This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Listened to this on Monday (haven't been able to post before due to utter outrage). He said JM was a blatant penalty but Maddely had a difficult game, due to Palace players, in particular Zaha going down to easily" WTF when did they go down to easily/ No wonder we are getting no decisions in our favour. No question about it, definite agenda against Wilf, no more penalties for him Im afraid....referees have been told not to give him a penalty no matter what happens..
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by the silurian
No question about it, definite agenda against Wilf, no more penalties for him Im afraid....referees have been told not to give him a penalty no matter what happens.. A bit like when AJ couldn't buy a penalty after winning a few...
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
I'm f***ing appalled. Whether there's a foul or not a player may have to go onto the ground to minimise injury risk. If you ever do say judo you learn how to fall without hurting yourself - not how to avoid falling altogether, because then you do hurt yourself. It is not Wilf's fault that he is fast and light and maybe doesn't have a low centre of gravity. And just because he falls over once it does not mean a) that he is diving or b) that the next time it happens it's also not a foul. As for the idea that it's Wilf's or Palace's fault that this buffoon of a ref gave such an appalling decision, this is so preposterous it beggars belief. The decisiob wasn't even against Zaha but McArthur - who is solidly built and does have a low centre of gravity, and whom (as I pointed out elsewhere) has no history of or reputation for diving whatsoever. Poll should bd roundly condemning such horrendous standards of officiating instead of excusing them by blaming perfectly fair play of the team wronged. This is coming from a senior figure in the setup and should know better than to spout such total bollocks. Except that the problem is it isn't bollocks. It's FA policy. What did he have to say about the Snodcrass case? Did Dann "make it difficult" for the ref by not committing to a challenge that he knew would risk a penalty? Absolutely outrageous. And Willo's argument that there's no agenda here blown completely out of the water. Edited by chateauferret (01 Mar 2017 8.22pm) I,m glad it is not just me being paranoid.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
A bit like when AJ couldn't buy a penalty after winning a few... When Andrew played against Birmingham Steve Bruce was interviewed on MOTD about him.We got a couple of penalties ,he said he went down easily. Pundits and Adrian Durham have said that Wilf is going down to easily,and now the Refs have stopped giving us Pens. For the record Andrew dived once against Norwich in that fateful season.
Palace 13th 2017/18. |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
I'm f***ing appalled. Whether there's a foul or not a player may have to go onto the ground to minimise injury risk. If you ever do say judo you learn how to fall without hurting yourself - not how to avoid falling altogether, because then you do hurt yourself. It is not Wilf's fault that he is fast and light and maybe doesn't have a low centre of gravity. And just because he falls over once it does not mean a) that he is diving or b) that the next time it happens it's also not a foul. As for the idea that it's Wilf's or Palace's fault that this buffoon of a ref gave such an appalling decision, this is so preposterous it beggars belief. The decisiob wasn't even against Zaha but McArthur - who is solidly built and does have a low centre of gravity, and whom (as I pointed out elsewhere) has no history of or reputation for diving whatsoever. Poll should bd roundly condemning such horrendous standards of officiating instead of excusing them by blaming perfectly fair play of the team wronged. This is coming from a senior figure in the setup and should know better than to spout such total bollocks. Except that the problem is it isn't bollocks. It's FA policy. What did he have to say about the Snodcrass case? Did Dann "make it difficult" for the ref by not committing to a challenge that he knew would risk a penalty? Absolutely outrageous. And Willo's argument that there's no agenda here blown completely out of the water. Edited by chateauferret (01 Mar 2017 8.22pm) Poll has nothing to do with the refereeing setup, let only a senior figure, he is now a journalist. His claim to fame was booking a Croatian twice in a game, only sending him off on third booking. Has very little credibility and likes the sound of his own voice.
