You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 10-man hoodoo history?
November 16 2026 10.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

10-man hoodoo history?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
regal_eagle Flag somewhere 20 Mar 17 6.33pm

On Saturday we (Troy) scored whilst the other team had 10 on the pitch.

Have we finally (with Troys help) shaken the losers against 10-men tag?

I struggling to think of the last time we scored, let alone scored a winning goal whilst we were a man up.

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 20 Mar 17 6.35pm

Am i missing something here?

 

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 20 Mar 17 6.40pm

Niang was off the pitch whilst we scored.

Does that help you find what you were missing?

 

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 20 Mar 17 6.55pm

Liverpool won from a goal and a man down.
[Link]

West Ham beat us 1-0 a man down
[Link]

And obviously Man U beat us with 10 men (ok, 11 if you count t***tenberg)
[Link]

The last time I can think of us scoring against 10-men (even briefly whilst an opposition player is receiving treatment off the pitch) was last season with Gayle against West Ham after Cheikhou Kouyate was sent off for a 2nd yellow.. so almost a year of not wanting an opponent sent off..or am I wrong?

Edited by regal_eagle (20 Mar 2017 6.56pm)

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 20 Mar 17 7.01pm

Originally posted by regal_eagle

Niang was off the pitch whilst we scored.

Does that help you find what you were missing?

Might have been an idea to say that...

 

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 20 Mar 17 7.15pm

Originally posted by spartakev2
Might have been an idea to say that...

Agreed, it was silly of me to assume others might have been paying attention to what was going on on the pitch.

But yes, after hearing the vast majority of the crowd telling the ref "You Don't Know What you're Doing", even though he obviously knew more than the crowd, I should never just assume that people on here or at matches know what they're talking about.

 

Eewires Flag Guildford 20 Mar 17 9.59pm

Originally posted by regal_eagle

Agreed, it was silly of me to assume others might have been paying attention to what was going on on the pitch.

But yes, after hearing the vast majority of the crowd telling the ref "You Don't Know What you're Doing", even though he obviously knew more than the crowd, I should never just assume that people on here or at matches know what they're talking about.

If ever a 'like' button was needed it is for this. I was trying to explain the rules to those around me during that chanting but they didn't want to hear.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 20 Mar 17 10.02pm

Originally posted by regal_eagle

Agreed, it was silly of me to assume others might have been paying attention to what was going on on the pitch.

But yes, after hearing the vast majority of the crowd telling the ref "You Don't Know What you're Doing", even though he obviously knew more than the crowd, I should never just assume that people on here or at matches know what they're talking about.

Silly me, I was watching us attacking and shouting at the ref for not sending their player off fof his assault on wilf.didn't notice what was happening to one of their players down the other end of the pitch. If you're going to start a thread, make it clear or don't bother.

 

jeeagles Flag 20 Mar 17 10.17pm

Originally posted by regal_eagle

Liverpool won from a goal and a man down.
[Link]

West Ham beat us 1-0 a man down
[Link]

And obviously Man U beat us with 10 men (ok, 11 if you count t***tenberg)
[Link]

The last time I can think of us scoring against 10-men (even briefly whilst an opposition player is receiving treatment off the pitch) was last season with Gayle against West Ham after Cheikhou Kouyate was sent off for a 2nd yellow.. so almost a year of not wanting an opponent sent off..or am I wrong?

Edited by regal_eagle (20 Mar 2017 6.56pm)

I'm sure Everton had a red card against us last season then we lost 1-0.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 21 Mar 17 9.58am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Might have been an idea to say that...

it's assumed that seeing as we are all super fans that we were obviously all watching the game and know the positioning of each and every player in the build up to said goal.

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


regal_eagle Flag somewhere 21 Mar 17 1.01pm

Originally posted by Eewires
If ever a 'like' button was needed it is for this. I was trying to explain the rules to those around me during that chanting but they didn't want to hear.

Cheers. It would seem this has put a few noses out of joint though. Empty vessels n'all...

 

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 21 Mar 17 1.02pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Silly me, I was watching us attacking and shouting at the ref for not sending their player off fof his assault on wilf.didn't notice what was happening to one of their players down the other end of the pitch. If you're going to start a thread, make it clear or don't bother.

A shoulder barge, and not being directly through on goal being a straight red, obviously.

