You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Time to change the skipper?
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Time to change the skipper?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
merganser Flag 02 Sep 18 10.11pm

The team seems to be playing without collective personality or character.

Would Luca’s performances improve if he was relieved of being skipper?

He quibbles petulantly with refs over decisions, but he isn’t
demonstrating effective team leadership when the chips are down.

That’s where Jedinak excelled.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 03 Sep 18 11.21am

No, all players and teams go through patches like this. Now is not the time to relieve him of his duties as it will bang his confidence rather than help. He is a classy player, he'll start showing it shortly.

 

premier fan Flag BR4 03 Sep 18 1.17pm

Originally posted by merganser

The team seems to be playing without collective personality or character.

Would Luca’s performances improve if he was relieved of being skipper?

He quibbles petulantly with refs over decisions, but he isn’t
demonstrating effective team leadership when the chips are down.

That’s where Jedinak excelled.

Just one bad game ...

 

crvenaeagle Flag 03 Sep 18 1.34pm

Whaaat? Guys an excellent captain, absolutely no need to change it up!

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 03 Sep 18 1.52pm

Yeah, tell one of our best players that he's no longer captain material

 

Username Flag Horsham 03 Sep 18 1.59pm

More than one bad game. He was dreadful against Watford and patchy against Liverpool.

Leadership definitely an issue, after that first goal he just stood there as everyone looked a bit shell-shocked. McArthur was the only one who looked like he was geeing up teammates.

He also spent a lot of the second half flying into ridiculous challenges that could (if he'd connected) easily have seen him sent off.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Osvaldo Flag Epsom 03 Sep 18 2.09pm

PLEASE, PLEASE, DROP BENTEKE. Everyone can see that he has no form and can't score goals. If Palace are going to win matches, he must go. How much longer are we going tolerate missed chances. This will cost us in the long term.
We must play the three new players, what the hec are we waiting for.
It seems our tactical no knowhow is zero.
Make the players fight for their places, yes drop the captain if he is not performing. These guys earn a lot of money, make them aware of that by replacing them if they are not performing.
Look what Man.City have done with Sane.
Turned over well and truly by a side that hasn't won a game, sorry just not good enough, even a draw would have been a reprieve. It won't be long before we are in the same position as last season, one win in eight!

 

magicshop Flag Toscana 03 Sep 18 2.21pm

Jedinak is...elsewhere and our problems too.
It's very difficult to change the skipper without a huge understanding of dressing room.

 


crystalpalaceitalia.blogspot.it [Link]
Twitter:

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 03 Sep 18 3.05pm

Originally posted by premier fan

Just one bad game ...


Two..

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

chateauferret Flag 03 Sep 18 7.03pm

We said this about Scott Dann once but the difference there was that he oughtn't to have been captain in the first place.

 


============
The Ferret
============

aashman12 Flag 04 Sep 18 8.09am

Originally posted by Bangell

Yeah, tell one of our best players that he's no longer captain material

He needs to start playing like one of our best players.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 04 Sep 18 8.16am

Luka needs a playmaker beside him, and that is what I thought Meyer was brought in for. Roy needs to stop the dithering and put him in the starting 11. Oh, and drop Benteke, just to see if he has any hunger left in him.

 

chateauferret Flag 04 Sep 18 8.27am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Luka needs a playmaker beside him, and that is what I thought Meyer was brought in for. Roy needs to stop the dithering and put him in the starting 11. Oh, and drop Benteke, just to see if he has any hunger left in him.

Is the correct answer. I don't think it's to do with captaincy.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 04 Sep 18 8.30am

Originally posted by chateauferret

Is the correct answer. I don't think it's to do with captaincy.

Agreed, if Meyer and Kouyate are in the starting 11, Luka does not have the same issues with having to play provider as well as protector.

 

merganser Flag 04 Sep 18 4.55pm

Posters are confusing his form/ abilities as a player with his qualities as a captain.

I rate him as a player but not as a skipper.

With more forceful and dynamic leadership, we might have won, or at least rescued, something from the matches we’ve lost.

Looking back, Shaun Derry wasn’t the most gifted of players, but his spirit of resolve and determination spread to the rest of the team.

I’m not convinced that’s happening with Luca, and it’s something for Roy to sort out.

(It could also be said that there is not a lot of fire and brimstone radiating from the dug-out - just heads being held in hands as we miss another sitter.)

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 04 Sep 18 7.26pm

I'm not really convinced that his performance as a captain have produced dips in other players form, some being iffy for sometime. He may well have jet lag from the World Cup. Didn't Cabaye go to the Euro's, didn't play but didn't appear for us for a few games ? Luckily in a way Wilf wasn't there. At the moment it doesn't look like any player that attended the World Cup is sparking. Maybe he just needs a couple of weeks rest, which he will get as he's fallen out with the Serbian manager.

Edited by Booted Eagle (04 Sep 2018 7.27pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

PatrickA Flag London 04 Sep 18 7.42pm

The current team seems to lack forceful characters in contrast to the side that came up - think Jedi and Delaney.
Jedi was an inspirational captain who led by example and apparently was influential off the field as well.
Since he left neither Dann or Puncheon have convinced.
Luka is still the most convincing candidate in the current squad unless I’m missing something.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 05 Sep 18 8.49am

Originally posted by merganser

Posters are confusing his form/ abilities as a player with his qualities as a captain.

I rate him as a player but not as a skipper.

With more forceful and dynamic leadership, we might have won, or at least rescued, something from the matches we’ve lost.

Looking back, Shaun Derry wasn’t the most gifted of players, but his spirit of resolve and determination spread to the rest of the team.

I’m not convinced that’s happening with Luca, and it’s something for Roy to sort out.

(It could also be said that there is not a lot of fire and brimstone radiating from the dug-out - just heads being held in hands as we miss another sitter.)

I have to admit I would like to see more passion and maybe anger from the management. These players need to know that if they miss sitters then they are at immediate risk of being dropped, along with a wtf was that at half time or end of game. Ward deffo deserved a wtf was that, as has Benteke every game this season, and most of last to be fair.

 

Bald---Eagle Flag 06 Sep 18 2.23am

Luca is our captain,

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 06 Sep 18 1.14pm

Originally posted by merganser

Posters are confusing his form/ abilities as a player with his qualities as a captain.

I rate him as a player but not as a skipper.

With more forceful and dynamic leadership, we might have won, or at least rescued, something from the matches we’ve lost.

Looking back, Shaun Derry wasn’t the most gifted of players, but his spirit of resolve and determination spread to the rest of the team.

I’m not convinced that’s happening with Luca, and it’s something for Roy to sort out.

(It could also be said that there is not a lot of fire and brimstone radiating from the dug-out - just heads being held in hands as we miss another sitter.)

You may or may not be right, i am not sure, but its a good point, problem is, if not Luka for captain, then who???

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Time to change the skipper?