You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Safe Standing
November 16 2026 7.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Safe Standing


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
se25 rudy Flag se25 27 Jan 18 7.37pm

I'd be interested to know what others think about incorporating a 'safe standing' area within the new stadium development plans. The official stance from the football authorities (that it is dangerous and contributes to hooliganism) has softened dramatically over the past few years and there is a distinct possibility that some clubs will convert existing areas within their grounds as soon as this summer

[Link]

I for one would love to amplify the already incredible atmosphere of Selhurst by adding a designated safe standing area either within the new stand or by converting an existing portion of the Holmesdale. The feedback from Celtic fans - who have converted a corner of Celtic Park - is overwhelmingly positive.

[Link]

Would love to know what the esteemed HOLers think,,,,,,,,,,,,

 

dorking Flag 27 Jan 18 7.47pm

No way it will happen in the new Main Stand, that is the 'money stand' as one poster bluntly calls it on another forum.

The other 3 sides all have the potential though.

Whitehorse would be very easy, as it was a terrace until 1993, so would be a very simple conversion. Added bonus of doing it there is that the family stand could be relocated somewhere else where the kids can see the big screen

Arthur Wait enclosure - incredible acoustics here. But suspect the club would want to keep the side stands as seating as they can charge more for the side on view seats

Holmesdale Lower - logical as it is where the atmosphere is, and the HF stand already. If this is where it does go, the club would have to be sensitive in allowing vast swathes of season ticket holders to move to other stands, as a lot of Holmesdale Lower S/T's would still prefer to sit

As for will it happen - I believe it will, yes.

Shrerwsbury have got a section of it I believe, and there is a fair chance they will be promoted to the Championship soon. When they come up, are the authorities really going to rip it out?

If they can have it, everyone else will want it too.

And haven't Brentford got terracing anyway?

 

J4COB65 Flag 27 Jan 18 8.39pm

Originally posted by dorking And haven't Brentford got terracing anyway?

Brentford have been allowed to keep it because they've been given planning permission for a new stadium

Would love to be able to stand up permanently instead of spending 90 mins sat down

Edited by J4COB65 (27 Jan 2018 8.42pm)

 

.TUX. Flag 27 Jan 18 8.56pm

Stand.
End of.

 


Buy Litecoin.

MikeCrete Flag Crete 27 Jan 18 9.40pm

It operate s abroad, and without problems so far. It is on a rail system, easy to remove/put back in the seats. Would be surprised oIf it was nor at least trialled in a couple of grounds in the next couple of seasons.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 27 Jan 18 10.19pm

It’s simply got to happen and I’m sure it will. Fans will always stand in certain parts of the ground at all stadiums regardless of the rules. It’s the safest thing to do as seats become obstacles when you’re not using them.

I suspect blocks A-D in the Holmesdale lower to start with. Would imagine demand in that area would be so high that it would soon spread to the whole lower tier. Perhaps many long term ST holders who prefer to sit would be attracted to the new main stand for an improved view.

Sooner the better I say. I’d be desperate to get a ST in there.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 27 Jan 18 10.25pm

Im sure if they want they could have a standing section in the main stand. The whole point of it is two fold.

1. To create a better atmosphere
2. To get more paying punters in to the ground.

Standing zone as I understand would allow more people in and thus any reduction in ticket price in that area would be offset against more people being in that area.

Added bonus is the extra people would spend more at the bars etc.

I'll be gobsmacked if any club is introducing this to take less revenue....

So yes it won't be in a corporate box area, but apart from that it could be placed anywhere including the new stand.

At least that's how I understand it works...

 

the.universal 27 Jan 18 11.29pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Im sure if they want they could have a standing section in the main stand. The whole point of it is two fold.

1. To create a better atmosphere
2. To get more paying punters in to the ground.

Standing zone as I understand would allow more people in and thus any reduction in ticket price in that area would be offset against more people being in that area.

Added bonus is the extra people would spend more at the bars etc.

I'll be gobsmacked if any club is introducing this to take less revenue....

So yes it won't be in a corporate box area, but apart from that it could be placed anywhere including the new stand.

At least that's how I understand it works...

The new safe standing areas abroad are re-convertible into seats if required e.g. for Champions league games. So you don't actually get more punters in. Hence I wouldn't hold your breath for any price reductions.

 


Vive le Roy!

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 28 Jan 18 12.47am

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Im sure if they want they could have a standing section in the main stand. The whole point of it is two fold.

1. To create a better atmosphere
2. To get more paying punters in to the ground.

Standing zone as I understand would allow more people in and thus any reduction in ticket price in that area would be offset against more people being in that area.

Added bonus is the extra people would spend more at the bars etc.

I'll be gobsmacked if any club is introducing this to take less revenue....

So yes it won't be in a corporate box area, but apart from that it could be placed anywhere including the new stand.

At least that's how I understand it works...

That depends on the regulations. In the Bundesliga, they allow 1.5 people per space, whilst I would imagine they would give us a 1:1 ratio.

 


[Link]

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 28 Jan 18 10.06am

Would be amazed if clubs changed anything that didn't then result in extra revenue.

Would imagine we'd be similar to the Bundesliga with an extra 50% attendance in those areas.

Ticket prices could drop by mayeb 25% and the club would still be making 10% more in that area.

