You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best Squad Ever ?
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Best Squad Ever ?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Croydonlad Flag sydenham 10 Aug 18 5.49am

I admit I’ve been very critical of the Chairmen’s transfer policy over the years , but I hold my hands up .
To keep hold of Zaha and everyone and get the players in he has its first class , and to my mind has created the strongest squad the club has ever had .
Very capable of a top 8 finish
Congrats

 

OneMax Flag Maidstone 10 Aug 18 6.43am

Agreed, very solid but with flare. The back bone is the same team that finished strongely last season we are unlikly to start messing about with a new system. So very positive.

 

Ben Vicar Flag London 10 Aug 18 8.03am

What a refreshingly honest and positive post. I couldn’t agree more. SP and the rest of the club deserve real credit for holding on to Wilf and making quality but financially canny additions to the squad. We start the season with the majority of players being very familiar with each other and the way we play and also super clear about their roles. I’d also love us to get the planned works on the ground done (I live in the South East and get constant grief for Brighton fans about their maginifjevnt stadium!!) so being clever with the clubs finances is super important. Can’t wait for the season to start.

 

chateauferret Flag 10 Aug 18 9.00am

Originally posted by Ben Vicar

What a refreshingly honest and positive post. I couldn’t agree more. SP and the rest of the club deserve real credit for holding on to Wilf and making quality but financially canny additions to the squad. We start the season with the majority of players being very familiar with each other and the way we play and also super clear about their roles. I’d also love us to get the planned works on the ground done (I live in the South East and get constant grief for Brighton fans about their maginifjevnt stadium!!) so being clever with the clubs finances is super important. Can’t wait for the season to start.

Seaweed's "magnificent" stadium looks like it's been assembled from Lego and bits of Subbuteo stuff. Shiny and new but plastic, soulless and generally s***.

Oh, and they haven't got Wilf either.

One thing we should credit the Board with is keeping Selhurst Selhurst and Palace Palace. It would have been easy to give in to the pressures of commercial football and put us in a plastic temple out in the sticks with lots of empty seats and telescopes to see the pitch through. Our atmosphere and character is a valuable part of the club and widely renowned, and they're things that the weed will never have.

Edited by chateauferret (10 Aug 2018 9.05am)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Aug 18 12.38pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

I admit I’ve been very critical of the Chairmen’s transfer policy over the years , but I hold my hands up .
To keep hold of Zaha and everyone and get the players in he has its first class , and to my mind has created the strongest squad the club has ever had .
Very capable of a top 8 finish
Congrats

Yes its a welcome change. Capable of achieving a high finish but I’d be thankful for being comfortably out of the drop zone all season.

I think there’s a mix of Parish getting the message more, Roy and the window closing before the season starts and also anybody knowing how desperate we are for one particular position, which parish is prepared to walk away from, which is great when there’s other possibilities but when it’s the eleventh hour you’re screwed.

 


COYP

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 10 Aug 18 4.57pm

I don’t see that this seasons squad is better than last seasons. We have lost to starters (RLC and Cabaye) and 2 effective replacements (Sako and TFM) and replaced with Kouyate Meyer and Ayew. Maybe it’s about the same but stronger... no.

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 10 Aug 18 7.47pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I don’t see that this seasons squad is better than last seasons. We have lost to starters (RLC and Cabaye) and 2 effective replacements (Sako and TFM) and replaced with Kouyate Meyer and Ayew. Maybe it’s about the same but stronger... no.

Completely agree.

Individually the 4 players who have come in might be better than the 4 strongest players who left but combined the 7 or 8 players who left are stronger than the 4 who came in.

Simple.

 

pssguy Flag 10 Aug 18 9.02pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Seaweed's "magnificent" stadium looks like it's been assembled from Lego and bits of Subbuteo stuff.
Edited by chateauferret (10 Aug 2018 9.05am)

But as an opening shot on TV the contrast with our stand could not be more marked. Bit embarrassing TBH. Can't wait for the improvements

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Aug 18 9.14pm

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

Completely agree.

Individually the 4 players who have come in might be better than the 4 strongest players who left but combined the 7 or 8 players who left are stronger than the 4 who came in.

Simple.

Well I’m glad we’ve done what we’ve done rather than fill the squad with sub standard championship players. The numbers in quality in all the departments is actually pretty good, they’re all permanent, and Ayew probably will be if it goes well. I take little confort in knowing there’s a good few sh1t players at this level we only use as a very last resooor not at all.

