.

He also disallowed a goal for Palace against Leeds at Selhurst that put us out of the FA Cup even though pictures show the ball clearly crossed the line.

Conspiracy or something more sinister?

If that's the game against Leeds I'm thinking it was as the ref didn't give the goal he should have given a penalty and a red card to the defender who handballed it after it went in. Week night game & shocking reffing.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 31 Dec 16 10.03am

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

If that's the game against Leeds I'm thinking it was as the ref didn't give the goal he should have given a penalty and a red card to the defender who handballed it after it went in. Week night game & shocking reffing.

Good old cheating Dermot Gallagher that was! In the days when Leeds were a big club, the bias was always there....

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Dec 16 10.09am

Originally posted by the silurian

Good old cheating Dermot Gallagher that was! In the days when Leeds were a big club, the bias was always there....

Where is the firm evidence he was "Cheating" ?
This is a serious allegation.

Why can you not entertain the notion that he could not possibly see that the ball had crossed the line ? That it was a genuine mistake ?
Referees cannot see everything you know !
And as someone once said to me "You can blink at the wrong time".

Edited by Willo (31 Dec 2016 10.10am)

 

Hoof Hearted 31 Dec 16 10.48am

Originally posted by Andy_G

Wasn't there some rubbish about Howard Webb favouring Man Utd a few years ago. It's all Bull, made up by conspiracy theorists and people with overly large chip on their shoulder.

Is it though?

What about this extract from Fergie's autobiography!

Fergy's Autobiography.jpg Attachment: Fergy's Autobiography.jpg (189.95Kb)

 

Hoof Hearted 31 Dec 16 11.09am

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

If that's the game against Leeds I'm thinking it was as the ref didn't give the goal he should have given a penalty and a red card to the defender who handballed it after it went in. Week night game & shocking reffing.

For accuracy... it was a Sunday afternoon FA Cup game live on the telly.

Not only did Gallagher not give us the goal and/or penalty for handball.... he gave a free kick to Leeds that should have been ours and allowed it to be taken before we could organise our defence and allowed Harry Kewell to score!

I've also witnessed Gallagher apply bias to WBA against us by sending off Sorondo from miles away when he got the ball! See the footage below...

[Link]

Superb match though (despite Gallagher) I was there!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Dec 16 11.27am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

For accuracy... it was a Sunday afternoon FA Cup game live on the telly.

Not only did Gallagher not give us the goal and/or penalty for handball.... he gave a free kick to Leeds that should have been ours and allowed it to be taken before we could organise our defence and allowed Harry Kewell to score!

I've also witnessed Gallagher apply bias to WBA against us by sending off Sorondo from miles away when he got the ball! See the footage below...

[Link]

Superb match though (despite Gallagher) I was there!

Firstly one cannot accuse Gallagher of being biased towards WBA, deliberately making an incorrect decision in their favour.

Secondly one can still win the ball but commit a foul eg one makes contact with the player first to foul him before making contact with the ball.

In the link, Sorondo challenges from the side but the ball appears to go forward so perhaps this influenced Gallagher's decision making.

 

Hoof Hearted 31 Dec 16 12.52pm

Originally posted by Willo

Firstly one cannot accuse Gallagher of being biased towards WBA, deliberately making an incorrect decision in their favour.

Secondly one can still win the ball but commit a foul eg one makes contact with the player first to foul him before making contact with the ball.

In the link, Sorondo challenges from the side but the ball appears to go forward so perhaps this influenced Gallagher's decision making.

I've just won £10 from my wife correctly forecasting your response pretty much word for word.

Result!

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 31 Dec 16 1.08pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

I've also witnessed Gallagher apply bias to WBA against us by sending off Sorondo from miles away when he got the ball! See the footage below...

Superb match though (despite Gallagher) I was there!

Me too

 

Hoof Hearted 31 Dec 16 1.29pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Me too

I nearly got into a fight.... I mimicked a crying face as we equalised in the last second and this Baggie bloke took offence and tried to climb over the fence to get at me.

My mate is a Baggie and we drove back to Bristol after in stony silence as he was gutted we had scored so late too.

 

lefty27 Flag ipswich 31 Dec 16 1.44pm

I have an idea. Why don't the major European leagues pool refs. They all ref champs league and uefa cup so travel no issue. It would iradicate any bias in these leagues and standardise league football in europe.This would benifit us internationaly and in European competition when we see fouls comitted that wouldnt be given in the pl.

 

Old Chap Flag Orpington 31 Dec 16 5.49pm

Originally posted by Willo

Where is the firm evidence he was "Cheating" ?
This is a serious allegation.

Why can you not entertain the notion that he could not possibly see that the ball had crossed the line ? That it was a genuine mistake ?
Referees cannot see everything you know !
And as someone once said to me "You can blink at the wrong time".

Edited by Willo (31 Dec 2016 10.10am)

A genuine mistake? Maybe - but I recall he said the whole ball hadn't crossed the line which is why he didn't give the goal. Well judge for yourself - photo clearly shows the ball at least a yard over the line.

And if he didn't see it clearly surely he'd watch carefully and must have seen the Leeds player handle the ball?

So it should either have been a goal, or a penalty and red card

IMG_4719.JPG Attachment: IMG_4719.JPG (33.14Kb)

 


Trivial fact - Palace used to win 5-1 at least once a season, maybe next season?

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 01 Jan 17 8.48am

Originally posted by Willo

Where is the firm evidence he was "Cheating" ?
This is a serious allegation.

Why can you not entertain the notion that he could not possibly see that the ball had crossed the line ? That it was a genuine mistake ?
Referees cannot see everything you know !
And as someone once said to me "You can blink at the wrong time".

Edited by Willo (31 Dec 2016 10.10am)

But how could avoid seeing the Leeds-arm that stopped the ball on second attempt? That was even worse from ref in the Cup game (with Venables in Leeds dugout)...

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Jan 17 9.15am

Originally posted by Old Chap

A genuine mistake? Maybe - but I recall he said the whole ball hadn't crossed the line which is why he didn't give the goal. Well judge for yourself - photo clearly shows the ball at least a yard over the line.

And if he didn't see it clearly surely he'd watch carefully and must have seen the Leeds player handle the ball?

So it should either have been a goal, or a penalty and red card

Yes photo shows it crossed the line and it can be seen from this angle but the referee had a different angle entirely and had to make a split-second decision in real time.Besides they often have to rely on their assistants for such calls but even they can be un-sighted with players in their line of vision.

Regards handling the ball, the above applies and just because a referee hasn't seen an offence from his angle doesn't mean that he is biased and purposely chooses NOT to give the foul.We are all terrific judges when we look at umpteen TV replays from different angles.

Edited by Willo (01 Jan 2017 9.16am)

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Mike Dean