You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sell Jimmy Mac, he ain't coming back
November 16 2026 9.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sell Jimmy Mac, he ain't coming back


Page 1 of 9 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
GladAllOver27 Flag 01 Jul 17 7.56pm

[Link]

Doesn't seem to , of recovered from the back spasms. He got in December was extremely poor under big Sam. If villa offered 12+m for a 29 year old. It makes good business sense to sell. We desperately need a number 10.

Would you sell Jimmy mac ?

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 01 Jul 17 8.05pm

nooo

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 01 Jul 17 8.09pm

yes

 

GladAllOver27 Flag 01 Jul 17 8.12pm

New managers have different ideas. I like jimmy mac as a player and person but his form in 2017 was bad. Like last summer, where we sold Bolasie, Gayle and jedinak. There will be some decisions that doesn't please the fans. If we offered 12million definitely sell. We got an ageing midfield.

 

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 01 Jul 17 8.14pm

Sell, sell, sell...

 


Most certainly not European.

coulsdoneagle Flag London 01 Jul 17 8.17pm

No way, we saw what happened when we sold Jedi, we were woefully short of cover in the middle of the park. We need a 25 of players who can all do a job. The fat we want to trim are people like Lee and Sako who don't ever contribute to the squad. MacArthur can still do a job and he proved this as he had his most productive season with regards to goals and assists last season.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 01 Jul 17 8.18pm

Originally posted by moylerg

Sell, sell, sell...

Ok delboy

Buy, buy

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Dan89 Flag Se25 01 Jul 17 8.19pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

No way, we saw what happened when we sold Jedi, we were woefully short of cover in the middle of the park. We need a 25 of players who can all do a job. The fat we want to trim are people like Lee and Sako who don't ever contribute to the squad. MacArthur can still do a job and he proved this as he had his most productive season with regards to goals and assists last season.

He's average though, what's he's best position. 12m for a sub, we can use that funds elsewhere. Might even get boateng more game time.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

davehuggins Flag 01 Jul 17 8.22pm

Jimmy has been brilliant for us, it is now time to say thanks and recoup some funds.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 01 Jul 17 8.25pm

Originally posted by davehuggins

Jimmy has been brilliant for us, it is now time to say thanks and recoup some funds.

Exactly. I personally sell dann too. Get some younger blood in the line up.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

TheArmaniCode Flag 01 Jul 17 8.39pm

If Villa offer £10 million+, sell him, great price for a 29 year old. Otherwise, keep him.

Edited by TheArmaniCode (01 Jul 2017 8.40pm)

 

TheArmaniCode Flag 01 Jul 17 8.40pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Exactly. I personally sell dann too. Get some younger blood in the line up.

Dann is still plenty good for this side. Great squad player for sure.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 01 Jul 17 8.43pm

Originally posted by TheArmaniCode

Dann is still plenty good for this side. Great squad player for sure.

Like you said if someone offers 10+m for dann sell. It's time boateng given a chance as Jimmy mac back up. Get a quality number 10 and powerful defender.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

TheArmaniCode Flag 01 Jul 17 8.47pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Like you said if someone offers 10+m for dann sell. It's time boateng given a chance as Jimmy mac back up. Get a quality number 10 and powerful defender.

I get your point but I also think he's got a couple more years in him, I think people forget just how good he was when we had a manager that could organise a back four. Plus, we don't have many decent CB's left, and with our injury luck I think we'll need some good depth. Also, I think £10m is too little for Dann. If we're going to sell him, £15m min I reckon.

 

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 01 Jul 17 8.48pm

The effort he put in, can never be questioned but if they offer 10+ m . We can find better then I would sell. If we want to push on. Then mcarthur needs to be sold.

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

Mr Palaceman Flag 01 Jul 17 8.49pm

Originally posted by TheArmaniCode

If Villa offer £10 million+, sell him, great price for a 29 year old. Otherwise, keep him.

Edited by TheArmaniCode (01 Jul 2017 8.40pm)

This all day long. He's a good player and has done very well for us. When you look at his drop in form, you have to remember that the whole team was playing sh!te.

But 10-12 million, I'd sell. As long as we don't make the same mistake and not have anyone to replace him a la Jedi.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Dan89 Flag Se25 01 Jul 17 8.51pm

Originally posted by TheArmaniCode

I get your point but I also think he's got a couple more years in him, I think people forget just how good he was when we had a manager that could organise a back four. Plus, we don't have many decent CB's left, and with our injury luck I think we'll need some good depth. Also, I think £10m is too little for Dann. If we're going to sell him, £15m min I reckon.

Good player but shocking captain. I hope Luka captain next season because it doesn't suit scotty dann.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

coulsdoneagle Flag London 01 Jul 17 8.51pm

Originally posted by Dan89

He's average though, what's he's best position. 12m for a sub, we can use that funds elsewhere. Might even get boateng more game time.

He's average? What does that make boateng. A player that has played once or twice for us and has failed to set league one alight and isn't even championship standard. This is what I mean about us being short of cover and relying on those who are not good enough. As for his best position, he is an absolute terrier in the middle of the park and can let Lula boss the space in front of the defence and set cabaye free behind the strikers. He has an incredible engine and reads the game well and if we are playing a high press recovery of the ball style, we have no one better in the squad at pressuring players in to mistakes.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 01 Jul 17 8.57pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

He's average? What does that make boateng. A player that has played once or twice for us and has failed to set league one alight and isn't even championship standard. This is what I mean about us being short of cover and relying on those who are not good enough. As for his best position, he is an absolute terrier in the middle of the park and can let Lula boss the space in front of the defence and set cabaye free behind the strikers. He has an incredible engine and reads the game well and if we are playing a high press recovery of the ball style, we have no one better in the squad at pressuring players in to mistakes.

Yeah that what he done in 2016. It's time the academy product are given a pathway to the first team. In 2017 he was shocking bad. I was disappointed when we sold jedinak last summer but 12m for a jimmy mac, sub makes total sense to sell. He's not an out and out defensive mid or a attacking mid.

Edited by Dan89 (01 Jul 2017 8.58pm)

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 01 Jul 17 9.08pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Ok delboy

Buy, buy

...no need to buy him, already ours, the question was should we sell him. Which I answered. Is Delboy from Sydney? Swear that was Peckham.

 


Most certainly not European.

Page 1 of 9 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sell Jimmy Mac, he ain't coming back