This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
I'm not aware of there being any reporting on Pulis' motivation. It was a bizarre sequence of decisions by him to be sure. The only thing I can think of is that he had another gig lined up that was time sensitive, but then fell through quickly after he freed himself from his Palace contract. It would be hilarious if it turns out that his new employer binned him once they realised that he'd do something as c***ish as he did to CPFC. Karma's a bitch. Edited by Ray in Houston (05 Mar 2017 5.21pm) the highlighted stuff is probably the pivotal bit. He deserved the bonus, but 'Breach of Contract' makes everything void. Edited by Forest Hillbilly (05 Mar 2017 5.26pm)
I disengage, I turn the page. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
I'm not aware of there being any reporting on Pulis' motivation. It was a bizarre sequence of decisions by him to be sure. The only thing I can think of is that he had another gig lined up that was time sensitive, but then fell through quickly after he freed himself from his Palace contract. It would be hilarious if it turns out that his new employer binned him once they realised that he'd do something as c***ish as he did to CPFC. Karma's a bitch.
Bexley Dave Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing! "The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum) |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Leaving aside whether you think Pulis deserved the chants yesterday or to keep the money and have a stand named after him, can anyone explain to me why he didn't just sit tight until after the season had started, pocket the money and then resign? I mean why risk it all to get the cash a few weeks earlier, if he could have taken it fair and square and then resigned at (for instance) the closing of the transfer window once the club had failed to sign his targets? It is clear that he didn't have a club lined up or anything. As I understand it he was due a bonus for keeping us up, not for loyalty. I get that he lied to parish etc but what did he gain by taking the risk? Also, parish won the case because Pulis obviously intended to resign and lied about it, but so what? The bonus was for keeping us up, not for keeping us up and then staying with us for a certain period of time thereafter. Or was it? Does anyone actually know? I thought the deal with the bonus was twofold. Keeping us up AND remaining at the club till a certain date minimum.
|
|
|
Originally posted by bexleydave
Those are all excellent questions. I have never really understood the details of the case and I'm not aware they've ever been made public. Whatever the rights and wrongs of it, my question is what has his keeping us in the PL been worth to the club since? Even if we were legally in the right to pursue the case, I have never wavered from believing we looked a bit cheap pursuing it. I don't suppose we'll ever get to know why he really left like that. I agree and think that whatever steps Parish takes to enforce the judgement will make us look even cheaper as I'm sure that most people (except Palace supporters) will think that he earned the bonus by keeping us in the Premiership and look at us as the club that is happy to shaft it's managers as well as it's suppliers, If and it's a big if Pulis had been approached by West Ham he could have just waited a week to fulfil his contractual obligations and then ask Parish to be released from his contract much as Dougie Freedman did before him which is why that conspiracy theory doesn't make sense.
|
|
|
Originally posted by babylonjohn
I also suspect he was unhappy that Parish hadn't given him a blank cheque book and more say. Im sure he would have rather spent money on several 7ft defenders instead of getting Wilf back from man.u. That seems like the view of a Palace supporter with tunnel vision for two reasons. Firstly there would have been an outline agreement with Parish about how much would be available and secondly he hasn't been spending West Brom's money on several 7ft defenders has he
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Leaving aside whether you think Pulis deserved the chants yesterday or to keep the money and have a stand named after him, can anyone explain to me why he didn't just sit tight until after the season had started, pocket the money and then resign? I mean why risk it all to get the cash a few weeks earlier, if he could have taken it fair and square and then resigned at (for instance) the closing of the transfer window once the club had failed to sign his targets? It is clear that he didn't have a club lined up or anything. As I understand it he was due a bonus for keeping us up, not for loyalty. I get that he lied to parish etc but what did he gain by taking the risk? Also, parish won the case because Pulis obviously intended to resign and lied about it, but so what? The bonus was for keeping us up, not for keeping us up and then staying with us for a certain period of time thereafter. Or was it? Does anyone actually know? It looks like by the timing day before start of season. that he got his money and then tried to hold club to ransom for more or he d leave. That is only what I think may of hapened though. we will never know for sure.
People standing in the rain just to see their dream again. The Damned |
|
|
Originally posted by Gidge
Everyone's entitled to their opinion but I cannot believe some people on here saying that we "look cheap" for taking Pulis to court over this. He did a magnificent job for us and he is a very good manager but for me, that was all undone the moment he threw his toys out and left us in turmoil 2 days before the season started. Here's my understanding of what happened; He didn't get the signings he wanted so he got on the blower to his contacts and pimped himself out for another job. He got job offers pretty quickly and, with the the clock ticking, lied to Parish to get his bonus paid early and left as soon as he could. He obviously didn't give a rat's arse about Palace or us fans. He's got history for this kind of behaviour with other clubs as well. The Judge even said his conduct had "been shown to be disgraceful" when ruling against him. Horrible, horrible man who deserves everything he gets. Not much by way of legal jargon but IMO a pretty accurate summing up of the likely events. I basically think that he believed he could roll us over and that timing was everything as his stock was high. Had he told the truth to the board he probably wouldn't be staring down the barrell of a £3.7M judgment debt which, incidentally won't be doing his credit score a lot of good.
Bring back Brolin |
|
|
Originally posted by m/k mick
Its about honouring the contract, he knew the details, he asked for it to be paid early, he knew what he was up to, why did he lie about buying a property as being his reason, and i bet we are honouring pardews contract, rightly so Totally, good point.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eagle@ tn34
Unfortunately winning a court case and getting the debtor to pay are two entirely different things. I have learnt this from my own experiences and have had to employ the sherriffs office to force the outcome to receive payment. It can take years and thats not counting if their is any reasonable course of appeal from the MR Pulis. COYP He must be out of time if he hasn't already lodged an appeal and there have been no reports that he has. So probably would need to apply for leave to appeal out of time which would require him to show grounds to justify the late appeal. As for enforcement that mainly proves difficult when a judgment debtor has no money. A bankruptcy petition would probably create some interest!
I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals. |
|
|
Originally posted by eagle@ tn34
Unfortunately winning a court case and getting the debtor to pay are two entirely different things. I have learnt this from my own experiences and have had to employ the sherriffs office to force the outcome to receive payment. It can take years and thats not counting if their is any reasonable course of appeal from the MR Pulis. COYP Indeed. I am (was) a chippie by trade & a guy bumped me for 900 odd quid. I was actually just going to shrug my shoulders & not worry about it, but my work colleague said 'Its alright for you, your a single bloke whereas i'm a married man with two kids'so we took him to the small claims court where we won our case.
Pro USA & Israel |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.