You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How did Jordan Mutch become so bad?
November 16 2026 7.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

How did Jordan Mutch become so bad?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
robforbe Flag cornwall 28 Jan 18 9.38am

He was actually rather good for Cardiff a few seasons ago , he's got a helluva strike on him too.

I have not seen him play in the flesh for PALACE.

Is really that bad? Guess he must be if successive bosses never picked him.

Where did it go wrong for him?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Jan 18 10.00am

Well Pardew considered him a 'baller'.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 28 Jan 18 10.02am

He's not a bad player, he's just not good enough for the PL. He would be a decent player to have if we got relegated.

 


[Link]

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 28 Jan 18 10.05am

Not sure he was any good to start with. Never broke sweat for the club....

Edited by Gary St.Andrews (28 Jan 2018 10.06am)

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 28 Jan 18 10.10am

None of us truly know what happens in a players personal life

Puncheon, benteke, Mutch, all could have lost someone and one could have depression issues, who knows

 

Painter Flag Croydon 28 Jan 18 10.17am

He hasn't become a bad player, just a player not worth £40k a week.
I expect he is quite happy.

 

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 28 Jan 18 10.25am

I recall him coming on in his debut (think it was anyway) as a sub v Everton. The way he cam on was slow and unbelievably lacklustre. I mentioned to my mate that you would like to see a bit of eagerness from a multi-million pound debutant, or you better have Pirlo like ability. He clearly doesn't.

Not his fault we signed him (I mean who scouted him, he was pony at QPR) but he is out of his depth at this level. Still that doesn't excuse not looking like he gives a s*** when he has played despite his limited ability. Unlike Frazier Campbell similarly playing above his level but still gave it everything when called upon.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 28 Jan 18 10.31am

He was better than OK when he played with the U23s against Maidstone United last summer. Thought he might even get a look in this season ... but obviously not.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 28 Jan 18 10.36am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

He was better than OK when he played with the U23s against Maidstone United last summer. Thought he might even get a look in this season ... but obviously not.

He should look pretty good against Maidstone though. So should most league players.

 

EaglesFan25 Flag 28 Jan 18 11.05am

I know he isn’t considered good enough but I am surprised with our stretched squad he hasn’t been on the bench. Has he been injured?
We’ve been making up the numbers with our bench these days. Especially during the winter period and FA cup game, not a start but a sub, you would of thought he’d get at least a place on the bench over somebody like Wan-Bissaka.

 

mattteo Flag 28 Jan 18 11.39am

How did Jordan Mutch become so bad?

He got fat.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Jan 18 12.01pm

Originally posted by matthau

None of us truly know what happens in a players personal life

Puncheon, benteke, Mutch, all could have lost someone and one could have depression issues, who knows

Close the site down then.

Will you stop posting your player analysis first?

The fact Mutch was completely sh1t from day 1 suggests you're wrong.

Puncheon and Benteke suffered from no competition and Benteke had even worse service under Frank. Mutch hasn't provided any competition. May as well have him working as a steward or burger flipper to get some value out of him.

Just agree with whichever club wants to pay part of his wages that we'll pay the rest. Whether that sends a bad message I'm not sure but it also sends one we don't tolerate spare parts.

 


COYP

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 28 Jan 18 12.14pm

Originally posted by cpfc1976

He should look pretty good against Maidstone though. So should most league players.

Exactly ... my point was that he looked consistent with most league players!

Incidentally, MUFC have just borrowed one of our U23s ... Andre Coker. He looked good too!

Edited by Henry of Peckham (28 Jan 2018 12.19pm)

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 29 Jan 18 8.20am

This in a nutshell.

Over priced , over paid and feeling like a lottery winner I expect.

A few good free kicks and set pieces in Championship does not make a PL regular starter

Originally posted by Painter

He hasn't become a bad player, just a player not worth £40k a week.
I expect he is quite happy.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

silvertop Flag Portishead 29 Jan 18 11.53am

Originally posted by Painter

He hasn't become a bad player, just a player not worth £40k a week.
I expect he is quite happy.

Would you be? I genuinely believe he would happily halve that income to play regularly in any premiership 1st XI. And do you think he gets off on the thought that every time he doea a search against his name all he finds is a stream of vicious invective from the fans of his own team?

The sooner he gets farmed out to mid table Championship the better for all concerned.

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 29 Jan 18 12.15pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Would you be? I genuinely believe he would happily halve that income to play regularly in any premiership 1st XI. And do you think he gets off on the thought that every time he doea a search against his name all he finds is a stream of vicious invective from the fans of his own team?

The sooner he gets farmed out to mid table Championship the better for all concerned.

Are you saying that it's the fans fault he's not a good enough player for the PL because of some comments on a forum? He gets off lightly compared to other players.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 29 Jan 18 12.28pm

the fact is he should never have been bought.

Pardew's fault, pure and simple.

There was never a natural position for him in the team (he's not a No10) and if he struggled to get a game at QPR (who were bottom of Prem at the time) why would it be different with us.

Additionally he had a minor injury when we signed him.

We know Champ club's can't pay £40k a week on wages so we need to do a deal just to allow him game time. Even £10k a week contribution to wages would be a positive result to Palace and might lead to a transfer in the summer.

Clearly all the £5m transfer fee is already written off.

Whilst I appreciate not all transfers will work out - this was a non starter from day 1.

 

Beastie Flag 29 Jan 18 12.32pm

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

Are you saying that it's the fans fault he's not a good enough player for the PL because of some comments on a forum? He gets off lightly compared to other players.

No, I think he referring to the quote about Mutch being 'happy' with the situation. And he probably isn't. Obviously he's on great money but you only get one career and his is being wasted.

You don't have to feel sorry for him because he's being paid a fortune, I just doubt this is how he wanted it to work out.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 29 Jan 18 3.59pm

Yes that is obviously what I was saying.

Southampton, 100 reads of my post and still i wouldn't have reached your interpretation. I have had conversations with my wife that followed similar lines.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 29 Jan 18 4.04pm

Originally posted by palace99

the fact is he should never have been bought.

Pardew's fault, pure and simple.

There was never a natural position for him in the team (he's not a No10) and if he struggled to get a game at QPR (who were bottom of Prem at the time) why would it be different with us.

Additionally he had a minor injury when we signed him.

We know Champ club's can't pay £40k a week on wages so we need to do a deal just to allow him game time. Even £10k a week contribution to wages would be a positive result to Palace and might lead to a transfer in the summer.

Clearly all the £5m transfer fee is already written off.

Whilst I appreciate not all transfers will work out - this was a non starter from day 1.

My thoughts exactly.

If you were a conspiracy theorist you may wonder if other parties apart from the player and his agent benefited from this transfer.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How did Jordan Mutch become so bad?