You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Big Club Bias and Loftus-Cheek
November 16 2026 8.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Big Club Bias and Loftus-Cheek


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
olliethomas98 Flag 03 Nov 17 1.24am

Hello lads, just made a video on the Loftus-Cheek and the big club bias if you don't mind checking it out [Link]

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 03 Nov 17 3.49am

Nice.

Scotty Dann was always one that i felt was unfairly over looked.

 


This was once a quality forum....

chateauferret Flag 03 Nov 17 8.08am

Originally posted by Vaibow

Nice.

Scotty Dann was always one that i felt was unfairly over looked.

At the peak of his powers I thought he would be a better choice than Smalling or Cahill, who mostly only looked good - Smalling especially - because they were playing behind teams that attacked well and whose forwards kept the pressure off their defence. Dann was at the centre of a machine that kept decent attacks out for whole games under constant pressure, until Chateau Pardew began to collapse.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Nov 17 8.11am

Originally posted by Vaibow

Nice.

Scotty Dann was always one that i felt was unfairly over looked.

Whilst I recognised Dann's positive contribution for our team I was never a flag-bearer for Dann playing for England. Nor was I for Ward when some on here were advocating an England call-up.

Edited by Willo (03 Nov 2017 8.12am)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 03 Nov 17 8.19am

Originally posted by Willo

Whilst I recognised Dann's positive contribution for our team I was never a flag-bearer for Dann playing for England. Nor was I for Ward when some on here were advocating an England call-up.

You've left out Puncheon whom many with the Palace tinted glasses thought was worthy of an England place

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 03 Nov 17 8.24am

There is no big club bias as it's just a mixture of the larger clubs having the financial muscle to buy up the best players plus the fans of smaller clubs thinking that their players are better than they really are.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Nov 17 8.26am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

You've left out Puncheon whom many with the Palace tinted glasses thought was worthy of an England place

I don't have a recollection of me taking an alternative view of Puncheon on HOL but I have never believed he was worthy of a call-up.Perhaps I did mention my views on HOL !!!!!

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 03 Nov 17 10.39am

Originally posted by Vaibow

Nice.

Scotty Dann was always one that i felt was unfairly over looked.


The problem with Dann is at his best he was always in a Palace team that defended deep and fairly compactly and didn't really look to retain possession. If I was Hodgson at time time I would have been hesitant to trust him in a high line and when being pressed to not hoof it.

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 03 Nov 17 10.47am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

There is no big club bias as it's just a mixture of the larger clubs having the financial muscle to buy up the best players plus the fans of smaller clubs thinking that their players are better than they really are.

So explain:
Lingard over Zaha?
Phil Jones over Dann?
Lingard over Townsend this time round?
Gomez over Lascelles?
How long it took Defoe to get a look in?
Jack Wilshere and Sturridge used to seemingly always getting in and amongst the squad.
How Drinkwater wasn't in the squad the season they won the league.

I think you are right, you'll always get a higher percentage of players from big clubs, but there is a clear bias.

Of the current selected squad:
6 (not including loans) come from outside the top 6. Half of them are 'keepers (Joe Hart, Butland and Pickford), baring in mind that no top 6 team has an English goalkeeper. The other three are Vardy, Maguire and Bertrand. Again, Vardy is an established forward and prolific last couple seasons and this, we have piss all left backs and Maguire.

 


[Link]

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Nov 17 10.58am

Originally posted by Dan1994

So explain:
Lingard over Zaha?
Phil Jones over Dann?
Lingard over Townsend this time round?
Gomez over Lascelles?
How long it took Defoe to get a look in?
Jack Wilshere and Sturridge used to seemingly always getting in and amongst the squad.
How Drinkwater wasn't in the squad the season they won the league.

I think you are right, you'll always get a higher percentage of players from big clubs, but there is a clear bias.

Of the current selected squad:
6 (not including loans) come from outside the top 6. Half of them are 'keepers (Joe Hart, Butland and Pickford), baring in mind that no top 6 team has an English goalkeeper. The other three are Vardy, Maguire and Bertrand. Again, Vardy is an established forward and prolific last couple seasons and this, we have piss all left backs and Maguire.

I suppose that Gomez has that versatility having played in central defence and in both full-back positions.Rodgers started him off at Liverpool as a left-back but at Charlton he was playing at right-back before his transfer to Anfield.

It has been thought for the last couple of years that his future was at centre-half and had been labelled "The next Rio Ferdinand".Certainly composed at the back not diving into reckless challenges and he is an intelligent player with pace.

