You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Officials (Again!)
November 16 2026 8.22am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Officials (Again!)


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 Dec 17 5.35pm

Just back from the match.

I thought the standard of officiating today was woeful.

Can anyone that saw a stream please tell me if the first goal came from a dodgy corner, we all thought so.

Also, any idea why Begovic wasn't sent off?

And was Loftus-Cheek really offside towards the end, pretty sure not.

The linesman at the Holmesdale end was particularly bad IMO.

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 09 Dec 17 5.38pm

1) Yeah, it was definitely a foul - even the commentators were saying as such.

2) Didn't get to see the pen.

3) I didn't think so at the time, and no replays were shown.

 


[Link]

Painter Flag Croydon 09 Dec 17 5.41pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Just back from the match.

I thought the standard of officiating today was woeful.

Can anyone that saw a stream please tell me if the first goal came from a dodgy corner, we all thought so.

Also, any idea why Begovic wasn't sent off?

And was Loftus-Cheek really offside towards the end, pretty sure not.

The linesman at the Holmesdale end was particularly bad IMO.

Sakho clearly knocked it out for first goal.

Not sent off, as not clear scoring chance, the ball was going out.

Yes, miles offside.

The linesman was fine, its Benteke who was bad.

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 09 Dec 17 5.51pm

Was in Arthur and ref looked piss poor despite giving us 2 pens. Far too whistle happy, Wouldn’t let us take any free kicks quickly slowed it right down so Bournemouth could get back. Kept penalising Benteke for 50/50 challenges. Reminded me of Clattemberg ... wanted to be centre of attention.. Cue willo to sing his praises....

 

Painter Flag Croydon 09 Dec 17 5.54pm

Originally posted by babylonjohn

Was in Arthur and ref looked piss poor despite giving us 2 pens. Far too whistle happy, Wouldn’t let us take any free kicks quickly slowed it right down so Bournemouth could get back. Kept penalising Benteke for 50/50 challenges. Reminded me of Clattemberg ... wanted to be centre of attention.. Cue willo to sing his praises....

I don't remember Clattenberg giving Zaha 2 penalties, the second one wasn't as well.

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 09 Dec 17 6.07pm

We got two pens that were, at best, 50/50, but Friend's performance all around was terrible. Everyone saw TFM get held back for their first goal - everyone except Friend and his lino.

How we ended up with more yellows is only a function of Friend;s failure to give them yellows when deserved. There were even yellow-card fouls that went unpunished completely. Both Cooks should've been sent offer multiple yellow cards each, and there were plenty of others who got away with murder.

To be fair, though, Begovich wasn't sent off because I believe that's the new rule when a penalty is given (which is something I agree with). Yellow only.

They never showed a replay of RLC's offside, so I have no idea. I think the linos did a good job on that throughout the game, so I expect it was also a good call.

Edited by Ray in Houston (09 Dec 2017 6.07pm)

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 10 Dec 17 5.43am

Friend's refusal to make calls early in the match meant he lost control and had to make those calls later on. A few foul calls early on could have prevented some dire ones being committed later.

He missed the foul on the first Defoe goal.

The two penalties were OK. The second one it appeared to me that although the defender did get the ball it was after he made contact with Zaha.

I did see replays on the RLH offside calls and they were correct. Also one on Zaha when RLC held the ball an instant too long.

The replay proved me wrong on a goal kick decision. I couldn't understand how a corner wasn't given but the replay showed it went out off of RLC. (2nd half).

At the end of the day, this one is not down to the ref. It is down to a stupid decision made by a Palace player.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

crvenaeagle Flag 10 Dec 17 6.05am

We can make excuses for the team all we like but frankly I'm bored of doing so.

Neither of those Defoe goals should have been allowed to happen. The first one was like watching Bournemouth play a game of pinball within the confines of our very own box. As for that absurd volley he just should not be given space to even try something so audacious. How stupid he made us look.
Lastly, the Benteke situation shows just how disorganised we are. Even childrens teams have a designated taker, even if they do bicker over it just as much.

 

The Dolphin Flag 10 Dec 17 9.18am

Top post - the referee was very poor but he didn't cost us two points - we did that all by ourselves - again!!!!!!

 

n wales eagles Flag llandudno 10 Dec 17 9.26am

On motd it would appear that the foul on schlupp that gave Defoe the space was a training ground set piece . Call me cynical and probably naive but surely practicing training ground set pieces which involves cheating very sad .

