You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player of the year and young player of the year
November 16 2026 7.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Player of the year and young player of the year


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
daverave69 Flag Kent 01 May 18 7.22am

Do we all vote Wilf so he will stay.

I'd vote

POTY

Milivojevic

Young Player

Wan-Bissaka

 


PALACE 5-0 BRIGHTON
LIVING THE DREAM

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 01 May 18 7.54am

Originally posted by daverave69

Do we all vote Wilf so he will stay.

I'd vote

POTY

Milivojevic

Young Player

Wan-Bissaka

They'd be my choices, but it's a tricky one with Zaha as we haven't won a game without him.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 8.59am

Milivojevic??????????

Took set pieces all year, didn't hit a single assist (edit: had one assist in the 34th matchday against Brighton, with only 4 matches to go until the end of the season, but it wasn't one of his set pieces). Makes you wonder why does he take set pieces actually? Ok, he scored 1 very nice goal from a free kick and is good from the penalty spot (7 of his 10 goals were from the penalty spot) but he couldn't cross for a goal an entire season despite taking set pieces!!

Guilty at plenty of goals (the one in the 90th minute against Man United easily comes to mind, but there were others too).

It's like fans here have a fascination with Milivojevic. Decent player but in no way player of the season. Not even a great season if you ask me, just a mediocre one.

Undoubtedly Zaha, Townsend, Tomkins, PVA, McArthur have kept this team up and deserve it a lot more.

Edited by mattteo (01 May 2018 10.00am)

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 01 May 18 9.10am

Originally posted by mattteo

Milivojevic??????????

Took set pieces all year, didn't hit a single assist. Guilty at plenty of goals (the one in the 90th minute against Man United easily comes to mind, but there were others too).

It's like fans here have a fascination with Milivojevic. Decent player but in no way player of the season. Not even a great season if you ask me, just a mediocre one.

Undoubtedly Zaha, Townsend, Tomkins, PVA, McArthur have kept this team up and deserve it a lot more.

I think I can safely discount every comment you ever post on here after that one. Time to take your eyes off the data and watch the bl00dy football.

That said, Tomkins just shaves it for me with Luka a very close second.

Youth player a no-brainer.

 

Adamoc123 Flag Ennis 01 May 18 9.22am

Originally posted by mattteo

Milivojevic??????????

Took set pieces all year, didn't hit a single assist. Guilty at plenty of goals (the one in the 90th minute against Man United easily comes to mind, but there were others too).

It's like fans here have a fascination with Milivojevic. Decent player but in no way player of the season. Not even a great season if you ask me, just a mediocre one.

Undoubtedly Zaha, Townsend, Tomkins, PVA, McArthur have kept this team up and deserve it a lot more.

Milivojevic has 10 goals and 1 assist in 33 games (+1 off the bench), while Zaha has 8 goals and 3 assists, no one else is that close in terms of goals created. The fact they came from set pieces when no one else could step up and score from a set piece only helps his case for POTY. He's second to none and tied with Townsend for games played showing he's a core part of the team. One of if not the most consistent player and his attitude and leadership is inspiring to say the least.

Apart from Zaha i can't see anyone other than Luka taking the honours. He's been immense in more ways than one, suggesting that he's not one of the players that have kept this team up is just not right, and if this a mediocre season for him in your words than i can't wait to see what he could do in a good season.

For me:
POTY = Luka Milivojevic
Young POTY = Aaron Wan Bissaka (Would say Loftus-Cheek if he was our player)

 


The First 90 Minutes Are The Most Important!

brides Flag Arnside . Lake District 01 May 18 9.25am

Originally posted by Adamoc123

Milivojevic has 10 goals and 1 assist in 33 games (+1 off the bench), while Zaha has 8 goals and 3 assists, no one else is that close in terms of goals created. The fact they came from set pieces when no one else could step up and score from a set piece only helps his case for POTY. He's second to none and tied with Townsend for games played showing he's a core part of the team. One of if not the most consistent player and his attitude and leadership is inspiring to say the least.

Apart from Zaha i can't see anyone other than Luka taking the honours. He's been immense in more ways than one, suggesting that he's not one of the players that have kept this team up is just not right, and if this a mediocre season for him in your words than i can't wait to see what he could do in a good season.

For me:
POTY = Luka Milivojevic
Young POTY = Aaron Wan Bissaka (Would say Loftus-Cheek if he was our player)

 

Come to Daddy Flag 01 May 18 9.25am

Wan Bissaka is nailed on for the "pleasant surprise, 'one of our own', young player of the season" but it'd be difficult to argue that Loftus Cheek hasn't contributed more. He was only 22 at the back end of January.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 01 May 18 9.28am

Lies, damn lies and statistics.

POTY is tough Any one of half a dozen though I am sure Wilf will get the glory.