 

Littlebogreek Flag 03 Nov 17 11.24am

I'm a firm believer that there is a big club bias but think its likely driven by financial reasons. Marketing and sponsorship etc is far easier a sell when you have players from Man U etc as opposed to Palace, Burnley etc. What worries me more is Joe Hart constantly being picked when he's useless... except against us.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 03 Nov 17 3.30pm

Originally posted by Dan1994

So explain:
Lingard over Zaha?
Phil Jones over Dann?
Lingard over Townsend this time round?
Gomez over Lascelles?
How long it took Defoe to get a look in?
Jack Wilshere and Sturridge used to seemingly always getting in and amongst the squad.
How Drinkwater wasn't in the squad the season they won the league.

I think you are right, you'll always get a higher percentage of players from big clubs, but there is a clear bias.

Of the current selected squad:
6 (not including loans) come from outside the top 6. Half of them are 'keepers (Joe Hart, Butland and Pickford), baring in mind that no top 6 team has an English goalkeeper. The other three are Vardy, Maguire and Bertrand. Again, Vardy is an established forward and prolific last couple seasons and this, we have piss all left backs and Maguire.

Zaha cannot now be selected for England, his choice
Jones has played in a defence that have conceded 4 goals, Dann 21 goals. Jones has raised his game this year.
Gomez is more versatile, but close shout.
Not so long ago Jake Livermore was in the team, so there is no big club bias, unless you class boring WBA as a big team.
Playing for England is no longer important to many players, England have to play to a system as dictated by Dan Ashworth.

 

leifandersonshair Flag Newport 03 Nov 17 5.32pm

Does anyone think that, if Loftus-Cheek had played exactly the same this season but was a Palace player, not a Chelsea player on loan at Palace, he would still be in the England squad? Not a chance

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 03 Nov 17 5.48pm

Originally posted by Painter

Zaha cannot now be selected for England, his choice
Jones has played in a defence that have conceded 4 goals, Dann 21 goals. Jones has raised his game this year.
Gomez is more versatile, but close shout.
Not so long ago Jake Livermore was in the team, so there is no big club bias, unless you class boring WBA as a big team.
Playing for England is no longer important to many players, England have to play to a system as dictated by Dan Ashworth.

None of those examples were in reference to the current squad selection, though.

 


[Link]

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Nov 17 5.51pm

Originally posted by Dan1994

None of those examples were in reference to the current squad selection, though.

What about Gomez v Lascelles ?

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 03 Nov 17 5.55pm

Originally posted by Willo

What about Gomez v Lascelles ?

I didnt realise that was highlighted tbh. But the only two I was referring to in this squad selection was Gomez over Lascelles and Lingard over Townsend

Edited by Dan1994 (03 Nov 2017 5.56pm)

 


[Link]

Casual Flag Orpington 03 Nov 17 6.33pm

Originally posted by Dan1994

So explain:
Lingard over Zaha?
Phil Jones over Dann?
Lingard over Townsend this time round?
Gomez over Lascelles?
How long it took Defoe to get a look in?
Jack Wilshere and Sturridge used to seemingly always getting in and amongst the squad.
How Drinkwater wasn't in the squad the season they won the league.

I think you are right, you'll always get a higher percentage of players from big clubs, but there is a clear bias.

Of the current selected squad:
6 (not including loans) come from outside the top 6. Half of them are 'keepers (Joe Hart, Butland and Pickford), baring in mind that no top 6 team has an English goalkeeper. The other three are Vardy, Maguire and Bertrand. Again, Vardy is an established forward and prolific last couple seasons and this, we have piss all left backs and Maguire.

Zaha can’t play for England . I don’t think Dann is one of our best 2 center backs.
When you look that Tottenham had 5 Englishmen that beat Madrid and Man City had 3 that won away in Italy. Add to that the Englishmen that are at the other top 6 clubs, plus the decent ones scattered around the other teams, ours will struggle to get a call up.
Apart from Townsend, if they named 2 England squads, I doubt we’d have any of ours in either.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 03 Nov 17 6.45pm

Originally posted by Dan1994

So explain:
Lingard over Zaha?
Phil Jones over Dann?
Lingard over Townsend this time round?
Gomez over Lascelles?
How long it took Defoe to get a look in?
Jack Wilshere and Sturridge used to seemingly always getting in and amongst the squad.
How Drinkwater wasn't in the squad the season they won the league.

I think you are right, you'll always get a higher percentage of players from big clubs, but there is a clear bias.

Of the current selected squad:
6 (not including loans) come from outside the top 6. Half of them are 'keepers (Joe Hart, Butland and Pickford), baring in mind that no top 6 team has an English goalkeeper. The other three are Vardy, Maguire and Bertrand. Again, Vardy is an established forward and prolific last couple seasons and this, we have piss all left backs and Maguire.

I know its one of the big mysteries in football - why Joel Ward is not starting for England

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Painter Flag Croydon 03 Nov 17 6.45pm

Originally posted by Dan1994

None of those examples were in reference to the current squad selection, though.

So what’s your point then?

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 03 Nov 17 6.47pm

Originally posted by Painter

So what’s your point then?

Was there a point then?

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Big Club Bias and Loftus-Cheek