 

Aolcpfc Flag Finchley, London 10 Dec 17 10.15am

N Wales eagle, I agree: training ground planned fouling practice. Eddie Howe should be banned from the touchline for a few games. Josh King should be banned for three games.

Premeditated fouling.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Dec 17 10.22am

Originally posted by babylonjohn

Was in Arthur and ref looked piss poor despite giving us 2 pens. Far too whistle happy, Wouldn’t let us take any free kicks quickly slowed it right down so Bournemouth could get back. Kept penalising Benteke for 50/50 challenges. Reminded me of Clattemberg ... wanted to be centre of attention.. Cue willo to sing his praises....

Refs should be told to let quick free kicks be taken. If fouls are committed it's often to take momentum away from the other team and get things level on the pitch again so they're not vulnerable. Refs are helping them by delaying free kicks. You also see refs uncomfortable pulling free kicks back for top teams v small clubs but it's okay when it's smaller teams for them to do it and ruining the game. It stinks.

 


COYP

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 10 Dec 17 10.45am

They were all s***e yesterday....

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 10 Dec 17 11.01am

The drop ball decision was bizarre. He dropped the ball then went mad when Luka had the temerity to actually play on.
Both pens are pens and the second one please stop with this got the ball s***. His studs may have scratched the ball, but he went through the player to do it. Clearest penalty of the two and remember it only has to impede you. It's only refs that insist it has to bring you crashing down in order for it to be given.
Ake got the ball, but went right through Benteke to get it. We scored from that corner, but that challenge was reckless IMO. Ake had a great game though tbf and Begovic proved we really should have gone for him.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 11 Dec 17 2.45pm

Originally posted by n wales eagles

On motd it would appear that the foul on schlupp that gave Defoe the space was a training ground set piece . Call me cynical and probably naive but surely practicing training ground set pieces which involves cheating very sad .

Yep.

Liverpool's first goal at Crystanbul was in the same vein. Joe Allen got free because his marker was getting mugged.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Uphill Flag Bedford 11 Dec 17 3.05pm

I am helpless with laughter.

We are always complaining about refs and usually blaming them for our failings ... but now along comes one who not only gives us a penalty but adds a bonus one at the end.

Yet still he is panned for some dubious decisions.

In the immortal words of the(almost)legendary, Kammie: unbelievable!

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 11 Dec 17 6.22pm

Could not agree more! And a rule change as in: touching the ball after the opponent gets a free kick is an immediate yellow, as is blocking the ball off and preventing it to be taken quickly. This has been long overdue I think.

And oh yes Kevin Friend, you idiot unfit for Sunday league games: stop worrying about a few yards, you are rewarding the fouls by insisting it is taken exactly at the spot of the foul.

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Refs should be told to let quick free kicks be taken. If fouls are committed it's often to take momentum away from the other team and get things level on the pitch again so they're not vulnerable. Refs are helping them by delaying free kicks. You also see refs uncomfortable pulling free kicks back for top teams v small clubs but it's okay when it's smaller teams for them to do it and ruining the game. It stinks.


 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 11 Dec 17 9.17pm

I agree with most of the law changes suggested as they would have tipped the game further in our favour but does any one understand that while we received five yellow cards they only received two?
Ps Wilf was fouled both times with Begovic's hands grabbing and impeding him.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

chateauferret Flag 11 Dec 17 9.22pm

Originally posted by Uphill

I am helpless with laughter.

We are always complaining about refs and usually blaming them for our failings ... but now along comes one who not only gives us a penalty but adds a bonus one at the end.

Yet still he is panned for some dubious decisions.

In the immortal words of the(almost)legendary, Kammie: unbelievable!

I've just looked at Bournemouth's first goal again and I'm not laughing. They sold the officials an absolute pup. The only reason Defoe is unmarked in the box is because King has literally wrestled Schlupp away from him. Three officials and none of them see it.

Not only is it no goal, it's also a deliberate and cynical foul designed specifically to get an advantage. Yellow card. Preposterous.

Edited by chateauferret (11 Dec 2017 9.23pm)

Edited by chateauferret (11 Dec 2017 9.25pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

bicycle repair man 11 Dec 17 9.35pm

The ref actually had a stinker,as did the lino on the main stand side of the pitch.
The corner Bournemouth scored from should have been a goal kick which the lino gave incorrectly,and the ref missed a pretty obvious foul on Schlupp as the goal was scored.
Wilf was clipped at speed on each of the penalty calls,and I don't think even he can defy gravity.


 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Officials (Again!)