This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
What about there offside goals vs palace and a player should have been sent off? Man U get all the decisions going there way!
|
|
|
Originally posted by peterg
In interviews last night, Mourinho complained about the ref in the Manure 2-1 over Palace last month - said he was learning to "cope" with bad decisions like the fact Manure should have had a pen for Ledley's handball. He presumably managed to "cope" with the fact that the first Manure goal was both handball and offside, and that Rojo should have got a red for his two-footer on Wilf. He must also have "coped" with Mike Dean sending off West Ham's Feghouli last night, when if anything Manure's Phil Jones should have got the red. He also had to "cope" with the fact that the second Manure goal was offside. Must be hard being Manure's manager when refs always favour the opposition, as so clearly demonstrated by Cluttenc*nt in the Cup Final v Palace. 100%agree with you!
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
It's all just part of the act. Any fool can see that Man U get different treatment from refs than clubs like ours - just look at the preposterous red card Wet Spam got yesterday and compare it with all sorts of occasions when Rojo, to take just one of their players for example, has committed the most outrageous dangerous challenges and not even been cautioned. Successive Man U managers have to keep the pressure up on the FA not to pi** off such a big club and influential stakeholder whilst trying to make it look as if they're being robbed blind as well. The whole thing is a fiasco and Murinho is as bent as Clattenburg. Edited by chateauferret (03 Jan 2017 10.37am) I accept that Feghouli never went in with studs showing but if a player leaves the ground with both feet and lunges into a tackle then he risks getting a 'Red'. If that happened to one of our players and our player had to go off injured with no 'Red' being shown there would be a huge outcry on HOL with cries of bias against our club etc etc.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I accept that Feghouli never went in with studs showing but if a player leaves the ground with both feet and lunges into a tackle then he risks getting a 'Red'. If that happened to one of our players and our player had to go off injured with no 'Red' being shown there would be a huge outcry on HOL with cries of bias against our club etc etc. You're the first person I know of, except the ref (and he will have realised his mistake when watching it again) who believes that was a correct red. It will get overturned on appeal. You're clearly a troll.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I accept that Feghouli never went in with studs showing but if a player leaves the ground with both feet and lunges into a tackle then he risks getting a 'Red'. If that happened to one of our players and our player had to go off injured with no 'Red' being shown there would be a huge outcry on HOL with cries of bias against our club etc etc. Here we go AGAIN !!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by gambler
You're the first person I know of, except the ref (and he will have realised his mistake when watching it again) who believes that was a correct red. It will get overturned on appeal. You're clearly a troll. Total and utter hogwash of course. Regards the incident, all I have said is that if a player leaves the ground two-footed and lunges into a challenge he risks a 'Red'.I admit it wasn't a high contact when the players came together but it was a two-footed lunge with both feet off the ground. Interestingly enough, Mike Dean didn't blow up initially for the challenge and looked the other way as if to allow play to continue but then all of a sudden looked towards the players involved in the incident and sent off Feghouli.Not sure if an 'Assistant' got involved as they are wired-up. Of course Dean will have to explain his decision as part of the normal 'Forensic' analysis. As Gary Neville said, it wasn't the worst decision he has seen. I repeat - If Feghouli had made that tackle on one of our players, our player got badly hurt and no 'Red' was issued there would be an interesting debate on HOL !
|
|
|
Originally posted by the silurian
Here we go AGAIN !!! NO,NO,NO ! I have made my comments, I have nothing more to add so wil refrain from doing so. I know you love a WILLO thread and all the WILLO baiting but alas I am going to disappoint you.
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 03 Jan 17 12.09pm | |
|---|---|
|
This bloke knows Willo for sure!
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
ManU players are trained to be attention-seeking and talk constantly to referees as this feeds their ego none more than Mike Dean who loves his celebrity role. Its hard luck on the paying public who won't be seeing much football but who cares about them.
I thought there was a new rule about players approaching the refs. Didn't stop them yesterday as usual. That rule obviously doesn't apply to them.
|
|
|
Pundits go on about what Rooney's best position is, but clearly it's wherever the referee is.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
NO,NO,NO ! I have made my comments, I have nothing more to add so wil refrain from doing so. I know you love a WILLO thread and all the WILLO baiting but alas I am going to disappoint you. So you are the ONLY person who believes that the ref was correct.....Even Graham poll, most referees all the pundits, even plenty of man u fans agree IT WAS NOT A RED CARD but the normal Red bias came into effect..... Rojo V Palace same tackle..No card ! Forensic analysis helps no one, it's hagwash piffle balderdash to cover up referees errors which are becoming all too common now!!
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
In the interests of fairness, yes the refereeing decisions made at the Palace Man Utd game were terrible, so much so, that both sides can feel extremely hard done by. He's right, there were any number of poor calls, that both sides can say changed the outcome of the game. And, yes, those challenges should be red cards, even if referees have a tendency to see them as yellows. Rojo should have been sent off, and I think probably Feghouli should have gone as well - The problem is that the critics and pundits, will tend to call an issue a red one week, when its not given, and then call it harsh, the following week when it is given. Its almost as if they're paid to talk about issues in the game, rather than the rules and regulations (which clearly many of them don't even remotely seem to understand).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
In the interests of fairness, yes the refereeing decisions made at the Palace Man Utd game were terrible, so much so, that both sides can feel extremely hard done by. He's right, there were any number of poor calls, that both sides can say changed the outcome of the game. And, yes, those challenges should be red cards, even if referees have a tendency to see them as yellows. Rojo should have been sent off, and I think probably Feghouli should have gone as well - The problem is that the critics and pundits, will tend to call an issue a red one week, when its not given, and then call it harsh, the following week when it is given. Jamie My view entirely. And these are the ones who complain about a lack of "Consistency" ! To be fair to Gary Neville he did say yesterday that it is very difficult to get "Consistency" when referees have different angles of view etc etc.I would add that no incidents are identical in terms of the angle/height/ferocity of challenges etc etc etc. I await with baited breath as to whether W.Ham will appeal the Feghouli 'Red' and if so whether it will be overturned.Will they overturn a decision whereby the player has left the ground two-footed and lunged in ?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.