You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Riedewald
November 16 2026 9.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Riedewald


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
slubglurge Flag welling 28 Aug 17 8.08pm

What are we going to do with him? If Frank switches to 4-3-3 he cant play in a back four and he is not physical enough to play in the rough and tumble of the midfield. He looks like a player who can only play in one system and that system doesn't work for us, so it's looking like 8m down the toilet already

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 28 Aug 17 8.10pm

How do you know he can't play in a back four?

 

Tommyp151211 Flag 28 Aug 17 8.13pm

Opinion based on one game.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 28 Aug 17 8.14pm

[Link]

Link says he can play center half, left back and defensive midfielder.

Guess some are quick to write things to suit there agenda rather than Google to find out if there talking nonsense or not....

He can play three positions. No idea if he'll be good but to write him off as a player who just plays one position is idiotic.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Aug 17 8.27pm

It's not an opinion I've seen mentioned too much on here but I would like to Riedewald in a holding midfield role. Whether he starts or not is a different matter.

Did look slightly out of his comfort zone at the back against Huddersfield but that was one game.

Must have some physical presence as a CB and can certainly play do I think for £8mil at his age it's a great price. Only problem is obviously if he is to be our only signing which is not enough!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 28 Aug 17 8.27pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

[Link]

Link says he can play center half, left back and defensive midfielder.

Guess some are quick to write things to suit there agenda rather than Google to find out if there talking nonsense or not....

He can play three positions. No idea if he'll be good but to write him off as a player who just plays one position is idiotic.

Mr Goldfinger,
Yes it does say he can play these positions and to be honest I don't see why a 20 year old kid shouldn't be able todo so as a defender. The problem is he has no PL experience and his first game found him seriously wanting in the physical dept. I wont write him though. As you say that would be stupid, but what I'm annoyed about is that he is our one singing so far and it was announced like it was a big thing. No it wasn't, he's a kid from Ajax who might become a good player in the future, and its £8m that could have gone towards Sakho, who yes is 3.5 times as much, but he is an experienced international. As a major signing, it isn't.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Alex1991 Flag Ashford 28 Aug 17 8.30pm

He got stitched up first game of the season, thrown in with another kid against a newly promoted side who were always going to be hugely up for it. He's played 1 game, how can anybody judge him already ?

 


"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 28 Aug 17 8.33pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

What are we going to do with him? If Frank switches to 4-3-3 he cant play in a back four and he is not physical enough to play in the rough and tumble of the midfield. He looks like a player who can only play in one system and that system doesn't work for us, so it's looking like 8m down the toilet already

You do know that Ajax play with a back four right? Normally 4-3-3.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Tommyp151211 Flag 28 Aug 17 8.37pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

It's not an opinion I've seen mentioned too much on here but I would like to Riedewald in a holding midfield role. Whether he starts or not is a different matter.

Did look slightly out of his comfort zone at the back against Huddersfield but that was one game.

Must have some physical presence as a CB and can certainly play do I think for £8mil at his age it's a great price. Only problem is obviously if he is to be our only signing which is not enough!

Playing football manager mate.


Doesn't work

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 28 Aug 17 8.38pm

Originally posted by kevlee

Mr Goldfinger,
Yes it does say he can play these positions and to be honest I don't see why a 20 year old kid shouldn't be able todo so as a defender. The problem is he has no PL experience and his first game found him seriously wanting in the physical dept. I wont write him though. As you say that would be stupid, but what I'm annoyed about is that he is our one singing so far and it was announced like it was a big thing. No it wasn't, he's a kid from Ajax who might become a good player in the future, and its £8m that could have gone towards Sakho, who yes is 3.5 times as much, but he is an experienced international. As a major signing, it isn't.

I was just answering the OP's question about positions he can play.

I hope he turns out to be a good signing he looked decent in preseason. But was found out for what seemed a lack of concentration and a baptism of fire on his Prem start.

But the OP's question was can he only play one position. The answer according to the Guardian is no he can play three.

Personally I think he'll turn out a decent signing for £8m, he looks good on the ball and is a huge unit and if he can adjust to the pace of the Prem thing should be good.

Let's not forget he's only 20 and many players costing far far more have taken longer to settle in to the Prem.