£40 ticket could be sold for £30.00 in a standing area. Club would pocket extra £5.00 compared to the £40 seats. Fans get in cheap. Great atmosphere.

1000 seats converted would equal 1500 standing.

1000 @ £40 = £40k
1500 @ £30 = £45k (£5k additional profit)

Plus 500 extra punters in the stadium drinking and eating in the bars...

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 28 Jan 18 1.18pm

Makes perfect sense for the Whitehorse to become the standing area initially. If we are going to do something with the old boxes upstairs then we can presumably get another seated area in with a decent roof over it to amplify the sound. Get the HF and others who fancy it to move from the Holmesdale Rd end. I would swap the season tickets holders of the Arthur down the other end of that stand and move the away supporters to the Holmesdale end of the stand. If the trial is successful and we get significant numbers wanting to stand I would in the future turn the whole of the Holmesdale lower tier into standing. A full standing lower tier Holmesdale would be an awesome sight.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Jan 18 2.22pm

Originally posted by Dan1994

That depends on the regulations. In the Bundesliga, they allow 1.5 people per space, whilst I would imagine they would give us a 1:1 ratio.

I believe I read somewhere that Borussia Dortmund can increase their capacity from 65,000 to 81,000 when they avail of 'Safe Standing'.

 

Pierre Flag Purley 28 Jan 18 2.57pm

Originally posted by Willo

I believe I read somewhere that Borussia Dortmund can increase their capacity from 65,000 to 81,000 when they avail of 'Safe Standing'.

I believe its the other way around. 81,360 capacity standing and rail seating and 65,829 for international matches seating only.
The 'Yellow wall' stand of rail seating has a ratio of 1-1.7 and they use a rail every 2 rows.
You can wear 'a veil' but scarves are more usual!

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 28 Jan 18 3.05pm

If standing was included in new stand in any way. It would not get planning approval as it would fail Risk assessment

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Jan 18 3.05pm

Originally posted by Pierre

I believe its the other way around. 81,360 capacity standing and rail seating and 65,829 for international matches seating only.
The 'Yellow wall' stand of rail seating has a ratio of 1-1.7 and they use a rail every 2 rows.
You can wear 'a veil' but scarves are more usual!

This is what I was saying - when they avail of 'Safe Standing' their capacity increases to 81,000.

I recall the terraces of old which were certainly NOT safe standing ! Supporters could be plumetted down due to surges, either crashing into each other or one of the barriers.And we had all those dastardly 'Crews' congregating en-masse with their 'Bovver boy' mentality.Dark days.

 

GerryQueen10 Flag Swanage 28 Jan 18 3.39pm

I sent CPFC an email about the main stand redevelopment on 5th Jan. Here is their reply.......

Many thanks for your email.

We will continue to be part of the ongoing discussion within the Premier League regarding safe standing. However, we are not incorporating this into the stadium at this stage.

We will make sure to keep you updated on the plans as they progress.

Kind regards

Rebecca


On behalf of Crystal Palace Football Club

 


Been to Anfield twice seen 14 goals and my team haven't scored any

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 29 Jan 18 8.05pm

Would they?
It seem to me that the bigger part of the Holmesdale lower is always standing up anyway. This you would think also is a big point for safe standing to be implemented. It is already there but in seating area's and in the process inconvenient for people who do want to sit.

I love standing myself.

Originally posted by dorking

No way it will happen in the new Main Stand, that is the 'money stand' as one poster bluntly calls it on another forum.

The other 3 sides all have the potential though.

Whitehorse would be very easy, as it was a terrace until 1993, so would be a very simple conversion. Added bonus of doing it there is that the family stand could be relocated somewhere else where the kids can see the big screen

Arthur Wait enclosure - incredible acoustics here. But suspect the club would want to keep the side stands as seating as they can charge more for the side on view seats

Holmesdale Lower - logical as it is where the atmosphere is, and the HF stand already. If this is where it does go, the club would have to be sensitive in allowing vast swathes of season ticket holders to move to other stands, as a lot of Holmesdale Lower S/T's would still prefer to sit

As for will it happen - I believe it will, yes.

Shrerwsbury have got a section of it I believe, and there is a fair chance they will be promoted to the Championship soon. When they come up, are the authorities really going to rip it out?

If they can have it, everyone else will want it too.

And haven't Brentford got terracing anyway?

 

Bearcage Flag Welling 29 Jan 18 11.15pm

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

If standing was included in new stand in any way. It would not get planning approval as it would fail Risk assessment

Why would ‘safe standing’ fail a risk assessment? How is it a higher risk than seating.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 30 Jan 18 9.24am

Originally posted by Bearcage

Why would ‘safe standing’ fail a risk assessment? How is it a higher risk than seating.


Because, from August 1994, under the Football Spectators Act 1989 (as amended), clubs in the English Premier League and Championship have been required to provide all-seated accommodation. The 1989 Act applies to England and Wales.

In November 2016, the Government said that all-seater stadiums remained the best means of ensuring the safety and security of fans. In February 2017, the Government said it was “unconvinced” by the case for safe standing:
[Link]

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 30 Jan 18 9.41am

Every away section is all standing anyway. Think Parish has said somewhere that PL rules stipulate as long as you pay for your seat you dont have to sit in it or something along those lines. Can only be a matter of time surely.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Safe Standing