AWB is a shoe in though surely RLC deserves it even if he is on loan?

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

brides Flag Arnside . Lake District 01 May 18 9.31am

Agree with guy above, had great performances, but based on recent games tomkins, van, marcathy, loftus, luka, wilf, andros all been great,

 

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 9.34am

Originally posted by Adamoc123

Milivojevic has 10 goals and 1 assist in 33 games (+1 off the bench), while Zaha has 8 goals and 3 assists


Seriously????
Foook, I'm out of this discussion. The guy has been taking penalties while Zaha has been creating from open play. Can you not see the distinction?

 

INTER YANAN ! Flag Maidstone 01 May 18 9.42am

for me its got to be Wilf, purely because without him I feel we would haven't had a chance to stay up. second Jimmy for me and then Luka.

RLC has to get young player for me too, AWB didn't play enough sadly, but I'm really excited for his future.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 01 May 18 9.44am

Zaha for me. Clearly our most important player. Luka has been excellent, as has Tomkins, but Zaha I think deserves it again given the fact that when he's in the team we win games and when he isn't we don't.

RLC for young player if he's eligible (don't see why he wouldn't be).

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 01 May 18 9.49am

I think it's great that we have strong candidates for POTY. I am old enough to remember seasons when the discussion was about cancelling the event.

Young Player - Loftus Cheek if eligible if not Aaron Wan-Bissaka

POTY - I would be happy with Zaha, Tompkins or Milo with a special mention for Loftus Cheek.

 


One more point

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 9.53am

Originally posted by Adamoc123

Milivojevic has 10 goals and 1 assist in 33 games (+1 off the bench), while Zaha has 8 goals and 3 assists, no one else is that close in terms of goals created

Townsend is also there with 2 goals and 8 assists (FROM OPEN PLAY)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 May 18 9.56am

Originally posted by mattteo

Milivojevic??????????

Took set pieces all year, didn't hit a single assist. Guilty at plenty of goals (the one in the 90th minute against Man United easily comes to mind, but there were others too).

It's like fans here have a fascination with Milivojevic. Decent player but in no way player of the season. Not even a great season if you ask me, just a mediocre one.

Undoubtedly Zaha, Townsend, Tomkins, PVA, McArthur have kept this team up and deserve it a lot more.

This proves once and for all you really do not know what you are talking about. I have supported Palace since 1960 and Luca is one of the most complete footballers I have seen at Palace. Everyone is entitled to their opinion but...

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 May 18 9.58am

Originally posted by mattteo


Seriously????
Foook, I'm out of this discussion. The guy has been taking penalties while Zaha has been creating from open play. Can you not see the distinction?

Can you not see that Luca is a DEFENSIVE midfielder whose main job is to break up play!! A job he does extremely well, it is not all about goals and assists. I wonder have you ever seen a live game involving Luca? I doubt it.

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 01 May 18 10.00am

Luka has had a decent season, you still need someone to score those penalties and I doubt Benteke would have 10 goals if he'd taken them all.

Tomkins, PVA and Townsend deserves mentions but Wilf wins it hands down. Anyone else winning it would just be because we want to give it to someone different this season.

Young player should be Loftus-Cheek, has played almost all season except when injured. Sorry but can't JUST give it to AWB for playing a few games while Ward was injured and discount Ruben for being a loan player.

 

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 10.02am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Can you not see that Luca is a DEFENSIVE midfielder whose main job is to break up play!! A job he does extremely well, it is not all about goals and assists. I wonder have you ever seen a live game involving Luca? I doubt it.

So why bring into discussion his goals and assist if we're talking about his contribution as a defensive midfielder?? ))

I was just answering to that question. I've given reasons why he hasn't had a good season: taking set pieces without eficiency, I can also show you goals where he was at fault. Yes, he had some solid matches too. But player POTY? Come on....

I'm giving you solid facts, you're giving me personal opinions. Answer me this: was Milivojevic a good set piece taker this entire year??

Edited by mattteo (01 May 2018 10.06am)

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 01 May 18 10.03am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Can you not see that Luca is a DEFENSIVE midfielder whose main job is to break up play!! A job he does extremely well, it is not all about goals and assists. I wonder have you ever seen a live game involving Luca? I doubt it.

You are right of course, but without Wilf we'd have gone down.

 

Adamoc123 Flag Ennis 01 May 18 10.09am

Originally posted by mattteo

So why bring into discussion his goals and assist if we're talking about his contribution as a defensive midfielder?? ))

Because as a defensive midfielder it's impressive regardless of how many were penalties, i do think Zaha will get it and i'm not trying to belittle the other players contributions they've been equally immense in their own roles, but to write off Luka so easily is disrespectful to him for what he has brought to the table.

 


The First 90 Minutes Are The Most Important!

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player of the year and young player of the year