You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should Allardyce appoint a new captain?
November 16 2026 10.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Should Allardyce appoint a new captain?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Simon22 Flag Gillingham 10 Jan 17 6.45pm

I feel that Palace need a new captain. After Jedinak left there has been a void.

I love Dann but he isn't a leader in my opinion and since being given the armband his performances have dropped. I imagine the weight of this responsibility is part of that.

Who in the current team could take over?

Personally I would go for Macarthur, any thoughts?

 

acepal Flag Mars 10 Jan 17 6.46pm

yes, but need to bring someone in

Edited by acepal (10 Jan 2017 6.47pm)

Edited by acepal (10 Jan 2017 6.48pm)

 


Stair Park Eagle

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Jan 17 6.47pm

Fonte

 

bertshead Flag Castlederg 10 Jan 17 6.49pm

Mac

 

Simon22 Flag Gillingham 10 Jan 17 6.50pm

I like the idea of Fonte. If we can get him that would be great but If United are interested as Ive read I can't see it happening.

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 10 Jan 17 6.52pm

Punch for me. Only trouble is that captaincy move may result in Dann transfer to another club. Is it not possible to share captaincy out across batches of games to key players so as to offer professional development?

 

MPE Flag Maidstone 10 Jan 17 7.00pm

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Punch for me. Only trouble is that captaincy move may result in Dann transfer to another club. Is it not possible to share captaincy out across batches of games to key players so as to offer professional development?

I was worried a few seasons back we would lose Dann. On current form can't see anybody wanting him? What have you seen in puncheon to warrant the captaincy?

And yes a new captain would be good, preferably a new signing who hopefully has some leadership qualities and some bollocks

 


Just when I thought that I was out...........they pull me back in

Simon22 Flag Gillingham 10 Jan 17 7.23pm

I'm not sure I see anyting in Puncheon that screams capatain.

With regards to sharing I suppose thats a possibility as In Dann controls the defence keeps them organised etc.

Then Macarthur ot whoever can help with the midfield and attack ensuring their pressing and finding space etc.

 

Mad4palace Flag 10 Jan 17 7.27pm

McArthur is not captain material from what I can tell, he doesn't communicate as much as required by your captain. Delaney and Flamini are the only other candidates.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 10 Jan 17 7.29pm

Puncheon.

Cares more than anyone. Regularly geeing up the others around him, showing passion. He's one of our own.

 

Simon22 Flag Gillingham 10 Jan 17 7.30pm

There in lies a big problem. We need leaders.

Macarthur could become more vocal he has the attitude on the pitch.

Delaney doesnt have the temperment for it and makes bad decisions. I like Flamini but he I feel needs to be here a bit longer before that decision.

I know people believe Pardew got rid of our leaders and he certainly treated Jedi badly, but did we have many beforehand?

Originally posted by Mad4palace

McArthur is not captain material from what I can tell, he doesn't communicate as much as required by your captain. Delaney and Flamini are the only other candidates.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 10 Jan 17 8.40pm

Definately take it off Dann and let him concentrate on being a decent centre back , which he hasn't been this year.
Puncheon ? I'm assuming this is a joke.
MacArthur is the only option , like him as a player, not sure he's a captain though.
The fact we haven't got a 'captain like 'figure is the real problem.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 10 Jan 17 8.43pm

Ideally I'd like Sam to sort Dann out and get him to prove he deserves the captaincy.

 

n wales eagles Flag llandudno 10 Jan 17 10.29pm

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Punch for me. Only trouble is that captaincy move may result in Dann transfer to another club. Is it not possible to share captaincy out across batches of games to key players so as to offer professional development?

Provided he's non playing captain

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 10 Jan 17 10.44pm

I would prefer a new captain but stripping Dann of the captaincy may damage his confidence, so I'm not sure if it would be a good thing for the whole team. However if a new captain is appointed, I would like it to be Damo as has real passion, fight and he seems to be someone who is constantly talking to other players and in some cases calming them down.

Flamini seems to be the only other leader inthe team to me.

Perhaps in a few years players like MacCarthur, Punch and maybe Wilf will devlop into better leaders. If Puncheon does ever become captain, he is goin to need to learn how to communicate and interact with fans better, at the moment he's a real misery

 

Simon22 Flag Gillingham 10 Jan 17 10.59pm

Originally posted by Shifty97

I would prefer a new captain but stripping Dann of the captaincy may damage his confidence, so I'm not sure if it would be a good thing for the whole team. However if a new captain is appointed, I would like it to be Damo as has real passion, fight and he seems to be someone who is constantly talking to other players and in some cases calming them down.

Flamini seems to be the only other leader inthe team to me.

Perhaps in a few years players like MacCarthur, Punch and maybe Wilf will devlop into better leaders. If Puncheon does ever become captain, he is goin to need to learn how to communicate and interact with fans better, at the moment he's a real misery

I take your points but would disagree. I think Dann has lost confidence already and the pressure of being captain has certainly contributed to that.

With regards to Delaney, I feel he is a poor decision maker and loses his head at times. That being said I am willing to concede that as captain there is a slight chance he can reign it in.

Puncheon has no chance, good player but no leadership qualities which I can see.

Macarthur for me is our most influential player as noted by how well we play with him in the team than when he isnt. I feel he is our talisman.

 

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 10 Jan 17 11.16pm

Needs to be someone who is an established long standing member of the team. Will never work in a million years if you basically bring someone in for the job. I would say delaney but as someone else has said he can be a bit hot headed and temperamental. However maybe the confidence and position given to him would rein that Side of his personality in a bit.

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 10 Jan 17 11.36pm

Leaders are not appointed - they are discovered. If there is not a suitable leader in the squad, we need to find one.

 


[Link]

Username Flag Horsham 11 Jan 17 10.07am

Flamini would be my choice if we'd changed, but I'd stick with Dann and see what Sam can do with him over the next few weeks.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

20 Spaces Isnt Enoug Flag Bolton 11 Jan 17 10.13am


Nobby Nolan ?

To complete his team.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should Allardyce appoint a new captain?