This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Hypothetical question.....
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
CrazyBadger Ware 14 Aug 17 2.15pm |
|
|
So It's the 1st week in September, FdB has persisted with the 343, and where there are signs for encouragement, we are still played 4 lost 4. ...meanwhile over at newcastle, RafaB has thrown a Sports Direct Chair at Mike Ashley and walked out of the club.
Do we: Keep faith with FdB or Get Rafa in at all costs ?
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"
|
glaziermart 14 Aug 17 2.23pm |
|
|
It is a bit ridiculous and totally hypothetical, but interesting all the same. I would like to think De Boer should have more than 4 games (actually it is 3 league games, the other one will be the Cup) by 1st September. But Benitez is a top class manager, and believe it or not we do actually possess a lot of quality players despite what some might think on here. We should be a top 10 club, especially if we can get another goalkeeper, centre back and striker to add to what we have
|
CPFC/SCCC Sutton 14 Aug 17 2.24pm |
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
So It's the 1st week in September, FdB has persisted with the 343, and where there are signs for encouragement, we are still played 4 lost 4. ...meanwhile over at newcastle, RafaB has thrown a Sports Direct Chair at Mike Ashley and walked out of the club.
Do we: Keep faith with FdB or Get Rafa in at all costs ?
We stop acting like a crazybadger and we give him our support until at least Nov/Dec. Remember Holloway won 1 in 9.
Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!
|
spartakev2 Anerley 14 Aug 17 2.29pm |
|
|
So benitez leaves Newcastle because there's no money to spend on players, to come to palace where there's mmmmmm
|
Bangell Oxford 14 Aug 17 2.31pm |
|
|
Should we sack the manager after 4 games? No.
|
Dan89 Se25 14 Aug 17 2.35pm |
|
|
Ffs , he's signed a 3 year deal. It took us 6 weeks to appoint him. You want him gone after 4 games. In which he only managed one. I just want de Boer to be flexible in his line up. He also needs to be backed more in the market. 2 loans and 1 permanent transfer isn't enough. At least give him until November, if he proves you right about not being good enough for us. Then parish will have to act.
Edited by Dan89 (14 Aug 2017 2.36pm)
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|
CrazyBadger Ware 14 Aug 17 2.50pm |
|
|
i didn't say I wanted him gone - but If Rafa suddenly becomes available - who is a proven PL Manager, and will be snapped up quickly, would you want to miss out on him...chances are he won't be available in November.
I'm putting my faith in FdB - what he wants to build has got great potential - but big risks at the same time.
It'd be an interesting quandary. RafaB is one of those managers that id have here in an instant!
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"
|
Dan89 Se25 14 Aug 17 2.54pm |
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
i didn't say I wanted him gone - but If Rafa suddenly becomes available - who is a proven PL Manager, and will be snapped up quickly, would you want to miss out on him...chances are he won't be available in November.
I'm putting my faith in FdB - what he wants to build has got great potential - but big risks at the same time.
It'd be an interesting quandary. RafaB is one of those managers that id have here in an instant!
If we wanted prem proven. I'm sure mr parish would of choose Sean dyche. Looking at the team currently struggling, I know it's one game but dyche would of been a safe choice. Parish took a risk and hand mr Boer a 3 year deal, especially with the amount of time pardew received. Highly doubt we'd sack de Boer yet or in a months time.
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|
Spender Orpington 14 Aug 17 2.57pm |
|
|
Get Benitez in because he is proven to be a much better Manager at this high level .
|
CrazyBadger Ware 14 Aug 17 3.25pm |
|
Originally posted by glaziermart
It is a bit ridiculous and totally hypothetical, but interesting all the same. I would like to think De Boer should have more than 4 games (actually it is 3 league games, the other one will be the Cup) by 1st September. But Benitez is a top class manager, and believe it or not we do actually possess a lot of quality players despite what some might think on here. We should be a top 10 club, especially if we can get another goalkeeper, centre back and striker to add to what we have
pretty much exactly where I was coming from. Unlikley to happen, but there aren't many managers who I would even consider dumping FdB for at the moment..and if Newcastle don't get in any Transfers targets before The window shuts, Benitez Might "Do a Pulis" 
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"
|
CrazyBadger Ware 14 Aug 17 3.26pm |
|
Originally posted by Dan89
If we wanted prem proven. I'm sure mr parish would of choose Sean dyche. Looking at the team currently struggling, I know it's one game but dyche would of been a safe choice. Parish took a risk and hand mr Boer a 3 year deal, especially with the amount of time pardew received. Highly doubt we'd sack de Boer yet or in a months time.