 

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 21 Mar 17 1.17pm

Originally posted by paperhat
it's assumed that seeing as we are all super fans that we were obviously all watching the game and know the positioning of each and every player in the build up to said goal.

A basic understanding of the rules of the sport we all follow would help when on a discussion forum, and knowing that when a player goes down and requires treatment he has to go off the pitch. Otherwise what is the point of discussion? I didn't realise I had to spoon-feed.

Next time I'll try to make it so indisputable and dead-ended that no replies or thinking are required.

Edited by regal_eagle (21 Mar 2017 1.18pm)

 

paperhat Flag croydon 21 Mar 17 1.26pm

Originally posted by regal_eagle

A basic understanding of the rules of the sport we all follow would help when on a discussion forum, and knowing that when a player goes down and requires treatment he has to go off the pitch. Otherwise what is the point of discussion? I didn't realise I had to spoon-feed.

Next time I'll try to make it so indisputable and dead-ended that no replies or thinking are required.

Edited by regal_eagle (21 Mar 2017 1.18pm)

and maybe just maybe, the guy that asked the question wasn't at the game, so wasn't aware that anyone was off the pitch at the time we scored?

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


regal_eagle Flag somewhere 21 Mar 17 1.26pm

Originally posted by jeeagles
I'm sure Everton had a red card against us last season then we lost 1-0.

I'd forgotten about Everton. I think we had 2 draws against them last season, but we definitely were a man up against them and failed to score or win.

Is this the match you were talking about jeeagles? [Link]

McCarthy got sent off at 52nd min, and we were pretty much all over them, if I remember rightly. On a side-note, that was one of Emmanuel Adebayors appearances, coming on in the 2nd half so maybe no surprise we didn't score..


Edited by regal_eagle (21 Mar 2017 1.41pm)

 

Beastie Flag 21 Mar 17 2.21pm

Originally posted by paperhat

it's assumed that seeing as we are all super fans that we were obviously all watching the game and know the positioning of each and every player in the build up to said goal.

Christ, it wasn’t exactly some obscure nerd fact. It was a major talking point in our game 3 days ago.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 21 Mar 17 3.30pm

Originally posted by regal_eagle

A basic understanding of the rules of the sport we all follow would help when on a discussion forum, and knowing that when a player goes down and requires treatment he has to go off the pitch. Otherwise what is the point of discussion? I didn't realise I had to spoon-feed.

Next time I'll try to make it so indisputable and dead-ended that no replies or thinking are required.

Edited by regal_eagle (21 Mar 2017 1.18pm)

Not so because it can, and has, happened that a player can be too seriously injured that he has to have treatment ON the pitch.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 21 Mar 17 4.22pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle
Not so because it can, and has, happened that a player can be too seriously injured that he has to have treatment ON the pitch.

Ahaa, but that player would still have to leave the pitch after receiving some treatment, and we wouldn't have been allowed to take the freekick with Niang still sobbing and rolling around.

Do you travel to matches from Penzance PZ Eagle?! That's one hell of a journey if so! Beautiful part of the World and really off topic but The Pirates Of Penzance was excellent at the Minack Theatre about 20 years ago. The Pirate boat sailing into the sunset was like the end of Goonies! 10/10

 

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 21 Mar 17 4.24pm

Originally posted by Beastie
Christ, it wasn’t exactly some obscure nerd fact. It was a major talking point in our game 3 days ago.

Thank you Beastie. I was beginning to question if I was actually a bigger nerd than I thought

 

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 21 Mar 17 6.05pm

Originally posted by paperhat
and maybe just maybe, the guy that asked the question wasn't at the game, so wasn't aware that anyone was off the pitch at the time we scored?

Should I then have to make a caveat that my posts & threads are for the reading; commenting; replying or making humorous quips by only those who are aware of what I speak of? Either way, I did answer the chaps' question.


Maybe (just maybe) rossboss wasn't at the match - Ignoring the fact one is probably more likely to notice this kind of thing on a TV screen with commentary instead of 'live' during the heat of battle. If that's the case then, someone who wasn't at the match or paying much attention to the online stream has managed to add more to this particular discussion with one open-ended question than you have with your two antithetical replies. But seeing as I didn't add the afore-mentioned caveat to my original post, you're well within your rights.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 10-man hoodoo history?