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
I'm f***ing appalled. Whether there's a foul or not a player may have to go onto the ground to minimise injury risk. If you ever do say judo you learn how to fall without hurting yourself - not how to avoid falling altogether, because then you do hurt yourself. It is not Wilf's fault that he is fast and light and maybe doesn't have a low centre of gravity. And just because he falls over once it does not mean a) that he is diving or b) that the next time it happens it's also not a foul. As for the idea that it's Wilf's or Palace's fault that this buffoon of a ref gave such an appalling decision, this is so preposterous it beggars belief. The decisiob wasn't even against Zaha but McArthur - who is solidly built and does have a low centre of gravity, and whom (as I pointed out elsewhere) has no history of or reputation for diving whatsoever. Poll should bd roundly condemning such horrendous standards of officiating instead of excusing them by blaming perfectly fair play of the team wronged. This is coming from a senior figure in the setup and should know better than to spout such total bollocks. Except that the problem is it isn't bollocks. It's FA policy. What did he have to say about the Snodcrass case? Did Dann "make it difficult" for the ref by not committing to a challenge that he knew would risk a penalty? Absolutely outrageous. And Willo's argument that there's no agenda here blown completely out of the water. Edited by chateauferret (01 Mar 2017 8.22pm)
|
|
|
I am being pedantic as warnock signed MacArthur, not pulis.... Edited by rossboss29 (01 Mar 2017 9.20pm)
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Poll has nothing to do with the refereeing setup, let only a senior figure, he is now a journalist. His claim to fame was booking a Croatian twice in a game, only sending him off on third booking. Has very little credibility and likes the sound of his own voice. That's a relief. I'm not convinced he's regarded as a joke, though; we all know people who command high levels of respect in the establishment despite being responsible for all sorts of ghastly cockups, mentioning no names.
============ |
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by stuckinbristol
I don't think I saw that. I don't rememmber ever seeing him dive and thought he was quite hard to knock over.
============ |
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
I don't think I saw that. I don't rememmber ever seeing him dive and thought he was quite hard to knock over. Even if true it's a long way from the reputation earned by, say, certain Chelsea forwards.
============ |
|
|
Video referees will save us all Parrot
Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello" |
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by bicycle repair man
I heard that on Talksport and I was fuming ! and I am not prone to fuming. Exactly. Costa is "entitled to go down", Zaha is "diving", Snodgrass "was successful in deceiving the referee", and McArthur's team "made the referee's job difficult". My reading is for Costa "the referee f***ed up", for Zaha "the referee f***ed up", for Snodgrass "the referee f***ed up" and for McArthur "the referee f***ed up". Edited by chateauferret (01 Mar 2017 10.27pm)
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
I'm f***ing appalled. Whether there's a foul or not a player may have to go onto the ground to minimise injury risk. If you ever do say judo you learn how to fall without hurting yourself - not how to avoid falling altogether, because then you do hurt yourself. It is not Wilf's fault that he is fast and light and maybe doesn't have a low centre of gravity. And just because he falls over once it does not mean a) that he is diving or b) that the next time it happens it's also not a foul. As for the idea that it's Wilf's or Palace's fault that this buffoon of a ref gave such an appalling decision, this is so preposterous it beggars belief. The decisiob wasn't even against Zaha but McArthur - who is solidly built and does have a low centre of gravity, and whom (as I pointed out elsewhere) has no history of or reputation for diving whatsoever. Poll should bd roundly condemning such horrendous standards of officiating instead of excusing them by blaming perfectly fair play of the team wronged. This is coming from a senior figure in the setup and should know better than to spout such total bollocks. Except that the problem is it isn't bollocks. It's FA policy. What did he have to say about the Snodcrass case? Did Dann "make it difficult" for the ref by not committing to a challenge that he knew would risk a penalty? Absolutely outrageous. And Willo's argument that there's no agenda here blown completely out of the water. Edited by chateauferret (01 Mar 2017 8.22pm) As someone has pointed out, 'Poll' is not part of the refereeing 'High command' and has no influence on them, he is now employed in the media.
|
|
|
Originally posted by alaneagle1
When Andrew played against Birmingham Steve Bruce was interviewed on MOTD about him.We got a couple of penalties ,he said he went down easily. Pundits and Adrian Durham have said that Wilf is going down to easily,and now the Refs have stopped giving us Pens. For the record Andrew dived once against Norwich in that fateful season. Wasn't it Wilf going over in the box (not saying a dive by the way) that relegated Peterborough from the Championship? Or have I dreamt up some fantastical scenario that didn't happen?
|
|
|
Originally posted by bicycle repair man
I heard that on Talksport and I was fuming ! and I am not prone to fuming. Totally agree. Benteke's name would've been on that list too, until he joined Palace of course. Those players are 'entitled to go down' if there's 'contact', or even if there's no contact if they have to dive to avoid it. Blatant double standards.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
As someone has pointed out, 'Poll' is not part of the refereeing 'High command' and has no influence on them, he is now employed in the media.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.