 


COYP

FanatiX Flag 10 Aug 18 9.36pm

I disagree to a degree, RLC is a loss yes and added greatly to the last 1/3 of the season. Cabaye wasn't as effective last season and I'm sure Meyer will fill that void and wage. Sako and TFM doubt they will be missed.

IMO, Ayew is going to give us a lot of options in terms of forward rotations, he’s fast and does possess some good skills that the team can unlock and maintain
just like RLC. If Roy can dial him in then we're onto a winner.

The squad looks in really good shape with some great talent...bring it on!!

 

FairweatherEagle Flag London 10 Aug 18 9.55pm

Its a very good squad, how do people (who really knew that team) think it compares to the team of the 80s?

Account for increased fitness levels and pace in the modern day game i.e. try and eliminate that as a factor.

 

twist Flag Miami, Florida 10 Aug 18 10.48pm

So your saying current squad is better than [Link]

or maybe even

[Link]

 

FanatiX Flag 10 Aug 18 11.23pm

The Coppell/Wright/Bright/Martyn era was a fab time to watch them on the pitch, they were a pretty special team that just clicked. My favourite part was when Salako (the super sub) came on and the crowd chants.

Hard to compare the squads but we dont have anything like that Wright/Bright connection in the current team.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 10 Aug 18 11.46pm

Originally posted by FairweatherEagle

Its a very good squad, how do people (who really knew that team) think it compares to the team of the 80s?

Account for increased fitness levels and pace in the modern day game i.e. try and eliminate that as a factor.

Grew up as a kid watching the team of the 80s (late 70s-early 80s)

The team today are in general far better in midfield but the team of the 80s were imho better at the back.

Both teams pretty damn average up front (that's where the team of the late 80s - early nineties would wipe the floor)

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Aug 18 11.46pm

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

Completely agree.

Individually the 4 players who have come in might be better than the 4 strongest players who left but combined the 7 or 8 players who left are stronger than the 4 who came in.

Simple.

Hmm. At the start of last season Sako was a write off and Tim unknown.

During the season both were often absent as was RLC.

Each had patches of brilliance. But better a good player 100 percent of the time than a mercurial player 40 %.

We just don’t know how good Meyer is but the others are clearly very good premier league players. Ayew was the players player of the season for Swansea. None of our leavers was a contender for that accolade at Palace

Edited by Mapletree (10 Aug 2018 11.57pm)

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 10 Aug 18 11.55pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Grew up as a kid watching the team of the 80s (late 70s-early 80s)

The team today are in general far better in midfield but the team of the 80s were imho better at the back.

Both teams pretty damn average up front (that's where the team of the late 80s - early nineties would wipe the floor)

Didn’t like Flanagan and Allen? Vince Hilaire on the wing? Jumpers for goal posts blah blah

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 11 Aug 18 12.15am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Didn’t like Flanagan and Allen? Vince Hilaire on the wing? Jumpers for goal posts blah blah

Mike Flanagan, temember him scoring a hatrick for us, possibly against Southampton. Wouldn't even make our reserves now.

Hilaire and Allen were quality though, not that we saw the best of Allen.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Mstrobez Flag 11 Aug 18 12.44am

The “best” squad isn’t necessarily the best group of individuals we’ve ever had. It’s also about how well the team collectively works with eachother and fits into the style of play the manager wants to implement.

Thus, we won’t know until the end of the season.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Aug 18 12.51am

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

Completely agree.

Individually the 4 players who have come in might be better than the 4 strongest players who left but combined the 7 or 8 players who left are stronger than the 4 who came in.

Simple.

Sako was good for about 2 games and you can count on 1 hand the amount of times TFM was really needed and not picked for loan relationship reasons.

We now have Bissaka and Ward at RB. Ok with 4 CB’s there is a risk but Kouyate can play there so we effectively have 5 and with 5 centrally capable midfielders we should be alright there also.

I’m just not interested in people trying to use the loss the likes of Lee’s ability in part of the 7-8 that had to go to play down the individual and total benefit of the additions to the squad. The club has deserved flack in recent windows but this isn’t one of them. If we couldn’t improve those squad numbers and kept them I’d be pretty fecked off. I’d rather have a few under 25 Prem quality players than a few lumps of sh1t making up the numbers on £35k or £65k per week thank you.

 


COYP

pssguy Flag 11 Aug 18 4.58am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle


The team today are in general far better in midfield but the team of the 80s were imho better at the back.

That's a stretch. Nicholas and Murphy were both top class

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best Squad Ever ?