Thats a fair point, but Benitez is of a much higher pedigree than Dyche ?
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"
|
Medway Eagle Whitstable Kent 14 Aug 17 4.11pm |
|
|
Why would we consider taking Benitez he spent a few years and a lot of money at Liverpool and didn't win anything despite all the money he spent, And he was caretaker manager at Chelsea until the end of a season I cant see why we would fall over ourselves to sign him up, Neither Chelsea or Liverpool fans were that keen on him. and both sets wanted him out, OK he won the championship with Newcastle but that was after taking them down, Lets see how he does this season's The Championship s a far cry from the Premier League.
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
So It's the 1st week in September, FdB has persisted with the 343, and where there are signs for encouragement, we are still played 4 lost 4. ...meanwhile over at newcastle, RafaB has thrown a Sports Direct Chair at Mike Ashley and walked out of the club.
Do we: Keep faith with FdB or Get Rafa in at all costs ?
Edited by Medway Eagle (14 Aug 2017 4.15pm)
|
Medway Eagle Whitstable Kent 14 Aug 17 4.15pm |
|
Originally posted by Medway Eagle
Why would we consider taking Benitez he spent a few years and a lot of money at Liverpool and didn't win anything despite all the money he spent, And he was caretaker manager at Chelsea until the end of a season I cant see why we would fall over ourselves to sign him up, Neither Chelsea or Liverpool fans were that keen on him. and both sets wanted him out, OK he won the championship with Newcastle but that was after taking them down, Lets see how he does this season's The Championship s a far cry from the Premier League.
|
homes New Eltham 14 Aug 17 4.39pm |
|
|
Didn't he win the champions league for Liverpool?
IH: "I thought Jonny and Wilf were brilliant but it took a 39 year old master to watch the ball and keep his eye on it to finish it".
|
homes New Eltham 14 Aug 17 4.41pm |
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
So It's the 1st week in September, FdB has persisted with the 343, and where there are signs for encouragement, we are still played 4 lost 4. ...meanwhile over at newcastle, RafaB has thrown a Sports Direct Chair at Mike Ashley and walked out of the club.
Do we: Keep faith with FdB or Get Rafa in at all costs ?
Would de boar manage us in the championship with all our best players sold and no money to spend on new players?
IH: "I thought Jonny and Wilf were brilliant but it took a 39 year old master to watch the ball and keep his eye on it to finish it".
|
sxp55 South Norwood 14 Aug 17 4.46pm |
|
|
Cause that's just what Rafa wants. Another club that won't let him spend money!
@sxp55555
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 14 Aug 17 4.51pm |
|
Originally posted by homes
Didn't he win the champions league for Liverpool?
And 1 or 2 weeks earlier in the Newcastle job and they would've survived. Or just not lose at Villa Park in the penultimate game of the season. That was inexcusable.
COYP
|
palace chick South Croydon 14 Aug 17 5.07pm |
|
|
I'm all for keeping this guy to see if he proves a lot of us wrong. Hopefully he will and this formation or a similar one together with the type of football he wants to play starts to work for us. However, I have serious doubts that we can play the way he wants with the squad we have or in fact in the premiership playing his way against anyone? I still don't understand how any team can start a season so unprepared as we have looked so far? If it ain't broke, don't change it!
|
tonymikejoe UK 14 Aug 17 6.50pm |
|
Originally posted by CPFC/SCCC
We stop acting like a crazybadger and we give him our support until at least Nov/Dec. Remember Holloway won 1 in 9.
I love it that this so-called voice of reason says give the new manager a chance until November!
|
CPFC/SCCC Sutton 14 Aug 17 6.53pm |
|
Originally posted by tonymikejoe
I love it that this so-called voice of reason says give the new manager a chance until November!
AT LEAST, before making a decision on whether de Boer the right man.
Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!
|