Writing him off as the OP has after one game is just bed wetting.

Of course he might be a complete flop but after one game no one knows either way.

IF LoftusCheek had had a bad first game would we be writing him off as well?

What about is Fosu fumble at the back on Saturday had lead to a goal? Let's write him off too...?

Anyway was just answering the OPs question of which positions he can play.

According to the Guardian three.

 

Harpo Flag Oxfordshire 28 Aug 17 8.39pm

I put him on a par with that Spanish bloke José Campaña who only managed about 90 minutes matchtime over a season and a half.

Edited by Harpo (28 Aug 2017 8.48pm)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Aug 17 8.40pm

Originally posted by Tommyp151211

Playing football manager mate.


Doesn't work

Sorry don't get the point here?

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Bangell Flag Oxford 28 Aug 17 8.54pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

You do know that Ajax play with a back four right? Normally 4-3-3.

Exactly.

Riedewald had an embarrassing first game, but he's widely regarded as having great potential. While I think now was not the time to be spunking 8m on a promising youngster, suggesting it's money 'down the toilet' is utterly stupid.

 

HeathMan Flag Purley 28 Aug 17 9.05pm

I am sure that he, with the support of the team knows he needs to get up to speed.

COYP

 

Reknaw Flag 28 Aug 17 9.57pm

lol this is comical! The OP has probably seen him play once in his life time and that's the game against Huddersfield. My money is on him having never even heard of him before we signed him but thinks he can call the shots on styles he can and can't play.

Idiot.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 29 Aug 17 2.32pm

Anyone remember the first seasons by Jules, FFS and Jedi? How about the 1st half of AJ's 1st season. Whatever became of those guys?

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

CPFCSwords Flag London 29 Aug 17 3.21pm

I'm no tactical genius here but logic tells me we should have our full-backs the more defensive sort, which Riedewald would be perfect for. Obviously allows more attacking freedom for wingers which should let us go back to being a threat attacking whilst also not having to worry as much defensively.

A team of:
4-3-3

Zaha Benteke Townsend
Cabaye Loftus Cheek
Milivojevic
Riedewald Sakho Dann TFM
Hennessey

seems good (on paper).

 

leejaneagles Flag 29 Aug 17 3.32pm

Originally posted by CPFCSwords

I'm no tactical genius here but logic tells me we should have our full-backs the more defensive sort, which Riedewald would be perfect for. Obviously allows more attacking freedom for wingers which should let us go back to being a threat attacking whilst also not having to worry as much defensively.

A team of:
4-3-3

Zaha Benteke Townsend
Cabaye Loftus Cheek
Milivojevic
Riedewald Sakho Dann TFM
Hennessey

seems good (on paper).

Quite possible but benching both PVA and Schlupp? I'd say no chance.

 

CPFCSwords Flag London 29 Aug 17 3.52pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

Quite possible but benching both PVA and Schlupp? I'd say no chance.

Maybe an unpopular opinion but I'm not PVA's biggest fan, seems a bit clumsy and loses himself often. The first goal on the weekend his defending was nothing short of pathetic.

As for Schlupp, I'd like to see him be our back up winger as opposed to full back. While he's not the most technically gifted, he's willing to run at the opposition defence relentlessly, loves going forward. Essentially reminds me of a less skillful Bolasie

 

leejaneagles Flag 29 Aug 17 4.30pm

Originally posted by CPFCSwords

Maybe an unpopular opinion but I'm not PVA's biggest fan, seems a bit clumsy and loses himself often. The first goal on the weekend his defending was nothing short of pathetic.

As for Schlupp, I'd like to see him be our back up winger as opposed to full back. While he's not the most technically gifted, he's willing to run at the opposition defence relentlessly, loves going forward. Essentially reminds me of a less skillful Bolasie

I think I'd be inclined to agree if it wasn't how good they both were for different reasons in a back 4 at back end of last season.

I think 4 of our solid performers under Sam were PVA, Sclupp, Mila and Tomkins. In the 3-4-3 our worst performers have probably been Tomkins, PVA and Mila, with Schlupp benched of course.

I think that says more about the ongoing Manager situation and formation argument than it does the players. PVA is a top left back and Schlupp is a beast going forward, agreed with you there.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Riedewald